User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP Bonuses for Impact Plays made on the field - a must add
Page:
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
This thread has been linked in the Master Suggestion thread on the first page. Good work guys!

Here's what we have so far:

1. Morale-XP Bonus & Penalty: system based on negative and positive plays
2. Global Morale-XP bonus/penalty & Benchmark system given to all offense and defense players based on overall team off & def performance and distributed based on amount of snaps played.
3. Level of Competition(L.O.C) modifier that adjusts the Morale-XP bonus/penalty based on your opponent's level. This can be applied to both the individual and global morale-xp systems.

Together, I think implementing these three ideas would do the following:

--Expand the role of morale and confidence while retaining the importance of stamina
--Encourage a team concept
--Foster more activity by player-owners in development of their players
--Make stats actually count toward player/team progression and/or regression
--Make it more advantageous for users to play against an equal or higher level of competition.
--Encourage players to play 'Hard'
--Give backups a chance to progress more despite limited playing time
--Give backups more hope that they might eventually earn a starting job on the team
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 21:08:57
 
uurrnn
offline
Link
 
I totally agree with all of it. Good work.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
The only other thing I can think of (that admins might go for) are small, end of season skill bonuses. For example:

The championship roster gets a .25 increase directly in confidence.

The team leaders in tackles would get a .1 increase in tackling.

The top 10 league leaders in interceptions and in receptions would get a .25 increase in catching.

Stuff like that. I don't think getting a bonus equivalent to one training day for an entire season's performance is too much to ask. This would also add umph to the awards and trophies the admins are planning to give those kinds of people.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
The Energy changes: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=79811&page=last#523313

...make it even more important for the player to make the absolute most of the snaps they get. The three systems suggested in this thread would be awesome compliments to the energy changes thus adding the sort of realism that the game is still sorely lacking at this point.
 
Ender
offline
Link
 
i dont think these things will improve the game much. I think there are plenty of other things that need to addressed before this.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ender
i dont think these things will improve the game much. I think there are plenty of other things that need to addressed before this.


The Energy Changes are one example of a higher priority addition. I don't think the features suggested above could be implemented before something was done to make XP-gain for playing time (simply being on the field) more realistic.

However, I do think these features would greatly improve the game from the simple fact that what your player actually does on the field will count toward progression for both himself and his teammates. Meanwhile, the LvL of your competition would become a bigger factor and further promote GBL's tier system.

 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by Ender

i dont think these things will improve the game much. I think there are plenty of other things that need to addressed before this.


The Energy Changes are one example of a higher priority addition. I don't think the features suggested above could be implemented before something was done to make XP-gain for playing time (simply being on the field) more realistic.

However, I do think these features would greatly improve the game from the simple fact that what your player actually does on the field will count toward progression for both himself and his teammates. Meanwhile, the LvL of your competition would become a bigger factor and further promote GBL's tier system.



Yes, I think the Energy Changes were a great idea.

I think there are a lot of other things that probably deserve a higher priority as far as changes/additions to the game. But I think with the addition of Chemistry we are starting to see different systems that could be linked with XP-gain in the future to create greater variation/individual development to the players and the players' performance.

The challenge is how to create variation without destroying playing balance. Playing balance after all is the reason why most XP suggestions get shot down.
 
alexander_37
offline
Link
 
it seems like it should but its a case of the rich getting richer therefore it imbalances the game
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
I think with the addition of Chemistry we are starting to see different systems that could be linked with XP-gain in the future to create greater variation/individual development to the players and the players' performance.


The game is still very young and we're all basically voluntary testers at this point. I realize nothing will happen overnight. Right now, even with the Energy Changes, stamina/fitness is basically the only means through which players progress (Gain XP -> Level Up -> Earn skill points) in-game without paying to Boost (Hmmm....). Meanwhile, actual on-field performance counts nothing towards progression rate. At some point that will have to change. As you stated, it's going to take a combination of new features working in conjunction (like the Energy Changes and three features we've suggested in this thread) to enhance the GBL experience and make progression realistic. I believe it'll happen eventually.
Last edited Apr 20, 2008 19:38:55
 
Killer V
offline
Link
 
I whole-heartedly agree with some sort of stat-related XP gain. Looking at the CB example someone used previously (a shut-down guy who doesn't rack up stats). It goes the other way too.

Let's say I'm on the field for 20 plays as an LB, have 2 forced fumbles, an INT, & 5 tackles. There's another LB who's in for 45 plays and does nothing. He gets more XPs than I do. Does that seem fair?

Create more stats for the positions if you need to, but "big" plays should get you more XPs. It doesn't even need to be a mother-load. Make it a flat 5 XPs for each "big" play.

It would make the games a little more interesting than just checking to see how many plays you were in for.
 
emehl
offline
Link
 
great job on getting this noticed
 
Yung1King
offline
Link
 
Nice work, im liking this idea
 
kowman28
offline
Link
 
What about a Reputation/Intimidation stat? It could play against an opponent's Confidence & Morale stats. When you make an impact play like a forced fumble, 50-yard run, or an interception, your Reputation increases. If you miss a tackle or throw an interception, your Reputation drops. The amount your Rep changes would depend on your level (Lower level players would get high rewards/small penalties for big plays, High level players would receive low rewards/high penalties). Like Morale, this is not a stat you can add skill points to - you have to earn your Rep.
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
This suggestion continues to struggle with the issue that stats and performance are not necessarily tied to each other. The CB who intercepts the ball may be the beneficiary of the LBs and DEs who harass and intimidate the passers. The WR who catches the TD may be wide open in the endzone because of an error. The DT who stuffs the middle may get zero tackles.
 
Killer V
offline
Link
 
I don't think it's as complicated as everyone is making it out to be. The way I see it, these bonus points wouldn't be for overall performance, they'd be for stats only. There's no need to get all introspective about "learning" and progress of players.

I want to build a player who I can root for to make an impact and put up some good numbers. When he plays well and has some good stats, a little reward shouldn't be too much to ask for (something like a flat 2 points per each stat or something).

As it stands now, I really only need to root for my player to stay in the game as long as he can, regardless of what he does. Woo. Fun.
Last edited May 3, 2008 18:48:37
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.