User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Defense AI Interface
Page:
 
dfitzo53
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TenTwo
I just read 49 pages of this stuff...whew...I did see my question on about page 40 but I'll bring it up again and ask if my solution is right:

ZONE BLITZ?

Example: In a 4-3, I want my ROLB to blitz and I want my RDE to drop. I want my #1 CB, FS and #2 CB to play deep. I want my RDE, MLB, SS, and LOLB to play short/intermediate zone coverage.

Would the settings be:

4-3 base

Cover 3

Zone Coverage

Number of Blitzers - 0

ROLB - 100%?



My thought on this is with the ROLB "rushing" and the RDE dropping, there is technically no blitz...just a standard 4 man rush in a 4-3.

I have made a few Zone Blitz plays and this is how I'm addressing it until I here from Bort or an Admin who knows tell me otherwise. It's the only way I can see forcing a DE to drop.




I think common sense would dictate that #1 of blitzers refers to the table of positions next to it, namely the linebackers and secondary. The line is not counted in the number of blitzers. If you set max blitzers to 0, nobody will blitz aside from the defensive line.

Also, the defensive end doesn't drop into coverage on every zone play in the game, and we don't currently have control over what the linemen do. This means that if you call zone and set your ROLB to blitz, you're not guaranteed that the DE will drop back to fill his zone in the flat.

That's why Bort warned people think about who's going to be in coverage if they go crazy with the blitzing.
Last edited Jul 27, 2008 13:28:46
 
T2
Killuh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dfitzo53
Originally posted by TenTwo

I just read 49 pages of this stuff...whew...I did see my question on about page 40 but I'll bring it up again and ask if my solution is right:

ZONE BLITZ?

Example: In a 4-3, I want my ROLB to blitz and I want my RDE to drop. I want my #1 CB, FS and #2 CB to play deep. I want my RDE, MLB, SS, and LOLB to play short/intermediate zone coverage.

Would the settings be:

4-3 base

Cover 3

Zone Coverage

Number of Blitzers - 0

ROLB - 100%?



My thought on this is with the ROLB "rushing" and the RDE dropping, there is technically no blitz...just a standard 4 man rush in a 4-3.

I have made a few Zone Blitz plays and this is how I'm addressing it until I here from Bort or an Admin who knows tell me otherwise. It's the only way I can see forcing a DE to drop.




I think common sense would dictate that #1 of blitzers refers to the table of positions next to it, namely the linebackers and secondary. The line is not counted in the number of blitzers. If you set max blitzers to 0, nobody will blitz aside from the defensive line.

Also, the defensive end doesn't drop into coverage on every zone play in the game, and we don't currently have control over what the linemen do. This means that if you call zone and set your ROLB to blitz, you're not guaranteed that the DE will drop back to fill his zone in the flat.

That's why Bort warned people think about who's going to be in coverage if they go crazy with the blitzing.


Thanks for the input but I'm not really looking for someone's "common sense". I mean, clearly I can see what you're saying but if there's a way to do it, would this not be the way? I've read every post in this thread, where did you see this Bort warning? Are you refering to not sending 7 players in on a blitz?
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TenTwo
Originally posted by dfitzo53

I think common sense would dictate that #1 of blitzers refers to the table of positions next to it, namely the linebackers and secondary. The line is not counted in the number of blitzers. If you set max blitzers to 0, nobody will blitz aside from the defensive line.

Also, the defensive end doesn't drop into coverage on every zone play in the game, and we don't currently have control over what the linemen do. This means that if you call zone and set your ROLB to blitz, you're not guaranteed that the DE will drop back to fill his zone in the flat.

That's why Bort warned people think about who's going to be in coverage if they go crazy with the blitzing.


Thanks for the input but I'm not really looking for someone's "common sense". I mean, clearly I can see what you're saying but if there's a way to do it, would this not be the way? I've read every post in this thread, where did you see this Bort warning? Are you refering to not sending 7 players in on a blitz?


I know you are only interested in Bort/Admin responses, but I think dfitzo's response was largely on the mark. Stepping back from it for a minute, doesn't it make more sense that the sim would read your output request, get to where it says "zero blitzers" and stop there rather than overriding that primary request with a secondary one (ROLB 100%)?

I understand how you were thinking about it, but you are putting a lot of faith in the sim to understand that when you say "zero blitzers" what you really mean is "OK, not actually zero blitzers ... one blitzer - but have him replace the right defensive end and have the RDE switch roles and drop into zone coverage".

Also, we don't know what any of the new defensive stuff will look like until we see it in action, but I wouldn't count on your two corners to both be involved in the deep thirds in a cover 3 - in the past it's looked like the safeties roll to one side and one corner drops to join them.
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
My question is with the 3-4 defense. I want our ROLB to play RILB and our RDE to play ROLB during 3-4 defenses. I want the ROLB playing ROLB and the RDE playing RDE during the 4-3.

Is it possible to do this? I am afraid of what will happen to my depth chart if I move guys around and its not right...any suggestions or is it just not possible to do?

I know Bort said the penalty was extremely minimal for a DE to play OLB but does that apply to ILB as well during the 3-4 spread? I'm thinking there is a stiffer penalty for playing ILB as a DE which is why I want to put my RDE at ROLB during the 3-4 and put my ROLB at the RILB spot during the 3-4. I just dont know how to make that happen? I hope this makes sense
Last edited Jul 27, 2008 17:01:20
 
dfitzo53
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whodey08
My question is with the 3-4 defense. I want our ROLB to play RILB and our RDE to play ROLB during 3-4 defenses. I want the ROLB playing ROLB and the RDE playing RDE during the 4-3.

Is it possible to do this? I am afraid of what will happen to my depth chart if I move guys around and its not right...any suggestions or is it just not possible to do?

I know Bort said the penalty was extremely minimal for a DE to play OLB but does that apply to ILB as well during the 3-4 spread? I'm thinking there is a stiffer penalty for playing ILB as a DE which is why I want to put my RDE at ROLB during the 3-4 and put my ROLB at the RILB spot during the 3-4. I just dont know how to make that happen? I hope this makes sense

I'm less confident about this than I was about the above response, but this is how I'm guessing you'd set up your depth chart.

MLB:
Mike MLB

LILB:
Mike MLB

RILB:
Joe ROLB

ROLB:
Joe ROLB
Johnny RDE

RDE:
Johnny RDE
 
Jcdawg23
offline
Link
 
Ok, this may be a dumb question, but say I have multiple plays that could work one situation. Like say I set up a defense for 3rd and long, and a formation for shotgun. Then the offense gets into a shotgun formation on 3rd and long. Will it use the play I put first, or will it use certain parts from both defensive sets? Does that make any sence?
 
dfitzo53
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jcdawg23
Ok, this may be a dumb question, but say I have multiple plays that could work one situation. Like say I set up a defense for 3rd and long, and a formation for shotgun. Then the offense gets into a shotgun formation on 3rd and long. Will it use the play I put first, or will it use certain parts from both defensive sets? Does that make any sence?

Each input is its own entity. The defensive AI won't combine them under any circumstances.

What it will do is go down the list from the top until it finds an input that matches the current situation, and call one of the corresponding outputs. It will never look past an input that matches the situation at hand.

In other words, if the 3rd and long input is at the top of the list, it will call that and never see the shotgun input. If the shotgun input is at the top of the list, the opposite would happen.

If you want a play specifically for 3rd and long when your opponent is in shotgun, you need specify all of the in the input, and your more specific plays need to be above your more general plays.

(In other words, a 3rd and long shotgun formation input needs to be above your general 3rd and long input.)
 
Jcdawg23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dfitzo53
Originally posted by Jcdawg23

Ok, this may be a dumb question, but say I have multiple plays that could work one situation. Like say I set up a defense for 3rd and long, and a formation for shotgun. Then the offense gets into a shotgun formation on 3rd and long. Will it use the play I put first, or will it use certain parts from both defensive sets? Does that make any sence?

Each input is its own entity. The defensive AI won't combine them under any circumstances.

What it will do is go down the list from the top until it finds an input that matches the current situation, and call one of the corresponding outputs. It will never look past an input that matches the situation at hand.

In other words, if the 3rd and long input is at the top of the list, it will call that and never see the shotgun input. If the shotgun input is at the top of the list, the opposite would happen.

If you want a play specifically for 3rd and long when your opponent is in shotgun, you need specify all of the in the input, and your more specific plays need to be above your more general plays.

(In other words, a 3rd and long shotgun formation input needs to be above your general 3rd and long input.)


Ok, so like my main input would be 3rd and long. As an output, I could put Shoutgun, so if they are in the shotgun formation, we will set up for that. right?
 
Jcdawg23
offline
Link
 
Oh wait, the input would have to say they are in the shotgun formation. hmm.... this is gunna take some getting use to.
 
dfitzo53
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jcdawg23

Ok, so like my main input would be 3rd and long. As an output, I could put Shoutgun, so if they are in the shotgun formation, we will set up for that. right?

Nope.

The AI will do no thinking for you.

Let's say you want to line up in Quarter against the Shotgun in 3rd and long, Dime against 3-wide sets, and Nickel against anything else.

Your AI would like like this:

Input settings:
Down: 3 to 3
Distance: 5 to 99 (or whatever you want to consider long)
Opp. Formation: Shotgun

Output settings:
Formation: 3-1-7

Below that, you'd have another input:
Settings:
Down: 3 to 3
Distance: 5 to 99
Opp. Wide Receivers: 3 to 3

Output:
Formation: 4-1-6

After that, you'd have your other 3rd and long input:
Input Settings:
Down: 3 to 3
Distance: 5 to 99

Output:
Formation: 4-2-5

Here's where multiple outputs come into play. Let's say you want to blitz 75% of the time on 3rd and long when they come out in a regular 2WR set. Instead of what's above, your last Input/Output would look like this:

Input Settings:
Down: 3 to 3
Distance: 5 to 99

Output 1:
25% Chance
Formation: 4-2-5
Shell: Cover 2
Zone Under

Output 2:
75% Chance
Shell: Cover 1
Man Under
Formation 4-2-5
Max # of Blitzers 2
MLB Blitz %: 100
ROLB Blitz %: 50

Whenever it encounters a 2WR set on 3rd and long, the computer will call a basic Cover 2 play 1/4 of the time. The other 3/4s, you'll play man-to-man with one deep safety, the MLB will always blitz, and the ROLB will sometimes blitz.

I hope all that made sense.
 
KangarWhoDey
offline
Link
 
Will the advanced defense AI interface be active when the new season begins?
 
Jcdawg23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dfitzo53
Originally posted by Jcdawg23


Ok, so like my main input would be 3rd and long. As an output, I could put Shoutgun, so if they are in the shotgun formation, we will set up for that. right?

Nope.

The AI will do no thinking for you.

Let's say you want to line up in Quarter against the Shotgun in 3rd and long, Dime against 3-wide sets, and Nickel against anything else.

Your AI would like like this:

Input settings:
Down: 3 to 3
Distance: 5 to 99 (or whatever you want to consider long)
Opp. Formation: Shotgun

Output settings:
Formation: 3-1-7

Below that, you'd have another input:
Settings:
Down: 3 to 3
Distance: 5 to 99
Opp. Wide Receivers: 3 to 3

Output:
Formation: 4-1-6

After that, you'd have your other 3rd and long input:
Input Settings:
Down: 3 to 3
Distance: 5 to 99

Output:
Formation: 4-2-5

Here's where multiple outputs come into play. Let's say you want to blitz 75% of the time on 3rd and long when they come out in a regular 2WR set. Instead of what's above, your last Input/Output would look like this:

Input Settings:
Down: 3 to 3
Distance: 5 to 99

Output 1:
25% Chance
Formation: 4-2-5
Shell: Cover 2
Zone Under

Output 2:
75% Chance
Shell: Cover 1
Man Under
Formation 4-2-5
Max # of Blitzers 2
MLB Blitz %: 100
ROLB Blitz %: 50

Whenever it encounters a 2WR set on 3rd and long, the computer will call a basic Cover 2 play 1/4 of the time. The other 3/4s, you'll play man-to-man with one deep safety, the MLB will always blitz, and the ROLB will sometimes blitz.

I hope all that made sense.


Made plenty of sence. Thanks bud! I have a lot of work to do again haha
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KangarWhoDey
Will the advanced defense AI interface be active when the new season begins?


Yes Sir
 
MHS619
offline
Link
 
So which LBs will be in the different formations? I already know the basic 4-3.
 
dfitzo53
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MHS619
So which LBs will be in the different formations? I already know the basic 4-3.


I'm not 100% sure, but I believe the 4-2-5 is MLB, ROLB, and the 4-1-6 is MLB.

I don't know how the 3-4 breaks down.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.