Well first there should be a no XP gain for playing out of positions unless it's similiar, Safetys, D-Line, etc. Have it so a Kicker/Punter can't be a QB/X position. That would cut down people trying to exploit this.
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Player goes up 8 levels in 4 games and 17 levels in 13 games
Robbnva
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Bort
How 'bout if you can only get XP for kicking/punting if you are actually a K/P...and set a limit on the number of kicks/punts that count, like 5 of each?
bad idea in my opinion
Why? Seems like a WR playing at K shouldn't be able to get K experience, since that kinda sounds exploity. Play your own position!
Or are you just against the cap of kicks that count?
cap at kick count is my problem. I agree a WR playing kicker should be saved for a scrimmage where no XP is gained. Look at my punter
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=700498
he is getting plenty of punts because he is on a bad team NO fishy stuff going on and his leveling should suffer because of 2 people?
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Bort
How 'bout if you can only get XP for kicking/punting if you are actually a K/P...and set a limit on the number of kicks/punts that count, like 5 of each?
bad idea in my opinion
Why? Seems like a WR playing at K shouldn't be able to get K experience, since that kinda sounds exploity. Play your own position!

Or are you just against the cap of kicks that count?
cap at kick count is my problem. I agree a WR playing kicker should be saved for a scrimmage where no XP is gained. Look at my punter
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=700498
he is getting plenty of punts because he is on a bad team NO fishy stuff going on and his leveling should suffer because of 2 people?
Last edited Aug 28, 2008 11:47:49
Robbnva
offline
offline
Originally posted by dano6482
Originally posted by Robbnva
did you know there were NFL GREATS who actually played multiple positions? A lot of old timers played Kicker AND something else, or Punter AND something else. This game is supposed to be fun so why ruin it for somebody who wants to experiment and see if they can create those kind of players in GLB
Did you know no NFL team has ever kicked or punted like those teams are doing?
fine bort can easily add no FG kicking on 1st, 2nd, and 3rd down unless you are in FG range and losing.
Originally posted by Robbnva
did you know there were NFL GREATS who actually played multiple positions? A lot of old timers played Kicker AND something else, or Punter AND something else. This game is supposed to be fun so why ruin it for somebody who wants to experiment and see if they can create those kind of players in GLB
Did you know no NFL team has ever kicked or punted like those teams are doing?
fine bort can easily add no FG kicking on 1st, 2nd, and 3rd down unless you are in FG range and losing.
Footballmike
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Bort
How 'bout if you can only get XP for kicking/punting if you are actually a K/P...and set a limit on the number of kicks/punts that count, like 5 of each?
bad idea in my opinion
Why? Seems like a WR playing at K shouldn't be able to get K experience, since that kinda sounds exploity. Play your own position!
Or are you just against the cap of kicks that count?
meh let them play duel positions if they want.....theres a penalty already for playing out of position right?
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Bort
How 'bout if you can only get XP for kicking/punting if you are actually a K/P...and set a limit on the number of kicks/punts that count, like 5 of each?
bad idea in my opinion
Why? Seems like a WR playing at K shouldn't be able to get K experience, since that kinda sounds exploity. Play your own position!

Or are you just against the cap of kicks that count?
meh let them play duel positions if they want.....theres a penalty already for playing out of position right?
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
How 'bout if you can only get XP for kicking/punting if you are actually a K/P...and set a limit on the number of kicks/punts that count, like 5 of each?
Bort,
this would be the most fair solution.
Give punters and kickers full exp every game, provided they are the only player at the position.
why should any kicker or punter be disadvantaged by being on a great team?
My own punter is on a team where he typically punts twice a game. if it were not for special teams return snaps (like 5 to 10 a game) I'd be getting like 50 exp a game. What's the point in playing for that?
How 'bout if you can only get XP for kicking/punting if you are actually a K/P...and set a limit on the number of kicks/punts that count, like 5 of each?
Bort,
this would be the most fair solution.
Give punters and kickers full exp every game, provided they are the only player at the position.
why should any kicker or punter be disadvantaged by being on a great team?
My own punter is on a team where he typically punts twice a game. if it were not for special teams return snaps (like 5 to 10 a game) I'd be getting like 50 exp a game. What's the point in playing for that?
Robbnva
offline
offline
Originally posted by Savage Smurf
Well first there should be a no XP gain for playing out of positions unless it's similiar, Safetys, D-Line, etc. Have it so a Kicker/Punter can't be a QB/X position. That would cut down people trying to exploit this.
do you see any teams of punters? NO nobody is trying to exploit this.
Well first there should be a no XP gain for playing out of positions unless it's similiar, Safetys, D-Line, etc. Have it so a Kicker/Punter can't be a QB/X position. That would cut down people trying to exploit this.
do you see any teams of punters? NO nobody is trying to exploit this.
Savage Smurf
offline
offline
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Savage Smurf
Well first there should be a no XP gain for playing out of positions unless it's similiar, Safetys, D-Line, etc. Have it so a Kicker/Punter can't be a QB/X position. That would cut down people trying to exploit this.
do you see any teams of punters? NO nobody is trying to exploit this.
People will. Because this idea is obviously getting out. You don't understand what looking into the future is do you?
Originally posted by Savage Smurf
Well first there should be a no XP gain for playing out of positions unless it's similiar, Safetys, D-Line, etc. Have it so a Kicker/Punter can't be a QB/X position. That would cut down people trying to exploit this.
do you see any teams of punters? NO nobody is trying to exploit this.
People will. Because this idea is obviously getting out. You don't understand what looking into the future is do you?
nightmaresabin
offline
offline
It's kinda tricky. I know my punter has had several games with 0 punts because we played so well, thus getting very small xp. I wouldn't want him to be screwed out of good xp when we have a bad game just to stop some exploiters.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by nightmaresabin
It's kinda tricky. I know my punter has had several games with 0 punts because we played so well, thus getting very small xp. I wouldn't want him to be screwed out of good xp when we have a bad game just to stop some exploiters.
This is exactly my point!
Punters have no control over their playing time. They are the starter without a backup...yet one game his team needs him for 5 punts, then only once the next two games.
It's kinda tricky. I know my punter has had several games with 0 punts because we played so well, thus getting very small xp. I wouldn't want him to be screwed out of good xp when we have a bad game just to stop some exploiters.
This is exactly my point!
Punters have no control over their playing time. They are the starter without a backup...yet one game his team needs him for 5 punts, then only once the next two games.
Forbin
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Bort
How 'bout if you can only get XP for kicking/punting if you are actually a K/P...and set a limit on the number of kicks/punts that count, like 5 of each?
bad idea in my opinion
Why? Seems like a WR playing at K shouldn't be able to get K experience, since that kinda sounds exploity. Play your own position!
Or are you just against the cap of kicks that count?
All that needs to happen is to drastically lower the exp ceiling for K/P. It should be just a little more than other positions, but you shouldn't be able to get exp at kicker, then on top of that, 50 regular snaps.
That, and de-leveling the people that have exploited this. Without de-leveling those people, all you're doing is handing them those free levels.
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Bort
How 'bout if you can only get XP for kicking/punting if you are actually a K/P...and set a limit on the number of kicks/punts that count, like 5 of each?
bad idea in my opinion
Why? Seems like a WR playing at K shouldn't be able to get K experience, since that kinda sounds exploity. Play your own position!

Or are you just against the cap of kicks that count?
All that needs to happen is to drastically lower the exp ceiling for K/P. It should be just a little more than other positions, but you shouldn't be able to get exp at kicker, then on top of that, 50 regular snaps.
That, and de-leveling the people that have exploited this. Without de-leveling those people, all you're doing is handing them those free levels.
Robbnva
offline
offline
so then punters and kickers max XP at every gave regardless of the performance and set it to whatever the average is per level for other positions. No other penalties needed as playing out of position will not earn you any extra XP.
6Kings
offline
offline
Count the punter as the holder for PAT's and FG's, that way if your team is scoring all day the punter gets play credit for each score.
Forbin
offline
offline
Originally posted by Robbnva
so then punters and kickers max XP at every gave regardless of the performance and set it to whatever the average is per level for other positions. No other penalties needed as playing out of position will not earn you any extra XP.
I wouldn't mind that. It's pretty sad for a punter on a team that dominates their league.
If not, at least grant a base XP amount for K and P, say 75% of max, then if they kick X times, they slowly go past that mark until they hit the max.
so then punters and kickers max XP at every gave regardless of the performance and set it to whatever the average is per level for other positions. No other penalties needed as playing out of position will not earn you any extra XP.
I wouldn't mind that. It's pretty sad for a punter on a team that dominates their league.
If not, at least grant a base XP amount for K and P, say 75% of max, then if they kick X times, they slowly go past that mark until they hit the max.
Robbnva
offline
offline
I just thought about my poor kicker who is on a bad team and has a few games where he didn't even get to kick a FG let alone an XP
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Robbnva
so then punters and kickers max XP at every gave regardless of the performance and set it to whatever the average is per level for other positions. No other penalties needed as playing out of position will not earn you any extra XP.
Exactly what I've said above. Simple solution. If two punters split punts, then the max experience is split. This will prevent teams from power farming multiple punters off of one punt a game.
so then punters and kickers max XP at every gave regardless of the performance and set it to whatever the average is per level for other positions. No other penalties needed as playing out of position will not earn you any extra XP.
Exactly what I've said above. Simple solution. If two punters split punts, then the max experience is split. This will prevent teams from power farming multiple punters off of one punt a game.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























