User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Dude, try read the whole thread before making idiotic comments like these.

I have never said "coasting" is a bad change, so don't put words in my mouth.

I have never said I wanted to score a TD on every single play.

I have never cried foul in this post.

I simply gave an example of two level 22 well built DTs missing tackle against a level 1 HB on the same play. Now, I think there might be something wrong there. Maybe there is, maybe there isn't. If you think that's normal, fine. But there really is no need for you to get your imaginations running wild and get all worked up over here.


1) I did read the whole post. Did you conveniently gloss over the part where I mention that I even responded earlier?

2) If you think that this one particular play in a 246-0 blowout is wrong, then you do think coasting is a bad thing. In fact, you specifically say that in real life there is no coasting, clearly implying that coasting is unrealistic.

3) You and the people who think this play is a bug keep using different analogies that lead to the same conclusion. The DTs were pro-caliber players and the HB was barely in puberty. If that was truly the case, then the HB should fumble every time. And, if the same extreme level difference occurs on offense, every play should be a TD. So, in essence, you do want this.

4) You do, in fact, cry foul. In your very first post in this thread, where you state "I'm simply pointing out a flaw in the game that is obviously need to be addressed."

5) I don't think that's normal. I think that it can only happen in a complete blowout when coasting is turned on. Even then, I think the chances are very miniscule. But, there is a chance, and when there are over 1200 sims in a day, things will happen that only have a small chance of occurring.

6) How is my imagination running wild? That doesn't even make sense, honestly. And I'm not getting worked up. I'm pointing out the obvious fact that this is not a bug and that it is no big deal.
 
nittany2b
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by datongw

Dude, try read the whole thread before making idiotic comments like these.

I have never said "coasting" is a bad change, so don't put words in my mouth.

I have never said I wanted to score a TD on every single play.

I have never cried foul in this post.

I simply gave an example of two level 22 well built DTs missing tackle against a level 1 HB on the same play. Now, I think there might be something wrong there. Maybe there is, maybe there isn't. If you think that's normal, fine. But there really is no need for you to get your imaginations running wild and get all worked up over here.


1) I did read the whole post. Did you conveniently gloss over the part where I mention that I even responded earlier?

2) If you think that this one particular play in a 246-0 blowout is wrong, then you do think coasting is a bad thing. In fact, you specifically say that in real life there is no coasting, clearly implying that coasting is unrealistic.

3) You and the people who think this play is a bug keep using different analogies that lead to the same conclusion. The DTs were pro-caliber players and the HB was barely in puberty. If that was truly the case, then the HB should fumble every time. And, if the same extreme level difference occurs on offense, every play should be a TD. So, in essence, you do want this.

4) You do, in fact, cry foul. In your very first post in this thread, where you state "I'm simply pointing out a flaw in the game that is obviously need to be addressed."

5) I don't think that's normal. I think that it can only happen in a complete blowout when coasting is turned on. Even then, I think the chances are very miniscule. But, there is a chance, and when there are over 1200 sims in a day, things will happen that only have a small chance of occurring.

6) How is my imagination running wild? That doesn't even make sense, honestly. And I'm not getting worked up. I'm pointing out the obvious fact that this is not a bug and that it is no big deal.

It's not that coasting is wrong, it's just that the coasting set up is unrealistic and hurts the stat lines of the paying customers in this game.

And your #4 makes little sense, making a statement like he did is not crying foul, it's trying to help the game as a whole. Crying foul would be saying that his team got ripped off and it is completely unacceptable and unfair that his DT's had to take missed tackles.
 
nittany2b
offline
Link
 
Further proof that there's flaw in the coasting system: How is it working when a team has its best performance and scores 96 points in the 4th quarter while leading 150+ to 0? Sensibly if a level 1 HB is slipping level 22 DT tackles at 59-0, how is the team playing BETTER when leading by over 150? Chance might increase the number a bit, but to go from scoring 52 points full speed to 96 points half speed (which it would take for the missed tackles in question) just doesn't make sense mathematically.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 22:39:48
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nittany2b
It's not that coasting is wrong, it's just that the coasting set up is unrealistic and hurts the stat lines of the paying customers in this game.


Wow. That's the death knell of this thread as far as I'm concerned.

 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by datongw

Dude, try read the whole thread before making idiotic comments like these.

I have never said "coasting" is a bad change, so don't put words in my mouth.

I have never said I wanted to score a TD on every single play.

I have never cried foul in this post.

I simply gave an example of two level 22 well built DTs missing tackle against a level 1 HB on the same play. Now, I think there might be something wrong there. Maybe there is, maybe there isn't. If you think that's normal, fine. But there really is no need for you to get your imaginations running wild and get all worked up over here.


1) I did read the whole post. Did you conveniently gloss over the part where I mention that I even responded earlier?

2) If you think that this one particular play in a 246-0 blowout is wrong, then you do think coasting is a bad thing. In fact, you specifically say that in real life there is no coasting, clearly implying that coasting is unrealistic.

3) You and the people who think this play is a bug keep using different analogies that lead to the same conclusion. The DTs were pro-caliber players and the HB was barely in puberty. If that was truly the case, then the HB should fumble every time. And, if the same extreme level difference occurs on offense, every play should be a TD. So, in essence, you do want this.

4) You do, in fact, cry foul. In your very first post in this thread, where you state "I'm simply pointing out a flaw in the game that is obviously need to be addressed."

5) I don't think that's normal. I think that it can only happen in a complete blowout when coasting is turned on. Even then, I think the chances are very miniscule. But, there is a chance, and when there are over 1200 sims in a day, things will happen that only have a small chance of occurring.

6) How is my imagination running wild? That doesn't even make sense, honestly. And I'm not getting worked up. I'm pointing out the obvious fact that this is not a bug and that it is no big deal.


There is no coasting in real life, a team will put in it's backups or keep on running the ball to keep the game short, but no one is out there jogging around or miss tackles (due to coasting). It is unrealistic. But just because that I think it's unrealistic does not mean I think it's bad, it's your imagination that makes you think I said or think that "coasting is bad".

Your "in essence" logic is as flawed as they come. Level 22 DTs should not be missing tackles against level 1 HBs, let alone twice in one play. <- this is my statement, anything else regarding fumbling on each play or scoring a TD on each play is just from your "in essence" imagination.

If you don't think it's a bug, just say it's not a bug, there is a 1 in millionth chance it could happen and it happened. There are plenty of people stated that in this thread. There is really no need for you to accuse me of wanting to score each time I have the ball or get a fumble every play on defense, or even saying "coasting" is a bad idea.

Just for the record, I think coasting is a great feature, it prevents teams from getting killed in energy loss when playing against gutted teams.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.