User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
fate3283
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TurboBoxer

as a example, the NFL (its not the same as GLB, i know, but they are similar and similar stats are expected)

punt returns, only 12 teams got a TD off a PR....only 3 had more then 1.

kick returns, 16 teams got one or more TDs, 6 teams had more then 1.



point is, your not supposed to be getting a return TD a game (MAYBE one a season), so count yourself lucky if you already have one. Just because others are getting TDs, people forget to take into account their opponents.


If you would read before you post, no one is complaining about not getting enough TD, they are complaining that a player 'built' to be a returner is under performing every other position in the game.

When a WR/HB/TE/FB/OT/DE often with lower attributes averages 30yrd KR and 15yrd PR and your CB who his fast/agile/smart is averaging 20yrd KR and 10yrd PR you've wasted flexpoints
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
^ What he said.
 
juicepod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fate3283

If you would read before you post, no one is complaining about not getting enough TD, they are complaining that a player 'built' to be a returner is under performing every other position in the game.

When a WR/HB/TE/FB/OT/DE often with lower attributes averages 30yrd KR and 15yrd PR and your CB who his fast/agile/smart is averaging 20yrd KR and 10yrd PR you've wasted flexpoints


+1
 
BizYard
offline
Link
 
Glad I'm not the only one seeing this problem. My CB/Return Specialist is having the same problems. Fumbles at least 1x per game, if he cuts it's always too late and he's an average CB at best because he was designed to return kicks/punts.
 
pestface
offline
Link
 
I don't mind RBs being decent kick returners, but offensive and defensive linemen should not be so hard to take down.

Perhaps one of the biggest problems with power-running this season is that missed tackles are largely based on strength, and not so much speed/agility. Weaker guys who try to tackle them just get bounced off like a little kid. Fast agile guys are unable to slip through or maneuver out of any kind of tackle without having good strength too.

Tackling is not blocking, you are allowed to hold onto them. In a real game of football, the big muscly fat man will be slow and easy to grab on to. A 180-lb safety will still slow an immensely strong 300-lb power runner, just by hitting him at full speed and holding on. The effort of having to pancake 200 pounds away from you should at least cause a small reduction in speed.

While I understand the OL or DL can pancake a weak blocker away, this should be much harder while carrying a ball. Especially when they don't have the SA's for power-running- they don't know how to stiff-arm or power thru as effectively. Pancake plays need to be largely limited to guys who have both hands free (blockers), and not guys who are carrying. The only exceptions should be the HBs and FBs who spend their points in SAs and get specifc bonuses to manhandling weak guys while running.


One other thing- the rate at which missed tackles are capable of happening is way too high. While I can see a fast CB with great agility pulling a hester and dodging his way through 5 tacklers who just weren't quick enough, it's a much harder feat for one man to plow directly through 5 guys at once without as much as flinching. A Jerome Bettis-type can plow through 5 defenders for a gain, but he's not going to stay at full speed, most of them will hold onto him, and in most cases he will get slowed to the point where he gets taken down. You can only pancake or stiff-arm so many guys per second and keep going, when you're dealing with one tackler another guy should have an easier job.
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 20:47:26
 
themadhobbit
offline
Link
 
Misery loves company, I thought something was wrong with my CB, now it seems I am not alone.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
I would love it if my CB became a good returner. Kick returning is the sexiest kind of football. My CB is the first player I made on GLB and kind of special to me. When I was playing, I always wanted to return kicks and punts, but never got the chance. I wish my old coach could see how good the big, slow, strong types were at returning kicks, then he would regret not letting me do it.
 
themadhobbit
offline
Link
 
At least now I won't whine to my Head Coach about letting a fullback return punts.
 
Baghern
offline
Link
 
cough * http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91751&pbp_id=1552451 * cough....

Against a good team...
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Your missed tackle was a failed diving tackle. Big whoop. And nobody is saying it can't be done. With speed like you've got, all you need is some open field in front of you. Show us a replay of your CB making a great cut to get into open field, or a replay where he fakes out a guy who is in front of him.

This run, although impressive, just shows us a guy weaving around some good blocks and evading a diving tackle.
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 21:31:06
 
d1sregard
offline
Link
 
Wow, I thought I was the only one. My PURE return spec CB is horrible:

Strength: 16.18 Blocking: 9
Speed: 81.12 Tackling: 15.38
Agility: 48.69 Throwing: 10
Jumping: 21.12 Catching: 21.12
Stamina: 30 Carrying: 31.86
Vision: 35.96 Kicking: 7
Confidence: 17.08 Punting: 8

Shutdown: 0-0-0-0-0

Speedster: 3-5-6-0-0

I was going to get Return Spec to 10, but after I realized how worthless it is I stopped putting points into last season. Yes, I could use more vision, but my priority was agility due to the changes made this season. He still runs in a straight line, right at a tackler. So worthless: can't play defense as well as a regular CB and isn't better than an offensive/defensive lineman at returning. GG $15 down the toilet.
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 22:01:05
 
pestface
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Baghern
cough * http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91751&pbp_id=1552451 * cough....

Against a good team...


While that was good, even you must see the plays like this, where the CB fails to even attempt a cut:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91751&pbp_id=1552749
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91751&pbp_id=1555774

Oh wait, that was the same guy, same game.
 
Rod Long
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
How much damn carrying does a kick returner need?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=87912

Our returner here fumbled THREE times in one game. THREE.

He has 52 speed, 72 agility, 48 vision, 30 carrying. How does he fumble three times when our RBs don't fumble nearly as much? Strength seems to be playing WAY too big of a role in kick returns right now. When people are able to have an O Linemen return the ball and do just as well or better than a cornerback returning it, there's a major problem with the game.

WR Returners don't seem to have the same megafumble problem that Corners seem to have -- is there some sort of penalty attached to CB returners that we don't know about?


this is absolutely ridiculous for such a thing to happen. This is the second game one of my teams has lost because of this asinine setup for CB returners.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pestface
Originally posted by Baghern

cough * http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91751&pbp_id=1552451 * cough....

Against a good team...


While that was good, even you must see the plays like this, where the CB fails to even attempt a cut:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91751&pbp_id=1552749
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91751&pbp_id=1555774

Oh wait, that was the same guy, same game.


that was epic pwn
 
lvscotty
offline
Link
 
Perhaps the bug is just in the SA return specialist. Perhaps the boost has some broken code in it and that is why most CB returners are doing poorly.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.