User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is some BS..INT out of bounds lost our game
Page:
 
firehazard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Originally posted by firehazard

Yep, that's what I was referring to. INTs in the endzone don't result in a touchback as it should. Not sure how "spouting" comes into play here, but whatever floats your boat.


Its spouting because your factoid, be it true or nor, does not apply here. In GLB, a play is either reported via the text as incomplete, interception, or as a gain or loss. It is not reported as both an interception and incomplete. So your opinion that interceptions are incomplete is spouting. If you could show me one time where a play is reported as both interception and incomplete when the ball was not out the back or near the back of the endzone I would give your arguments some weight.

My second reason for calling it spouting is that you showed up in that thread to say your little unhelpful opinion and then never checked back on the thread. If you had, you would have seen Bort claim that they play should have been ruled incomplete. Then you would have shared that knowledge with us. No, you are not being helpful to this thread or that, so kindly take your own advice and move along.


Wow, talk about some pent up hostility. Don't forget that this is a game and you need to be a bit more light hearted. I don't have time to check up on every thread I've ever replied to considering this forum is lacking that capability like most of the popular forum applications available these days.

It appears that both interceptions in question also say that it's "incomplete," most likely due to buggy coding. So we've seen 2 interceptions in endzones which result in the exact same behavior. I'd say that's pretty good evidence what's happening here. You show me an interception in the endzone which does not result in a "incomplete" in the text, and then I'd say that there might be something fishy here. As it is, the only bug is that the play did not result in a touchback.

You should spend less time here and more time scouring the internet for more girl on girl porn. Maybe that would lighten you up a bit.
 
rivergato
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by firehazard


So we've seen 2 interceptions in endzones which result in the exact same behavior. I'd say that's pretty good evidence what's happening here. You show me an interception in the endzone which does not result in a "incomplete" in the text, and then I'd say that there might be something fishy here.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84870&pbp_id=3580072

 
firehazard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rivergato
Originally posted by firehazard



So we've seen 2 interceptions in endzones which result in the exact same behavior. I'd say that's pretty good evidence what's happening here. You show me an interception in the endzone which does not result in a "incomplete" in the text, and then I'd say that there might be something fishy here.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84870&pbp_id=3580072



He wasn't downed in the endzone... You do see the difference, right?
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Firehazard, you have completely misread me. Don't mistake cold logic for pent up hostility. I get to spend my hostility every weekend playing Dagorhir. Do a web search and then predictably come and mock me.


As per your request about interceptions in the endzone, there are plenty to choose from, I hope this one will satiate you.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=89783&pbp_id=5257764


The bug is the ball was intercepted out of bounds and should have been reported as incomplete. If you read the thread that I posted a while ago, you will see that Bort agrees with me. I can either take your word for it, a suspected board troll, or I can take Bort's word for it, the confirmed owner/creator/coder for the game.

I appreciate your bumping this thread with your pithy nuances, but I think your work here is done.
Last edited Sep 2, 2008 08:01:21
 
rivergato
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by firehazard

He wasn't downed in the endzone... You do see the difference, right?


What's your point? You didnt ask for that.

Interception in the end zone, example provided.
No incomplete in text, example provided.
Now it has to be touchback material?

I originally thought it an interception, with mistake output read of [incompletion] and mistake down placement of a turnover ball. Example provided earlier by Jose, with a linked thread of a similar play, which contains a response provided by the person who actually knows the code to the game, has proven me wrong.
I was wrong. You should find it not hard to admit to also.

 
TheBuckmister
offline
Link
 
It's a bug, regardless of what random people are claiming. Hopefully Bort will take a look at this for you guys, though I doubt it. The lack of bug attention is pretty disturbing sometimes...
 
meathead013
offline
Link
 
firehazard set to mental ignore
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
Bort still hasn't looked at this?
 
Stokes36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kalkmanc
Bort still hasn't looked at this?


It would appear as such
 
CROC
offline
Link
 
BUMP
 
Jarrik
offline
Link
 
Atleast your team hasnt gone undefeated 3 regular seasons in the row with absolutly no compition to lose in the playoffs.
 
guzzdude
offline
Link
 
Maybe he intercepted it and tried to throw it and the receiver dropped the ball. That's my only off the wall guess (and not helpful at all).
 
rc_ziggy84
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg

1. Interceptions ARE considered incompletions.
2. The 2D view is not accurate.

Move along.


i buy that this is a bug. in real life yes interceptions are incompletions, but in this game in have a suspicion that incomplete only occurs when a pass hits the ground (aka no one catches it.) why do i believe this? well you never see "incomplete" listed after any other interceptions. the logic that follows is that an "incomplete pass" is recorded when a ball hits the ground.

so the fact that we see interception and incomplete most likely means that both happened and is indeed a bug. sorry man.
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
bort, stop ignoring your customers
 
po
offline
Link
 
This is pretty messed up.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.