User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America A Leagues > South America A #3 > South America A #3: The Committee's Pro Bowl Thread
Page:
 
MGood030
offline
Link
 
Um, I'm not a fan of team rep's.

Everyone deserves a voice, and they shall have one. This is nothing to get excited over yet, there are still three games to be played. Details will be ironed out when I have the time to put together a large list of choices.
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 17:37:05
 
lolShowtime
offline
Link
 
Yeah that was just copy pasted. Team reps dont have to vote. Everybody can, but that can just be the ballot. Just throwing out ideas.
 
MGood030
offline
Link
 
That Ballot can definatly be used. It would just have to be modified to fit the entire list of players on there.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Well, we were planning a team vote for the players that we choose. I'm not necessarily for a team rep though some teams will choose to do it this way. Basically, I believe limiting the votes is important for two reasons. 1.) The sanity of the person compiling the votes and 2.) to limit the effect of collusion or over representation.
 
PeeJJK
SM4LL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Like both of mine.

Out of all these people we've played LB Sidney Grapeshot from Belo Horizone was by far the single best player we've faced.

I don't see how you can pick HB Dexter Gonzalez after the egg he laid against us.

Would also like to nominate CB keiko minoru from San Cristobal Blaze
WR Crystal Aquarius and QB Kyoko Hasegawa-Ciudad del Este Golden Jaguars

Hm, I'll just wait an make a full list right before season's end.


thanks! thats my RB ur talking about
 
MGood030
offline
Link
 
I dunno GMath.

Since I'd be the person collecting votes, the first issue isn't that big of a deal to me. Luckily, the whole league likely won't participate, so that limits things already. The second issue is interesting, however. Anyone else have an opinion? How do you guys want to do it? What if some TEAMS don't even contribute? Not all of them make their thoughts on this board known, and that severely limits the amount of votes coming in if teams as a whole are missing.
 
dirkthe1
offline
Link
 
enforce team voting.surely everyone wants this?
Last edited Aug 28, 2008 00:06:24
 
Jarlaxle
offline
Link
 
Sure we'll send over one of those midgets with a bat if they don't vote... I offer my services to fuel said midget with quality vodka
 
S3M1N0L3
offline
Link
 
I say, if a team doesn't vote, count the votes without them. This is for fun on the forums. If teams don't care to hang out or be involved, what can ya do? Surely you won't wait around for a response that will never come.. Move on without them.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by dirkthe1
Originally posted by BucktheFroncos

Buster would be Pro-Bowl at QB if they let him throw the ball. Hell, he would probably lead the league in Interceptions and FG made if he didn't have to satisfy all his lady fans, and thus have to "rest".


im not trying to be harsh, but he dosnt lead the league in anything!


Oh, he leads the league in one Stat. Believe that. It's like a Baby's arm holding an apple.
 
S3M1N0L3
offline
Link
 
LMAO hahahaha.. Quit braggin' there "Tripod"..
 
MGood030
offline
Link
 
I'm just worried about the number of votes, as in sample size. For example, in a survey would it be better to have 40 people participating or 5? Which one would be more accurate?

Felt I needed to add some clarification about my concerns.

 
MGood030
offline
Link
 
Ok...new thought. How about..

If you own a team in this lovely league, PM me assuring participation in this. That way I can get a feel for how many teams we really have. If most of the team owners, or at least one representative, contact me we'll go ahead as planned using team votes. I'll then, whenever we're ready, respond to those who PM'd me giving them the ballot.

If we don't get at least 75% of teams participating, we'll just post the ballot on here and I'll just sort through the individual votes as people turn them in.

How's that? Can ya dig it?
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
sounds like a good idea. I'd put participation expectation somewhere between 50-75% though. I think if you PM all the owners, you'll get a better response. Hell, I might do it for you because I know not everyone comes to the forums.
 
Jarlaxle
offline
Link
 
I like that, lets take some time out from trying to smash each other in the head so that we might come together and work as one!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.