User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Slothrop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asmodan
Oh and while i'm at it, in my league, only 2 out of 32 teams managed higher than 50% completeed passes.


That is crazy. BTW, I messed up my QB's completion percentage above. I was wrong when I wrote that he completed 19% of his passes - IT WAS 13%!!!!!!!

My other QB, also level 24 completed 35%.

I was stoked about the changes this season, but I am thinking they may have to scrap it and try again next season.
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The earlier in the day your game ran today the more likely you were to drop passes. Been tuning it with each hour's runs.



Never seemed to get better by the end of the day yesterday. Any upper level teams play yet today for a comparison?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Slothrop
Originally posted by Asmodan

Oh and while i'm at it, in my league, only 2 out of 32 teams managed higher than 50% completeed passes.


That is crazy. BTW, I messed up my QB's completion percentage above. I was wrong when I wrote that he completed 19% of his passes - IT WAS 13%!!!!!!!

My other QB, also level 24 completed 35%.

I was stoked about the changes this season, but I am thinking they may have to scrap it and try again next season.


No way. Last season's sim was a disaster in a million ways.

It wouldn't be too hard in this sim for QB's to be tuned to be more accurate, not throw as much to RB's, etc..

I also looked at box scores from a few random leagues, and saw that drops themselves weren't a huge, universal problem. I also saw yards per pass attempt were below real life, but only as much as they were last season. Almost all receivers I saw in the box scores had more catches than drops, most having something like 5 catches and 1 drop.

Completion percentage is way too low and that needs to be fixed (although it was always too low given the length of passes); but I'm not sure that drops are as much of a problem as just needing more QB accuracy and needing fewer dump-offs.

Also, the improved pass rush because O-linemen were all strength and blocking, not caring about agility, could be part of all this as well. Hurried QB's miss passes.
 
Asmodan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Slothrop

Originally posted by Asmodan


Oh and while i'm at it, in my league, only 2 out of 32 teams managed higher than 50% completeed passes.


That is crazy. BTW, I messed up my QB's completion percentage above. I was wrong when I wrote that he completed 19% of his passes - IT WAS 13%!!!!!!!

My other QB, also level 24 completed 35%.

I was stoked about the changes this season, but I am thinking they may have to scrap it and try again next season.


No way. Last season's sim was a disaster in a million ways.

It wouldn't be too hard in this sim for QB's to be tuned to be more accurate, not throw as much to RB's, etc..

I also looked at box scores from a few random leagues, and saw that drops themselves weren't a huge, universal problem. I also saw yards per pass attempt were below real life, but only as much as they were last season. Almost all receivers I saw in the box scores had more catches than drops, most having something like 5 catches and 1 drop.

Completion percentage is way too low and that needs to be fixed (although it was always too low given the length of passes); but I'm not sure that drops are as much of a problem as just needing more QB accuracy and needing fewer dump-offs.

Also, the improved pass rush because O-linemen were all strength and blocking, not caring about agility, could be part of all this as well. Hurried QB's miss passes.


Thats entirely different from the numbers i got from my league, were 20%+ drops was the normal.
As for yard pr pass i counted 5 teams with an average number (5yd/pass) and only 2 with a good number out of 32.
 
DLight03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Slothrop

Originally posted by Asmodan


Oh and while i'm at it, in my league, only 2 out of 32 teams managed higher than 50% completeed passes.


That is crazy. BTW, I messed up my QB's completion percentage above. I was wrong when I wrote that he completed 19% of his passes - IT WAS 13%!!!!!!!

My other QB, also level 24 completed 35%.

I was stoked about the changes this season, but I am thinking they may have to scrap it and try again next season.


No way. Last season's sim was a disaster in a million ways.

It wouldn't be too hard in this sim for QB's to be tuned to be more accurate, not throw as much to RB's, etc..

I also looked at box scores from a few random leagues, and saw that drops themselves weren't a huge, universal problem. I also saw yards per pass attempt were below real life, but only as much as they were last season. Almost all receivers I saw in the box scores had more catches than drops, most having something like 5 catches and 1 drop.

Completion percentage is way too low and that needs to be fixed (although it was always too low given the length of passes); but I'm not sure that drops are as much of a problem as just needing more QB accuracy and needing fewer dump-offs.

Also, the improved pass rush because O-linemen were all strength and blocking, not caring about agility, could be part of all this as well. Hurried QB's miss passes.


I agree. We didn't have a huge problem with drops, but we had a big problem with QB-related deflections and QB accuracy despite great protection. Both QBs in the game had 27% or so completion. It was very weird.

 
Rudog
offline
Link
 
My TE had the same issue. 5 catches, 4 Drops. Level 17 TE and I've got 46 catching and 3 sticky hands. I understand that other things factor in now... but that's nuts (Vision is 25ish and Confidence is 20ish).
 
xeef
offline
Link
 
Bottom line, just like EVERY other thread up here bitching about the new sims, is that they just overcompensated every way they could.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Bort, are you still tweaking drops? We had like 13 of them today on a team with very good catching. My WR with like 38 vision and 48 catching dropped 2 balls and only caught one. Same story for our other WR's, tons of drops more than last season yet many of us boosted already so our QB has more throwing, more tight spiral; our WR's have more vision, more catching; and we still dropped a ton of balls. Seems very odd to me. I understand you're trying to improve the game, but some of these nerfs aren't jsut minor tweaks, they're completely changing the game.
 
foshizzel17
my drizzt
offline
Link
 
We are moving toward every attribute needs to be the same 40,40,40,40,40 ect ect

A bunch of cookie cutter players with no specialization.
 
jasonwm123
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foshizzel17
We are moving toward every attribute needs to be the same 40,40,40,40,40 ect ect

A bunch of cookie cutter players with no specialization.


+1 I followed build guides on my players that was stickied to the top by the people running this game. And by common sense, I think if you build a player with 65 catching he should be able to catch the damn football. I spent money to see my players perform better in that aspect and I get worse than 1st season numbers. Oh well, this was just to tide me over through baseball season until college football and the NFL starts back up anyways. GLB has seen the last of my cash. You Bort homers go ahead and flame away.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 17:25:51
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jasonwm123
Originally posted by foshizzel17

We are moving toward every attribute needs to be the same 40,40,40,40,40 ect ect

A bunch of cookie cutter players with no specialization.


+1 I followed build guides on my players that was stickied to the top by the people running this game. And by common sense, I think if you build a player with 65 catching he should be able to catch the damn football well. I spent money to see my players perform better in that aspect and I get worse than season 1 numbers. Oh well, this was just to tide me over through baseball season until college football and the NFL starts back up anyways. GLB has seen the last of my cash. You Bort homers go ahead and flame away.


This makes the 65 Catching matter more, because as it was there wasn't that much of an improvement between 45 or so and 65: They'd both catch anything.

Now the 65 will/should very rarely drop passes, and the 45 will a little more-- more often than the 65.

It isn't cookie cutter where you have 40's across the board, because even 40's will sometimes fail at things. It does mean that anywhere you ignore, if it's relevant to the position, there's a price to be paid.

Ignore Catching to build a track star WR, fine. But he'll have a lot of drops. He'll also be able to beat CB's on long passes, though.

40 won't be close to enough Tackling for a LB once running backs reach high levels and there are RB's with 75 strength and 8 Power Thru.

But a player can't be good at everything, is the point.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I'm guessing that this has something to do with the close coverage and PD's as well:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=717424&page=1
 
jasonwm123
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by jasonwm123

Originally posted by foshizzel17


We are moving toward every attribute needs to be the same 40,40,40,40,40 ect ect

A bunch of cookie cutter players with no specialization.


+1 I followed build guides on my players that was stickied to the top by the people running this game. And by common sense, I think if you build a player with 65 catching he should be able to catch the damn football well. I spent money to see my players perform better in that aspect and I get worse than season 1 numbers. Oh well, this was just to tide me over through baseball season until college football and the NFL starts back up anyways. GLB has seen the last of my cash. You Bort homers go ahead and flame away.


This makes the 65 Catching matter more, because as it was there wasn't that much of an improvement between 45 or so and 65: They'd both catch anything.

Now the 65 will/should very rarely drop passes, and the 45 will a little more-- more often than the 65.

It isn't cookie cutter where you have 40's across the board, because even 40's will sometimes fail at things. It does mean that anywhere you ignore, if it's relevant to the position, there's a price to be paid.

Ignore Catching to build a track star WR, fine. But he'll have a lot of drops. He'll also be able to beat CB's on long passes, though.

40 won't be close to enough Tackling for a LB once running backs reach high levels and there are RB's with 75 strength and 8 Power Thru.

But a player can't be good at everything, is the point.


I'm following you, but can you explain to me why my player with 65 catching dropped 3/5 passes thrown to him? Other than the usual argument that says (insert whatever attribute here) was too low? You see, because of that argument they are forcing you to have 40's across the board to be successful.

 
foshizzel17
my drizzt
offline
Link
 
If you have 65 catching all other attributes will have to suffer. 65 ctch 30 spd. 65 spd 25 agi, 50cht 50spd 50agi= 15 con 15 vis, ect ect. I understand that their need sto be balance. When we get to lvl 30 all attributes will be good, but right now everyone is unbalanced.
 
jasonwm123
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foshizzel17
If you have 65 catching all other attributes will have to suffer. 65 ctch 30 spd. 65 spd 25 agi, 50cht 50spd 50agi= 15 con 15 vis, ect ect. I understand that their need sto be balance. When we get to lvl 30 all attributes will be good, but right now everyone is unbalanced.


I can agree with that, but what I don't understand is the catching factor in this. I mean, if he is slow as a snail and still manages to get open, shouldn't he at least be able to catch the ball because of his high catching? That's where I'm confused and I think it's because I'm relating this to real football.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.