User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is clearly an exploit and should be addressed ASAP
Page:
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Bort


It really just sounds like a job for CB -> WR matchup priorities. Of course that wouldn't apply to zone defenses -- only man-to-man -- but it would probably help.

The new DC 1/2/3 positions were supposed to help in this regard but I think they have caused more problems than they have solved really, which is too bad.

I don't know if it would be very easy to just lock the offense part of the DC earlier than the defense, since they are on the same page and part of the same form submission. It would take some doing, and it doesn't really address the problem completely. More of a band-aid than anything.


I agree with the "band-aid over a chest wound" thing, but wouldn't having CBs match up to the "Best" WR (and the god awful levels of describing "best" in such a way the AI can understand and apply it) be murder.

I mean, maybe a simple match-up by name would work (assuming it didn't go off the other team's DC because people would just leave it blank for a while so the Def. couldn't plan) but I have no idea the amount of work required.


Yeah, I'm talking about matchups that the team owner enters.

Like he can edit his list of CB's and use some pulldowns to select the name of the WR he wants to to be the #1 priority for each CB. If that WR's in the game, the CB covers him. If not it just falls back to the same logic as now.

There's probably some conflict stuff that might get hairy, like if you choose the same matchup on more than one player, but you get the idea.


I think that's the only solution. It would looke like

Designate main receiver threat - <drop down>
Coverage option 1 - <drop down>
Coverage option 2 - <drop down>
Coverage option 3 - <drop down>

Designate 2nd receiver threat - <drop down>
etc...

In the event of conflicts, the designated #1 threat will go down its list first and choose the coverage option that fits within the energy settings paramaters. THen the designated #2 threat, etc.

IN the event of a non-designated threat or an exhausted coverage depth chart, it will default to the CB depth chart.
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
not to change the subject but if your going to do all this it would be a good time to implament a double team check box as well
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
not to change the subject but if your going to do all this it would be a good time to implament a double team check box as well


Probably needs to be more than a check box. I think it would work like blitzing where you assign who is helping with the double team and what % of the time.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by Bort



It really just sounds like a job for CB -> WR matchup priorities. Of course that wouldn't apply to zone defenses -- only man-to-man -- but it would probably help.

The new DC 1/2/3 positions were supposed to help in this regard but I think they have caused more problems than they have solved really, which is too bad.

I don't know if it would be very easy to just lock the offense part of the DC earlier than the defense, since they are on the same page and part of the same form submission. It would take some doing, and it doesn't really address the problem completely. More of a band-aid than anything.


I agree with the "band-aid over a chest wound" thing, but wouldn't having CBs match up to the "Best" WR (and the god awful levels of describing "best" in such a way the AI can understand and apply it) be murder.

I mean, maybe a simple match-up by name would work (assuming it didn't go off the other team's DC because people would just leave it blank for a while so the Def. couldn't plan) but I have no idea the amount of work required.


Yeah, I'm talking about matchups that the team owner enters.

Like he can edit his list of CB's and use some pulldowns to select the name of the WR he wants to to be the #1 priority for each CB. If that WR's in the game, the CB covers him. If not it just falls back to the same logic as now.

There's probably some conflict stuff that might get hairy, like if you choose the same matchup on more than one player, but you get the idea.


I think that's the only solution. It would looke like

Designate main receiver threat - <drop down>
Coverage option 1 - <drop down>
Coverage option 2 - <drop down>
Coverage option 3 - <drop down>

Designate 2nd receiver threat - <drop down>
etc...

In the event of conflicts, the designated #1 threat will go down its list first and choose the coverage option that fits within the energy settings paramaters. THen the designated #2 threat, etc.

IN the event of a non-designated threat or an exhausted coverage depth chart, it will default to the CB depth chart.


Would that work better than:

CB Bob Jones: <primary wr to cover> <secondary wr to cover> <tertiary wr to cover>
CB Bill Johnson: <primary wr to cover> <secondary wr to cover> <tertiary wr to cover>

?

Just trying to figure out which would be easier? I guess it would have to list every single player on the other team, too, since you can put anybody anywhere on the DC.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Also, in the meant time, I think that in the short term you do what I said at the beginning. If you use the slotted depth chart and a spot is blank, it will default to the General DT but will pass over any players already designated as the first pick in any of the slotted DP spots.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
not to change the subject but if your going to do all this it would be a good time to implament a double team check box as well


I guess the first suggested list (drifters) would work better for that.

threat #1: <drop down> [ double %]
<cover guy 1>
<cover guy 2>
<cover guy 3>

etc.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by Bort




It really just sounds like a job for CB -> WR matchup priorities. Of course that wouldn't apply to zone defenses -- only man-to-man -- but it would probably help.

The new DC 1/2/3 positions were supposed to help in this regard but I think they have caused more problems than they have solved really, which is too bad.

I don't know if it would be very easy to just lock the offense part of the DC earlier than the defense, since they are on the same page and part of the same form submission. It would take some doing, and it doesn't really address the problem completely. More of a band-aid than anything.


I agree with the "band-aid over a chest wound" thing, but wouldn't having CBs match up to the "Best" WR (and the god awful levels of describing "best" in such a way the AI can understand and apply it) be murder.

I mean, maybe a simple match-up by name would work (assuming it didn't go off the other team's DC because people would just leave it blank for a while so the Def. couldn't plan) but I have no idea the amount of work required.


Yeah, I'm talking about matchups that the team owner enters.

Like he can edit his list of CB's and use some pulldowns to select the name of the WR he wants to to be the #1 priority for each CB. If that WR's in the game, the CB covers him. If not it just falls back to the same logic as now.

There's probably some conflict stuff that might get hairy, like if you choose the same matchup on more than one player, but you get the idea.


I think that's the only solution. It would looke like

Designate main receiver threat - <drop down>
Coverage option 1 - <drop down>
Coverage option 2 - <drop down>
Coverage option 3 - <drop down>

Designate 2nd receiver threat - <drop down>
etc...

In the event of conflicts, the designated #1 threat will go down its list first and choose the coverage option that fits within the energy settings paramaters. THen the designated #2 threat, etc.

IN the event of a non-designated threat or an exhausted coverage depth chart, it will default to the CB depth chart.


Would that work better than:

CB Bob Jones: <primary wr to cover> <secondary wr to cover> <tertiary wr to cover>
CB Bill Johnson: <primary wr to cover> <secondary wr to cover> <tertiary wr to cover>

?

Just trying to figure out which would be easier? I guess it would have to list every single player on the other team, too, since you can put anybody anywhere on the DC.



Your way might be simpler but the advantage of my way is that my designating primary threat, secondary threat, etc. You give a clear progression of priority in the event of conflicts.

Once again, it would need to be able to be left blank or go back to the general DT if it exhausted it's options.
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rezlov
Even if the above is true, regular college/pro/HS teams would do the same. You don't HAVE to stick your best WRs in the #1 spot. Go cry because your CBs can't cover their shade.


+1
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter

Exactly - which has been stated several times, is something the devs have clearly said they want to avoid as it provides advantages for those who can be by their computers at game time.


And by setting the CB to always guard the WR of choice - what this does is exactly the same thing, except insure that the Defense wins the matchup of who can be at their computer at game time.

I wouldn't have a problem with that at all, except the offense should be able to look at the matchups, before the ball is snapped, and determine that the passing play looks bad and audible it to a running play.

Anyways, Bort has final say -- and just like everything else in life.. our options are either to Deal with it, or register our opinions by going elsewhere. (not a threat, just the way things are)
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by drifter


Exactly - which has been stated several times, is something the devs have clearly said they want to avoid as it provides advantages for those who can be by their computers at game time.


And by setting the CB to always guard the WR of choice - what this does is exactly the same thing, except insure that the Defense wins the matchup of who can be at their computer at game time.

I wouldn't have a problem with that at all, except the offense should be able to look at the matchups, before the ball is snapped, and determine that the passing play looks bad and audible it to a running play.

Anyways, Bort has final say -- and just like everything else in life.. our options are either to Deal with it, or register our opinions by going elsewhere. (not a threat, just the way things are)


except the rule in football is the defense always determines the matchups thats why the line has to set before the snap
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by drifter


Exactly - which has been stated several times, is something the devs have clearly said they want to avoid as it provides advantages for those who can be by their computers at game time.


And by setting the CB to always guard the WR of choice - what this does is exactly the same thing, except insure that the Defense wins the matchup of who can be at their computer at game time.

I wouldn't have a problem with that at all, except the offense should be able to look at the matchups, before the ball is snapped, and determine that the passing play looks bad and audible it to a running play.

Anyways, Bort has final say -- and just like everything else in life.. our options are either to Deal with it, or register our opinions by going elsewhere. (not a threat, just the way things are)



You might want to look at the last few posts
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by iMan
Originally posted by Rezlov

Even if the above is true, regular college/pro/HS teams would do the same. You don't HAVE to stick your best WRs in the #1 spot. Go cry because your CBs can't cover their shade.


+1


ditto to you
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

Originally posted by drifter



Exactly - which has been stated several times, is something the devs have clearly said they want to avoid as it provides advantages for those who can be by their computers at game time.


And by setting the CB to always guard the WR of choice - what this does is exactly the same thing, except insure that the Defense wins the matchup of who can be at their computer at game time.

I wouldn't have a problem with that at all, except the offense should be able to look at the matchups, before the ball is snapped, and determine that the passing play looks bad and audible it to a running play.

Anyways, Bort has final say -- and just like everything else in life.. our options are either to Deal with it, or register our opinions by going elsewhere. (not a threat, just the way things are)


except the rule in football is the defense always determines the matchups thats why the line has to set before the snap



There's no using logic or analogies to real life football with these types.
 
Wass
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by iMan
Originally posted by Rezlov

Even if the above is true, regular college/pro/HS teams would do the same. You don't HAVE to stick your best WRs in the #1 spot. Go cry because your CBs can't cover their shade.


+1


When the offense breaks from the huddle, the CB's can just follow the WR they're assigned to because the WR has to set. The WR can't wait for the CB to set and then choose where to go. And you know which receivers you want to cover with which CB's because you have game tape and game scouts that tell you.

against a zone defense, you may be able to stick the best reciever in a slot to expose a matchup or atleast cause confusion, but when a CB is told "you're covering WR A" then he'll line up on him regardless of how the offense lines up.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Wass
Originally posted by iMan

Originally posted by Rezlov


Even if the above is true, regular college/pro/HS teams would do the same. You don't HAVE to stick your best WRs in the #1 spot. Go cry because your CBs can't cover their shade.


+1


When the offense breaks from the huddle, the CB's can just follow the WR they're assigned to because the WR has to set. The WR can't wait for the CB to set and then choose where to go. And you know which receivers you want to cover with which CB's because you have game tape and game scouts that tell you.

against a zone defense, you may be able to stick the best reciever in a slot to expose a matchup or atleast cause confusion, but when a CB is told "you're covering WR A" then he'll line up on him regardless of how the offense lines up.


And even with zones, teams will still line up the best CB on the same side of the field as the best WR. There are some exceptions with CBs that only ever played one side of the field (Darryl Green was one, I think), but for the most part, a zone can be adjusted just like man coverage can.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.