User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Using teams as "growth vats" for a single individual player
Page:
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
Yay, semantics!

May I, without further ceremony, invite the pair of you to shut up because it doesn't matter?


If you want either of them to shut up you're going to need further ceremony
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
I'm done.

Back on topic - you simply won't convince me that exploiting the game is even remotely 'right' - but seeing as the precedent has been set by the alpha testers and the game designers have never bothered closing the loopholes that continue to be abused, then I'm not naieve enough to think that it won't go on.

As I say, it's not the way I do things, but maybe I'm just old fashioned and have a more acute sense of right and wrong...........
 
upsair
offline
Link
 
seriously tho if you want this issue or any other major issue fixed with this game they need to hire a moderator that will handle these problems as there sole job. bort is probably overwhelmed with whatever it is hes doing atm. how many times have you seen a significant post, update or homepage warning from him this season? hes even went inactive during the season, its time for an enforcer to be brought in to keep the kiddies in line and drop some bans. just my 2cents
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
I'm done.

Back on topic - you simply won't convince me that exploiting the game is even remotely 'right' - but seeing as the precedent has been set by the alpha testers and the game designers have never bothered closing the loopholes that continue to be abused, then I'm not naieve enough to think that it won't go on.

As I say, it's not the way I do things, but maybe I'm just old fashioned and have a more acute sense of right and wrong...........


'Exploiting' grey and unorthodox areas of the game are part of the very nature of competition. If it is not explicitly disallowed, either by big flashing instructions of 'do not do this or be punished' or by changes to the game code, then it's fair game as far as I'm concerned.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando


'Exploiting' grey and unorthodox areas of the game are part of the very nature of competition. If it is not explicitly disallowed, either by big flashing instructions of 'do not do this or be punished' or by changes to the game code, then it's fair game as far as I'm concerned.


Again - I tend to agree in part. But there are certain loopholes (min/max builds for EG) that get closed whilst these get left open. But the caveat still remains that certain, largely un-named things, are considered to be against the spirit of the game, hence classed as cheating.

Thing is, as no-one has defined cheating explicitly, then people will continue to push the grey areas.

Decide whether this is a game or a simulation. Stop changing the rules (ie game mechanics) half way through seasons and just let people get on and play the game, knowing that what they do this week will also work next week, the player they build this year will also work next year, etc, etc..........

Either that, or tell everyone what is and isn't allowed and punish those that break the rules, no matter who they are and who they know........
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
It's a game, not a simulation. And change is always necessary to keep things fresh and balanced. When player build and tactics loopholes are closed, the penalty for walking so close to the cutting edge is that when things change it's harder to adapt. It's a risk that some are willing to take, others not so. But to remove any capacity for future change will result in a stale game, so I can't agree with such things.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Have drifter repost the topic so we can get some feedback.

I will not rest until these asshats have been banned.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
Originally posted by 1VBChaos

I'm done.

Back on topic - you simply won't convince me that exploiting the game is even remotely 'right' - but seeing as the precedent has been set by the alpha testers and the game designers have never bothered closing the loopholes that continue to be abused, then I'm not naieve enough to think that it won't go on.

As I say, it's not the way I do things, but maybe I'm just old fashioned and have a more acute sense of right and wrong...........


'Exploiting' grey and unorthodox areas of the game are part of the very nature of competition. If it is not explicitly disallowed, either by big flashing instructions of 'do not do this or be punished' or by changes to the game code, then it's fair game as far as I'm concerned.


This is not a gray area. This is abusing a fix that was put in to help another area and you cannot make any argument that people doing this are playing withing the bounds of what any normal person would call fairness
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
This is not a gray area. This is abusing a fix that was put in to help another area and you cannot make any argument that people doing this are playing withing the bounds of what any normal person would call fairness


(I'm not stalking you drifter, I promise)

I think this *is* a grey area for two reasons:

1. There are no clearly posted rules about what is, and is not allowed. For example, is it an exploit to have your kicker play on ST to get more XP? Most would say "no". But is it an exploit to have your kicker attempt a field goal every single set of downs to power level the player? That's much more dubious and in my opinion an exploit. But currently there's no black-and-white set of rules.

2. Admins have been inconsistent in how they handle exploiters. Sometimes people get banned, and sometimes they just get a slap on the wrist.
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Seems like leagues need a "homeowners association"-type policy.

There are reasons I can't paint my house with polka dots. There are consequences.

It seems that f'ing up a league for 15 other teams has no consequences.


Originally posted by Vando
It's a game, not a simulation.


Um, no. This game IS a simulation. Says so on the main page.
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 09:26:52
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by drifter

This is not a gray area. This is abusing a fix that was put in to help another area and you cannot make any argument that people doing this are playing withing the bounds of what any normal person would call fairness


(I'm not stalking you drifter, I promise)

I think this *is* a grey area for two reasons:

1. There are no clearly posted rules about what is, and is not allowed. For example, is it an exploit to have your kicker play on ST to get more XP? Most would say "no". But is it an exploit to have your kicker attempt a field goal every single set of downs to power level the player? That's much more dubious and in my opinion an exploit. But currently there's no black-and-white set of rules.

2. Admins have been inconsistent in how they handle exploiters. Sometimes people get banned, and sometimes they just get a slap on the wrist.


Until Bort changes something to stop it happening, it's fair game. I think most of us agree that putting a stop to it through the engine is the best method, but these things take time.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by drifter

This is not a gray area. This is abusing a fix that was put in to help another area and you cannot make any argument that people doing this are playing withing the bounds of what any normal person would call fairness


(I'm not stalking you drifter, I promise)

I think this *is* a grey area for two reasons:

1. There are no clearly posted rules about what is, and is not allowed. For example, is it an exploit to have your kicker play on ST to get more XP? Most would say "no". But is it an exploit to have your kicker attempt a field goal every single set of downs to power level the player? That's much more dubious and in my opinion an exploit. But currently there's no black-and-white set of rules.

2. Admins have been inconsistent in how they handle exploiters. Sometimes people get banned, and sometimes they just get a slap on the wrist.


In my mind, because I 'think' it's running against the spirit of the rules, whether specified or not, I'd say it was an exploit. Little white lies are still lies, after all.... so I'm with Drifter on that.

Got to agree with Krunchy's second point though - inconsistency is what's making the problem far worse than it should be. As is the close association to 'shady' things by mods and aplha testers - it's constantly being brought up, yet no official word either way has ever been forthcoming.........

 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sois
Seems like leagues need a "homeowners association"-type policy.

There are reasons I can't paint my house with polka dots. There are consequences.

It seems that f'ing up a league for 15 other teams has no consequences.

It's not really fucking up the league for 15 other teams, maybe for one or two guys that think this is the NFL, but not for any reasonable players of the game.

Originally posted by
Originally posted by Vando

It's a game, not a simulation.


Um, no. This game IS a simulation. Says so on the main page.


And we're back to semantics again. Those arguments are the best, they're just so convincing...
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by Krunchy

Originally posted by drifter


This is not a gray area. This is abusing a fix that was put in to help another area and you cannot make any argument that people doing this are playing withing the bounds of what any normal person would call fairness


(I'm not stalking you drifter, I promise)

I think this *is* a grey area for two reasons:

1. There are no clearly posted rules about what is, and is not allowed. For example, is it an exploit to have your kicker play on ST to get more XP? Most would say "no". But is it an exploit to have your kicker attempt a field goal every single set of downs to power level the player? That's much more dubious and in my opinion an exploit. But currently there's no black-and-white set of rules.

2. Admins have been inconsistent in how they handle exploiters. Sometimes people get banned, and sometimes they just get a slap on the wrist.


In my mind, because I 'think' it's running against the spirit of the rules, whether specified or not, I'd say it was an exploit. Little white lies are still lies, after all.... so I'm with Drifter on that.

Got to agree with Krunchy's second point though - inconsistency is what's making the problem far worse than it should be. As is the close association to 'shady' things by mods and aplha testers - it's constantly being brought up, yet no official word either way has ever been forthcoming.........



No official word either way = it is fine.

Mods and alpha testers are long-time players of the game, accustomed to finding the finest of edges wherever possible. I'm really not surprised that they've gravitated towards methods that give good returns in this manner.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Vando - if it were 'fine' like you seem to think, then you wouldn't get quite so many people who think that the game is being exploited - it's not an isolated thing and, in all honesty, I do think that people who came here expecting a realistic and fair game are being driven away quicker than ever.

I'm afraid we'll always be in different camps.

You think it's fine, because you do it.

I don't think it's fine and I won't do it.

Anyway - nothing personal -

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.