User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Everybody is just making up excuses for the sim. It doesnt matter if your running game carried him the whole season, look at the stats. If he is going to have 1 game like this wouldnt it show in previous sims? Atleast a 4-5 INT game would show this, but it didnt, thus leading you to the conclusion the formula is flawed.


Tell me this, I will use Matthew Stafford as an example. He never throws more than 25 passes per game because their running game is so deadly on Georgia. So if their running game finally got shut down and he was forced to throw 50 passes in one game would he have more ints than before? Yes. Would it be an outragous amount? No because he is a good player unlike the guy in this build.
 
hambone77us
offline
Link
 
no one is saying that ten interceptions is cool , we are saying that the quarterback sucks so bad that it is possible
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by superman8456


Everybody is just making up excuses for the sim. It doesnt matter if your running game carried him the whole season, look at the stats. If he is going to have 1 game like this wouldnt it show in previous sims? Atleast a 4-5 INT game would show this, but it didnt, thus leading you to the conclusion the formula is flawed.


Why would a 4-5 INT game show up before this? What logical reason do you reach for that? Especially given the fact that his team RUSHED the ball almost the entire season.


You're saying that his build is so horrible. You cant have both sides to the argument. Bad build would show atleast a game with 4-5 INT's for the team to know. It didnt happen that way, this was an out of the blue thing and you guys are making up excuses for it.


You aren't even making a sound argument - the QB never ran into a defense this season that planned him out like this defense did. It happens. If he had a good build, we wouldn't be talking about a 9 INT game. But he doesn't, and when the bad things started, with a bang, early and often, the morale loss was more than he had experience before. Don't think the massive number of sacks he endured had nothing to do with how this game played out.
 
RxExAx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by superman8456


Everybody is just making up excuses for the sim. It doesnt matter if your running game carried him the whole season, look at the stats. If he is going to have 1 game like this wouldnt it show in previous sims? Atleast a 4-5 INT game would show this, but it didnt, thus leading you to the conclusion the formula is flawed.


Why would a 4-5 INT game show up before this? What logical reason do you reach for that? Especially given the fact that his team RUSHED the ball almost the entire season.


You're saying that his build is so horrible. You cant have both sides to the argument. Bad build would show atleast a game with 4-5 INT's for the team to know. It didnt happen that way, this was an out of the blue thing and you guys are making up excuses for it.


I agree with this - but as I said earlier - "Thanks for your understanding and patience with this beta game. We are working hard to improve the game every day."

Nuff said - there's gonna be problems you're gonna have to deal with.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by superman8456


Everybody is just making up excuses for the sim. It doesnt matter if your running game carried him the whole season, look at the stats. If he is going to have 1 game like this wouldnt it show in previous sims? Atleast a 4-5 INT game would show this, but it didnt, thus leading you to the conclusion the formula is flawed.


Why would a 4-5 INT game show up before this? What logical reason do you reach for that? Especially given the fact that his team RUSHED the ball almost the entire season.


You're saying that his build is so horrible. You cant have both sides to the argument. Bad build would show atleast a game with 4-5 INT's for the team to know. It didnt happen that way, this was an out of the blue thing and you guys are making up excuses for it.


How am I having both sides, the QB was fucking brutal, and his team RAN The ball most of the season,

It also happens out of the blue in the NFL, ie, Brett Favre's six picks, Peyton Mannings six picks etc,

 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by superman8456


Everybody is just making up excuses for the sim. It doesnt matter if your running game carried him the whole season, look at the stats. If he is going to have 1 game like this wouldnt it show in previous sims? Atleast a 4-5 INT game would show this, but it didnt, thus leading you to the conclusion the formula is flawed.


Why would a 4-5 INT game show up before this? What logical reason do you reach for that? Especially given the fact that his team RUSHED the ball almost the entire season.


You're saying that his build is so horrible. You cant have both sides to the argument. Bad build would show atleast a game with 4-5 INT's for the team to know. It didnt happen that way, this was an out of the blue thing and you guys are making up excuses for it.


SOmeone brought this up earlier when Bort was posting but over the course of this season about 60 years of NFL football would have been played. You are bound to see record breaking games and this guys awefull build showed it! Do you think that guy in 1953 that threw 8 ints wasn't possible? He even was a pro bowler that season!
 
Link
 
Just like in the real NFL, sometimes a team has an off-day and there is a perfect storm type of situation where everything goes wrong. Our team was 12-1 and going into a huge matchup with the team right behind us in the standings.

We had not given up more than 24 points all season and sure in the hell hadnt been dominated defensively by anyone.

Then this happend: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=38059

Of course, we went on to win our next 2 games and they got knocked out in the first round of the playoffs.

Sometimes flukes happen.
 
hambone77us
offline
Link
 
the main problem is you should be able to sub when your player does certain things like drop to low on confidence and what not
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Really good discussion here:

Here is the only point I have on this issue:

I keep seeing this game compared to NFL teams and NFL playoff teams...

We are in the third season of this game.
The top leveled players are around 27.
They will max out around 55-60, where they will perform at their peak. (Season 9 or 10)

These players are not NFL caliber players. They are not even half way as good as they are going to be. Even if you factor in dimenishing returns, they are probably sitting at 55 or 60% of their potential. That translates to a High School player from my expirence. Players in college play at about 75-85% of their potential. They get a little better in the pro's but not much.

So we are looking at a situation here, where we have very good High school players playing and comparing them to NFL caliber players...

I'd be interested to see how the sim function as is, at max levels (players around level 60) and see if the same problems still occur...

Domer

Last edited Jul 15, 2008 09:14:54
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hambone77us
the main problem is you should be able to sub when your player does certain things like drop to low on confidence and what not


NO NO NO NO NO,

the MAIN PROBLEM is that the SIM was wrong, we should have won, and I wanna cry about it now.

the MAIN PROBLEM is that I can't understand why ten picks were thrown by a subpar QB

the MAIN PROBLEM is that this NEVER HAPPENS in real football, DESPITE what you have posted to show the exact opposite.

THAT is the main problem
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Otis T. Scupper
Just like in the real NFL, sometimes a team has an off-day and there is a perfect storm type of situation where everything goes wrong. Our team was 12-1 and going into a huge matchup with the team right behind us in the standings.

We had not given up more than 24 points all season and sure in the hell hadnt been dominated defensively by anyone.

Then this happend: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=38059

Of course, we went on to win our next 2 games and they got knocked out in the first round of the playoffs.

Sometimes flukes happen.


Musta been an INVALID sim, and you should try to get your money back bud.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
A few thoughts.

I don't think anyone said Miami didn't deserve to win.

Just because everyone has to deal with the same issues, doesn't make those issues right.

We are all Beta testers, it is our JOB to point out things we think are not right.

Of course the game has to be compared to real football. If not, what are we trying to Simulate?

I honestly think the "refund" part of the post was only meant to draw attention. Maybe I am wrong though.

Those "offended" by this thread probably are taking this game too seriously. So is Larry.


Let the flaming begin.



Bumped to allow the flamers to refocus.

 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by wombat killer

A few thoughts.

I don't think anyone said Miami didn't deserve to win.

Just because everyone has to deal with the same issues, doesn't make those issues right.

We are all Beta testers, it is our JOB to point out things we think are not right.

Of course the game has to be compared to real football. If not, what are we trying to Simulate?

I honestly think the "refund" part of the post was only meant to draw attention. Maybe I am wrong though.

Those "offended" by this thread probably are taking this game too seriously. So is Larry.


Let the flaming begin.



Bumped to allow the flamers to refocus.



We are focused Larry, almost every post in here has been to counter the 10 ints, it is your reading comprehension skills that must be lacking
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by hambone77us

the main problem is you should be able to sub when your player does certain things like drop to low on confidence and what not


NO NO NO NO NO,

the MAIN PROBLEM is that the SIM was wrong, we should have won, and I wanna cry about it now.

the MAIN PROBLEM is that I can't understand why ten picks were thrown by a subpar QB

the MAIN PROBLEM is that this NEVER HAPPENS in real football, DESPITE what you have posted to show the exact opposite.

THAT is the main problem


I dont agree with them wanting their money back, but I agree there is some flaw. Now he is a subpar QB? Even a lvl 16 QB wouldnt throw 10 picks in a game like that.
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by hambone77us


the main problem is you should be able to sub when your player does certain things like drop to low on confidence and what not


NO NO NO NO NO,

the MAIN PROBLEM is that the SIM was wrong, we should have won, and I wanna cry about it now.

the MAIN PROBLEM is that I can't understand why ten picks were thrown by a subpar QB

the MAIN PROBLEM is that this NEVER HAPPENS in real football, DESPITE what you have posted to show the exact opposite.

THAT is the main problem


I dont agree with them wanting their money back, but I agree there is some flaw. Now he is a subpar QB? Even a lvl 16 QB wouldnt throw 10 picks in a game like that.


He would throw alot of picks against level 25's. I wouldn't even consider starting a level 16 against 25's. Take a look at the last place USA pro teams and you will see they are the ones who start low level qb's.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 09:20:37
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.