And just to affirm Bort, I think the latest tweaks were a great overall improvement to the game.
hntrr31
offline
offline
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
And just to affirm Bort, I think the latest tweaks were a great overall improvement to the game.
For the most part, I agree.
And just to affirm Bort, I think the latest tweaks were a great overall improvement to the game.
For the most part, I agree.
j10er
offline
offline
Here are the main issues:
1) The dots are approximately 2x2 yards. That's 6 feet by 6 feet. That's an ENORMOUS amount of space to represent a human being. Of course, any smaller, and we couldn't see what was going on.
Honestly, how much space does a football player occupy, with his arms at his side? 2x3 feet? See the discrepancy?
2) Also, the dots don't represent which direction the player is facing. That's another big factor. If the player isn't watching the pass, what chance does he have of properly defending?
3) And here's probably the biggest problem... defensive builds. Bort indicated that there are essentially two checks to determine the result of a pass from the defender's viewpoint. The position of the defender and the defender's swatting ability.
Obviously, positioning seems to be ok (still tough to determine direction facing, or even if that's a factor). Which makes sense, because that probably has to do with speed, agility and vision.
Now... swatting ability. What factors into that? Jumping? Catching? Strength?
How many defenders have better jumping/catching than a WR?? How many CBs have better strength than a WR?
I'm not so sure it merits a change. Once defenders adjust, the pendulum will swing again.
1) The dots are approximately 2x2 yards. That's 6 feet by 6 feet. That's an ENORMOUS amount of space to represent a human being. Of course, any smaller, and we couldn't see what was going on.
Honestly, how much space does a football player occupy, with his arms at his side? 2x3 feet? See the discrepancy?
2) Also, the dots don't represent which direction the player is facing. That's another big factor. If the player isn't watching the pass, what chance does he have of properly defending?
3) And here's probably the biggest problem... defensive builds. Bort indicated that there are essentially two checks to determine the result of a pass from the defender's viewpoint. The position of the defender and the defender's swatting ability.
Obviously, positioning seems to be ok (still tough to determine direction facing, or even if that's a factor). Which makes sense, because that probably has to do with speed, agility and vision.
Now... swatting ability. What factors into that? Jumping? Catching? Strength?
How many defenders have better jumping/catching than a WR?? How many CBs have better strength than a WR?
I'm not so sure it merits a change. Once defenders adjust, the pendulum will swing again.
UCHI_MATA_MASTER
offline
offline
As the title of this forum says....."this is getting stupid"....I'd like to complain that my LB hasn't had a sack yet.... or my HB hasn't run a score on the PR.....or My CEnter hasn't gotten a pancake, ran off down the field to block a runner who gets a forced fumble on him where my C picks the ballup and lumbers down the field 87yds and makes an amazing touchdown............leave it alone...shit happens....and as a D-line/LB coach I've seen my allstate D have a short pass, in double coverage turn into 62 yard touchdown. It's football. BOrt please don't change it. It's almost as realistic as you can get without telling the dfensive linemen which route to run in a blitz. of course on a side note, Bort it would be nice to set our blitzing lanesand stunts for the D-line/LB Hm I think I'll put a post int eh suggestions box...
pestface
offline
offline
The TE is a pretty good receiver:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=148950
1) He's got 6 levels on the LB and 2 on the SS
2)42 Catching is pretty good
3) While you may be taller, height doesn't mean much and I'm sure 33 jumping gets him off the ground
4) He's got 3 in sticky hands
5) He's got 43 strength, which may or may not factor in, but if it does he probably has a pretty good presence inbetween the the SS and LB
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=148950
1) He's got 6 levels on the LB and 2 on the SS
2)42 Catching is pretty good
3) While you may be taller, height doesn't mean much and I'm sure 33 jumping gets him off the ground
4) He's got 3 in sticky hands
5) He's got 43 strength, which may or may not factor in, but if it does he probably has a pretty good presence inbetween the the SS and LB
23yrwej
offline
offline
Originally posted by Undead Merchant
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Undead Merchant
The dots are three yards wide. If someone is covered by three people in the game, they could easily be three yards away from him each way. Also, the replays aren't exactly what happens, the text says what happens, go by that, and don't complain if the replay is a little off. And yes, recievers in real life can catch the ball in double coverage and even triple coverage.
How often does that happen to WRs not named Moss or TO when covered by 3 guys all around them? Almost never.
Tyree in the damn superbowl. Steve Smith of the NYG made a catch with two guys on top of him when the ball reached him in an earlier game. Shockey in the 2007 season made a catch while being hit to the ground by two people. Plaxico Burress made a catch in double coverage with a guy in front of him, and another right behind him.
IT HAPPENS!!!
Deal with it. Go watch a youtube video of the Panther's Steve Smith and you'll find a few.
Tyree was not in double or triple coverage. He caught the ball behind Rodney Harrison in single coverage which is why the play is so great. I am not saying WRs and TEs can't win jump balls but I am saying it should just be less frequent when well covered by 2 guys. Bort I think you are doing a solid job and you are working hard so thank you. This is just one man's opinion.
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Undead Merchant
The dots are three yards wide. If someone is covered by three people in the game, they could easily be three yards away from him each way. Also, the replays aren't exactly what happens, the text says what happens, go by that, and don't complain if the replay is a little off. And yes, recievers in real life can catch the ball in double coverage and even triple coverage.
How often does that happen to WRs not named Moss or TO when covered by 3 guys all around them? Almost never.
Tyree in the damn superbowl. Steve Smith of the NYG made a catch with two guys on top of him when the ball reached him in an earlier game. Shockey in the 2007 season made a catch while being hit to the ground by two people. Plaxico Burress made a catch in double coverage with a guy in front of him, and another right behind him.
IT HAPPENS!!!
Deal with it. Go watch a youtube video of the Panther's Steve Smith and you'll find a few.
Tyree was not in double or triple coverage. He caught the ball behind Rodney Harrison in single coverage which is why the play is so great. I am not saying WRs and TEs can't win jump balls but I am saying it should just be less frequent when well covered by 2 guys. Bort I think you are doing a solid job and you are working hard so thank you. This is just one man's opinion.
23yrwej
offline
offline
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Undead Merchant
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Undead Merchant
The dots are three yards wide. If someone is covered by three people in the game, they could easily be three yards away from him each way. Also, the replays aren't exactly what happens, the text says what happens, go by that, and don't complain if the replay is a little off. And yes, recievers in real life can catch the ball in double coverage and even triple coverage.
How often does that happen to WRs not named Moss or TO when covered by 3 guys all around them? Almost never.
Tyree in the damn superbowl. Steve Smith of the NYG made a catch with two guys on top of him when the ball reached him in an earlier game. Shockey in the 2007 season made a catch while being hit to the ground by two people. Plaxico Burress made a catch in double coverage with a guy in front of him, and another right behind him.
IT HAPPENS!!!
Deal with it. Go watch a youtube video of the Panther's Steve Smith and you'll find a few.
Tyree was not in double or triple coverage. He caught the ball behind Rodney Harrison in single coverage which is why the playhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxWDnWpctlY is so great. I am not saying WRs and TEs can't win jump balls but I am saying it should just be less frequent when well covered by 2 guys. Bort I think you are doing a solid job and you are working hard so thank you. This is just one man's opinion.
This is the Tyree catch which is considered amazing and it's in SINGLE Coverage:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxWDnWpctlY
Like I said...wining jump balls in single coverage happens a good deal in the NFL but it almost never happens in double or triple coverage unless your name is Moss or TO.
Originally posted by Undead Merchant
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Undead Merchant
The dots are three yards wide. If someone is covered by three people in the game, they could easily be three yards away from him each way. Also, the replays aren't exactly what happens, the text says what happens, go by that, and don't complain if the replay is a little off. And yes, recievers in real life can catch the ball in double coverage and even triple coverage.
How often does that happen to WRs not named Moss or TO when covered by 3 guys all around them? Almost never.
Tyree in the damn superbowl. Steve Smith of the NYG made a catch with two guys on top of him when the ball reached him in an earlier game. Shockey in the 2007 season made a catch while being hit to the ground by two people. Plaxico Burress made a catch in double coverage with a guy in front of him, and another right behind him.
IT HAPPENS!!!
Deal with it. Go watch a youtube video of the Panther's Steve Smith and you'll find a few.
Tyree was not in double or triple coverage. He caught the ball behind Rodney Harrison in single coverage which is why the playhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxWDnWpctlY is so great. I am not saying WRs and TEs can't win jump balls but I am saying it should just be less frequent when well covered by 2 guys. Bort I think you are doing a solid job and you are working hard so thank you. This is just one man's opinion.
This is the Tyree catch which is considered amazing and it's in SINGLE Coverage:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxWDnWpctlY
Like I said...wining jump balls in single coverage happens a good deal in the NFL but it almost never happens in double or triple coverage unless your name is Moss or TO.
Vagrant God
offline
offline
I didn't mean to suggest that he was in triple coverage, I meant to suggest ridiculous catches happens.
23yrwej
offline
offline
Originally posted by Undead Merchant
I didn't mean to suggest that he was in triple coverage, I meant to suggest ridiculous catches happens.
That's wasn't what I was arguing against. Like I said how many times do guys make catches in real life in double to triple coverage? Surely not 5 times a game.
I didn't mean to suggest that he was in triple coverage, I meant to suggest ridiculous catches happens.
That's wasn't what I was arguing against. Like I said how many times do guys make catches in real life in double to triple coverage? Surely not 5 times a game.
Vagrant God
offline
offline
Every game... Just kidding. I just got a little mad because he showed one play initially, and complained about it. I know it is a little extreme now, but the current system is better than the old, and Bort said he is tweaking it, so there should be less problems.
Devolution
offline
offline
why are we debating this? it clearly states that the TE was Antonio Gates, you can't stop him, nobody can stop him. The SS must have been Roy Williams and the Linebacker was...well it doesn't matter who the linebacker was because the TE was Antonio Gates.
In the NFL people get double covered all the time, it doesn't mean they don't get any catches.
In the NFL people get double covered all the time, it doesn't mean they don't get any catches.
Rush Hour700
offline
offline
thanks Bort....i 2 would like too se a change in this...as much as it was a joy to see my WR moss the shit out of 2 Defenders it isnt realistic......at least not every time
In my game today..my team has great athletes...even the Lb's fast with agility n vision and can jump.....the TE was catching BS in triple coverage.....The WR's were constantly catching passes in double coverage.....
it is a bit on realistic.....if a guy is double covered it should be like 2 out of 10 times does he make that catch....seriously
In my game today..my team has great athletes...even the Lb's fast with agility n vision and can jump.....the TE was catching BS in triple coverage.....The WR's were constantly catching passes in double coverage.....
it is a bit on realistic.....if a guy is double covered it should be like 2 out of 10 times does he make that catch....seriously
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by stahu miguel
Originally posted by Bort
Well the other option to help the passing game not completely suck is to allow receivers to get open even more often, by increasing the likelihood of a fake, or reducing reaction time yet more. Of course, then people would complain that their CB can't stick to every receiver like glue all the time.
But that would be more realistic. I'm not saying I like the thought, but I think that is the right thing to do.
Why don't you like the thought when you say yourself it's more realistic?
We didn't have anything near realistic stats before the tweaks, and ypa are still lower overall than the NFL's after them.
Now, I agree that it should be harder to cover man to man, and that once that's done it can be a little easier to knock the ball away, especially in double or triple coverage.
Bort is absolutely right here. He could make that change, and it would be better overall with the same overall averages; but people would then complain that their CB can't cover WR's step for step every time. I can see the posts, "If I have higher speed and agility, there's no way the receiver should get open." Wrong. The receiver knows where he's going. Your defender doesn't. Defenders should sometimes be fooled.
Why do you think zones are often used in real life? Why do you think in real life defenders usually give a cushion?
And if you're going for the interception, you should accept that if you don't get it your chance to deflect the ball will be impaired.
Originally posted by Bort
Well the other option to help the passing game not completely suck is to allow receivers to get open even more often, by increasing the likelihood of a fake, or reducing reaction time yet more. Of course, then people would complain that their CB can't stick to every receiver like glue all the time.
But that would be more realistic. I'm not saying I like the thought, but I think that is the right thing to do.
Why don't you like the thought when you say yourself it's more realistic?
We didn't have anything near realistic stats before the tweaks, and ypa are still lower overall than the NFL's after them.
Now, I agree that it should be harder to cover man to man, and that once that's done it can be a little easier to knock the ball away, especially in double or triple coverage.
Bort is absolutely right here. He could make that change, and it would be better overall with the same overall averages; but people would then complain that their CB can't cover WR's step for step every time. I can see the posts, "If I have higher speed and agility, there's no way the receiver should get open." Wrong. The receiver knows where he's going. Your defender doesn't. Defenders should sometimes be fooled.
Why do you think zones are often used in real life? Why do you think in real life defenders usually give a cushion?
And if you're going for the interception, you should accept that if you don't get it your chance to deflect the ball will be impaired.
drifter
offline
offline
As was pointed out, keep in mind that we are watching dots. Did anyone see the Steelers - Bills preseason game last night?
On the bomb to Santonio Holmes, he was wide open, but by the time he caught the ball in the end zone both the CB and Safety had gotten pretty close to him. If we were to depict that play as dots, it would appear that when he caught the ball he was double covered when in reality he was not. Dots are not a perfect depiction of what goes on - the number crunching that the sim puts on does its best to simulate plays like the Holmes bomb last night and just because it looks like two dots were draped over another dot, it does not mean it was an accurate portrayal of what might have occurred.
On the bomb to Santonio Holmes, he was wide open, but by the time he caught the ball in the end zone both the CB and Safety had gotten pretty close to him. If we were to depict that play as dots, it would appear that when he caught the ball he was double covered when in reality he was not. Dots are not a perfect depiction of what goes on - the number crunching that the sim puts on does its best to simulate plays like the Holmes bomb last night and just because it looks like two dots were draped over another dot, it does not mean it was an accurate portrayal of what might have occurred.
Laggo
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
Why do you think zones are often used in real life? Why do you think in real life defenders usually give a cushion?
Zone is relatively useless atm because you can pretty much cover man-to-man 100% effective with non-suck CB's
Why do you think zones are often used in real life? Why do you think in real life defenders usually give a cushion?
Zone is relatively useless atm because you can pretty much cover man-to-man 100% effective with non-suck CB's
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























