User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > A WPL WITHOUT MM-OFGand WW IS BS
Page:
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Deserving means nothing if they don't have to play their way into the WL through a tournament - all deserving means in the absence of a tournament is subjective opinion. We all know the story about opinions though.......


Ok, use the Pro World Tournament Elite 8, use the Hazy's GLB Addicts Trounament Elite 8. There is your tourney.

 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Deserving means nothing if they don't have to play their way into the WL through a tournament - all deserving means in the absence of a tournament is subjective opinion. We all know the story about opinions though.......


They play their way into the WL through a tournament.
It's called "playoffs".
 
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Originally posted by Tony Dungy


I think some are saying that balancing the leagues is just as important as having the top teams together

taking all USAPL teams means that no one currently in APL, EE, or SEA will EVER be able to recruit the best players and be the #1 team in the game.

It will take 4-5 seasons of relegations for there to be even 2-3 top teams relegated there and odds are that the recruiting of those teams would go way down and they might have to gut unless it is a Evil Monkeys or Benitos that somehow gets relegated there. Even then, we all saw how recruiting for a elite team like WSI withered in 1 season.



Like I said - people can't have it both ways. They either want the best teams in there or they don't - and if that means 10 teams from 1 league EARN their way there so be it. The world won't stop revolving if USA AAA has to send 10 teams to cover the vacancies in USA Pro - any more than what is happening with teams getting promoted 3 levels in the Minors.


I think balancing the leagues is more important than having the best teams. I've never tried to have it both ways.

Otherwise, we might as well just make USPL the top tier and CPL and SLAP the 2nd tier and EE, SEA, APL, and OPL as the 3rd tier. Many in WEPL don't want to be in the WPL system so move WEPL to their own league. Might as well do it that way then, right?

 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by PackMan97

Originally posted by taurran


When it comes to hard facts, not human opinion, the teams that won playoff games are the most deserving.


That's your opinion.


And yours is yours, nothing more.


Actually, winning official playoff games is anything but opinion.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
How is winning playoff games human opinion?

I'm curious how you came up with that.


Because that is your opinion of "deserving".

Some of us think that league strength matters. You don't. That's your opinion.

The fact is with your plan, about half of the best teams in GLB will be sitting in their Pro Leagues while a bunch of undeserving (but playoff victorious teams) get the crap beat out of them in the World League next season.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

I think some are saying that balancing the leagues is just as important as having the top teams together

taking all USAPL teams means that no one currently in APL, EE, or SEA will EVER be able to recruit the best players and be the #1 team in the game.

It will take 4-5 seasons of relegations for there to be even 2-3 top teams relegated there and odds are that the recruiting of those teams would go way down and they might have to gut unless it is a Evil Monkeys or Benitos that somehow gets relegated there. Even then, we all saw how recruiting for a elite team like WSI withered in 1 season.


wat?

Talent will spread out if making the World League is the new goal, teams will flock to weaker leagues to make the World League.

It won't take 4-5 seasons of relegation if you do it right. It would take one. This isn't about how demotion/promotion works. Pretty much everyone agrees, non-playoff teams go down, league finalists go up. 16 down, 16 up. There will be plenty of churn to get new blood in the World League.

This is about how you want the World League to start. Do you want it to be the best of the best, or just some of the best?


Not everything is best of the best, though.

In the 2008-09 UEFA champions league, yeah, there was Barcelona, Manchester United, but there was also BATE, Dynamo Kyiv, and Werder Bremen. 2006 NCAA Men's tourney noticeably had George Mason in the final four despite them choking in the CAA tourney and needing an at-large bid to get in as the 11 seed. And in the 2009 Orange Bowl - you really think Cincinnati was the best team in the Big East, on paper?

But that's what it is. On paper. You can get the best teams on paper but eventually everything is going to be settled on the dotball field. You can't argue with an L, even how better the teams may be. Ask the 2007 Patriots.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by greengoose

Deserving means nothing if they don't have to play their way into the WL through a tournament - all deserving means in the absence of a tournament is subjective opinion. We all know the story about opinions though.......


Ok, use the Pro World Tournament Elite 8, use the Hazy's GLB Addicts Trounament Elite 8. There is your tourney.




Because it will still make all the players want to play in USPL only? Are you not getting that point we keep saying?
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by taurran

How is winning playoff games human opinion?

I'm curious how you came up with that.


Because that is your opinion of "deserving".

Some of us think that league strength matters. You don't. That's your opinion.

The fact is with your plan, about half of the best teams in GLB will be sitting in their Pro Leagues while a bunch of undeserving (but playoff victorious teams) get the crap beat out of them in the World League next season.


Playoffs are the official method of ranking in GLB, not user polls.

They are not the opinion of anyone, they're a mechanic of the game.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Actually, winning official playoff games is anything but opinion.


No, but claiming it is the only/best way to seed the World League is most definitely an opinion.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Balancing the leagues is a UTOPIAN idea - and one not worth chasing IMHO. Leagues within the same region are balanced and they are done so by teams playing their way to the top.

The reality is to balance the leagues you'd have to put limits on the ability of FA's to move - and that should never happen.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by taurran

Actually, winning official playoff games is anything but opinion.


No, but claiming it is the only/best way to seed the World League is most definitely an opinion.


and a flawed one considering teams like OFG, WW, and MM are among the top 16 teams in the game.
Claiming otherwise Taurran?

Pick a team from out of the country, but not in the 'top 16'. I'll personally DC one more game for the Wolfpack just to ensure we'll kick the shit out of them. Put the bid on the line.

We lost to one foreign team all season. Marblehead, 19-17. Marblehead, the team that went to the PWT finals, the team that just beat Drygerian. We defeated each and every other foreign team this season.

Am I bitter? Mostly because Bort said 'hey lets just have an official tournament' instead...and now is allowing for a waffle. This, more then the initial possibility this was going to happen, is infuriating.

tl, dr version: I'm honestly mad the Wolfpack aren't going, but what put me over the edge is Bort's waffling on the implementation post announcement.
Edited by islander1 on Jul 28, 2009 07:45:40
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by taurran

How is winning playoff games human opinion?

I'm curious how you came up with that.


Because that is your opinion of "deserving".

Some of us think that league strength matters. You don't. That's your opinion.

The fact is with your plan, about half of the best teams in GLB will be sitting in their Pro Leagues while a bunch of undeserving (but playoff victorious teams) get the crap beat out of them in the World League next season.


You realize that they would have the same recruiting chances as a USPL team this offseason also for the first time too? Maybe they get enough talent to catch up to the USPL teams. Ever think of that?

I think the main thing some people are going to complain about is losing that recruiting tool that they have had for the last 2 to 8 seasons: "come play in the best league in GLB....USA PRO!"

Especially when free agents only have 1 or 2 seasons left. Come join the other 7/8ths of the game in not having that advantage?
Edited by Tony Dungy on Jul 28, 2009 08:34:33
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by greengoose

Deserving means nothing if they don't have to play their way into the WL through a tournament - all deserving means in the absence of a tournament is subjective opinion. We all know the story about opinions though.......


They play their way into the WL through a tournament.
It's called "playoffs".


Playoffs which are limited to your own league mean nothing when you talk about forming a league from a bunch of different leagues.

It's why the Scottish Premiership only has 1 automatic bid to the Champions league - because the Scottish Premiership is about as weak as a Premiership league can be in European Football.

Would you really rather have Celtic in the Champions League rather than Chelsea, Arsenal or even Everton?

Edited by greengoose on Jul 28, 2009 07:51:20
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

I think the main thing some people are going to complain about is losing that recruiting tool that they have had for the last 10 seasons: "come play in the best league in GLB....USA PRO!"

I HAVE IT ON GOOD AUTHORITY THAT THERE ARE MANY TEAMS THAT HAVE BEEN IN USA PRO FOR THE LAST 10 SEASONS. DOZENS OF THEM IN FACT.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by PackMan97

Originally posted by taurran


Actually, winning official playoff games is anything but opinion.


No, but claiming it is the only/best way to seed the World League is most definitely an opinion.


and a flawed one considering teams like OFG, WW, and MM are among the top 16 teams in the game.
Claiming otherwise Taurran?

Pick a team from out of the country, but not in the 'top 16'. I'll personally DC one more game for the Wolfpack just to ensure we'll kick the shit out of them. Put the bid on the line.

We lost to one foreign team all season. Marblehead, 19-17. Marblehead, the team that went to the PWT finals, the team that just beat Drygerian. We defeated each and every other foreign team this season.

Am I bitter? Mostly because Bort said 'hey lets just have an official tournament' instead...and now is allowing for a waffle. This, more then the initial possibility this was going to happen, is infuriating.

tl, dr version: I'm honestly mad the Wolfpack aren't going, but what put me over the edge is Bort's waffling on the implementation post announcement.



Didn't Painmaker say that he was fine with not being in the WPL after you guys lost? I seem to recall saying that he didn't want to "back in"?

The only thing that I didn't think was fair was that USA Pro teams didn't have a choice to pick a easier league after they found out that the WPL was going to happen for sure.

Are you in favor of waiting one more season and allowing teams to move this offseason knowing what the new structure will be?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.