User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Bort there is no passing bug, my QB passed well just like last season.
Page:
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB

I've really seen more defensive guys with vision above 50 than offensive guys (besides QBs). So since they earned their reaction time, what's wrong with that?


+1
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


No, what that shows is that LBs can't react to a run play without first completing their entire assignment, no matter how ridiculously awful it is.

And I totally disagree about route reactions for CBs. I constantly see CBs getting toasted.


I sure don't.

Why have we never come close to realistic passing averages?

CB's don't get really beaten nearly as much as in real life.

You have to accept that defenses dominated last season, and that that needs to be ended.


What are realistic passing averages?

Yards? I think passing yards gained is WAAAAAAY out of hand, so that can't be the problem.

YPA? You think level 25s and lower should be going for 7-8 yards per attempt. That's damn high.

Completion percentage? Again, how accurate do you want level 25 and lower players to be? Our QB has no problems roasting defenses last season, and he was underleveled for the league: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=174614


7 yards per attempt is real life average. For top QB's, but against top defenses!

And again, the better players are mostly as developed as they will be. Leveling is going to be very slow for those level 25 now, and their key attributes are above soft-caps.

People will hide behind that even in Season 10: "Well, sure our players are Level 42, but NFL players are level 100! You see, this was a high school football sim all along!"

I'm thinking there may still be a few too many drops after watching the game of the other team I help run, but more important is too many deflections.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by Ken1

I'd definitely base defensive reaction time on Vision and Agility, although right now it seems so good that to get it as good as it is now it would take 100 of both (although you also, for obvious reasons, don't want to overadjust it; if 30% of passes are batted down now, then it should be maybe 20% are batted down when playing against 20 vision/agility, 25% against 50 vision/agility, and the full 30% against 100 vision/agility).


Great idea! Base another important behavior on agility.

- sidewards movement/turning (slowing down also, I guess)
- shed blocks
- acceleration
- reaction time

What else?

Just create a super attribute, everyone MUST have 80+ to perform.

25% against 50 vision/agility? You sure talk about the defender only, right? So you basically like to suggest any defender needs at least 50 vision, 50 agility to swat down 1/4 of all passes - no matter how badly they are thrown and how good the WR was covered?


Okay, then make it mostly or totally Vision, if Agility would be a super-attribute. That also solves the "They earned it with their high Vision!" problem.

I said, first, "If the current rate is 30%." Now, certainly there can't be 50% of passses batted down, as that would mean even if there were no poor throws and no drops, and no beaten coverages, there could be no more than 50% completions.

If the rate of deflections is 30% now, then the ceilinhg is 70%. If it's 25%, then the ceiling, before drops or bad throws, is 75%. If the QB always was on target and a receiver never dropped a ball, then 75% would be the completion percentage.

But of course, there will be bad throws and drops, so we'd have something close to real life results, 60% complete, 7 yards per attempt.

People are way too used to last season's super defenses that they can't stand to see a defense get burned.

The DC in the game I just watched basically played 0-man all game. That should be nearly impossible to sustain, and it got burned precisely once.

Man coverage is not hard enough to sustain in the current sim.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 18:50:26
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
7 yards per attempt is real life average. For top QB's, but against top defenses!

And again, the better players are mostly as developed as they will be. Leveling is going to be very slow for those level 25 now, and their key attributes are above soft-caps.

People will hide behind that even in Season 10: "Well, sure our players are Level 42, but NFL players are level 100! You see, this was a high school football sim all along!"

I'm thinking there may still be a few too many drops after watching the game of the other team I help run, but more important is too many deflections.



So building offensive guys must be way easier than defensive guys!

I for like to spend at least 70 additional Skill Points on my level 22 FS - and I'm always afraid that those (yet) unraised attributes and skills might hurt him someday all of a sudden.

But obviously, offensive guys are finished off at lv. 25 already and only need to "drop" a point here and there sometimes. All great studs already, just raising all attributes equally from now on...

Really?

If most defensive guys were build like the majority of offensive guys I've seen, they sure would suck. Missing out vision - probably the most important overall skill on a DB? No way, you'd be benched and asked to raise a.s.a.p. But beeing dumb as hell on offense is no problem. At least, you want it to be that way and rather "nerf" reaction time of CBs.

What about that:
The smarter the WR gets (vision), he'd turn just in time as the pass is thrown and really gain separation of a DB at same speed, agility and vision? Of course, he'd need a QB at equal vision that just throws in the right moment.

Sounds fair? I'd sure support that!

What about strength effecting the outcome of swatting attempts by the defender? A LB sure can shake a WR anytime - causing him to loose a ball almost sure in his hands before, but a CB at 20 strength has to hit a WR of 30 strength right at the very moment of the catch.

Sounds fair? I'd sure support that!

But just tuning something down in order to take away something defensive guys have earned with their Skill Points doesn't sound fair to me! Does it to you?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by Ken1

7 yards per attempt is real life average. For top QB's, but against top defenses!

And again, the better players are mostly as developed as they will be. Leveling is going to be very slow for those level 25 now, and their key attributes are above soft-caps.

People will hide behind that even in Season 10: "Well, sure our players are Level 42, but NFL players are level 100! You see, this was a high school football sim all along!"

I'm thinking there may still be a few too many drops after watching the game of the other team I help run, but more important is too many deflections.



So building offensive guys must be way easier than defensive guys!

I for like to spend at least 70 additional Skill Points on my level 22 FS - and I'm always afraid that those (yet) unraised attributes and skills might hurt him someday all of a sudden.

But obviously, offensive guys are finished off at lv. 25 already and only need to "drop" a point here and there sometimes. All great studs already, just raising all attributes equally from now on...

Really?

If most defensive guys were build like the majority of offensive guys I've seen, they sure would suck. Missing out vision - probably the most important overall skill on a DB? No way, you'd be benched and asked to raise a.s.a.p. But beeing dumb as hell on offense is no problem. At least, you want it to be that way and rather "nerf" reaction time of CBs.

What about that:
The smarter the WR gets (vision), he'd turn just in time as the pass is thrown and really gain separation of a DB at same speed, agility and vision? Of course, he'd need a QB at equal vision that just throws in the right moment.

Sounds fair? I'd sure support that!

What about strength effecting the outcome of swatting attempts by the defender? A LB sure can shake a WR anytime - causing him to loose a ball almost sure in his hands before, but a CB at 20 strength has to hit a WR of 30 strength right at the very moment of the catch.

Sounds fair? I'd sure support that!

But just tuning something down in order to take away something defensive guys have earned with their Skill Points doesn't sound fair to me! Does it to you?


You're forgetting the real life dynamic:

In real life, every offensive player knows exactly what the play is going to be. In real life the defense has no idea.

I build offensive players with good Vision: It already helps catching; it helps them know which way to go, etc.. But, defense by its nature requires more Vision than offense.

On the other hand, WR's need Catching (now more than ever) but DB's don't even have a Swatting ability to swat balls down (Swat Ball is an SA, but you can break up passes without it, and definitely without much of it). They can just do it. No Vision? They're never turned the wrong way! They always come in and knock it down.

If the DB's are playing like pro DB's, then of course the QB's should be playing like pro QB's and WR's like pro WR's. I'm not actually calling for that. I'm actually saying that there needed to be more drops this season than last. I did call for better QB accuracy, but when Bort suggested slower defensive reactions, I realized that was the key.

Specifically, man to man coverage should be very hard, because the receiver knows his route and the DB has no idea. Really, I'm simply calling for DB's to have the same amount of trouble, make the same mistakes, WR's do. Even make it so it's in proportion to Vision.

Why wouldn't the defense require more Vision than non-QB offensive players? The offensive players have no need to guess the play. Of course, Vision's quite underrated on offense as well; but that's a different story.

I'm saying, don't make it easier for WR's to catch with poor Catching. Keep drops in the game, although allowing Catching ability if it's high enough to alleviate some. Just make the DB's make mistakes, too. And they can make fewer, if they have more Vision. But the offensive guys are already making theirs.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
The DC in the game I just watched basically played 0-man all game. That should be nearly impossible to sustain, and it got burned precisely once.

Man coverage is not hard enough to sustain in the current sim.


Well if the WRs are all rather slow and less agile (but high catching/jumping) - playing them close at man coverage is the only way to defend. If you give up cushion, the WR will win.

If the offense build speedsters up to 80 speed /60 agility - they sure should burn those CBs almost all the time on long routes (but QB has to throw that perfect long TD pass too). First problem: how do you tell the sim to send this WR on those long routes? Second problem: that WR sure misses something out; like catching... so he should drop quite a bit.

I.m.h.o. it's more like those rock-scissor-paper game. And each offense can dictate what the defense has to bring up (try to build a decent working defense vs. pass heavy AND run heavy teams in the same conference this season). So that naturally puts the offense in advantage.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by Ken1

The DC in the game I just watched basically played 0-man all game. That should be nearly impossible to sustain, and it got burned precisely once.

Man coverage is not hard enough to sustain in the current sim.


Well if the WRs are all rather slow and less agile (but high catching/jumping) - playing them close at man coverage is the only way to defend. If you give up cushion, the WR will win.

If the offense build speedsters up to 80 speed /60 agility - they sure should burn those CBs almost all the time on long routes (but QB has to throw that perfect long TD pass too). First problem: how do you tell the sim to send this WR on those long routes? Second problem: that WR sure misses something out; like catching... so he should drop quite a bit.

I.m.h.o. it's more like those rock-scissor-paper game. And each offense can dictate what the defense has to bring up (try to build a decent working defense vs. pass heavy AND run heavy teams in the same conference this season). So that naturally puts the offense in advantage.


Well, what I'm worried about is that because the running game, I think, is fixed and works fine and realistically now but the passing game is still not realistic and in fact weaker than last season, is that there won't be any pass heavy teams.

But, yes, WR's should be vulnerable to drops if they're all speed, and QB's should make some mistakes on passes, and the longer the pass the more mistakes. I'm with you on that.

I'm just saying that if they make those mistakes then defenders have to as well. Right now they're supermen, with super reaction time and all. That's why...if you notice the purpose of the part of the post where I mentioned the 25%...I was actually urging Bort not to overcompensate by cutting all deflections in half or anything, that "if they're 30% now, they should be 20% with 20 vision, 25% with 50 vision." (I included agility, but its necessity there can be questioned)

I'm not a pro-offense zealot; I just want balance. Making guys actually tackle seems to have balanced rushing. I just want to balance passing as well so that we can have real football games.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
"On the other hand, WR's need Catching (now more than ever) but DB's don't even have a Swatting ability to swat balls down (Swat Ball is an SA, but you can break up passes without it, and definitely without much of it). They can just do it. No Vision? They're never turned the wrong way! They always come in and knock it down."

That might just be the solution to both problems!

I noticed WRs with higher catching making a completion in the wink of an eye (sometimes even in perfect coverage). So if you let them slip away just a bit, there'll be no way to swat the ball down.

So that swatted passes might just go down as the catching goes up?

Just a guess...

Besides that, most WRs will get their agility up to accomplish their speed. Since agility helps making turns, that'll create more separation... more time till the CB catches up... and since more catching gives the defender less time to deflect...


We need to end this now. I'll see where you want to go and I basically agree on the result. But I strongly disagree with the way you want to get there.

I.m.h.o. defensive guys might just have better builds in general, for they discovered the "secret of the game" a bit more (not each for himself, but in terms of sharing what worked). Now as carrying, catching, confidence, jumping are getting into the focus of the "average player" - it might just even up!


EDIT:

...and since defenders have to care about tackling quite a bit this season, the offensive guys get ahead in the race towards speed, agility and vision.

Just give it a chance before pointing it out. Most guys havn't adjusted to season 4 changes yet!
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 19:47:26
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
"On the other hand, WR's need Catching (now more than ever) but DB's don't even have a Swatting ability to swat balls down (Swat Ball is an SA, but you can break up passes without it, and definitely without much of it). They can just do it. No Vision? They're never turned the wrong way! They always come in and knock it down."

That might just be the solution to both problems!

I noticed WRs with higher catching making a completion in the wink of an eye (sometimes even in perfect coverage). So if you let them slip away just a bit, there'll be no way to swat the ball down.

So that swatted passes might just go down as the catching goes up?

Just a guess...

Besides that, most WRs will get their agility up to accomplish their speed. Since agility helps making turns, that'll create more separation... more time till the CB catches up... and since more catching gives the defender less time to deflect...


We need to end this now. I'll see where you want to go and I basically agree on the result. But I strongly disagree with the way you want to get there.

I.m.h.o. defensive guys might just have better builds in general, for they discovered the "secret of the game" a bit more (not each for himself, but in terms of sharing what worked). Now as carrying, catching, confidence, jumping are getting into the focus of the "average player" - it might just even up!


Well, I'm glad we agree on the desired result; because as long as Bort's work is toward getting the result we both agree should occur, I won't care so much if we get there some way other than the way I suggested.
 
MeHigh7
offline
Link
 
Just finished my sim and there were TONS of deflected passes. 4 Drops but that was OK because we threw a lot. My QB went 9/27.... definitely needs some tweaking.
 
shaun123987
offline
Link
 
My QB did pretty normal (he is only a backup though) but he passed to the HB quite a lot.

Also, there was one play where the CB blitzed, the MLB blitzed, the LOLB covered the TE, and the ROLB covered the TE. SS was playing man to man with the WR and the SS and CB were back playing zone. The two WRs on the left were wide open, one in the middle, and one way down the left side and he decided to throw to the underneath guy when the other WR was way farther and more wide open: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79045&pbp_id=172084

By the way, he has very high vision and very high throwing.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 20:20:43
 
Robbiesol
offline
Link
 
My QB was damn near 80% completion percentage. Looks good to me.
 
MeHigh7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbiesol
My QB was damn near 80% completion percentage. Looks good to me.


You played against a way crappier team and their team chemistry was in the 20's.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1

And again, the better players are mostly as developed as they will be. Leveling is going to be very slow for those level 25 now, and their key attributes are above soft-caps.


Boosters have at least 21 levels left, in addition to natural leveling.

I think they have quite a bit of growing to do.

Last edited Jul 30, 2008 21:11:49
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Ken1


And again, the better players are mostly as developed as they will be. Leveling is going to be very slow for those level 25 now, and their key attributes are above soft-caps.


Boosters have at least 21 levels left, in addition to natural leveling.

I think they have quite a bit of growing to do.



Crap. If we aren't playing at least major college by now, I'd leave. I didn't sign up for a pee wee football sim.

Funny how defenders play like pros but you don't want the offense to.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.