Originally posted by dpell
There's a team in Canada right now using an OT as a returner and the game physics give him a huge benefit because he's 300+ pounds. He's averaging close to 40yards per return and has 4 return TD's this season already. It is stupid, and should be fixed.
The idea that different positions should have different scales for when the soft caps kick in has been suggested many times and makes perfect sense, but the problem is that that would be a HUGE penalty for everyone who came after the players who were already above those caps. I agree it is a fundamental change that is needed though.dpell - how do you know the 300 lbs has anything to do with my player's ability to return kicks? He is built specifically to return kicks. Sure, he was an OT when I created him, but he definitely does not have the attributes of an OT.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=477727Feel free to take a look and tell me if you'd play this guy on your o-line or if he is simply a KR/PR specialist player.
I opened up his attributes because I have a feeling his build type will be nerfed thanks to all the complaints, but there is no exploit here, just a smart build in my opinion. He is build to do one thing and one thing only...return kicks. I am working on rounding him out to be a complete special teams player, and I really don't see why that is such a bad thing.
If you watch a lot of the returns, he benefits from very good blocking and uses his speed/agility/vision to make the right cuts. He does break some tackles at times vs. weaker cover units. You have to realize that a lot of teams put their worst (i.e. backup) players on special teams and can get dummied by a solid returner and return blocking scheme.
I for one urge Bort and co. not to kill these specialty builds, but rather ensure that they need to be specialty builds to succeed. Putting a DT or O-Lineman at KR/PR with low carrying, he should fumble almost every time (I've already fumbled 3 times this season and am working to correct that, but with my strength/carrying I should fumble even more often, but probably am not due to low tackling/strength kickoff team players).
I envision the game down the road having a big need for specialized players...if it doesn't, and it is all cookie cutter builds, the game will be a lot less fun. There have been a lot of suggestions on how to handle this that should be considered, namely:
1. Being able to choose from a list of special abilities for each player to specialize them (have a bigger list of specials to choose from...rated by effectiveness -- Level 1 through 5 specials, you can choose 2 from each level to build your trees)
2. Being able to train your player to gain/lose weight (assuming weight has an effect...if weight affected top speed, for example, I'd train my OT to lose weight to make him more effective at his KR/PR job, whereas another player may want to gain weight to be better)
3. If you want, make it harder but not impossible for certain positions to gain in certain attributes (i.e. have the first speed softcap for o-linemen hit at a lower number compared to DB's & WR's; vice-versa for strength/blocking, etc.) This would still leave the ability to build a specialty player for a specific purpose.
There were others as well that I'm forgetting...GG's idea of specific build types for position that match up well against other build types but suffer against others...I like this idea but it could probably be solved with advanced tactics...for example we have evasive, combo & bull rush pass rushing tactics...maybe the o-linemen should have to choose to stop the evasive or bull rush, or go with a combo defense. Work that in with their focus (run blocking focus would lessen their ability to pass protect) and their attributes and you should get some interesting/realistic results.
Okay, this is long enough for now
