User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
and CBs in Close Aggressive coverage do things like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92461&pbp_id=3559854


I don't know why I'm entering this debate because I know how it's going to end, but anyway...

That CB is horrible. A 36 Pass Defense and a 30 Overall at level 27?? He is slow, unagile and has poor vision. I don't know what you expect him to do, honestly.

And it almost looks like that WR stopped for a curl or hook route and then had to adjust for the way the ball was thrown. But, as has been argued many, many times, we're talking about 2x2 yard dots that are supposed to represent human beings. What you think happened and what actually happened are two different things.
 
Sledge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Sledge


So what you mean Bort is that if I just set my tactics for long bombs that the I'm Looking at a 50% to 65 % completion rate ...Wow..I'll take that...I know in the Nfl that kinda completion rate on the long stuff is much much lower....


No, I'm looking for 50-60% on short and medium length passes. Long passes are harder to catch, obviously.


I guess the Biggest question I could ask you Bort on the cb question that alot of peeps would be interested in would about the Shutdown Coverage Sa.

Would you advise people not to spend there skill points on what apears now to be a outdated SA in Shutdown coverage. Or will cb's with High Levels of Shutdown Coverage actually be able to affect that completion rate % ??? I only ask because that SA is at the end of a SA chain and many many points are spent to achieve a high rating in that SA. At the moment it doesnt seem to do alot for the points spent.

Last edited Aug 17, 2008 23:02:29
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

and CBs in Close Aggressive coverage do things like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92461&pbp_id=3559854


I don't know why I'm entering this debate because I know how it's going to end, but anyway...

That CB is horrible. A 36 Pass Defense and a 30 Overall at level 27?? He is slow, unagile and has poor vision. I don't know what you expect him to do, honestly.


Hate to break it to you, but you can't tell anything from the meter. A guy has 22 SP in equipment at level 27 that could be anywhere. He could have the highest vision in all of GLB for all you know.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by j10er

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


and CBs in Close Aggressive coverage do things like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92461&pbp_id=3559854


I don't know why I'm entering this debate because I know how it's going to end, but anyway...

That CB is horrible. A 36 Pass Defense and a 30 Overall at level 27?? He is slow, unagile and has poor vision. I don't know what you expect him to do, honestly.


Hate to break it to you, but you can't tell anything from the meter. A guy has 22 SP in equipment at level 27 that could be anywhere. He could have the highest vision in all of GLB for all you know.


Do you really believe this? You can tell a ton about a player's build from the meters. I've exploited matchup after matchup specifically against CBs because of the meters.

And while I agree equipment is a factor, 27 points on a CB with a poor base build means diddly-squat, because of that poor base build.

Here's an example of a level 24 CB with a green 39 Pass D bar. All attributes are without equipment and rounded:

Speed = 55+
Agility = 50+
Vision = 50+
Jumping = 25+
Strength = 20+

Those are the primary stats that affect the Pass D bar, in that order. Vision also has a large impact on the Overall bar.

So if this is a level 24 CB with a green 39 Pass D bar, what must your CB have at level 27?? Not to mention he's going up against a level 24 WR with just as much equipment who is at least soft-capped in speed/agility.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sledge
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Sledge



So what you mean Bort is that if I just set my tactics for long bombs that the I'm Looking at a 50% to 65 % completion rate ...Wow..I'll take that...I know in the Nfl that kinda completion rate on the long stuff is much much lower....


No, I'm looking for 50-60% on short and medium length passes. Long passes are harder to catch, obviously.


I guess the Biggest question I could ask you Bort on the cb question that alot of peeps would be interested in would about the Shutdown Coverage Sa.

Would you advise people not to spend there skill points on what apears now to be a outdated SA in Shutdown coverage. Or will cb's with High Levels of Shutdown Coverage actually be able to affect that completion rate % ??? I only ask because that SA is at the end of a SA chain and many many points are spent to achieve a high rating in that SA. At the moment it doesnt seem to do alot for the points spent.



I think it has been discussed at length that throwing points into SA's might help you now at the expense of later on, and sometimes they won't help you now.

I've seen many a post where both mods and devs have reiterated that we are not even half way through a player's lifespan, so you don't really need massive SA's yet. I think pounding SA's is shortsighted, and lots of season 1 players, myself included, made this mistake on a number of players, who had early success but the competition who caught on early is already catching up / surpassing our builds.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jakemall
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Sledge



So what you mean Bort is that if I just set my tactics for long bombs that the I'm Looking at a 50% to 65 % completion rate ...Wow..I'll take that...I know in the Nfl that kinda completion rate on the long stuff is much much lower....


No, I'm looking for 50-60% on short and medium length passes. Long passes are harder to catch, obviously.


I hope that's not a blanket statement or a lot of possession WRs will be out of a job.


Hey,

Don't give him a hard time because he answered a question. I asked the question so I could understand what he was looking for when evenly matched builds meet on a playing field. 50-65% completion for short medium passes is pretty damned good and gives a slight advantage to the offense which doesn't seem a bad idea.

I think too many people are looking at this game as a finished product, and don't understand that there are still growing pains left to get through. Right now he is addressing the CB/WR dynamics, which is good.

Just using his numbers of 50-65%, most of the advantage ends up in the offense's hands. Remember that percentage chance is for evenly matched players, BUT the WR can focus his training on agility, catching, and the possession tree to move the percentage bar upwards for his specialties, while that CB has to be able to adequately cover both the agile possession guys, and the lightning fast deep threat guys.

I think his number there seems about right.

PinTBC
 
Jakemall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Jakemall

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Sledge




So what you mean Bort is that if I just set my tactics for long bombs that the I'm Looking at a 50% to 65 % completion rate ...Wow..I'll take that...I know in the Nfl that kinda completion rate on the long stuff is much much lower....


No, I'm looking for 50-60% on short and medium length passes. Long passes are harder to catch, obviously.


I hope that's not a blanket statement or a lot of possession WRs will be out of a job.


Hey,

Don't give him a hard time because he answered a question. I asked the question so I could understand what he was looking for when evenly matched builds meet on a playing field. 50-65% completion for short medium passes is pretty damned good and gives a slight advantage to the offense which doesn't seem a bad idea.

I think too many people are looking at this game as a finished product, and don't understand that there are still growing pains left to get through. Right now he is addressing the CB/WR dynamics, which is good.

Just using his numbers of 50-65%, most of the advantage ends up in the offense's hands. Remember that percentage chance is for evenly matched players, BUT the WR can focus his training on agility, catching, and the possession tree to move the percentage bar upwards for his specialties, while that CB has to be able to adequately cover both the agile possession guys, and the lightning fast deep threat guys.

I think his number there seems about right.

PinTBC


I don't see how you can call that giving him a hard time. It's expressing a legit concern. Agility and Speed WRs are always a threat to take one to the house, possession WRs should enjoy a better completion rate.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jakemall
I don't see how you can call that giving him a hard time. It's expressing a legit concern. Agility and Speed WRs are always a threat to take one to the house, possession WRs should enjoy a better completion rate.


A WR is a WR is a WR is a WR. Since those speed WRs are a threat to go the distance more often, don't you think that most CBs will be focused on stopping them? That would mean that they were not trained as well to stop the possession WR. Remember those percentages he gave were for equally trained players, not equal levels.

I'd bet that possession receiver would automatically find their receptions increase due to the CBs concentrating on the burners.

PinTBC
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Jakemall

I don't see how you can call that giving him a hard time. It's expressing a legit concern. Agility and Speed WRs are always a threat to take one to the house, possession WRs should enjoy a better completion rate.


A WR is a WR is a WR is a WR. Since those speed WRs are a threat to go the distance more often, don't you think that most CBs will be focused on stopping them? That would mean that they were not trained as well to stop the possession WR. Remember those percentages he gave were for equally trained players, not equal levels.

I'd bet that possession receiver would automatically find their receptions increase due to the CBs concentrating on the burners.

PinTBC


You've actually just summed up exactly why WRs are currently catching passes with defenders draped all over them.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Jakemall

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Sledge




So what you mean Bort is that if I just set my tactics for long bombs that the I'm Looking at a 50% to 65 % completion rate ...Wow..I'll take that...I know in the Nfl that kinda completion rate on the long stuff is much much lower....


No, I'm looking for 50-60% on short and medium length passes. Long passes are harder to catch, obviously.


I hope that's not a blanket statement or a lot of possession WRs will be out of a job.


Hey,

Don't give him a hard time because he answered a question. I asked the question so I could understand what he was looking for when evenly matched builds meet on a playing field. 50-65% completion for short medium passes is pretty damned good and gives a slight advantage to the offense which doesn't seem a bad idea.

I think too many people are looking at this game as a finished product, and don't understand that there are still growing pains left to get through. Right now he is addressing the CB/WR dynamics, which is good.

Just using his numbers of 50-65%, most of the advantage ends up in the offense's hands. Remember that percentage chance is for evenly matched players, BUT the WR can focus his training on agility, catching, and the possession tree to move the percentage bar upwards for his specialties, while that CB has to be able to adequately cover both the agile possession guys, and the lightning fast deep threat guys.

I think his number there seems about right.

PinTBC


I don't want to rip into you too hard, because what you're saying isn't all that bad; but 50-65% completion on short and medium passes is an advantage to the offense?!

60.8% is NFL median (regular season, 2007), including ALL passes-- short, medium, and long. If one just looks at short passes, one would likely get something like 80%. Short and medium passes would most likely be 65% (it certainly would be higher than the 60.8% includes short, medium, and long). The longer the pass, obviously the lower the completion rate should be.

But a range of 50-65%, not counting long passes, is a small advantage to the defense, not the offense.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
We should move this to an area better suited to discussion.

I'd love to give you examples of what I am saying.

Ken,

You are not looking at the game as a whole, you are seeing the game as it exists today. You like to quote NFL numbers, but we are only in season four here. These players have 6 more seasons to train before they even start to decline, giving them what a 14 season lifetime?

In season 4 there isn't a huge difference between a receiver trained for speed and a receiver trained to be a possession receiver, and the same base CB can do a decent job covering both. Although, on Crimson, one of our top receivers is pretty much a possession receiver, so they definately get open now.

What happens in season 6 when the builds diverge by 8 or so more levels? or season 10 when they look VERY different? Do you honestly think that same base CB will be able to cover either? Or match up equally with either? The offense is going to have a huge advantage due to the way player builds can go. Hell by having multiple sets of gear, you can morph possession receivers into pretty decent deep ball threats, and at level 10 it will be worse.

PinTBC
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
I agree 100% with PinTBC.

There are some nasty fast/quick WR's out there...talking about guys with 80+ speed and 70+ agi with good catching skills that CB's HAVE to protect against. While they can cover a slower possession WR, they have to adjust their D to play off the line or give a cushion so they don't get beat long every play. This allows the possession guys room to move. Not to mention with their catching,jumping and vision the possession guys will get thrown to because the QB has confidence in them.

You can see the same thing happening on defense with DE's vs OT's. You can run two DE's at an OT, one is an elusive guy, one a bull rusher. The OT can't have enough STR/BLK to deal with one AND have enough SPD/AGI to deal with the other. It's a total mismatch on the defensive side.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
We should move this to an area better suited to discussion.

I'd love to give you examples of what I am saying.

Ken,

You are not looking at the game as a whole, you are seeing the game as it exists today. You like to quote NFL numbers, but we are only in season four here. These players have 6 more seasons to train before they even start to decline, giving them what a 14 season lifetime?

In season 4 there isn't a huge difference between a receiver trained for speed and a receiver trained to be a possession receiver, and the same base CB can do a decent job covering both. Although, on Crimson, one of our top receivers is pretty much a possession receiver, so they definately get open now.

What happens in season 6 when the builds diverge by 8 or so more levels? or season 10 when they look VERY different? Do you honestly think that same base CB will be able to cover either? Or match up equally with either? The offense is going to have a huge advantage due to the way player builds can go. Hell by having multiple sets of gear, you can morph possession receivers into pretty decent deep ball threats, and at level 10 it will be worse.

PinTBC


One thing you aren't keeping in mind is that not only has leveling slowed down quite a bit for any high level player, but everything, from base attributes to SA's, has a very rapidly increasing cost.

The players aren't nearly as far as you suggest from where they'll be at their peaks.

Even if they were, they're playing against players at a lower level than they'll be playing against, and it ought to be relative.

I am not willing to accept it as "We're still playing High School ball" or something, because I didn't sign up for a high school sim; I signed up for a sim of pro/major college type football, and with my players' careers 1/3 over I would hope that we're playing at major college levels by now.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1

One thing you aren't keeping in mind is that not only has leveling slowed down quite a bit for any high level player, but everything, from base attributes to SA's, has a very rapidly increasing cost.

The players aren't nearly as far as you suggest from where they'll be at their peaks.


Let's look at my WR as an example. He is level 25 and his base stats are:

Strength: 10 Blocking: 9
Speed: 55.43 Tackling: 8
Agility: 48.12 Throwing: 7
Jumping: 30.95 Catching: 41.3
Stamina: 29.06 Carrying: 26.27
Vision: 40.34 Kicking: 7
Confidence: 27.38 Punting: 8

specials of 2-3-1-2-0, and 2-4-6-1-1

By simply modifying his equipment, I have 22 points I can adjust almost anywhere I need to. You want a possession receiver, bump his agility to 60, and his catching to 53. You want more of a pure speedster? Bump his speed to 75 and agility to 50. You want someone to run through some tackles bump his strength up to 32. And that is at level 25, he will get another increase at 32, and 40. Figure that if for the next 6 seasons he will at the very least get his boosts, he gets to at least level 41 just by boosting, and by the way, he has boosts left for this season.

By the way, as you level, your equipment will become extremely important in your builds. Eventually the bonus from equipment greatly exceeds the bonus you will get from boosting three times.

How do you design cornerbacks that can cover all those options without either guessing which path the Receiver will take, or by building a general all around trade kind of guy who isn't as good at specific things as that receiver, therefore raising that completion percentage some.


Originally posted by Ken1
Even if they were, they're playing against players at a lower level than they'll be playing against, and it ought to be relative.


Except that as I said before, right now there is a bit of a difference between a speedster, and a possession guy, but not enough to make the corners have to make hard choices. I'm expecting that around level 32ish, it is going to start to be tough to design a good all around CB that can handle the possession guys as well as Flame's speedsters.

Originally posted by Ken1
I am not willing to accept it as "We're still playing High School ball" or something, because I didn't sign up for a high school sim; I signed up for a sim of pro/major college type football, and with my players' careers 1/3 over I would hope that we're playing at major college levels by now.


No where in my post did I mention High school ball. BUT, since your players progress, and you assign or add to their abilities, you can't expect to hit NFL averages at level 1. If you could, then why would you ever even desire to progress further? and how exactly would you limit things? even worse, how would you address the differences in builds that at top levels will be or at least should be rather extreme.

PinTBC
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 16:15:45
 
Link
 
Now I understand what Bort is saying, and how he needs to test the algorythms out on a seperate server and it takes time and all that. Thats fantastic, please continue doing you job like we pay you to please.

But I must say something, I dont care how short the pass is, or how long. When a CB is literally covering more than 60% of the WRs dot, a 50-65 completion % is way way too high. The replay is just an 'estimate' yes, but its too common of a thing for the dots to be innacurate representations. Anyone with that argument cant tell me they ever saw the CB make an INT from 3 yards away from the ball, or a HB caught up a ball with noone within diving tackle range.(jjust for example)

I see WRs catching the ball directly ontop of the CB on atleast a 3:1 catch : PDs rate.

CBs look aweful, you took away reaction time that WRs did not need. The agility changes were harder on CBs than they were WRs, I believe that was enough.

WRs usually move in relatively the same direction throughout their route as they do when they come off the line and never really have start from 0 speed again.
CBs are forced to make up extra ground all game long, a CB can stop dead in his tracks up to 2 or 3 times per play.

I watch some of the best CBs from last season 'suck ass' nowadays, and while I know the problems we speak of are not something you completely disagree with, and your working to balance things out, I think things were pretty solid as-is.

My main point is, the agility changes were enough to put CBs at a disadvantage. Hire some help, its week 8 already.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 17:28:30
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.