User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AAA Leagues > Canada AAA #1 > Canada AAA#1 Western Conference Pre-Season Power Rankings
Page:
 
douglasiv
offline
Link
 
Thanks for doing this Beefcake.
 
blevstone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Beefcake
Originally posted by blevstone

Yea...it's going to make complete sense to still have them ranked above us after you do that adjustment...


Looks like somebody has a problem with 4th grade math...


Ok...so it makes STILL no sense to have them with the same rating as us...care to actually explain how that makes sense at all instead of a condescending remark?
 
Hawks24
offline
Link
 
Kings beat Dildos, so much for being #2!
 
Beefcake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blevstone
Ok...so it makes STILL no sense to have them with the same rating as us...care to actually explain how that makes sense at all instead of a condescending remark?


If you beat a higher level team, it proves you are at least an equal. In theory two equally matched teams have a 50/50 chance at winning, therefore the reasoning behind the bonus/penalty based on the difference in scores. If I made it more than half the difference in the scores, you run the chance of ranking a lower level team about a higher level one they have not yet even played, which would make less sense.

As the season wears on, and you get more upsets, those bonuses will accumulate and push you higher in the rankings, if you get none, that 40 point bonus will still stick with you, but it's overall importance will decline with time.
 
blevstone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Beefcake
Originally posted by blevstone

Ok...so it makes STILL no sense to have them with the same rating as us...care to actually explain how that makes sense at all instead of a condescending remark?


If you beat a higher level team, it proves you are at least an equal. In theory two equally matched teams have a 50/50 chance at winning, therefore the reasoning behind the bonus/penalty based on the difference in scores. If I made it more than half the difference in the scores, you run the chance of ranking a lower level team about a higher level one they have not yet even played, which would make less sense.

As the season wears on, and you get more upsets, those bonuses will accumulate and push you higher in the rankings, if you get none, that 40 point bonus will still stick with you, but it's overall importance will decline with time.


Maybe you should look into having it weighted based on margin of victory or something? If you beat a higher level team by say 2 points, then yes, it proves that you are at least an equal with them....but if you beat them by say 30 points, then I think it kinda proves that you are a little beyond just equal with them and it should be adjusted accordingly. We beat them by 18 points and they only scored a late TD that didn't matter when we were up 28-3...so I would hardly call that a "close" game where we are equal with them despite what their roster levels are.

Levels mean NOTHING right now...teams continue to prove that time and time again but people still insist on using levels as a way to rank teams.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hawks24
Kings beat Dildos, so much for being #2!


Dildos too high, imo
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
BTW, 28-10 was too close. BS TD at the end for Dildo, so should have been 28-3 or possibly more for Kensington.
 
Beefcake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blevstone
Maybe you should look into having it weighted based on margin of victory or something? If you beat a higher level team by say 2 points, then yes, it proves that you are at least an equal with them....but if you beat them by say 30 points, then I think it kinda proves that you are a little beyond just equal with them and it should be adjusted accordingly. We beat them by 18 points and they only scored a late TD that didn't matter when we were up 28-3...so I would hardly call that a "close" game where we are equal with them despite what their roster levels are.

Levels mean NOTHING right now...teams continue to prove that time and time again but people still insist on using levels as a way to rank teams.


You are right, there are probably better ways to doing it, taking more and more data into account. However that would require more time that I just don't have, so for now, I'm sticking with levels and simple bonuses and penalties for upsets. As I said, as the season goes on good builds and tactics will start showing themselves as more important than levels.
 
Beefcake
offline
Link
 
updated 1st post with new rankings following game 1
 
blevstone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Beefcake
Originally posted by blevstone

Maybe you should look into having it weighted based on margin of victory or something? If you beat a higher level team by say 2 points, then yes, it proves that you are at least an equal with them....but if you beat them by say 30 points, then I think it kinda proves that you are a little beyond just equal with them and it should be adjusted accordingly. We beat them by 18 points and they only scored a late TD that didn't matter when we were up 28-3...so I would hardly call that a "close" game where we are equal with them despite what their roster levels are.

Levels mean NOTHING right now...teams continue to prove that time and time again but people still insist on using levels as a way to rank teams.


You are right, there are probably better ways to doing it, taking more and more data into account. However that would require more time that I just don't have, so for now, I'm sticking with levels and simple bonuses and penalties for upsets. As I said, as the season goes on good builds and tactics will start showing themselves as more important than levels.


Well...the problem is that with a statistical approach, your starting point needs to be pretty solid and I think it was flawed so completely that the rankings will reflect that all season long. I don't think it would take too much more time to just add in a weighted system for "upsets" and it would correct at least a little of the starting error.
 
Beefcake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blevstone
Well...the problem is that with a statistical approach, your starting point needs to be pretty solid and I think it was flawed so completely that the rankings will reflect that all season long. I don't think it would take too much more time to just add in a weighted system for "upsets" and it would correct at least a little of the starting error.


There is no 'starting point' per-se. There are 2 parts to the formula - a weighted levels part, that part is 100% based on the level right now, it is reset after every game. The second part is the upsets bonus/penalties, and those are cumulative for the season and added to the current level based score. Win one upset, move up a little (maybe it was luck). Win two or more, now you are getting somewhere, and it will show.

Anyway enough about the formula, I have a game to plan for. If you are good enough, maybe we will face you in the championship game.
 
blevstone
offline
Link
 
That's ridiculous....of course there's a starting point...there are numbers that you start with which EVERY other number is affected by over the course of the season. So if the numbers aren't very good to start with, it can throw all of the other ones off for the rest of the year. So what I'm saying...is when you base it off of level to start with, it's inherently flawed from the start because level is a truly poor gauge of which teams are best.

And I think it's supposed to be if YOU'RE good enough you'll meet US in the championship game.
 
Snydes
offline
Link
 
Instead of talking about his 'starting point', suggest a better one.
 
blevstone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snydes
Instead of talking about his 'starting point', suggest a better one.


How about....NOT using levels and a statistical based system and just evaluating the teams and ranking them using some actual logic. Those are always more interesting to read anyway and tend to be more accurate...I'd do it myself if I had some more free time but I just don't think that this statistical approach is worth the time it takes to put together.
 
douglasiv
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snydes
Instead of talking about his 'starting point', suggest a better one.


After week 8, the Schatmo dizzy spreadsheet is pretty good. I like the rankings by level in the preseason, but I also understand that levels aren;t everything. I am a lot more concered about getting wins than getting a high ranking.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.