Originally posted by Voltron
A few sacks doesn't even really help much because of how easy it is to convert on third downs. Sacks far from dictate a game, my DE put up 90 last season but we still didn't win the championship.
I'll have to disagree. Most of our drives are stopped, primarily by sacks TBPH. So when a team racks up double digit sacks against another team, it does in-fact, dictate a game. The 2 blow-outs my team was a part of this season, was completely dominated by sacks, by one team (we won one and lost the other).
While I agree that converting on 3rd down is too easy, for the most part. I think that the issue should be solved, in ways that don't involve making a single position more important (I.E. game changing) than every other position. Each player should contribute to a group effort, not totally control the game themselves (because that very rarely happens in the real world).
The thing that most people don't understand is that due to a lack of in-game adjustments, things have to be balanced so that a single mismatch isn't abused all game. Most coaches would make the proper adjustments to stop a huge mismatch. In this game, it comes down to scouting and game-planning, but what if my opponent swaps his DEs right before the game... I game-planned to stop his speed DE, but because I wasn't constantly refreshing his depth chart, he just created a huge mismatch... which will probably result in 4-5 sacks. That's not acceptable IMHO. This means that mismatches cannot be drastically game-changing or it's unfair.
A few sacks doesn't even really help much because of how easy it is to convert on third downs. Sacks far from dictate a game, my DE put up 90 last season but we still didn't win the championship.
I'll have to disagree. Most of our drives are stopped, primarily by sacks TBPH. So when a team racks up double digit sacks against another team, it does in-fact, dictate a game. The 2 blow-outs my team was a part of this season, was completely dominated by sacks, by one team (we won one and lost the other).
While I agree that converting on 3rd down is too easy, for the most part. I think that the issue should be solved, in ways that don't involve making a single position more important (I.E. game changing) than every other position. Each player should contribute to a group effort, not totally control the game themselves (because that very rarely happens in the real world).
The thing that most people don't understand is that due to a lack of in-game adjustments, things have to be balanced so that a single mismatch isn't abused all game. Most coaches would make the proper adjustments to stop a huge mismatch. In this game, it comes down to scouting and game-planning, but what if my opponent swaps his DEs right before the game... I game-planned to stop his speed DE, but because I wasn't constantly refreshing his depth chart, he just created a huge mismatch... which will probably result in 4-5 sacks. That's not acceptable IMHO. This means that mismatches cannot be drastically game-changing or it's unfair.






























