User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by tautology

From earlier today:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=344901&pbp_id=231675


If that's not gang tackling, i don't know what would be...


That's not gang tackling, that's him bouncing off guys until one brings him down, Gang tackling is all those guys grabbing hold of him and stopping him in place instead of hoping that one will eventually bring him down.


Yeap. It's nothing more than a series of 1 vs 1s, where the HB won out on the first 3 or 4.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by tautology


From earlier today:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=344901&pbp_id=231675


If that's not gang tackling, i don't know what would be...


That's not gang tackling, that's him bouncing off guys until one brings him down, Gang tackling is all those guys grabbing hold of him and stopping him in place instead of hoping that one will eventually bring him down.


each tackle attempt is a separate roll for each defender. Bort himself said that is how it works, although the RB's "balance" is effected each time he breaks a tackle (making each subsequent defender more likely to bring down the runner). Gang tackling IMO would be a single roll where the defenders 'stack' attributes in a combined attempt to bring the runner down if they are both within their tackling radius. Big difference.


Big difference indeed...possibly big enough to end all inside running games.

That would be sad. Especially since the all-speed teams would not need to do much...just get faster so they can put more bodies on the HB.

 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by tautology

From earlier today:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=344901&pbp_id=231675


If that's not gang tackling, i don't know what would be...


That's guys swarming to the ball. That's not at all gang tackling. That is a gang trying to tackle.


LOL, +1
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Tautology if anything that's an example of SWARM defense not gang tackling.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Tautology if anything that's an example of SWARM defense not gang tackling.


Agreed, but the effect is similar.

Iceman16 had the best line though
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 22:59:18
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by schrauben8542

70 strength
70 tackling
50 speed
50 agility
50 vision
40 confidence

With pertinent SA's as well included should be able to bring down this power back. My issue is when they are breaking tackle after tackle on the same play. Then on the next play they break more tackles than the play before.

There needs to be a formula that takes into account stamina and reduces their chance to break a tackle after each broken tackle on the same play, consecutive plays, etc. The chance/ability of breaking a tackle should lessen the more it happens.


There is a formula. It's ITT. Less tackles are broken per play for each successive BrTk.


as bort described it, there's a balance rating the ball carrier has. when he's hit, it's negatively affected. if he's tackled well, it hits zero, and he goes down. if he breaks the tackle, it's only lowered, making the next attempt easier.
if he has time to right his ship before the next tackle attempt, it corrects back to default.

of course, were it that simple, this wouldnt happen:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=287405&pbp_id=12955880

because things like morale and energy play into it as well.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by jrry32

Tautology if anything that's an example of SWARM defense not gang tackling.


Agreed, but the effect is similar.


Yes and no, on gang tackling they'd work together and no RB is going to break free from 5 guys pulling him down while on that play it was not out of the realm of possibilities that he breaks the FS's tackle and gets a big gain.

 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by jdros13

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by tautology



From earlier today:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=344901&pbp_id=231675


If that's not gang tackling, i don't know what would be...


That's not gang tackling, that's him bouncing off guys until one brings him down, Gang tackling is all those guys grabbing hold of him and stopping him in place instead of hoping that one will eventually bring him down.


each tackle attempt is a separate roll for each defender. Bort himself said that is how it works, although the RB's "balance" is effected each time he breaks a tackle (making each subsequent defender more likely to bring down the runner). Gang tackling IMO would be a single roll where the defenders 'stack' attributes in a combined attempt to bring the runner down if they are both within their tackling radius. Big difference.


Big difference indeed...possibly big enough to end all inside running games.

That would be sad. Especially since the all-speed teams would not need to do much...just get faster so they can put more bodies on the HB.



it wouldnt stop inside running games at all...holes would still be made...rb's would still be powerful or fast enough to plow through...they just wouldnt be able to constantly fend off 4 Dlineman and 3 LB's on their way to 7-10 yard gains in a battle of 1 vs 1 at all times.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by schrauben8542


70 strength
70 tackling
50 speed
50 agility
50 vision
40 confidence

With pertinent SA's as well included should be able to bring down this power back. My issue is when they are breaking tackle after tackle on the same play. Then on the next play they break more tackles than the play before.

There needs to be a formula that takes into account stamina and reduces their chance to break a tackle after each broken tackle on the same play, consecutive plays, etc. The chance/ability of breaking a tackle should lessen the more it happens.


There is a formula. It's ITT. Less tackles are broken per play for each successive BrTk.


as bort described it, there's a balance rating the ball carrier has. when he's hit, it's negatively affected. if he's tackled well, it hits zero, and he goes down. if he breaks the tackle, it's only lowered, making the next attempt easier.
if he has time to right his ship before the next tackle attempt, it corrects back to default.

of course, were it that simple, this wouldnt happen:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=287405&pbp_id=12955880

because things like morale and energy play into it as well.


I think that the tackling from behind mechanics for powerbacks may be a bit wonky...god help you if he gets out in front beuase they are murder to bring down from behind.
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
well anyways, going off to bed. But I will leave with this:

It is funny seeing people bitch about power RB's breaking too many tackles, when on the other hand now that the new VA's have come out, I see this topic in a private LB forum that I am in:

"Days of low tackling are over"


So apparently the builders of LBs understand that they have low tackling compared to the rest of their build. Like I have said, I have never had a problem with any of my players missing more than a handful of tackles a season. But because some level 18 CB misses tackles all the time they want to come to the forums and bitch about it. When my players started missing tackles when they were level 10-20 I increased strength and tackling. Sure I sacrificed speed/agility/vision, but guess what they stopped missing tackles.

So figure out what you would rather have. Miss tackles but get to the play quickly, Make all tackles but get to the play slowly, or a balance of the two. Its not that difficult.
 
The Lurker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by jdros13


Originally posted by jrry32



Originally posted by tautology




From earlier today:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=344901&pbp_id=231675


If that's not gang tackling, i don't know what would be...


That's not gang tackling, that's him bouncing off guys until one brings him down, Gang tackling is all those guys grabbing hold of him and stopping him in place instead of hoping that one will eventually bring him down.


each tackle attempt is a separate roll for each defender. Bort himself said that is how it works, although the RB's "balance" is effected each time he breaks a tackle (making each subsequent defender more likely to bring down the runner). Gang tackling IMO would be a single roll where the defenders 'stack' attributes in a combined attempt to bring the runner down if they are both within their tackling radius. Big difference.


Big difference indeed...possibly big enough to end all inside running games.

That would be sad. Especially since the all-speed teams would not need to do much...just get faster so they can put more bodies on the HB.



it wouldnt stop inside running games at all...holes would still be made...rb's would still be powerful or fast enough to plow through...they just wouldnt be able to constantly fend off 4 Dlineman and 3 LB's on their way to 7-10 yard gains in a battle of 1 vs 1 at all times.


You could also incorporate the ability to drag defenders and actually fall forward at the end of runs, which power backs usually do.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 23:04:20
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Lurker


You could also incorporate the ability to drag defenders and actually fall forward at the end of runs, which power backs usually do.


which is the proposed solution earlier in the thread....bort loved the idea...he loved the thought of dots dragging dots...wouldnt be surprised to see it added soon...
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by jrry32

Tautology if anything that's an example of SWARM defense not gang tackling.


Agreed, but the effect is similar.

Iceman16 had the best line though


Redemption .

I get sidetracked way too easily.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by schrauben8542


70 strength
70 tackling
50 speed
50 agility
50 vision
40 confidence

With pertinent SA's as well included should be able to bring down this power back. My issue is when they are breaking tackle after tackle on the same play. Then on the next play they break more tackles than the play before.

There needs to be a formula that takes into account stamina and reduces their chance to break a tackle after each broken tackle on the same play, consecutive plays, etc. The chance/ability of breaking a tackle should lessen the more it happens.


There is a formula. It's ITT. Less tackles are broken per play for each successive BrTk.


as bort described it, there's a balance rating the ball carrier has. when he's hit, it's negatively affected. if he's tackled well, it hits zero, and he goes down. if he breaks the tackle, it's only lowered, making the next attempt easier.
if he has time to right his ship before the next tackle attempt, it corrects back to default.

of course, were it that simple, this wouldnt happen:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=287405&pbp_id=12955880

because things like morale and energy play into it as well.


So are you saying that it's wrong or it could be better, or are you telling him what Bort said?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Bort



How do you define "elusive" or "power" back for this, though? Just based on their running style?


Well, elusive broken tackles and power broken tackles are calculated differently ain't they? Maybe it should be "power moves" and "elusive moves" instead of "power/elusive back".


Elusive guys don't really break tackles except for spinning - they avoid contact entirely with fakes and such. Breaking tackles is a power back thing.

Maybe just

Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked


Wouldn't this just boil down to "okay guys, this week's game is against a team with a power back. Everyone set to power tackle... *snore*"...

Doesn't seem like anything substantial is being added to the game. Maybe something is being lost as well IMO.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.