User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World Pro Championship Tournament
Page:
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smallbugger
Originally posted by Bort


I do not have a 100% solid idea of how to deal with demotion at the end of next season. There are several ideas, all of which have their own set of quirks that are not ideal.


in each conference there are 2 teams from each league. You demote the lower seeded team from each region of the two and promote the conference champion from each league.

You have a high turnover of teams and a good reward for every pro conference champion.


to add something... the issue of USPL having more top teams is true, but that is also a result of most ambitious teams and players wanting to play in USA to be able to play the best.

if you add equal promotion to all leagues the opportunity to reach the top league from any region would in time help balance the regions more as well.

Being that we can have a preferred region in the minors, but not a real choice... if you basically screw over most teams the chance to play the best in an actual league to all teams not in the best region you've done a great disservice to everyone.
 
coachviking
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Ubasstards


Yeah Bort, if you do the World League do not come up with the demotion process right away. Lets get the users to make some suggestions and we have a long time til season 11 demotion


Sounds like a recipe for disaster if it is not figured out within the first week or so of the new season.

Also, I cannot currently do a Pro owner only poll at the moment. I have it set up for team owner or not only. Shouldn't every team really be included anyway? They all have their shot to make it to the world pro league or tourney eventually, right?


Well some teams are very low on the totem pole, you could do a weighted poll depending on what leagues the other owners are in. I think it would be silly to automatically restrict other owners from voicing their opinions.

Although MY ADVICE is to NOT do this poll. Do you realize what is going to happen? There's going to be a mob of people that get upset with THAT poll, such as a massive amount of PLAYERS that think they should have a say, and ALL of the owners not included.

Forget the poll for now and just come up with a better solution to quell the concerns. You just need to reinvent the plan to something that fits better.


UHHHH


Never mind
 
RTJakarta
offline
Link
 
I'm so hungry, but I can't pull myself from the action ITT.
 
jfbueno
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Havoc
Originally posted by Bort



Lets say I run a team owner only poll and the majority likes the idea of the world league over the tournament (if it's the other way then we're good to go). Are people OK with moving ahead to say we are making the league without the demotion for the next season being 100% figured out right now? I wouldn't feel too hot about it myself.


How about a team owner poll of the teams that qualified for the world league?


I have a feeling at least 80% of the teams would want the WPL, just for the fact that they'd be in it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PLAYMAKERS
how do you solve the world league demotion problem?


1.) Randomly assign demoted teams

2.) Move any teams who only want to play in WEPL for example to a separate league and not have them in the WPL system. The teams who don't want to be relegated to a different league also don't want to be PROMOTED to a different league.


The only solution is to take them to a non-promotion league.
 
James128
offline
Link
 
so what page will this end?
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RTJakarta
I'm so hungry, but I can't pull myself from the action ITT.


 
robponce
online
Link
 
BTW bort, if you still need someone who's in touch with the user base, let me know. I'll put a committee together if need be.

My PM box is always open if you dont have too much pride to reach out and use it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Havoc
Originally posted by Bort



Lets say I run a team owner only poll and the majority likes the idea of the world league over the tournament (if it's the other way then we're good to go). Are people OK with moving ahead to say we are making the league without the demotion for the next season being 100% figured out right now? I wouldn't feel too hot about it myself.


How about a team owner poll of the teams that qualified for the world league?


 
glengerman
offline
Link
 
Why shouldn't ALL owners comment? Won't they be in Pro someday? This GLB Oligarchy is getting out of hand.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RTJakarta
I'm so hungry, but I can't pull myself from the action ITT.


I'll make a summary post in the Beans forum later. You can catch up there.

Go eat.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James128
so what page will this end?


Depends. It fluctuates higher or lower depending how many stupid posts like this are in the thread.
 
Tigerbait0307
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Ubasstards

Yeah Bort, if you do the World League do not come up with the demotion process right away. Lets get the users to make some suggestions and we have a long time til season 11 demotion


Sounds like a recipe for disaster if it is not figured out within the first week or so of the new season.

Also, I cannot currently do a Pro owner only poll at the moment. I have it set up for team owner or not only. Shouldn't every team really be included anyway? They all have their shot to make it to the world pro league or tourney eventually, right?


All of this could have been avoided if you would have let the masses know the WPL wasn't set in stone. As you said in an earlier post a mod quoted you and the GLB world ran with it. If you saw that you could have stepped in and let everyone know that it wasn't a sure thing. People wouldn't have gotten there hopes up or gotten pissed off.

 
coachviking
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by coachviking

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Ubasstards



Yeah Bort, if you do the World League do not come up with the demotion process right away. Lets get the users to make some suggestions and we have a long time til season 11 demotion


Sounds like a recipe for disaster if it is not figured out within the first week or so of the new season.

Also, I cannot currently do a Pro owner only poll at the moment. I have it set up for team owner or not only. Shouldn't every team really be included anyway? They all have their shot to make it to the world pro league or tourney eventually, right?


THe only ones that would be affect by this years like of a demotion plan are current pro team owners so they should be the ones voting IMO


The poll I'd likely be putting up would be:

Do you prefer:

[ ] A world league
[ ] A world champion tournament (as just posted)
[ ] Neither, I like it the way it is

Nothing about how the demotion would work.


That would work, is it filtered for all owners? Pee wee and casual owners really shouldn't be involved in all honesty
 
blankspace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Havoc

Originally posted by Bort




Lets say I run a team owner only poll and the majority likes the idea of the world league over the tournament (if it's the other way then we're good to go). Are people OK with moving ahead to say we are making the league without the demotion for the next season being 100% figured out right now? I wouldn't feel too hot about it myself.


How about a team owner poll of the teams that qualified for the world league?




 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.