User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
The sim, is not accurately, representing the behavior or characteristics of a football game. Granted this is beta and all that jazz... I don't think some sort of answer is unreasonable. At least something more than "you're stupid, deal". Which is how I interpret, the responses from the devs, that I've found thus far.


So, I guess I can sum up 4 pages of whinging thusly:

You're upset that this Beta game isn't finished yet, and you're upset that you spent money on a Beta game that you knew was Beta when you chose to spend the money on it.

Tell ya what: if the game as-is bugs you so much, retire your players, pocket the FP, walk away, and come back in a year. Hopefully by then it will be up to your standards. Problem solved.

Now if you'll excuse us, the rest of us are going to have fun playing a game that we know is flawed but that is still fun for us despite those flaws.
 
Link
 
like ya mom
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
I guess it's partially my fault, assuming that most people here, would have a pretty good understanding of what I have been saying all along...


You've never been clear. All you've done is spouted off about bugs and issues, accused the sim of cheating, being fishy, smelling something, that you're blanked by Devs. The majority of people would put down to the end result of one great build vs a possibly shocking build + combination of other factors. The fact is "we don't know". We're taking your word for it, and presuming to know what Dee 'has'.

Only on page 4 did you eventually put forward a suggestion as to what you believed is required - acute gameplanning.

Great, super, we all agree.

But it doesn't exist at the moment - so 8 sacks is pretty "realistic".

Originally posted by Warlock
...I guess I should have spelled it out for the low football IQ people.


At which point did this turn into an IQ competition? And how exactly do you measure football IQ? Can I do a degree in it, or is it just something you're born with? What relevance does it have to GLB?

Condescending and you've got no reason to be.

Originally posted by Warlock
I've been saying all along that the sim isn't accurate or realistic. Based on an extensive knowledge of football, this is true and I doubt anyone would disagree with me on this.


Yes you have. But you've as yet not provided any reason 'why' the sim is not accurate in relation to your LT and DE aside from to dispute the impact of confidence/luck and/or question why the oppositions defence did so well.

The rest of us would put it down to gameplan.

Originally posted by Warlock
Since you have no real knowledge of the game (as a player), you merely assumed that I was talking specifically about only the mathematics.


No I didn't. You'll see for the first few pages you whined on about how 8 sacks was unbelievable, until people came forward and said it wasn't. You then bleated on about. What I provided you with was an analysis. Football is numbers, no matter how you might want to look at it - all sports are. It's all percentages, fractions, physics etc.

Originally posted by Warlock
I'm not an idiot, one cannot argue mathematics intelligently. I'm not stupid enough to think that perceived anomalies, are nothing other than the laws of probability.


Again - it's not essentially an anomaly. It could be. Or it could be a realistic representation of how well they gameplanned for your offensive line.

Originally posted by Warlock
See, this is where you just don't get it... the game is borked. It's borked for the reasons I've already explained. The sim is inaccurate, because the variables are incorrect.


What variables? Now if you're on about variables such as "I can't do things within the game" then you have a fair point, but that's just the limitations of this game. If you're on about "I can't line my FB up over the DE" then fine, that's also a variable you can't control. Doesn't make the variables incorrect - because nobody actually knows the correct values (and indeed they are changing as and when the players in the game develop and Bort is able to identify issues).

Originally posted by Warlock
Football is a much more complex sport than the average fan will every really understand.


Let me guess, you're not the average fan...

Originally posted by Warlock
That's been clearly shown in this thread.


...in at least one case, yes.

Originally posted by Warlock
It's not merely a game where two teams of 11 players, all line up across from one another and attempt to beat (not literally) the person standing directly in front of them. There are individual battles yes, but there are also deep strategies. Many similar to warfare... like turning a front to over-powered an enemy flank, even if it exposes a weakness in your own line. The football equivalent, would be a play that relies on misdirection.


Yes. Like every other team sport in the known world. Well done.

Originally posted by Warlock
The points I brought up aren't suggestions, they're the core of what makes football, football.


Well, seeing as they don't exist or aren't yet represented in GLB - don't you think you should perhaps make then suggestions?

Originally posted by Warlock
This is why there was confusion on my part initially, I assumed that these aspects are part of the sim. So, when I didn't see these things being done, I thought something was "fishy". Now, I know that fish, wasn't what I smelled...


Was it roses?

Originally posted by Warlock
So tell me again, how my evidence is half-baked


Because all you've got to hand is 1 random accusation of a 10 interception game, and a 1 x 8 sack game - then lots of bluster about "realism in a simulation". Everybody who is signed up knows there are limitations to the engine. Everybody knows that there are bugs.

Your QB getting sacked isn't one though.

Originally posted by Warlock
, when you don't even have the slightest clue what makes football realistic?


Based on the fact that what? I didn't play in the NFL? What's your great experience.

Originally posted by Warlock
And no, none of those sports you listed are anything like American football. Football is heavily dependent on teamwork and precision.


Biased much? If I have no idea about American Football, then you've just proved you have a complete lack of understanding of every sport.

Originally posted by Warlock
Every play in football, has three phases... strategy, execution and the result.


Well done, reading that from the coaches manual eh? Direct from Tom Landry?

Originally posted by Warlock
Within each of those phases are many variables, but very rarely are things purely luck. Right now, the sim is heavily luck dependent.


Quite often things are purely luck. Or good fortune. A great manager once said "I don't believe in luck, but I do believe you need it".

Originally posted by Warlock
]Such as confidence and vision... this isn't to say that probability doesn't influence things, but I firmly believe the probability has entirely too much weight. For example, regardless of how bad an OL's vision is, he should never miss a blocking assignment.


As we're unable to see the DE's arms pushing away the LT, its wrong to presume the LT "missed" his blocking assignment and instead safer to presume that the DE arm slapped him and went by faster than the LT could adjust his stance.

Originally posted by Warlock
That isn't to say that he'll be able to pick up a stunt, blitz, double team, trap block or second-level defender though. The guy is generally standing right in front of him, barring the listed circumstances. The first and second sack given up, was the LT completely blowing his assignment... that's complete and utter horse shit.


Given the number of players I've seen blow assignments in my lifetime, I have to say "that is complete and utter horse shit".

Originally posted by Warlock
Which in turn ruined the LT's confidence (which then, due to the unrealistic influence of confidence, made the LT pretty much worthless for the rest of the game). So if the sim caused that, there's a major problem.


Why the leap in logic from LT confidence being damaged, to conceding 6 sacks in 47 snaps making him worthless?

Originally posted by Warlock
Did I spell it out enough for you now? Or will you continue to believe you know better, based on your very limited understanding of football?


I'll continue to know better on the basis that I'm not so self absorbed to believe what happened was due to the sim being borked.

Stuff here http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=407741&page=1 broken secondary plays. These are bugs.

Your LT getting splatted.

Not a bug.
Last edited Jul 20, 2008 07:41:29
 
Link
 
Koncorde put you straight! Go Koncorde!
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus

So, I guess I can sum up 4 pages of whinging thusly:

You're upset that this Beta game isn't finished yet, and you're upset that you spent money on a Beta game that you knew was Beta when you chose to spend the money on it.

Tell ya what: if the game as-is bugs you so much, retire your players, pocket the FP, walk away, and come back in a year. Hopefully by then it will be up to your standards. Problem solved.

Now if you'll excuse us, the rest of us are going to have fun playing a game that we know is flawed but that is still fun for us despite those flaws.


Let me point out, just for accuracy, that the game stopped being a beta when it started being a for-pay project. It's in flux, yes; it isn't complete, true. But it's not a beta.

The argument "it's a beta, so you can't complain" is flawed and stupid. When I pay for something, I expect to get value in return. If I don't I have every right to complain. When someone playing complains, this is a good thing, as it allows the developers to take a look and see if there really is a problem and if so, fix it. I understand that some people want to defend Bort and company, and that's fine, but they don't need defending. One thing Bort wants is feedback, and frankly, the feedback that says "I think this is broken." is much more useful to him than the feedback "I love this game!"

T
 
grayghost
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Yes you have. But you've as yet not provided any reason 'why' the sim is not accurate in relation to your LT and DE aside from to dispute the impact of confidence/luck and/or question why the oppositions defence did so well.

The rest of us would put it down to gameplan.


Other than running the ball - there is no way to gameplan to avoid a missmatch like the one that existed between that RDE and that LOT.

He got owned - and it's most likely a result of a "balanced" LOT being put on an island against a speed rusher. Kinda like Jeff Backus being asked to block Trent Cole last year. Now that was ugly - because not only did he beat him with speed - he tossed him like a ragdoll too. Backus of course had an excuse (sore ribs).

 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Let me point out, just for accuracy, that the game stopped being a beta when it started being a for-pay project. It's in flux, yes; it isn't complete, true. But it's not a beta.


Bort calls it a Beta. Everyone on here knows what he means by that, so arguing over the definition of Beta is simply being pedantic.

Originally posted by tsherr
The argument "it's a beta, so you can't complain" is flawed and stupid.


I didn't say Warlock can't complain. What I DID say is that he's dragged this inane blather on for 4 pages. He's gone WELL beyond simply reporting a bug. At this point, he's whining, and nothing more.

Originally posted by tsherr
When I pay for something, I expect to get value in return. If I don't I have every right to complain.


Ah, but Warlock IS getting value in return: he's getting expanded access to the game and the ability to create more players and own a team. That's value.

And more importantly, that's what Bort promised him, nothing more. Warlock got exactly what he paid for.

In addition, Warlock ALSO wants a perfectly realistic simulation of football. Bort would be the first to admit he's nowhere near that goal. That's why he didn't promise any such thing to Warlock. Bort was completely up-front with Warlock about what he would -- and more importantly wouldn't -- be getting in exchange for his money. And now Warlock is complaining because Bort hasn't given him something that Bort never promised him in the first place.

Warlock: I want a burger and fries!

Bort: Well, our fry machine is down, but I can give you a burger for $1.

Warlock: Okay, here's a dollar.

Bort: Okay, here's your burger.

Warlock: HEY!!! WHERE'S MY FRIES?!? THIS RESTAURANT IS BORKED!!!

Sorry. Doesn't work that way.

Originally posted by tsherr
When someone playing complains, this is a good thing, as it allows the developers to take a look and see if there really is a problem and if so, fix it. I understand that some people want to defend Bort and company, and that's fine, but they don't need defending. One thing Bort wants is feedback, and frankly, the feedback that says "I think this is broken." is much more useful to him than the feedback "I love this game!"


Feedback is one thing. 4 pages of pointless whining is quite another.

To go back to the restaurant analogy, Warlock has now been in at the counter for 30 minutes, screaming that Bort's fry machine is broken. But Bort already knows the fry machine is broken. He doesn't need Warlock to tell him again, let alone to tell him repeatedly at top volume for an extended period of time.

And in the meantime, Warlock's burger is sitting on the counter, half-eaten and stone-cold. And it was a tasty burger while it was still hot and fresh, certainly worth the $1 Warlock paid for it, but it's hard to chew a burger and yell at the same time. So rather than enjoy what he has, Warlock prefers to complain about what he doesn't have.

His loss. And that would be the end of it...

...except that the rest of the restaurant is full of other diners who also knew the fry machine was down and decided to just buy burgers and enjoy them. And while we're all eating, we have to listen to Warlock up at the counter. Because he's yelling. About the fry machine. The one Bort already knows is broken.
 
Reinar
offline
Link
 
we had frys?
Dangit, I knew I was getting Borked!
HAH
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
The one Bort already knows is broken.


I'm disappointed you didn't do an analogy involving Warlock ordering a hot apple pie, which is then "boosted" and ends up burning his mouth.

Otherwise well done.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by grayghost
Originally posted by Koncorde

Yes you have. But you've as yet not provided any reason 'why' the sim is not accurate in relation to your LT and DE aside from to dispute the impact of confidence/luck and/or question why the oppositions defence did so well.

The rest of us would put it down to gameplan.


Other than running the ball - there is no way to gameplan to avoid a missmatch like the one that existed between that RDE and that LOT.

He got owned - and it's most likely a result of a "balanced" LOT being put on an island against a speed rusher. Kinda like Jeff Backus being asked to block Trent Cole last year. Now that was ugly - because not only did he beat him with speed - he tossed him like a ragdoll too. Backus of course had an excuse (sore ribs).


Well I was more suggesting perhaps Cavalier and the Apline Golfers had a better gameplan rather than he could gameplan against it. Though without being able to see all the players involved its difficult to work out what took place as a result of which attributes.

And then sometimes you can't gameplan for things - even if you stack 8 in the box, or line up 5WR every down.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
You guys can continue to be clueless and take things out of context. You know the old saying, "ignorance is bliss", fits really well here.

Novus,

You consider it 5 pages worth of me whining, I consider it 5 pages of discussion about this game. I also never said "omg, I payed for a good sim, wtf?", I merely said that the sim isn't accurate and the responses that I've seen (from the devs) have been unprofessional. So I won't continue to support this Company.

Besides, you basically acknowledged that there is in-fact a problem, you just believe that I approached the situation, poorly. Show me where Bort has acknowledged these specific issues and I'll shut up... until then you're analogies are inaccurate. Last season when the sim completely changed the game-plan on us, his response was basically "tough shit, I don't know why it happened, so it had to be the owner/GM sabotaging the settings". He didn't acknowledge that there was in-fact, a problem. He merely dismissed it as some conspiracy, in which the owner/GM changed the setting before and after the game. Is it possible, sure, but what if it didn't happen? How is that a conducive approach to getting things to where they need to be?

Koncorde,

As explained, it has nothing to do with game-planning (unless of course, you lump player development into game-planning, which would be wrong). And yes... you can game-plan for any situation in the real world football, whether or not it's successful is a whole different animal. Alas, that's the problem isn't it? No ability to game-plan for this situation exists in GLB and the sim isn't good enough to make the adjustments for you... hence, you have a borked game.

I'd really like to continue banging my head against the wall... errr debate these issues with such enlightened folks, but I'm a bit tired of repeating myself and speaking slowly, in a vain attempt for some to follow along in the conversation. So I'll just let this thread die a beautiful death, unless the Devs decide to weigh in on the topic.
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Explain to me how we gave up as many sacks in this last game, as we did for the entire season combined (all 17 games)... we even played the same team earlier in the season, yet somehow they managed 4 times the number of sacks this time around.

There's definitely something fishy about this one, just like last season, when the sim had my FB run up the middle 7 of the first 8 plays (getting 70% of the total carries overall, the other FBs accounted for the another 15% of the carries).

I'm sorry, I'm not buying the owner or a GM would sabotage the team two seasons in a row. Nor do I think game-planning had anything to do with our opponent getting more sacks in a single play-off game, than we allowed all season.

Edit: We even had a higher morale.


ya think their D-line just got better as they leveled up? Geez..Y"know tha tCOULD be the reason. Stop whining already...sometimes ya get beat.

 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock


Koncorde,

As explained, it has nothing to do with game-planning (unless of course, you lump player development into game-planning, which would be wrong). And yes... you can game-plan for any situation in the real world football, whether or not it's successful is a whole different animal. Alas, that's the problem isn't it? No ability to game-plan for this situation exists in GLB and the sim isn't good enough to make the adjustments for you... hence, you have a borked game.



umm...how would you NOT game plan around your player development? you wouldnt wanna do something that your players couldnt... LIke..say you have a power back..which means he's slow.. would you have him running to the outside? Or slow recievers that cant go long becuase they cant break away. Saying that just makes you look like a complete tool when it comes to game-planning. You gameplan to the things that you team can do...that you PLAYERS can do

 
skibodragula
McFroggin
offline
Link
 
Dude, have you looked around and seen any of the underdog wins? Some of us have won against teams we had no business beating...tactics+ builds+ chemistry+ like five other things...get those right and undefeated teams eat dirt...get off the wagon...this sim works well...PLAY HARDER..WORK HARDER..GET OFF THE NFL AND INTO THE SIM. frog out
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
You guys can continue to be clueless and take things out of context. You know the old saying, "ignorance is bliss", fits really well here.

Koncorde,

As explained, it has nothing to do with game-planning (unless of course, you lump player development into game-planning, which would be wrong). And yes... you can game-plan for any situation in the real world football, whether or not it's successful is a whole different animal. Alas, that's the problem isn't it? No ability to game-plan for this situation exists in GLB and the sim isn't good enough to make the adjustments for you... hence, you have a borked game.

I'd really like to continue banging my head against the wall... errr debate these issues with such enlightened folks, but I'm a bit tired of repeating myself and speaking slowly, in a vain attempt for some to follow along in the conversation. So I'll just let this thread die a beautiful death, unless the Devs decide to weigh in on the topic.


As stated since page 1; in the end we don't know what your gameplan is/was or the relevant players attributes or settings. We don't know if you had auto-adjust on or not.

What we do know is that 6 sacks is not outside of the realm of possibility and no other 'bugs' were visible within the actual plays involved (and indeed in the vast majority of the plays, the LT 'won').
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.