User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Problem with Stamina/Substitution/Depth?
Page:
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
And honestly all these "you can't play football with only one backup at each position" posts are completely wrong.

QB = never come out
RB = backup might get 25% the snaps the starter does. #3 very seldom.
WR = many teams only carry 4-5 WR's (one backup at each position, get on field in 3/4 WR sets)
TE = many teams only carry 2
OL = seldom will the starters ever come out
DL/LB = one spot where subs occur more frequently but even then it's usually 2 people on the bench rotating in
Secondary = seldom come out, subs come in to act as 3rd/4th DB in nickel/dime situations.

 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
If they are going to make stamina matter it needs to be position specific. Positions that hardly ever require subbing in real life should be the same here. Honestly the only positions I see acting unrealistically right now are RB's, maybe WR's a little bit... OL seldom ever come out of a game... maybe DL and LB's a bit as well.

Here's a game where I set the stamina to 0 out/30 in... was testing... starters never came out. With the exception of the RB and maybe a few too many plays by the OL, I don't see many abnormalities.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=2813

A small fix would be nice but please don't make it to where you HAVE to bring in back ups at a position where you would never ever use one.

This is fixed on its own, if you have all stats drop at the same rate when energy is being depleted.

I mean, O-lineman don't need to come out as much because it comes down to blocking and strength; those are their two high stats, so it'll be a while before they're low enough to really be noticeably weakened, especially when you consider that their counterparts are wearing down almost equally. A RB, by contrast, needs speed and agility and vision and carrying and strength; loss of energy is going to be very noticeable very quickly.

Quarterbacks need vision and strength and throwing, not a ton. A running QB is going to have speed and agility and carrying though, so they would properly be more prone to 'getting tired'.

Edit for thehazyone: That's at the highest level. In pee wee football and high school, a lot of teams rotate in players at all those positions. If you leave it as it is now, everyone gets stamina to 20 and nobody puts points in it the rest of the way. It needs to scale so that the top layer is playing most snaps, but the young guys that need less playing time to XP are getting enough by having a rotation.
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 23:51:17
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chevyman
Originally posted by thehazyone

If they are going to make stamina matter it needs to be position specific. Positions that hardly ever require subbing in real life should be the same here. Honestly the only positions I see acting unrealistically right now are RB's, maybe WR's a little bit... OL seldom ever come out of a game... maybe DL and LB's a bit as well.

Here's a game where I set the stamina to 0 out/30 in... was testing... starters never came out. With the exception of the RB and maybe a few too many plays by the OL, I don't see many abnormalities.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=2813

A small fix would be nice but please don't make it to where you HAVE to bring in back ups at a position where you would never ever use one.


What were the players energys at after the game?


Lowest one was 69. Yea, that I could see being the fix (more plays = lower energy)... the others I don't get.
 
claystone
offline
Link
 
I said this around 3 weeks ago. Have a play time settings for all positions. That way you can set each positions play time. This will allow you to use depth without having all players coming off the field at once.

ie:
set LB at 85% play time
set D-line to play 75% time
set WR to play 90%

etc.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Hey, I have no problem with making energy affect you more, for next season. It used to be, but people got me second guessing myself. I should probably go with my gut more often than letting the internets sway me.


Bort, can we now assume stamina will play a bigger role in season 2 so teams can plan ahead?

 
chevyman~Cult~
like a rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
Originally posted by chevyman

Originally posted by thehazyone


If they are going to make stamina matter it needs to be position specific. Positions that hardly ever require subbing in real life should be the same here. Honestly the only positions I see acting unrealistically right now are RB's, maybe WR's a little bit... OL seldom ever come out of a game... maybe DL and LB's a bit as well.

Here's a game where I set the stamina to 0 out/30 in... was testing... starters never came out. With the exception of the RB and maybe a few too many plays by the OL, I don't see many abnormalities.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=2813

A small fix would be nice but please don't make it to where you HAVE to bring in back ups at a position where you would never ever use one.


What were the players energys at after the game?


Lowest one was 69. Yea, that I could see being the fix (more plays = lower energy)... the others I don't get.


If I would have known something like that I would have planned the whole season diferently.
 
claystone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chevyman
Originally posted by Bort

Hey, I have no problem with making energy affect you more, for next season. It used to be, but people got me second guessing myself. I should probably go with my gut more often than letting the internets sway me.


I would love to see this done. I based the season off the thought that this was supost to be realistic. So I made sure I had depth. Alot of talk was about how stamina was important. How it is now it is not important at all. All you need is one backup per type of position is not real football. It really sucks to be beaten by a team that has no depth. When you have depth and all players play a good amount of plays across the board. Not just the starters getting all the playing time. Had the belief that energy afected how well you played so to guys with very close builds same level but one with 80% energy will play better then the other guy with 60-70% energy. That seams not the case. If this game is supost to be a realisic as it can then energy and depth need to play a bigger part. Non of this one guy can play 90+ plays. Unrealistic. If you want realism then "max numbers" can not play a part. That is my thought.


I also made sure I had depth, because I thought we were playing a "Sim Football Game", not "Ironman Football".

 
aeakers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
If they are going to make stamina matter it needs to be position specific. Positions that hardly ever require subbing in real life should be the same here. Honestly the only positions I see acting unrealistically right now are RB's, maybe WR's a little bit... OL seldom ever come out of a game... maybe DL and LB's a bit as well.

Here's a game where I set the stamina to 0 out/30 in... was testing... starters never came out. With the exception of the RB and maybe a few too many plays by the OL, I don't see many abnormalities.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=2813

A small fix would be nice but please don't make it to where you HAVE to bring in back ups at a position where you would never ever use one.


In the NFL, linemen, linebackers, and even defensive backs miss plays, series, even halves of games routinely due to injuries and fatigue. Not only that, but it seems in GLB, guys do not get "worn down", which I think is many people's concern.

 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Yea me too, in fact my offseason planning adjusted to just this. If they go around changing it again I'm gonna have to scramble to readjust.
 
GRiPSSL
offline
Link
 
I pumped stamina in my players thinking it mattered.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aeakers
Originally posted by thehazyone

If they are going to make stamina matter it needs to be position specific. Positions that hardly ever require subbing in real life should be the same here. Honestly the only positions I see acting unrealistically right now are RB's, maybe WR's a little bit... OL seldom ever come out of a game... maybe DL and LB's a bit as well.

Here's a game where I set the stamina to 0 out/30 in... was testing... starters never came out. With the exception of the RB and maybe a few too many plays by the OL, I don't see many abnormalities.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=2813

A small fix would be nice but please don't make it to where you HAVE to bring in back ups at a position where you would never ever use one.


In the NFL, linemen, linebackers, and even defensive backs miss plays, series, even halves of games routinely due to injuries and fatigue. Not only that, but it seems in GLB, guys do not get "worn down", which I think is many people's concern.




What player in the NFL doesn't get wore down? I think the thing that needs to happen more realistically is a time of possession check that gives the other team a boost or minus... if a defense has been on the field for 30 minutes as opposed to 15 minutes for the other team, they should be more tired and susceptible to giving up big plays (vice versa if the defense is rested, more likely to stop opponent). On an equal time possession though, the effect would usually be linear between offense and defense thus negating any fatigue effect on play.

And advanced tactics could allow an owner to make substitutions in these instances mentioned above.
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 23:58:43
 
chevyman~Cult~
like a rock
offline
Link
 
Hopefully we can get a final word on what will happen with this so guys can plan properly
 
chevyman~Cult~
like a rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GRiPSSL
I pumped stamina in my players thinking it mattered.


A lot of people did. So basicly we hurt our players in a way. Cause that took points away from other skills. The points could of been added to other skills to make that player better.
 
claystone
offline
Link
 
I hope they can adjust this for the new season. It's no fun if I can have superman play the whole game.
 
chevyman~Cult~
like a rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by claystone
I hope they can adjust this for the new season. It's no fun if I can have superman play the whole game.


Hear yea on that one.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.