Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83
I am not 100% for divisions. I am 100% for all 8 regions being represented equally. If that is possible without divisions, I am all for it. Show me the way and I will follow.
Done.
4 teams from each get a shot in the first season.
2 more each season after that.
Make the playoffs or go home.
Always at least two from a region.
Always opportunity for more.
All 8 regions repped equally.
: middlefinger :
How does this ultimately make OPL = USAPL?
The same way any of these suggestions do ... players look at the ladder, they see wow OPL is easy, let's join a team there, win, and get to the WL quick.
I can see from where this thread is going that USAPL will always remain the elite pro league in the game. I don't like it, but that ultimately does not matter in the grad scheme of things. The inferior regions will never close the gap on USAPL because the perception of USAPL is not going to change. USA will own the WL and up-and-coming teams will want to be a part of that and not the underdog OPL, SEAPL, etc. I honestly did not know why I thought it could be any different.
Luke, do you think I'm pushing a USAPL-first bias? I'm not, no reason to and really don't get why the system I support would lead you to think that. You want four teams from each region each season, period. I want the best to stay regardless of home region with two from each getting a chance to join each season. Yeah, it may for a while be USAPL heavy, but it may also be OPL heavy at some point in the future, or EEPL, or whatever. I just don't want to sacrifice competition - potentially the best this game has seen - just to make each region feel loved.
I don't think it supports USAPL bias, but it doesn't change the perception of USAPL either. I will try to explain what I am thinking...
If I have a player that the top OPL team and top USAPL teams both want and I see that the WL is composed of 15+ USA teams, which region do you think I am going to choose for my player? USA teams do better in the WL, so I will assume I have a better chance at winning in the WL with the USA team. See how this leads to USA remaining the preferred region?
Maybe we will be surprised and WEPL will rise up and dominate the WL, but the odds are that USA will rule supreme, have four playoff teams, and 6 teams in the WL for Season 12 (and very likely 8 teams for Season 13). As long as agents see USAPL as the easiest avenue for their players getting to the WL and staying there, they will choose USAPL over any other region that wants their players. I hope I am wrong, but it is what it is.
A simpler way of putting this is that with the system turnit is supporting there is equal opportunity to reach the WPL, however the stronger FA's will still go to USAPL and they will therefore have a huge advantage to stay in the WPL having better players. Who cares about getting an easy pass to the WPL if there is no shot at competing and staying there because all the top notch recruits are still going to USAPL.
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83
I am not 100% for divisions. I am 100% for all 8 regions being represented equally. If that is possible without divisions, I am all for it. Show me the way and I will follow.
Done.

4 teams from each get a shot in the first season.
2 more each season after that.
Make the playoffs or go home.
Always at least two from a region.
Always opportunity for more.
All 8 regions repped equally.
: middlefinger :
How does this ultimately make OPL = USAPL?
The same way any of these suggestions do ... players look at the ladder, they see wow OPL is easy, let's join a team there, win, and get to the WL quick.
I can see from where this thread is going that USAPL will always remain the elite pro league in the game. I don't like it, but that ultimately does not matter in the grad scheme of things. The inferior regions will never close the gap on USAPL because the perception of USAPL is not going to change. USA will own the WL and up-and-coming teams will want to be a part of that and not the underdog OPL, SEAPL, etc. I honestly did not know why I thought it could be any different.
Luke, do you think I'm pushing a USAPL-first bias? I'm not, no reason to and really don't get why the system I support would lead you to think that. You want four teams from each region each season, period. I want the best to stay regardless of home region with two from each getting a chance to join each season. Yeah, it may for a while be USAPL heavy, but it may also be OPL heavy at some point in the future, or EEPL, or whatever. I just don't want to sacrifice competition - potentially the best this game has seen - just to make each region feel loved.
I don't think it supports USAPL bias, but it doesn't change the perception of USAPL either. I will try to explain what I am thinking...
If I have a player that the top OPL team and top USAPL teams both want and I see that the WL is composed of 15+ USA teams, which region do you think I am going to choose for my player? USA teams do better in the WL, so I will assume I have a better chance at winning in the WL with the USA team. See how this leads to USA remaining the preferred region?
Maybe we will be surprised and WEPL will rise up and dominate the WL, but the odds are that USA will rule supreme, have four playoff teams, and 6 teams in the WL for Season 12 (and very likely 8 teams for Season 13). As long as agents see USAPL as the easiest avenue for their players getting to the WL and staying there, they will choose USAPL over any other region that wants their players. I hope I am wrong, but it is what it is.
A simpler way of putting this is that with the system turnit is supporting there is equal opportunity to reach the WPL, however the stronger FA's will still go to USAPL and they will therefore have a huge advantage to stay in the WPL having better players. Who cares about getting an easy pass to the WPL if there is no shot at competing and staying there because all the top notch recruits are still going to USAPL.





























