User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Iceman16

The running game already has a success rate that is way too high. Why make it even harder to stop it?


I am asking about the current state of it TBH.


The only reason people are complaining is because they have made these SUPER FAST, Low tackling, Low Strength Lber's. Yes you should get put on your ass. Do something besides pumping all your points into speed and agility. There are other skills and attributes. Instead of "nerfing" something force people to man up and adjust.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Deathblade


Originally posted by Bort




How do you define "elusive" or "power" back for this, though? Just based on their running style?


Well, elusive broken tackles and power broken tackles are calculated differently ain't they? Maybe it should be "power moves" and "elusive moves" instead of "power/elusive back".


Elusive guys don't really break tackles except for spinning - they avoid contact entirely with fakes and such. Breaking tackles is a power back thing.

Maybe just

Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked


Wouldn't this just boil down to "okay guys, this week's game is against a team with a power back. Everyone set to power tackle... *snore*"...

Doesn't seem like anything substantial is being added to the game. Maybe something is being lost as well IMO.


Better than before though.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Iceman16


The running game already has a success rate that is way too high. Why make it even harder to stop it?


I am asking about the current state of it TBH.


The only reason people are complaining is because they have made these SUPER FAST, Low tackling, Low Strength Lber's. Yes you should get put on your ass. Do something besides pumping all your points into speed and agility. There are other skills and attributes. Instead of "nerfing" something force people to man up and adjust.


I'm saying that the system is wrong. Something should be done to make LBs put more points into strength and tackling. But something should ALSO be done to tone down the offense.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
well anyways, going off to bed. But I will leave with this:

It is funny seeing people bitch about power RB's breaking too many tackles, when on the other hand now that the new VA's have come out, I see this topic in a private LB forum that I am in:

"Days of low tackling are over"


So apparently the builders of LBs understand that they have low tackling compared to the rest of their build. Like I have said, I have never had a problem with any of my players missing more than a handful of tackles a season. But because some level 18 CB misses tackles all the time they want to come to the forums and bitch about it. When my players started missing tackles when they were level 10-20 I increased strength and tackling. Sure I sacrificed speed/agility/vision, but guess what they stopped missing tackles.

So figure out what you would rather have. Miss tackles but get to the play quickly, Make all tackles but get to the play slowly, or a balance of the two. Its not that difficult.


This is pretty much my take too...and I have lead the league in fewest missed tackles every year, so i guess I try to stay to one side of that curve
 
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
well anyways, going off to bed. But I will leave with this:

It is funny seeing people bitch about power RB's breaking too many tackles, when on the other hand now that the new VA's have come out, I see this topic in a private LB forum that I am in:

"Days of low tackling are over"


So apparently the builders of LBs understand that they have low tackling compared to the rest of their build. Like I have said, I have never had a problem with any of my players missing more than a handful of tackles a season. But because some level 18 CB misses tackles all the time they want to come to the forums and bitch about it. When my players started missing tackles when they were level 10-20 I increased strength and tackling. Sure I sacrificed speed/agility/vision, but guess what they stopped missing tackles.

So figure out what you would rather have. Miss tackles but get to the play quickly, Make all tackles but get to the play slowly, or a balance of the two. Its not that difficult.


Exactly....and that should be the most important skill for a Lber but most think Speed and agility is. How many NFL LBers run a 4.2 forty yard dash? Every GLB running back is an olympic sprinter. GTFO.
 
Boxcutter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Iceman16


The running game already has a success rate that is way too high. Why make it even harder to stop it?


I am asking about the current state of it TBH.


The only reason people are complaining is because they have made these SUPER FAST, Low tackling, Low Strength Lber's. Yes you should get put on your ass. Do something besides pumping all your points into speed and agility. There are other skills and attributes. Instead of "nerfing" something force people to man up and adjust.


I agree with the scientist. If you don't like getting run over, don't build and 50 agil 80 sp LB who hasn't even soft capped str and tackling. Powerbacks should run over corners.

 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Iceman16



The running game already has a success rate that is way too high. Why make it even harder to stop it?


I am asking about the current state of it TBH.


The only reason people are complaining is because they have made these SUPER FAST, Low tackling, Low Strength Lber's. Yes you should get put on your ass. Do something besides pumping all your points into speed and agility. There are other skills and attributes. Instead of "nerfing" something force people to man up and adjust.


I'm saying that the system is wrong. Something should be done to make LBs put more points into strength and tackling. But something should ALSO be done to tone down the offense.


To tone down the offense, put more points into strength and tackling. Its not that difficult and its what most people have been saying the whole time.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by fletch03

well anyways, going off to bed. But I will leave with this:

It is funny seeing people bitch about power RB's breaking too many tackles, when on the other hand now that the new VA's have come out, I see this topic in a private LB forum that I am in:

"Days of low tackling are over"


So apparently the builders of LBs understand that they have low tackling compared to the rest of their build. Like I have said, I have never had a problem with any of my players missing more than a handful of tackles a season. But because some level 18 CB misses tackles all the time they want to come to the forums and bitch about it. When my players started missing tackles when they were level 10-20 I increased strength and tackling. Sure I sacrificed speed/agility/vision, but guess what they stopped missing tackles.

So figure out what you would rather have. Miss tackles but get to the play quickly, Make all tackles but get to the play slowly, or a balance of the two. Its not that difficult.


Exactly....and that should be the most important skill for a Lber but most think Speed and agility is. How many NFL LBers run a 4.2 forty yard dash? Every GLB running back is an olympic sprinter. GTFO.


There are quite a few that run 4.3s though. There should be balance. There should be room for creativity, but there should be balance, and backs should not be averaging 5-6 YPC against good teams.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too


I'd say you need a better build.


Originally posted by Bort
The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?


On balanced tackling adv. tactic, I would say 70-ish TAC and 60-ish STR, assuming the DEF has decent AGI, SAs/VAs and Adv. Eq. too. If that player wanted to stop that RB EVERY time, I'd say he needs to have quite a bit more TAC and STR (i.e., 70/60 should stop that RB about 70% of the time).
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Iceman16




The running game already has a success rate that is way too high. Why make it even harder to stop it?


I am asking about the current state of it TBH.


The only reason people are complaining is because they have made these SUPER FAST, Low tackling, Low Strength Lber's. Yes you should get put on your ass. Do something besides pumping all your points into speed and agility. There are other skills and attributes. Instead of "nerfing" something force people to man up and adjust.


I'm saying that the system is wrong. Something should be done to make LBs put more points into strength and tackling. But something should ALSO be done to tone down the offense.


To tone down the offense, put more points into strength and tackling. Its not that difficult and its what most people have been saying the whole time.


While they do that, the offense get SP too. That's far from solving the issue.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Deathblade



Originally posted by Bort





How do you define "elusive" or "power" back for this, though? Just based on their running style?


Well, elusive broken tackles and power broken tackles are calculated differently ain't they? Maybe it should be "power moves" and "elusive moves" instead of "power/elusive back".


Elusive guys don't really break tackles except for spinning - they avoid contact entirely with fakes and such. Breaking tackles is a power back thing.

Maybe just

Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked


Wouldn't this just boil down to "okay guys, this week's game is against a team with a power back. Everyone set to power tackle... *snore*"...

Doesn't seem like anything substantial is being added to the game. Maybe something is being lost as well IMO.


Better than before though.


No, it's not better than before. It would add ZERO strategy, ZERO sophistication, and ZERO depth to the game. Unless you count brain-dead right/wrong decisions as strategy....
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by fletch03

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by Iceman16





The running game already has a success rate that is way too high. Why make it even harder to stop it?


I am asking about the current state of it TBH.


The only reason people are complaining is because they have made these SUPER FAST, Low tackling, Low Strength Lber's. Yes you should get put on your ass. Do something besides pumping all your points into speed and agility. There are other skills and attributes. Instead of "nerfing" something force people to man up and adjust.


I'm saying that the system is wrong. Something should be done to make LBs put more points into strength and tackling. But something should ALSO be done to tone down the offense.


To tone down the offense, put more points into strength and tackling. Its not that difficult and its what most people have been saying the whole time.


While they do that, the offense get SP too. That's far from solving the issue.


Get some level 35+ players, then come talk to me. Its not an issue.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Deathblade




Originally posted by Bort






How do you define "elusive" or "power" back for this, though? Just based on their running style?


Well, elusive broken tackles and power broken tackles are calculated differently ain't they? Maybe it should be "power moves" and "elusive moves" instead of "power/elusive back".


Elusive guys don't really break tackles except for spinning - they avoid contact entirely with fakes and such. Breaking tackles is a power back thing.

Maybe just

Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked


Wouldn't this just boil down to "okay guys, this week's game is against a team with a power back. Everyone set to power tackle... *snore*"...

Doesn't seem like anything substantial is being added to the game. Maybe something is being lost as well IMO.


Better than before though.


No, it's not better than before. It would add ZERO strategy, ZERO sophistication, and ZERO depth to the game. Unless you count brain-dead right/wrong decisions as strategy....


I count them as more strategy than "Everyone set to wrap-up".
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by fletch03

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by Iceman16





The running game already has a success rate that is way too high. Why make it even harder to stop it?


I am asking about the current state of it TBH.


The only reason people are complaining is because they have made these SUPER FAST, Low tackling, Low Strength Lber's. Yes you should get put on your ass. Do something besides pumping all your points into speed and agility. There are other skills and attributes. Instead of "nerfing" something force people to man up and adjust.


I'm saying that the system is wrong. Something should be done to make LBs put more points into strength and tackling. But something should ALSO be done to tone down the offense.


To tone down the offense, put more points into strength and tackling. Its not that difficult and its what most people have been saying the whole time.


While they do that, the offense get SP too. That's far from solving the issue.


The reason offenses score so much is due to poor defensive co-ordinators to be honest.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by fletch03


Originally posted by Iceman16



Originally posted by ImTheScientist




Originally posted by Bort





Originally posted by Iceman16






The running game already has a success rate that is way too high. Why make it even harder to stop it?


I am asking about the current state of it TBH.


The only reason people are complaining is because they have made these SUPER FAST, Low tackling, Low Strength Lber's. Yes you should get put on your ass. Do something besides pumping all your points into speed and agility. There are other skills and attributes. Instead of "nerfing" something force people to man up and adjust.


I'm saying that the system is wrong. Something should be done to make LBs put more points into strength and tackling. But something should ALSO be done to tone down the offense.


To tone down the offense, put more points into strength and tackling. Its not that difficult and its what most people have been saying the whole time.


While they do that, the offense get SP too. That's far from solving the issue.


Get some level 35+ players, then come talk to me. Its not an issue.


I'm a coordinator with higher level players than yours, you ignorant fuck.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.