User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > League fix for player disparity
Page:
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Yea I think the years in each league need to be adjusted, or the 10 season decline needs to be adjusted for this idea to work.


I was all about 12 years. This would give 4-5 seasons to play in the pros (before a decline...which we are still in the dark as to how long we could last). Keep in mind, the NFL career is 3.5 years on average. You must also realize that the journey would be fun...it is not just about the destination. Dominating in highschool or college would still be awesome. Right now, tearing up the D-Leagues is kind of lame. There is nothing to compare it to. Most people on here played in HS, and some in college. It is an MMORPG after all. It is a virtual way to re-live our lives or make projections about them, imo.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Yea I think the years in each league need to be adjusted, or the 10 season decline needs to be adjusted for this idea to work.


I was all about 12 years. This would give 4-5 seasons to play in the pros (before a decline...which we are still in the dark as to how long we could last). Keep in mind, the NFL career is 3.5 years on average. You must also realize that the journey would be fun...it is not just about the destination. Dominating in highschool or college would still be awesome. Right now, tearing up the D-Leagues is kind of lame. There is nothing to compare it to. Most people on here played in HS, and some in college. It is an MMORPG after all. It is a virtual way to re-live our lives or make projections about them, imo.


Well I agree it's about the journey, but at the same time is just as much about the destination. Only problem is where would we start? Who would be in pros and who would be in highschool at this point in time?

**EDIT 3.5 years as a pro is widely dependant on what position. Most QBs play way longer than that. Many LBs and RBs play far longer than that as well.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 19:09:14
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
TBH, that is why this idea is getting no attention from the Mods/Admins. It would be a huge overhall and piss a lot of people off. They would have to announce it a season ahead of time and let everyone know that they were going to rework the leagues. They would have to take the median level of each team and randomly distribute them into tiers. The highest level teams (basically already pro) would be pro. All teams would be kept in their respective continents/countries. The other teams would be distributed throughout the college level system and the crap/gutted teams would end up somewhere the highschool level system.

Greater team demand than player demand? Add more HS teams. If they are CPU-owned teams, so be it. Someone will step up and run them eventually.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
TBH, that is why this idea is getting no attention from the Mods/Admins. It would be a huge overhall and piss a lot of people off. They would have to announce it a season ahead of time and let everyone know that they were going to rework the leagues. They would have to take the median level of each team and randomly distribute them into tiers. The highest level teams (basically already pro) would be pro. All teams would be kept in their respective continents/countries. The other teams would be distributed throughout the college level system and the crap/gutted teams would end up somewhere the highschool level system.

Greater team demand than player demand? Add more HS teams. If they are CPU-owned teams, so be it. Someone will step up and run them eventually.


I think the biggest issue with be Owners no longer owning their own team but just being 1 of the many GMs on the team, You end up with a bad DC you're screwed and you don't get to choose the next one. You could be the best damn OC in GLB but never win a game because you ended up with poor GMs with other responsibilities.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
OK, I think we are not on the same page, here. I have thrown out the whole CPU owned teams idea. I am for keeping teams together right now.

I guess the most plausible implementation of this idea is to implement it soon, but not force teams to break apart. Redistribute teams into pro/college/HS based on median level of players. Then, within those levels, break them further into tiers.

If you cut someone the season before it is implemented, you cannot sign them again for 2 seasons (to avoid teams trying to get around this and ruining parity)...or add a signing cap for each league/division until it all works out. Make only the gutted teams the HS teams and add some CPU controlled teams (if needed).

Eventually, it will all work out. The issue is, either address it soon and deal with bitching and moaning for a while, or have another reset. Either way, people are not going to be happy. But, you have to imagine that this game is going to grow if you do it right. If you keep it as is, it will die in a few seasons.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
I like the ideas flowing in here and the debate going on...I'll throw my 2 cents in later once I get a chance to work on some graphics...
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
OK, I think we are not on the same page, here. I have thrown out the whole CPU owned teams idea. I am for keeping teams together right now.

I guess the most plausible implementation of this idea is to implement it soon, but not force teams to break apart. Redistribute teams into pro/college/HS based on median level of players. Then, within those levels, break them further into tiers.

If you cut someone the season before it is implemented, you cannot sign them again for 2 seasons (to avoid teams trying to get around this and ruining parity)...or add a signing cap for each league/division until it all works out. Make only the gutted teams the HS teams and add some CPU controlled teams (if needed).

Eventually, it will all work out. The issue is, either address it soon and deal with bitching and moaning for a while, or have another reset. Either way, people are not going to be happy. But, you have to imagine that this game is going to grow if you do it right. If you keep it as is, it will die in a few seasons.


I agree with that portion of it... so if you own a HS or College team you'll never move up WITH your team, you'll have to get a new team in a different tier correct? Seems to make sense kind of like a real life Coach type thing. I'd say have it different costs for different levels of competition as well. Say HS is 200 a season to own, 500 to buy in. College is 300 a season to own, 750 to buy in, and Pros are the same as they are now.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Original Post updated with the various more valid points coming out - as far as my opinion of them goes.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
I agree with that portion of it... so if you own a HS or College team you'll never move up WITH your team, you'll have to get a new team in a different tier correct? Seems to make sense kind of like a real life Coach type thing. I'd say have it different costs for different levels of competition as well. Say HS is 200 a season to own, 500 to buy in. College is 300 a season to own, 750 to buy in, and Pros are the same as they are now.


Yeah, I posted earlier on what the pricing tier should be. It should be more to have a pro team than a college team than a HS team.

I know that free FPs are a big no-no, but here are two ideas to encourage owners to take it seriously:

1) If you move up in league (HS to College or College to Pro) you should get a free season (since you went from a great team to a gutted or crappy team). This would give you 46+ days to get your affairs in order before you have to decide if you will keep paying for a team. If need be, make the new owners pay an initial deposit of 1/2 the cost of the team in case they quit.

2) At the pro level, give the league-winning owners 1/2 the FP back.

I guess the big issue here is if a ton of owners quit and Bort lost a substantial amount of money on relegation. Then again, if this were in place, we would all know that a bad league structure was costing him money and we could assume that he was doing everything to resolve these issues. The pro-league champion boone would be countered by making teams more expensive at that level, overall.

Just a thought, this seems to be a think tank, after all. Tear into it.

P.S. Bort popped in on the Top Player Threats thread if you hadn't noticed.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 21:37:22
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop


P.S. Bort popped in on the Top Player Threats thread if you hadn't noticed.


I did notice that, and I immediately jumped in this thread in the hopes of seeing his thoughts on this one, but to no avail...
 
GG
offline
Link
 
turnerhero...ive been reading the thread and re-visiting the OP as you update it.

I like a lot of stuff being mentioned in there, the general concept is very fun and offers another way to create parity.

I have a few questions because Im a bit thick absorbing it all...

How are the Pro, Arena, HS etc leagues broken up? Based on the AGE of the player in seasons, or a level cap as such? I ask because a player could be 4 seasons old that has never boosted and would be out-matched in levels and SPs compared to a 4 seasons old player that has boosted each season. Also, long-term back-ups often tend to rise in levels a lot slower than starters. If the leagues are broken up based on levels, then what happens in the middle of a season (or end of) when players from a lower league end up hitting the 'pro' level but are still under contract with the 'arena' level etc.

And i dunno about the CPU owned team that players buy a GM role on. It's a very interesting idea, and im just not sure because i dont understand the pros and cons of that idea. Can you like explain/sell it to me so I can see the plus/minus in it? Because off the top of my head, that idea while very interesting also doesnt appeal for other reasons.

Another thing which may have been answered but im not sure, is that one of the "will not happen" things is the idea that GLB will force people to not be able to own teams and sign all their own players on it etc and create new players for it, and spend money on them. Ie, the disparity of having level 30 players in a BBB league because an owner wants to bring his players there. Or, a pro league team owner who brings in all his level 5 players and gets murdered in games.

Im not saying "no" to these ideas myself, like GLB has before, but just wondering how this whole idea will get around that issue/problem should Bort reject this idea BASED ON those restrictions. Like what plan B ideas and alternatives are you proposing here as well?

When I think of more questions I'll post.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
I am sure that by the time I finish this Turner will have answered your questions, GG. To have this idea taken seriously by Bort, there needs to be the arena league for those that don't make it pro. I imagine 1/2 of the people that play this and boost through 8 seasons and end up without a league would quit forever, understandably.

The thing is that it is a season cap. You can't go to college and then go back to HS. After you 1st 4 years, you have to enter the college league. After 4 years of college, you have to enter some sort of pro league.

Problems:
-This somewhat becomes booster v non-booster leagues
-It would be a huge deal to have to reassign teams to the different tiers
-It would take quite some time for this idea to actually affect the league

Benefits:
-Sweet, sweet parity
-Players always have somewhere to go and do not stay stagant on the same team in the same league forever
-Realism to your players' careers'
-An unofficial farm system will develop
-Owners/GMs can still move up in leagues, but cannot recruit uber players (as it is based on seasons)
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
turnerhero...ive been reading the thread and re-visiting the OP as you update it.

I like a lot of stuff being mentioned in there, the general concept is very fun and offers another way to create parity.

I have a few questions because Im a bit thick absorbing it all...

How are the Pro, Arena, HS etc leagues broken up? Based on the AGE of the player in seasons, or a level cap as such? I ask because a player could be 4 seasons old that has never boosted and would be out-matched in levels and SPs compared to a 4 seasons old player that has boosted each season. Also, long-term back-ups often tend to rise in levels a lot slower than starters. If the leagues are broken up based on levels, then what happens in the middle of a season (or end of) when players from a lower league end up hitting the 'pro' level but are still under contract with the 'arena' level etc.

And i dunno about the CPU owned team that players buy a GM role on. It's a very interesting idea, and im just not sure because i dont understand the pros and cons of that idea. Can you like explain/sell it to me so I can see the plus/minus in it? Because off the top of my head, that idea while very interesting also doesnt appeal for other reasons.

Another thing which may have been answered but im not sure, is that one of the "will not happen" things is the idea that GLB will force people to not be able to own teams and sign all their own players on it etc and create new players for it, and spend money on them. Ie, the disparity of having level 30 players in a BBB league because an owner wants to bring his players there. Or, a pro league team owner who brings in all his level 5 players and gets murdered in games.

Im not saying "no" to these ideas myself, like GLB has before, but just wondering how this whole idea will get around that issue/problem should Bort reject this idea BASED ON those restrictions. Like what plan B ideas and alternatives are you proposing here as well?

When I think of more questions I'll post.


Ok this is gonna be a long, drawn-out reply, because GG basically spawned this thought in my head in one of his threads earlier today, so I've been looking for his response here...

The Professional, Arena, and "Minor League" teams would be at the same 'level' but the Pros would be the super elite. The Arena and Minors would be a place for those individuals who are slow bloomers or something, simply didn't get a contract to the Pros when they were done in College and don't want to restart, and are good enough for the Arena/Minors, or older players reaching retirement 'age' and declining, but want to stick it out as long as possible because they're attached to the player.

Below this would be College level, and below that, the High School level.

As far as CPU owned teams, I think this idea is now being tossed to the wind, but my reasoning behind it is that with a CPU owner, and humans running the team as a GM, Coach, Scout, Financial Adviser, the CPU owner would technically be nothing but a placeholder, so that the team wouldn't suddenly fall into ruin because an owner vanished and went inactive, or sold teh team without warning back to the game, or simply decided "fuck it, FIRE SALE!" etc etc etc the list goes on and on. On top of that, Owning a team that could never possibly reach the Professional Level might not sit well with most team owner candidates, which is why I suggested a CPU owner, with humans running everything. If a human GM, or Coach, or whatever was 'fired' by the CPU rating system however it might work, the CPU owner would take over that position until a new human would be 'hired' to fill the position, so if it's a GM, the CPU would do nothing basically, unless there were below the necessary number of players for whatever position (based on a set value per position), it would sign someone. If the human being fired was the Offensive Coach for example, the CPU would take over the offensive depth chart, and AI settings for the team until a human's 'hired' again to take over. Basically, the CPU is a placeholder and a fail safe against a team falling into ruin with absolutely everything crumbling at the same time.

As for a player hitting the Pro level, or being "bumped up" as I put it earlier, but still being under contract with a College team (I'll get to Arena example in a minute), basically, if a player signs to a Collegiate level team out of High School, the maximum contract length would be the end of their 4th season, being that it's the limit to their tenure there. Now, as far as an Arena player wanting to sign Pro if an offer comes along, or someone starts scouting him out, he would have to do like we do now if we want out of a contract, except instead of a team owner, we'd talk to the General Manager, who's in charge of team signings, releases, and trades. The Pro teams could trade between the Minors and Arena teams because all three of them would be considered "Pro Level".

And the whole "never going to happen" about forcing team owners to not have all their players on their own team...well, that's the current system, and it works with the current system, but I personally think the current system doesn't work at all the way Bort wants it to, and needs a major change/overhaul - such as this. Throw the never forcing owners to not have their players on their own team out the window on this one...it's a whole new system, with whole new rules.

I hope this clears a few things up...
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
You don't have to read this, but it is my take on things. I refuse to delete it even if it contradicts what Turner wrote (I have not read it yet).

Originally posted by GG
1} How are the Pro, Arena, HS etc leagues broken up? Based on the AGE of the player in seasons, or a level cap as such? I ask because a player could be 4 seasons old that has never boosted and would be out-matched in levels and SPs compared to a 4 seasons old player that has boosted each season. Also, long-term back-ups often tend to rise in levels a lot slower than starters. If the leagues are broken up based on levels, then what happens in the middle of a season (or end of) when players from a lower league end up hitting the 'pro' level but are still under contract with the 'arena' level etc.

2) And i dunno about the CPU owned team that players buy a GM role on. It's a very interesting idea, and im just not sure because i dont understand the pros and cons of that idea. Can you like explain/sell it to me so I can see the plus/minus in it? Because off the top of my head, that idea while very interesting also doesnt appeal for other reasons.

3) Another thing which may have been answered but im not sure, is that one of the "will not happen" things is the idea that GLB will force people to not be able to own teams and sign all their own players on it etc and create new players for it, and spend money on them. Ie, the disparity of having level 30 players in a BBB league because an owner wants to bring his players there. Or, a pro league team owner who brings in all his level 5 players and gets murdered in games.


1) It is based on age. Season 1-4 are in HS. Season 5-8 are in College. Season 9-12 are in Pros or Arena. HS, College, and Arena are organized in A, AA, and AAA. The best teams move up and the worst teams move down.

When an owner wins enough, he/she is put on a waiting list and is eligable to own a team in the higher tier (College, or Pro). If there are no openings, they continue to coach their team in their tier until an opening occurs. If an owner wins 2 titles, they are bumped ahead of the owners that have won one title. An owner can stay in their tier as long as they like.

2) Bort would never approve of this, as it would take too much work and destroy the money-maker of friends working together as a team

3) A pro-team owner can bring in whomever he/she wants. If they get clowned that season, they are moved down. And any owner that can find a high level player within the season cap deserves to get that player.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Hey, say whatever ya want...the more perspectives on this the more chance of finding the 'right mesh' of ideas to get this into something feasible that Bort would WANT to do...not simply see as another thing to work on and be a drain...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.