User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Tareton
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drewsky
I don't know, I am more of a Stuckey Adams fan myself. He has 3281 rushing yards compared to Hermann's 3076. And, sure, a lot of that could be because he has great blockers. But he also has 229 broken tackles compared to Hermann's 213, which is all due to the Stuckey and has nothing to do with the O-line. Stuckey shared carries with Kade Dunco who is a TD hawk, otherwise he would be a lock for MVP. Stuckey's worst game was 90.5 yards rushing 0 TD's and his best game was 450 yards and 8 TD's; both are better than Hermann's best and worst.

Hell, the only way I see that Hermann is more of an MVP than Stuckey is that without Hermann the RHCP would have lost more games. BBB would have still had Kade Dunco running the ball and our record would have been identical.


Sure he had more rushing yards but I would submit this to you then.

Randall Hermann - 342 attempts at 9 YPC
Stuckey Adams - 384 attempts at 8.5 YPC

All things considered would you not agree that given the same opportunities the rushing title would have changed hands?

Also if you do the math for broken tackles per carry you get.

Randall Hermann - 0.62
Stucky Adams - 0.60

Lastly, I would also submit that since Stuckey never had to run against BBB there is no way to know how to rate his worst game because against the same BABE's team this was our respective numbers.

Randall Hermann - 19 for 251 w/ 4 TD
Stuckey Adams - 15 for 90 w/ 0 TD

This all being said I am also a teamate of Stuckey and I know first hand that he is a VERY VERY strong candidate for MVP and OPotY and if my HB was to lose awards to him I would in no way feel cheated.

Once again not a shot at Stuckey at all. I think he is very deserving. I am just defending my year as well. Good debates are fun anyhow!!
 
drewsky
offline
Link
 
I gotta call em like I see them. And the best RB that I saw play this year not in a Bushmaster uniform was SaX Soapman and he trumps all of our running backs with 9.5 ypc.
 
Tareton
offline
Link
 
I wouldn't disagree with that choice either. Another extremely strong RB in our league.
 
TuckiTucky
offline
Link
 
wait & see playoff game then u know who the best ^^
 
Tareton
offline
Link
 
Does this award count the playoffs or just the regular season?
 
GmanV2
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tareton
Does this award count the playoffs or just the regular season?


Just regular season. Playoffs, well, they're their own reward aren't they?
 
Guppy, Inc
online
Link
 
My vote for POY would go to Wolfwood Peng. We didnt ask our FBs to carry much in the regular season so he doesnt have those stats, but he was a total beast on PR and he's a great blocker and did very well as backup TE. I tend to like the guys that exceed expectations
 
thomdunco32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tareton
Originally posted by thomdunco32

Originally posted by Tareton


Originally posted by countsnake



how was your stat line aganist the best team you faced all year 10 carries for 31 yds.


Kade Dunco, another MVP candidate, same game, 10 carries for 45 yards.


In this game against you when I had the 10 carries for 45 yards I also had two 80+ yard kick return touchdowns and was the player of the game. Maybe I got a little tired from those runs.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=119625


Wasn't a shot at ya bro. But by snakes definition we shouldn't consider the rest of your season because of your 45 yd performance. More of a comparison.



Got it.
 
GmanV2
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MarionBarber3rd
Originally posted by drewsky


Hell, the only way I see that Hermann is more of an MVP than Stuckey is that without Hermann the RHCP would have lost more games. BBB would have still had Kade Dunco running the ball and our record would have been identical.


which brings up a point about mvp's that not even professionals can agree on.. is it the most valuable player award, or is it the best offensive player on the best team award.


This is an excellent point of course, and the debate rages.

I'd like for our MVP vote to be a mix of Dominated in the League and was invaluable to his teams performance.

Either way, I've updated all the nominations on the first post. Now, for those Owners/GMs (1 person per team please) wishing to vote, here's how we'll do it.

You cannot vote for your own teams player either, only another teams please.

Send in this format:
League MVP:
1st place: Player Name
2nd place: Player Name
3rd place: Player Name

Off POY
1st place: Player Name
2nd place: Player Name

Def POY
1st place: Player Name
2nd place: Player Name

I'll tally the votes, and we'll have our winners. I'd honestly like this done sooner rather than later as well. Also, please choose from the nominees.
 
jmorgalis
offline
Link
 
League MVP
1st: Adams BBB
2nd: Soapman SS
3rd: Dunco BBB

Off POY
1st Adams BBB
2nd Soapman SS

Def POY
1st Rap Tor BBB
2nd Sackman VW

I almost choked not voting for my own players, but rules is rules.
 
GmanV2
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
My Votes. They were tough, but I took a lot of things into consideration, and saw some compelling plays and stats as I've researched for my Season All Pro picks.

League MVP
1st: Hermann RHCP
2nd: Soapman SS
3rd: Kraima SS

Off POY
1st Sopaman SS
2nd Madine BP

Def POY
1st T Reese RHCP
2nd Sackman VW
 
GmanV2
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Really? That's it?
 
Tajson
offline
Link
 
Maybe you should have open a new thread for the voting.

League MVP:
1st place: Terry Reese, DE
2nd place: Randall Hermann, HB
3rd place: Brady Quinn, QB

Off POY
1st place: Randall Hermann, HB
2nd place: Brady Quinn, QB

Def POY
1st place: Terry Reese, DE
2nd place: Big Pussy, DT
 
TuckiTucky
offline
Link
 
League MVP
1st: Hermann RHCP
2nd: Adams BBB
3rd: Terry Reese RHCP

Off POY
1st Hermann RHCP
2nd Adams BBB

Def POY
1st Terry Reese RHCP
2nd Rap Tor BBB
 
Guppy, Inc
online
Link
 
Rap Tor says thanks for the vote
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.