User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
kbl06
offline
Link
 
RDEs still go to the outside
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=110463&pbp_id=6477060
 
foobar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by foobar

7) This does NOT affect Left DEs. In fact the Left DEs got better on this game since the RG and RT suddenly started leaving a gaping hole for the left DE to run through. This is the case in MANY of the conference games I wathced.


I'm confused by that. So it's OK for the LDE to go to the inside if there is a hole, but it's not OK for the RDE to do the same thing?


Except that the RDE is trying to do it when there ISN'T A GAP. Once again, go back and read the rest of the thread.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foobar
Originally posted by Jose Bagg

Foobar: I did a little research.


In your league, the top 12 pass rushers have a combined total of 158 sacks.

In your league, the QB that started against you in the last game had only been sacked twice. You got him 4 times, so now he has been sacked 6 times. There are 32 teams in your league, and after facing you, there are 32 other QBs who have been sacked 6 or more times. That means that almost every starting QB and many backup QBs have been sacked more than this guy, and yet you think it is a mystery that your DE didn't beat the LT on the outside very often. HUH! All evidence would seem to indicate that he is one helluva lineman. He only gave up 2 sacks against the most sack happy league I have ever seen, and to be truthful, he might not even have given those up.

In summary, your build is great, so was the LTs.


Reading comprehension really is a problem in these forums. Please go back and READ the entire thread since you obviously have missed several key points that I have had to re-state every time a new muppet feels like jumping into this conversation.

1) I have the leading sacker in the league - so it is not a build problem.

2) I know my DE very well and I know how he reacts. I have seen how he rushes against the best O-linemen in the conference.

3) For the last 8 games or so he has reacted consistently even against excellent lineman.

4) Bort posts updated code and the very next game my DE suddenly no longer tries to outside the LT

5) Hmm...Maybe I should go look at the bugs forum and see if a new bug was reported on this. Oh look, other to Right DEs are reporting the exact same problems. I will add my comments to the thread to help get a response from Bort.

6) Oh look, all the cluesless muppets that haven't read the thread and don't understand what is going on start chiming in.

7) This does NOT affect Left DEs. In fact the Left DEs got better on this game since the RG and RT suddenly started leaving a gaping hole for the left DE to run through. This is the case in MANY of the conference games I wathced.

8) Arguing with all these muppets is getting old.


1) I acknowledged that. I said your build was great.
2) And now you have seen how he rushes against the statistically BEST oline in the conference. The o-line you faced only gave up 2 sacks in a league with over 200 sacks already. And even after facing you, there are 32 other QBs in a 32 team league who have been sacked more often. All stats would indicate you just played the BEST pass protection in your league. Now you really know how your DE behaves.
3) I guess he hadn't faced the best. Last I checked excellent is still less than best.
4) Bort posted updated code the day before you played the best pass protection in your league. Why isn't the other owner be here crying about how his O-line only gave up 2 sacks all season and now they gave up 4 in one game. Would he be here crying if you put 10 sacks on him?
5) Only two or three people are complaining about this. There are thousands of teams and thousands of DEs. Doesn't it seem logical to you that there would be hundreds of complaints if something really did break?
6) I read the thread, I understand, and I am impressed that someone as young as you remembers the muppets. I liked Gonzo and Animal and the critics. They were my favorites, and you can't overlook Pigs in Space!
7) You may be right, I saw that bug too, but maybe RT aren't as good at protection as LT and people are switching their pass rushers to the other side in response to a thread that was getting big a few days ago about how effective it is to switch your DEs. Both theories are cromulent
8) You're telling me!
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 11:20:25
 
foobar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kbl06
RDEs still go to the outside
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=110463&pbp_id=6477060


TIP OF THE DAY:

In programming, simulation logic code can be very complex. Situational bugs arise that only manifest themselves under certain conditions. Only when those conditions are met does the bug become noticeable.

Obviously your DE is not tripping the right conditions.
 
Pensfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EagleOtto
Pensfan,
I looked over the film for your lv23 guy, who I assume you are referring to,
your team lines up 3-4 alot, and 3-4 does prevent the DE from going outside, mostly because where they line up, or pathing or whatever, but yes out of 30+ sacks this year, I have 0 while running in the 3-4 defense.

That is some of the problem, the other being that your opponent through so many short passes there wasn't time for a rush much.

I saw a few 4-3 defensive sets and you took the inside approach on them, but there was a hole there as the OT backs up to protect the outside rush. Nothing conclusive that I see there.

If there is any problem its the 3-4 defense at the center of it.




We have been using that def all year though... Why the change now? I also use the 3-4 def on passing formations on my other team and haven't seen this over all drastic of a change.

My dots are not happy


Last edited Aug 26, 2008 11:20:45
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foobar
Originally posted by kbl06

RDEs still go to the outside
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=110463&pbp_id=6477060


TIP OF THE DAY:

In programming, simulation logic code can be very complex. Situational bugs arise that only manifest themselves under certain conditions. Only when those conditions are met does the bug become noticeable.

Obviously your DE is not tripping the right conditions.


That must be it...your guy tripped the "lets screw foobar" code.

The only thing that's obvious is your inability to see any opinion other than your own is true...or ever possible.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 11:24:13
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
I hope I can remember to watch the rest of Foobars games. His DEs will go back to their dominant ways for the rest of the season. Then maybe he will face the Poison in the playoffs and get his DEs stymied again. That would be fun to comment on.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
foobar, looked at your game, you really were shutdown pretty well and the way you rushed, I agree it does not look like elusive style, your guy defiantely ran straight ahead most of the time, didnt even try to go inside alot.

No answers for you, except maybe somehow the OT you faced was a monster, built against speed DEs, I only say this cause here are 2 plays where you try to go outside him, and he just holds you like glue, wish I could see that OTs build.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=97393&pbp_id=6261503
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=97393&pbp_id=6264192
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Just a note: latest update didn't touch pass rushing other than making it easier to knock a blocker over when you smash into him. Latest update was focused on running with the ball tactics, which are unrelated.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
So it is written, so let it be done.
 
Pensfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Just a note: latest update didn't touch pass rushing other than making it easier to knock a blocker over when you smash into him. Latest update was focused on running with the ball tactics, which are unrelated.


Any idea on why several people are noting the same effects yesterday though Bort?

What about the 3-4 comments raised earlier. They seem to be well thought out, but only you would know for sure.


 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Just a note: latest update didn't touch pass rushing other than making it easier to knock a blocker over when you smash into him. Latest update was focused on running with the ball tactics, which are unrelated.


Ok Bort,

Thanks for the answer.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
I think people are expecting way too much. Maybe there's a bug with the pathing. Maybe not. I'm not convinced. I've seen just as many go to the outside as I have seen try to shoot the gap.

The difference is that the vocal minority thinks their DE should have 20+ sacks in a season, which is ridiculous.

Getting even 1 sack in a game should be rare. Hurries are another issue, but sacks should not be an every-game occurrence for all but the league leaders.

Again, there MIGHT be a bug with RDE pathing, and there might NOT be a bug with RDE pathing. One game is not scientific proof.
 
Link
 
Is speed or Agility more important for speed rushers?
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by South Carolina Kid
Is speed or Agility more important for speed rushers?


Both are pretty important, but speed is king.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.