User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > What sense is it that the best teams only have 1 person on the depth chart.
Page:
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
This really needs to be bumped over and over and over and over and over until it is changed.

I do not mind people finding ways to game the system, that is part of competing.

However, there does need to be a mandatory depth chart in place. i.e. if the mandatory depth chart for NT is two, a line up with one is invalid.

The depth could be just two (or even one at QB) but it needs to be mandatory to keep this game looking at least marginaly realistic and to allow for more people to play.

While it certainly isn't cheating, it looks very bad to have a moderator engaging in a scheme to game the system that reduces available roster slots on two teams while people are paying for players and begging to get onto a roster. It looks beyond bad.
 
drkbgrk
offline
Link
 
i agree with the stance that people playing their team out of position or with no backups to max out xp are making a strategic decision that is yielding early returns this season but will yield diminishing returns as player level rises in the community. their relative headstart will shrink compared to their opponents' level and they will end up pitting their tired players against fresher more competitive rotations.

if they continue to dominate past this season then the energy mechanic needs fixing so that it features higher penalties for low energy.

as of now it is merely a coaching choice and way too early to call it broken. (minimum roster size is already coming though, for the bumping paranoiacs.)
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 03:57:03
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drkbgrk
i agree with the stance that people playing their team out of position or with no backups to max out xp are making a strategic decision that is yielding early returns this season but will yield diminishing returns as player level rises in the community. their relative headstart will shrink compared to their opponents' level and they will end up pitting their tired players against fresher more competitive rotations.

if they continue to dominate past this season then the energy mechanic needs fixing so that it features higher penalties for low energy.

as of now it is merely a coaching choice and way too early to call it broken. (minimum roster size is already coming though, for the bumping paranoiacs.)


Minimum roster size may not address the issue of one-deep depth charts. I agree it is a coaching choice and may backfire but that is not my concern.

With the glut of players (people, many of whom may pay) that simply cannot find a team it is detrimental to the game as a whole to have some teams that employ this unrealistic although currently legal ploy. It is in all of our interest to see a forced minimum depth chart at each position. It needn't be much but would yield more realistic looking teams and competition and more importantly ensure that valuable roster spots are not wasted with so many players looking for a home.

A minimum depth chart with a more realistic energy drain for playing every snap is sorely needed in addition to the minimum roster rules.

 
RUN HARD
offline
Link
 
I just traded all my DEPTH because I researched the top teams and realized DEPTH does not matter. If we are going to make rule changes I wish it would happen after the 1st 10 seasons play out.

It's hard being an owner trying to structure a team, then BOOM...here are some changes.

I understand its BETA and expected, but if we are going to make changes we need to try and give a warning so owners can prepare. I looked at Detroit & Philadelphia and saw no DEPTH yet both teams dominated. I been trading all DEPTH so that I could just play starters. I hope settings do change to FAST so that I would then need to trade for Depth.

Last edited Apr 15, 2008 05:03:49
 
drkbgrk
offline
Link
 
i agree that if minimum roster reqs arrive without a drop in performance of the 1 deep team build, yes, GLB will have a large problem of angry back ups, angry free agents, angry 2 deep team owners, angry DEs that can't blow buy a 90 play deep OT.

it might just be that the crazy low level competition everyone is fielding doesn't tire out an opponent fast enough. it might also be broke assed. i wonder if the devs have to wait and see too, or if they already know the answer.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Here is another solution

I've looked at game logs from several games and 40 plays looks to be a good cut off for getting XP. Many games there are only a few defensive players get over 40 plays when they do well and the team has depth. With offensive positions, once again many players fail to get to 40 or more plays.

Here are my arguments on why the cap

1. It fights against owners building 30 players on the same team then starting them all the time and building up. While backups sit and get nothing.

2. It encourages human player depth on teams and getting backups in to keep non owner players happy.

3. It fights against gaming the system. (calling all pass plays in early games to level up players faster)

4. It counters the penalty to good defenses or quick strike offenses.

5. It helps lower level players catch up to upper level players faster, because they get more XP per play and starters can't keep outgaining them by getting 50 more plays per game.

6. It retains importance of boosting, because it gets harder and harder to level up through XP as players get to higher levels.

edited to add 7. It stops players from leveling up as fast and contracts continually needing to be renegotiated.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 13:09:16
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Energy will have to just be revamped..you can't have a RB taking 56 carries a game. Injuries should lower your stamina by half or something. Also you should HAVE to have so many players to fill certain positions like madden. That would make things a lil more fair. With the Level caps this would REALLY be a big step up.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS
This really needs to be bumped over and over and over and over and over until it is changed.


Keep talking about/debating the issue, bring up new points, all good things and ways to keep a topic like this going. If anyone starts just bumping this or any other topic over and over without adding anything, it'll be locked.
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS

This really needs to be bumped over and over and over and over and over until it is changed.


Keep talking about/debating the issue, bring up new points, all good things and ways to keep a topic like this going. If anyone starts just bumping this or any other topic over and over without adding anything, it'll be locked.


Is this an issue that will be addressed then? If not, more teams may migrate to this form of unrealistic make up and then you will need many more multiples of teams or see an increase in dissatisfied players that give up when they can't find a home I would suppose.

There isn't much to add other than input from development that it is being considered or that it is not being considerder. The issue will be off the front page in a few hours. I guess that there aren't too many options if there is no input from development. Forget it and let it get burried or bump it so it can be locked and burried. Cay sera sera.

 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
I think i should add that i see lots of teams with WAY TOO MUCH depth around. I saw one guy talking about his #3 FB...another about playing time for his #3 QB. Honestly guys you dont need that many players. Nowhere in football do you ever play with more than 1 (maybe 2 maybe) FBs. The starting QB will play every play at most levels of football. Starting RB's get 70-90% of the carries on most alot of NFL teams.

EDIT Chris...i think the admins are well aware of this "issue" so no real need to bump if you dont have anything to add.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 16:47:16
 
CoachMauler
offline
Link
 
This is a huge problem and with SUCH an easy fix.

1) Associate a % that drops the overall skills of a player down the lower his stamina gets. Stamina at 100 speed at 45, stamina at 75 speed at 30, stamina at 50 speed at 20 etc...

2) Injuries SHOULD take a player completely out of a game. Not this "they just get weaker" nonsense. 5 different injury lvls ( injury lvl 1- out a quater, 2- out a game, 3- out 3 games, 4- out 5 games, 5- out 8 games).

Counter this by NOT having injury time be part of the "age" thing yet to be installed. Also, maybe injured players dont play, but get 50% of the average xp gained on the team. (so if the average xp per player for the game is 300 the injured players get 150)

3) Age- As age and seasons go up, skills start degrading.




Thoughts?
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xxsyrusvb
This is a huge problem and with SUCH an easy fix.

1) Associate a % that drops the overall skills of a player down the lower his stamina gets. Stamina at 100 speed at 45, stamina at 75 speed at 30, stamina at 50 speed at 20 etc...

2) Injuries SHOULD take a player completely out of a game. Not this "they just get weaker" nonsense. 5 different injury lvls ( injury lvl 1- out a quater, 2- out a game, 3- out 3 games, 4- out 5 games, 5- out 8 games).

Counter this by NOT having injury time be part of the "age" thing yet to be installed. Also, maybe injured players dont play, but get 50% of the average xp gained on the team. (so if the average xp per player for the game is 300 the injured players get 150)

3) Age- As age and seasons go up, skills start degrading.




Thoughts?


3 is already done. 10 season max (and skills die slowly). As for the other two, heh.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
I'm not posting in this thread after this. Here are my suggestions for keeping this game competitive and balancing things out. Remember, at some point the current players are going to have to retire and you don't want a huge drop off between their level of play and their replacements. If all the new player only people are run off because they can't develop their players, how big a drop will it be when you are having to get season 4 or 5 players to replace some of your season 10 players after retirement?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=73784&page=1#463341
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
EDIT Chris...i think the admins are well aware of this "issue" so no real need to bump if you dont have anything to add.


Bingo. And if you do some searches for things I've been posting since the alpha season (if they're not deleted by now), you'll see I've been pushing for a change in how the EXP system works in order to promote backups.

Just a couple other comments:

Min rosters will do NOTHING. You know what I'll do if there's min roster requirements? Exactly what I do right now, plus sign however many level 1 punters I need to in order to fill out my roster. Nothing will change there.

Injuries will have to be very severe in order for injuries to matter. For instance, if someone on my team who's level 12 gets injured and then is instead playing like a level 7, I'll take notice. If it's just a small bump and he's playing like level 10, what's going to be worse, me keeping around some level 5-8 backups and playing them or having my guy who's now playing like level 10 just tough it out? The answer is to just still stick with my starters. And on top of it all, they'll still be getting the EXP.

There's really only 2 ways I, or anyone who's thinking like me will care about backups:

1) There's a much lower cap put in place for experience (40 or so plays before the big dropoff instead of 90). Then I'll carry a few extra players to have more options. Even under that system, I can't imagine wanting to carry more than 40-45 players. I'd still keep the Energy penalty in the same place (gets much higher after the 80-90 play range) so if a team wants to just have single starters, they can, they're just not helped very much by it.

2) Lower the cap for the point where the Energy penalty hits hard to around 50 plays. That basically forces teams to carry a lot of depth and eliminates single starters across the board (other than maybe P/Ks). I don't like this idea since I don't think teams should be forced into a system like that if they don't want to, but hey, it'll solve the current problem....



And finally, since I know people are annoyed by the current system, I just want to say this: Don't hate the playa, hate the game. We're just playing by the current rules. If they're changed, we'll adapt and play by the new rules. I, for one, hope they do.
 
CoachMauler
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by bigtisme

EDIT Chris...i think the admins are well aware of this "issue" so no real need to bump if you dont have anything to add.


Bingo. And if you do some searches for things I've been posting since the alpha season (if they're not deleted by now), you'll see I've been pushing for a change in how the EXP system works in order to promote backups.

Just a couple other comments:

Min rosters will do NOTHING. You know what I'll do if there's min roster requirements? Exactly what I do right now, plus sign however many level 1 punters I need to in order to fill out my roster. Nothing will change there.

Injuries will have to be very severe in order for injuries to matter. For instance, if someone on my team who's level 12 gets injured and then is instead playing like a level 7, I'll take notice. If it's just a small bump and he's playing like level 10, what's going to be worse, me keeping around some level 5-8 backups and playing them or having my guy who's now playing like level 10 just tough it out? The answer is to just still stick with my starters. And on top of it all, they'll still be getting the EXP.

There's really only 2 ways I, or anyone who's thinking like me will care about backups:

1) There's a much lower cap put in place for experience (40 or so plays before the big dropoff instead of 90). Then I'll carry a few extra players to have more options. Even under that system, I can't imagine wanting to carry more than 40-45 players. I'd still keep the Energy penalty in the same place (gets much higher after the 80-90 play range) so if a team wants to just have single starters, they can, they're just not helped very much by it.

2) Lower the cap for the point where the Energy penalty hits hard to around 50 plays. That basically forces teams to carry a lot of depth and eliminates single starters across the board (other than maybe P/Ks). I don't like this idea since I don't think teams should be forced into a system like that if they don't want to, but hey, it'll solve the current problem....



And finally, since I know people are annoyed by the current system, I just want to say this: Don't hate the playa, hate the game. We're just playing by the current rules. If they're changed, we'll adapt and play by the new rules. I, for one, hope they do.



I would definetly expect alot more from a Mod. But hey..to each his own.

You or anyone else shouldnt focus on flawed aspects of the game, if you really cared, you would be helping to improve the problem. Not saying how this or that wont work.

Min roster wouldnt work. BUT a Min roster PER POSITION would. MUST have 5 WR's, 3 TE's, 2 QB's, 2 FS's, etc...

Although I am sure exploiters will have a field day with that too. Bottomline is that depth should be just as crucial to winning as strategy and playmakers.


Already posted but...

1) Associate a % that drops the overall skills of a player down the lower his stamina gets. Stamina at 100 speed at 45, stamina at 75 speed at 30, stamina at 50 speed at 20 etc...

2) Injuries SHOULD take a player completely out of a game. Not this "they just get weaker" nonsense. 5 different injury lvls ( injury lvl 1- out a quater, 2- out a game, 3- out 3 games, 4- out 5 games, 5- out 8 games).

Counter this by NOT having injury time be part of the "age" thing yet to be installed. Also, maybe injured players dont play, but get 50% of the average xp gained on the team. (so if the average xp per player for the game is 300 the injured players get 150)

3) Age- As age and seasons go up, skills start degrading.


You DONT slow down nearly enough. There are PLAYOFF teams out there with 1 person in each position, dont tell me its high stamina either. Bottom line is this low of a lvl there SHOULD NOT be a high enough stamina to let a player last the entire game. Only at stamina 75+ should that happen.




 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.