User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World Pro Championship Tournament
Page:
 
jfbueno
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Ubasstards


Yeah Bort, if you do the World League do not come up with the demotion process right away. Lets get the users to make some suggestions and we have a long time til season 11 demotion


Sounds like a recipe for disaster if it is not figured out within the first week or so of the new season.

Also, I cannot currently do a Pro owner only poll at the moment. I have it set up for team owner or not only. Shouldn't every team really be included anyway? They all have their shot to make it to the world pro league or tourney eventually, right?


All you would have to do is point to this thread and you could say...

"look....the WPL is what you all wanted"


Because you know EXACTLY how things will turn out in the future, right?
 
blankspace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by txag2k
Originally posted by Bort


Sounds like a recipe for disaster ...


i lol'd


The irony hurts my eyes.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Ubasstards

Yeah Bort, if you do the World League do not come up with the demotion process right away. Lets get the users to make some suggestions and we have a long time til season 11 demotion


Sounds like a recipe for disaster if it is not figured out within the first week or so of the new season.

Also, I cannot currently do a Pro owner only poll at the moment. I have it set up for team owner or not only. Shouldn't every team really be included anyway? They all have their shot to make it to the world pro league or tourney eventually, right?


yeah, i am just saying you dont need to figure out demotion right this second. We (GLD Users and Admins) will figure it out in the next few days and you can poll EVERYONE on the best options/suggestions
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I do not have a 100% solid idea of how to deal with demotion at the end of next season. There are several ideas, all of which have their own set of quirks that are not ideal.


You will never have a perfect idea regardless of what you do, WPL or WP Tourny. If/when the WPL is created it has to be under the assumption that league affiliation will be less important (ie.. there is something better now than playing in USAPL). The ultimate prize will no longer be to win your league affiliated championship... it will be to win a WPL Championship. That said was is so wrong with this idea...

Promote only the league champions from the 8 leagues and demote 8 of 32 WPL teams. Who cares where the 8 demoted teams end up? The ultimate goal is to get to the top of the pyramid and that is the WPL (early on, demoting back to USA just makes your road back to the WPL that much more difficult... why would anyone want to go back there at least during the first few seasons of the WPL). Eventually it will create parity among the 8 leagues as FA's/teams will move away from the high concentration of good teams in USA.
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001



BORT SIGN MY WHOLE TEAM FOR ANOTHER SEASON!!!! THE ONLY REASON I GUTTED WAS BECAUSE OF THE WORLD LEAGUE!!!



Can you do this for me?

Thanks in advance...

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coachviking
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Ubasstards


Yeah Bort, if you do the World League do not come up with the demotion process right away. Lets get the users to make some suggestions and we have a long time til season 11 demotion


Sounds like a recipe for disaster if it is not figured out within the first week or so of the new season.

Also, I cannot currently do a Pro owner only poll at the moment. I have it set up for team owner or not only. Shouldn't every team really be included anyway? They all have their shot to make it to the world pro league or tourney eventually, right?


THe only ones that would be affect by this years like of a demotion plan are current pro team owners so they should be the ones voting IMO


The poll I'd likely be putting up would be:

Do you prefer:

[ ] A world league
[ ] A world champion tournament (as just posted)
[ ] Neither, I like it the way it is

Nothing about how the demotion would work.
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Ubasstards


Yeah Bort, if you do the World League do not come up with the demotion process right away. Lets get the users to make some suggestions and we have a long time til season 11 demotion


Sounds like a recipe for disaster if it is not figured out within the first week or so of the new season.

Also, I cannot currently do a Pro owner only poll at the moment. I have it set up for team owner or not only. Shouldn't every team really be included anyway? They all have their shot to make it to the world pro league or tourney eventually, right?


no...


non owners shouldn't comment

you can have my vote
 
Havoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


Lets say I run a team owner only poll and the majority likes the idea of the world league over the tournament (if it's the other way then we're good to go). Are people OK with moving ahead to say we are making the league without the demotion for the next season being 100% figured out right now? I wouldn't feel too hot about it myself.


How about a team owner poll of the teams that qualified for the world league?
 
coachviking
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blankspace
Originally posted by txag2k

Originally posted by Bort



Sounds like a recipe for disaster ...


i lol'd


The irony hurts my eyes.


Cowtesticles Avatar Hurts my eyes
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Ubasstards

Yeah Bort, if you do the World League do not come up with the demotion process right away. Lets get the users to make some suggestions and we have a long time til season 11 demotion


Sounds like a recipe for disaster if it is not figured out within the first week or so of the new season.

Also, I cannot currently do a Pro owner only poll at the moment. I have it set up for team owner or not only. Shouldn't every team really be included anyway? They all have their shot to make it to the world pro league or tourney eventually, right?


Well some teams are very low on the totem pole, you could do a weighted poll depending on what leagues the other owners are in. I think it would be silly to automatically restrict other owners from voicing their opinions.

Although my advice is to NOT do this poll. Do you realize what is going to happen? There's going to be a mob of people that get upset with THAT poll, such as a massive amount of PLAYERS that think they should have a say, and ALL of the owners not included.

Forget the poll for now and just come up with a better solution to quell the concerns. You just need to reinvent the plan to something that fits better.
Edited by The Strategy Expert on Jul 27, 2009 17:17:56
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Ubasstards

Yeah Bort, if you do the World League do not come up with the demotion process right away. Lets get the users to make some suggestions and we have a long time til season 11 demotion


Sounds like a recipe for disaster if it is not figured out within the first week or so of the new season.

Also, I cannot currently do a Pro owner only poll at the moment. I have it set up for team owner or not only. Shouldn't every team really be included anyway? They all have their shot to make it to the world pro league or tourney eventually, right?


My team is in 13 cap minors. I need to know by day 40 if there will be a WPL, so I can recruit accordingly.
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
LOL
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Ubasstards


Yeah Bort, if you do the World League do not come up with the demotion process right away. Lets get the users to make some suggestions and we have a long time til season 11 demotion


Sounds like a recipe for disaster if it is not figured out within the first week or so of the new season.

Also, I cannot currently do a Pro owner only poll at the moment. I have it set up for team owner or not only. Shouldn't every team really be included anyway? They all have their shot to make it to the world pro league or tourney eventually, right?


a level 13 cap team would take 9 seasons to get to WPL.... yeah, pretty sure they aren't making it


Thats the part that people are not seeing right now. Its a shame imo. I am in the minority and will obviously be happy regardless of the decision made.
 
James128
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by Bort


Ok, here's the deal:

I know how this tournament would work, from start to finish, and both DD and I like it in general, and always have.

A world league for season 11 would consist of the 4 top playoff teams from each region (or the next team down if one of those teams quits).

I do not have a 100% solid idea of how to deal with demotion at the end of next season. There are several ideas, all of which have their own set of quirks that are not ideal.

Lets say I run a team owner only poll and the majority likes the idea of the world league over the tournament (if it's the other way then we're good to go). Are people OK with moving ahead to say we are making the league without the demotion for the next season being 100% figured out right now? I wouldn't feel too hot about it myself.


Bort: Please decide on how to run the demotion first, then write the poll.

Don't make people guess at something.


Yes. The promotion / demotion plan outlined in other threads does not create more headaches, should be the first considered IMO. If needed an extra demotion in a pro conference (pro to AAA) to make room for a returning former world league team is not hard to adjust for ... especially considering the extra AAA to Pro promotions that would happen at the outset and the potential for further AAA to Pro promotions in future seasons. If that is the worry about that suggestion, it's silly. No one worries about the extra promotions that will be the result of creating the WL in the first place.


agreed
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Guys, don't forget that uneven demotion will make the system wonky for the entire pyramid. Gutting already does that yeah, but it doesn't help for a shit pie to have more shit put on it. Oh well. Let's have a poll already.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.