User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
bort is on the prowl maybe he will tell you who is right.


The AI tester uses the same "select output" function as the in game code, so it should match the same assuming you enter the scenario the same as it's expecting.

I've tested more than once and it counts yardage correctly (when adding a print statement to print what it's using) in the sim when within the 10.

I'm wondering if the problem is not being approached from the right angle, as in we're missing something else in the equation that doesn't have to do with yardage, etc.
 
RandomBeast
offline
Link
 
is it possible to copy a teams AI and run a sim to include specific scenarios to recreate a specific play by down, distance, time, etc.?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RandomBeast
is it possible to copy a teams AI and run a sim to include specific scenarios to recreate a specific play by down, distance, time, etc.?


yeah bort. I would take Dpell's since he is the one who complained the most and run his through your own sim to see what happens. there are also a few other guys who keep posting in here also.

 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
I've complained too! haha, we've had 2 or 3 situations (I can remember 2 off the top of my head). Both times went for short runs, once on 4th and 8.5 and once on 4th and 4.5 at the goal line, in the early 4th and 2nd quarters, respectively, in different games.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
I'd love an answer here because it's happened to me twice now. I was about to change my yardage range from 0 - 1 to 0.001 - 1 to see if that makes it go away.
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Robbnva

bort is on the prowl maybe he will tell you who is right.


The AI tester uses the same "select output" function as the in game code, so it should match the same assuming you enter the scenario the same as it's expecting.

I've tested more than once and it counts yardage correctly (when adding a print statement to print what it's using) in the sim when within the 10.

I'm wondering if the problem is not being approached from the right angle, as in we're missing something else in the equation that doesn't have to do with yardage, etc.


So my AI has the following:
Time remaining - blank
Ball spot - Own 10 and opponent 5
Down - 2 and 2
Yards to go - 0 and 2
Score difference - blank
Sp circ - none
Output - 100% Goal line offense

In game, 2nd and goal from the 11.5 yard line (yes, lost yardage on 1st down), we run goal line offense.

2nd AI was similar:
4th and short - same as above except:
Ball spot - opponent 35 and opponent goal
Down - 4 and 4
Yards to go - 0 and 1
Score difference - -300 to -4 (more than a FG behind)
Output - 100% run HB random.

Again, in the game, 4th and goal from the 11.5 yard line, run HB is called.

I think it's pretty obvious something is not quite right in both these scenarios... seems to be the "goal to go" matching the "0" yards, but could be something else....

I could use "0.5" yards (assume that will work), but that missed the "inches" to go...could make the yards to go a pull down similar to the ball spot.
 
SeattleNiner
NINERS
offline
Link
 
Same thing just happened to us today http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=116203&pbp_id=6665244.

Late in 2nd quarter, scored tied from the 4 yard line....
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
To muse about Bort's question... Is there possibly some bug causing the AI to not recognize the current game score? To fall back into a "behind late and gotta go for it" mode? I'm not sure.
 
goshann
offline
Link
 
This is definitely a bug.
I am pretty good at the AI.
Please fix it - it is not user error. Please trust me.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Any update on this?
 
Ginger Yellow
offline
Link
 
Or a decent workaround, for that matter? We've figured one out (assuming that the problem is goal=0 for the 4th and x calculation), but it's less than optimal.
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
I'm still leaving it in and hoping not to get bit by it in the playoffs.
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
Bort, when the sim sees 4th & G at OPP 4 does it enter yards to go as 4 or as G?

When I enter G into the tester it gives my 4th and short output, but 4 into the tester gives the FG output.

I entered a goalline FG input for my next game just using the yardline as a guide, but it takes away going for it in 4th and short situations inside the 10.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
I'd like Bort's answer to that, too, but our experience has been that on 4th and goal from, say, the 4, the sim sees the yards to go as goal (which seems to equal 0 in its little sim head) and runs the 4th and short option rather than the FG option.

Your fix seems like the only way to solve (other than risking using your 4th and short play on 4th and goal from more than a couple yards out) the problem with the sim as it is now, unfortunately.

Would really like to know whether Bort at least acknowledges this as a problem not caused by human error, or, if caused by human error, could help us isolate what we're doing wrong. He mentions that the tester and the in-game code use the same syntax, but it seems that our AI output itself does not.
Last edited Sep 2, 2008 17:06:30
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.