User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
razor9
offline
Link
 
This would all depend on whether our skill points spent will remain assigned. If they are refunded essentially, then it really doesn't matter what we do this season. If they remain assigned, then switching to an archtype would pointless, unless you are already geared toward that.

So the question is (and I'm not going to dig through thousands of pages of discussion for it):

Will we get a skill point reset along with the archtype conversion?
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by razor9
This would all depend on whether our skill points spent will remain assigned. If they are refunded essentially, then it really doesn't matter what we do this season. If they remain assigned, then switching to an archtype would pointless, unless you are already geared toward that.

So the question is (and I'm not going to dig through thousands of pages of discussion for it):

Will we get a skill point reset along with the archtype conversion?


No.
 
razor9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by razor9

This would all depend on whether our skill points spent will remain assigned. If they are refunded essentially, then it really doesn't matter what we do this season. If they remain assigned, then switching to an archtype would pointless, unless you are already geared toward that.

So the question is (and I'm not going to dig through thousands of pages of discussion for it):

Will we get a skill point reset along with the archtype conversion?


No.


I thought not. So the success of such a conversion would entirely depend on whether you already geared yourself in that direction already, it would seem.
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
nm
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
No lol

You should see the 2 HB's I made trying out the new ALG's. They are by far better then anything we can make now.


I think that's what PM means. The current positions that benefit the most by the changes are HB/WR/LB.

Therefore, the biggest difference between S14 and S15 players will be in those three positions.
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
I think that's what PM means. The current positions that benefit the most by the changes are HB/WR/LB.

Therefore, the biggest difference between S14 and S15 players will be in those three positions.


Ah yes, then he is very correct.
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
I think that's what PM means. The current positions that benefit the most by the changes are HB/WR/LB.

Therefore, the biggest difference between S14 and S15 players will be in those three positions.


To add to that, so far everything looks better. Some like much better, and others looks just as good as we have now.
 
Hagalaz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
^ of course, that's really only a benefit of those with the same or higher ALGs under the new system. Someone going from a 6 major under the old to a 4 major under the new will be kinda gimped.

The biggest "hurts" are HB/WR/LB imo.


Why do you say that about LB?
 
sborats
offline
Link
 
why are HB/LB/WR worse off than the other positions?
 
Shayde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sborats
why are HB/LB/WR worse off than the other positions?


Because in many ways, these new archetypes don't quite correspond to how many build now. Those that do are actually hurt more it seems.

Ah well, beta is as beta does. Don't like the new system, but what are you gonna do?
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunshineduck
I could compile all the builds into a thread for easy viewing if all else fails..


Just take a DE, try and visualize tackling being catch/jump/vis/w/e else you want for w/e player you want, I mean de's already are .5 on the 4 good attributes, and they suck, so its not like this is going to be the be all end all for imbalances, things will change but it should be fun.

That list would be awesome to see tho dude
 
Llyranwyar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Are you kidding? The biggest problems with the sim have always been from Bort springing changes on us without getting customer input. How disastrous would the new VAs have been if people hadn't rioted over how obviously unbalanced some of them were going to be? Maybe if the staff of GLB listened to the users once in a while, you wouldn't constantly screw up the game, and maybe we wouldn't feel so unwanted. At least pretend to give a crap about our ideas while you're taking our money.


+1 for him.

My own opinion...

Cap building is the issue with the system. ALG's in themselves create a system where you have to choose to be good now and so-so later or suck now and be good later. Why should the players settle for that? Cap building is the primary reason the minors suck and aren't competitive.

Make whatever comparisons to major MMO's you want. People either like building characters or competing with them. Every MMO has to figure out a way to entertain the players on the way up.

Why should anyone be penalized on SA's? That's a serious hit toward diversity and innovation. I really would have rather seen SA substitutions or reordered trees applied to archetypes rather than bonuses and penalties toward the SA's we have. Acceleration and speed are already penalized by weight....why should power type players be further penalized by a change to his first step or quick cut SA?



 
Link
 
too many walls of text...
Edited by Timetoshine-Beta on Feb 10, 2010 20:01:20
 
Link
 
Ok, time to send myself a PM to note page number (50) that I've been through to check later/tomorrow..

Conclusion: -- This is going to happen and WE the consumer DON'T have a say in it.. This is Catch22/thehazyone and others ideas and it is obvious THEY don't want anyone to talk about it or discuss it (based on merged threads)..

And FYI, catch22 I've been here just as long as you have
 
WalterManning
offline
Link
 
Another change made. Maybe tomorrow another one will also be made. Ahhhh the development of making a game.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.