Sorry, lost connection there at the worst possible moment.
Forum > Suggestions > Passing needs to be fixed in this game, very long post with a ton of research, don't discard as another whine post
Veggies
offline
offline
You know Ilok, I think a big reason you got those results, is because the league you took almost all your results from, is crap. I mean a capped league is going to have some pretty wacky things regardless, but some of those games are like D-league level teams playing one another. If you just go through the Pro leagues and sample random games from there, you'll see the majority tend to be much pass heavier than their lower cousins in matches that aren't one-sided slaughters. Even looking through an entire one I'm willing to bet the majority of teams had heavier passing games than rushing. It sure looked that way in the quick lookthrough I just did of Oceania and Canada Pro.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 22:48:45
Ken1
offline
offline
I've gone into Bugs. I'll only keep any argument that might start with opponents going if I get backup. Yesterday was too taxing, going 1 on 4 or whatever.
TDmaker99
offline
offline
if i can convince u that the problem with passing is the speed nerf, ill be right there with u
go watch te louisville warpath replay fom earlier today and tell me that what happened in tha game looked right to you, the db's dominad the wr's on almost every play ( on both sides), because now the wr's have no acceleration
go watch te louisville warpath replay fom earlier today and tell me that what happened in tha game looked right to you, the db's dominad the wr's on almost every play ( on both sides), because now the wr's have no acceleration
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 23:05:31
Yukon Don
offline
offline
Originally posted by dpell
Again, I've got a WR with 55 catching and soft-capped vision dropping lots of passes. I'd venture that that's in the top 2-5% of GLB WR's for catching.
Where is your WR's speed and agility...(rhetorical I don't expect you to post it in open forum)...however I'd question whether he is getting any separation? Also, route running, isn't that a factor of vision, is that low?
An incomplete pass isn't necessarily a function of your QB, it could be the WR, and it isn't just his catching, but also his ability to get open, and run the right route.
Again, I've got a WR with 55 catching and soft-capped vision dropping lots of passes. I'd venture that that's in the top 2-5% of GLB WR's for catching.
Where is your WR's speed and agility...(rhetorical I don't expect you to post it in open forum)...however I'd question whether he is getting any separation? Also, route running, isn't that a factor of vision, is that low?
An incomplete pass isn't necessarily a function of your QB, it could be the WR, and it isn't just his catching, but also his ability to get open, and run the right route.
Ilok
offline
offline
So for the game to play right, you need to be on a pro league and be a player since season 1? Are you serious?
People spent money to buy the capped league teams. People spent money to boost their players in those leagues. The game should work as well in the capped leagues as it does the pro leagues. Plain and simple. No I haven't checked the scrimmage games in the pro leagues cause i can't see them. I did look at some of the A and AA leagues and their passing looks as screwy as our does.
Also when you look at balance, the capped leagues in general will be more balanced, sure I don't hold much credit to the one game where 3 FB had over 100 yards rushing. But show many any week in the nfl in the past 10 years that no team threw for over 200 yards. And if it was a balance issue because of the league, would there be a outrageous passing total game to counter the outrageous rushing games? There isn't any. It was shown earlier in the thread where a completely human offense had crappy throwing numbers again a mostly CPU team, and in one case had a SS playing corner like Champ Baily.
Something is wrong, needs to be addressed before the season goes live. I don't care if it's a different sim in the capped leagues than there is in pro leagues. My money is the same as yours so I should play a fair game like yours regardless if I'm playing in the pros or AAA
People spent money to buy the capped league teams. People spent money to boost their players in those leagues. The game should work as well in the capped leagues as it does the pro leagues. Plain and simple. No I haven't checked the scrimmage games in the pro leagues cause i can't see them. I did look at some of the A and AA leagues and their passing looks as screwy as our does.
Also when you look at balance, the capped leagues in general will be more balanced, sure I don't hold much credit to the one game where 3 FB had over 100 yards rushing. But show many any week in the nfl in the past 10 years that no team threw for over 200 yards. And if it was a balance issue because of the league, would there be a outrageous passing total game to counter the outrageous rushing games? There isn't any. It was shown earlier in the thread where a completely human offense had crappy throwing numbers again a mostly CPU team, and in one case had a SS playing corner like Champ Baily.
Something is wrong, needs to be addressed before the season goes live. I don't care if it's a different sim in the capped leagues than there is in pro leagues. My money is the same as yours so I should play a fair game like yours regardless if I'm playing in the pros or AAA
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 23:07:48
kruegs
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ilok
Something is wrong, needs to be addressed before the season goes live. I don't care if it's a different sim in the capped leagues than there is in pro leagues. My money is the same as yours so I should play a fair game like yours regardless if I'm playing in the pros or AAA
This.
Something is wrong, needs to be addressed before the season goes live. I don't care if it's a different sim in the capped leagues than there is in pro leagues. My money is the same as yours so I should play a fair game like yours regardless if I'm playing in the pros or AAA
This.
dpell
offline
offline
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by dpell
Again, I've got a WR with 55 catching and soft-capped vision dropping lots of passes. I'd venture that that's in the top 2-5% of GLB WR's for catching.
I'll share. Lvl 28 WR being covered by a lvl 13 SS playing out of position at CB. Lvl 26 QB chucking him the ball.
Strength: 10 Blocking: 10
Speed: 67.22 Tackling: 10
Agility: 49.06 Throwing: 9
Jumping: 29.24 Catching: 59.5
Stamina: 38.22 Carrying: 32.69
Vision: 39.43 Kicking: 7
Confidence: 22.39 Punting: 10
Similar builds on some of the other WR's although some of them have higher vision and less catching. That's not a WR who should be dropping balls or getting repeated deflections by the CB coming over his back.
And I know his strength is low, new FA who's been asked to train it as I hope that's a component of catching that can be fixed with some training. But we've got WR's with 25str with dropsies and getting manhandled by DB's too.
Originally posted by dpell
Again, I've got a WR with 55 catching and soft-capped vision dropping lots of passes. I'd venture that that's in the top 2-5% of GLB WR's for catching.
I'll share. Lvl 28 WR being covered by a lvl 13 SS playing out of position at CB. Lvl 26 QB chucking him the ball.
Strength: 10 Blocking: 10
Speed: 67.22 Tackling: 10
Agility: 49.06 Throwing: 9
Jumping: 29.24 Catching: 59.5
Stamina: 38.22 Carrying: 32.69
Vision: 39.43 Kicking: 7
Confidence: 22.39 Punting: 10
Similar builds on some of the other WR's although some of them have higher vision and less catching. That's not a WR who should be dropping balls or getting repeated deflections by the CB coming over his back.
And I know his strength is low, new FA who's been asked to train it as I hope that's a component of catching that can be fixed with some training. But we've got WR's with 25str with dropsies and getting manhandled by DB's too.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 23:18:08
Paul Kemp
offline
offline
Passing has definitely gone down the shitter with the speed nerf and other changes. Although, I will say that my WR looked a lot better today than he did in the first sim.
As a member of one of my teams suggested, the wisest thing to do at this point in the game would be to sign an offense full of centers and run the wishbone.
As a member of one of my teams suggested, the wisest thing to do at this point in the game would be to sign an offense full of centers and run the wishbone.
Yukon Don
offline
offline
Originally posted by dpell
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by dpell
Again, I've got a WR with 55 catching and soft-capped vision dropping lots of passes. I'd venture that that's in the top 2-5% of GLB WR's for catching.
I'll share. Lvl 28 WR being covered by a lvl 13 SS playing out of position at CB. Lvl 26 QB chucking him the ball.
Strength: 10 Blocking: 10
Speed: 67.22 Tackling: 10
Agility: 49.06 Throwing: 9
Jumping: 29.24 Catching: 59.5
Stamina: 38.22 Carrying: 32.69
Vision: 39.43 Kicking: 7
Confidence: 22.39 Punting: 10
Similar builds on some of the other WR's although some of them have higher vision and less catching. That's not a WR who should be dropping balls or getting repeated deflections by the CB coming over his back.
And I know his strength is low, new FA who's been asked to train it as I hope that's a component of catching that can be fixed with some training. But we've got WR's with 25str with dropsies and getting manhandled by DB's too.
Nope...you've got a good build there, and a lv 13 SS (even with a great build) shouldn't be able to shut you down, (assuming the QB doesn't have a flaw). Did the QB have time to throw, or was he under constant pressure? I'm not saying that there can't be a problem, I just didn't see it in my games, so it seems different than the results we had.
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by dpell
Again, I've got a WR with 55 catching and soft-capped vision dropping lots of passes. I'd venture that that's in the top 2-5% of GLB WR's for catching.
I'll share. Lvl 28 WR being covered by a lvl 13 SS playing out of position at CB. Lvl 26 QB chucking him the ball.
Strength: 10 Blocking: 10
Speed: 67.22 Tackling: 10
Agility: 49.06 Throwing: 9
Jumping: 29.24 Catching: 59.5
Stamina: 38.22 Carrying: 32.69
Vision: 39.43 Kicking: 7
Confidence: 22.39 Punting: 10
Similar builds on some of the other WR's although some of them have higher vision and less catching. That's not a WR who should be dropping balls or getting repeated deflections by the CB coming over his back.
And I know his strength is low, new FA who's been asked to train it as I hope that's a component of catching that can be fixed with some training. But we've got WR's with 25str with dropsies and getting manhandled by DB's too.
Nope...you've got a good build there, and a lv 13 SS (even with a great build) shouldn't be able to shut you down, (assuming the QB doesn't have a flaw). Did the QB have time to throw, or was he under constant pressure? I'm not saying that there can't be a problem, I just didn't see it in my games, so it seems different than the results we had.
dpell
offline
offline
Snipped from another thread. The other WR he's covering here is a 24 with a similar build. A little less catching but more vision. The SS build was open yesterday. Someone probably PM'd him after I smeared it on the boards here. Decent build for a 13 but I don't think he had a single attribute over 45.
Originally posted by dpell
Here's the build of the lvl 13 SS who seems to be deflecting so many passes:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=404596
Nothing against the SS, but 3 deflections against a lvl 26 QB with 50+ vision throwing to WR's who have him beat in every major stat?
Maybe the problem isn't a nerf to the passing game as much as the fact that defenders are now seemingly super-human.
Deflections:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79219&pbp_id=393246 - Looks like it could be pass interference to me. CB is mugging the WR just as the ball gets there. Good play I suppose.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79219&pbp_id=393257
The DB just impedes the WR. Should be a penalty or needs to be fixed.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79219&pbp_id=393514
And again, it sure looks like the CB is committing pass interference here. His dot is overlapping the WR well before the ball even gets there. This either has to be a penalty or needs to be fixed.
Originally posted by dpell
Here's the build of the lvl 13 SS who seems to be deflecting so many passes:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=404596
Nothing against the SS, but 3 deflections against a lvl 26 QB with 50+ vision throwing to WR's who have him beat in every major stat?
Maybe the problem isn't a nerf to the passing game as much as the fact that defenders are now seemingly super-human.
Deflections:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79219&pbp_id=393246 - Looks like it could be pass interference to me. CB is mugging the WR just as the ball gets there. Good play I suppose.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79219&pbp_id=393257
The DB just impedes the WR. Should be a penalty or needs to be fixed.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79219&pbp_id=393514
And again, it sure looks like the CB is committing pass interference here. His dot is overlapping the WR well before the ball even gets there. This either has to be a penalty or needs to be fixed.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 23:28:18
Ken1
offline
offline
I can only find the place you said this in quotes, but the problem is the superhuman pass defenders.
TDmaker99
offline
offline
admit it peeps, its the speed nerf, if u agree please start talking about it, becasue nerfing other positions isnt going to make it any better just means that someone else besides us will get to decide what our build will eventually look like because they cant stop it or dont like it
and if they nerf db's thre will be some kind of unforseen impact somewhere else, it will never end
and if they nerf db's thre will be some kind of unforseen impact somewhere else, it will never end
TDmaker99
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
I can only find the place you said this in quotes, but the problem is the superhuman pass defenders.
huh ?
I can only find the place you said this in quotes, but the problem is the superhuman pass defenders.
huh ?
Rook33
offline
offline
Here is a game that makes no sense and we went pass happy:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=81145
They had 25,15,12,12 CB's to our 18,16,16,15 WR's and we throw for only 237.5 yards??
Just not possible since I adjusted my DC with my 18 and a 16 at 2 and 3 WR = huge mismatch and then took the other 16 vs #1 just to occupy the #1 CB.
We had 6 drops not bad but the best was the level 18 scores a 73 yard TD in first half and does nothing the rest of the game? He finished with 107 yards?
And I agree somehow these level 12 CB's are all over my WR's?
I know its a SIM but I seen the game and the coverage was kinda amazing
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=81145
They had 25,15,12,12 CB's to our 18,16,16,15 WR's and we throw for only 237.5 yards??
Just not possible since I adjusted my DC with my 18 and a 16 at 2 and 3 WR = huge mismatch and then took the other 16 vs #1 just to occupy the #1 CB.
We had 6 drops not bad but the best was the level 18 scores a 73 yard TD in first half and does nothing the rest of the game? He finished with 107 yards?
And I agree somehow these level 12 CB's are all over my WR's?
I know its a SIM but I seen the game and the coverage was kinda amazing
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























