User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Why did I lose in the playoffs?
Page:
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
...
Those extra 5-10 points I invested in stamina at the beginning of his career helps my players level up faster because they are able to get enough plays for max XP the very first day they take the field. Not to mention once players get faster and stronger you will probably have to give them more stamina anyways. Many O-linemen and D-linemen, for example, can get away with low stamina due to their superior strength, but as their opponents get stronger and faster, they have to work harder to do the same things and get tired faster. It will happen. My players will already be set.


Nah... you got me wrong. Adding stamina early is one of the things I consider a clever move - for exactly the reasons you put down. Playing much, leveling fast. And you can't overestimate stamina when it's too low.

We are talking about one player of 50 stamina /40 confidence vs. 2 players of 44 stamina / 34 confidence - and just the effects on one particular game. And it had to be a close game with all similar builds.

But it's theory after all, because most teams can't decide. Either they have fine depth and it's a no brainer that you'll play two similar guys at high in/out settings or you just give your lv. 27 the playoff-snaps over his lv. 21 backup.

I just wanted to point out that I consider it stupid to choose to play your lv. 23 all the way down to 35 breath in the playoffs because he got 75 strength instead of the 70 of his lv. 21 backup.



Last edited Jul 18, 2008 11:22:16
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Point taken. I know a lot of people disagree with me on this subject, but I am perfectly willing to go my own way. I get the feeling that people tend to recycle information to a ridiculous degree on here and gobble up anything someone says and after it gets passed around for a week suddenly it is gospel and posted on everyone's forums. I wrote a team specific building guide for the Hiroshima Radiation and 3 weeks later someone wanted to post it on another one of my team forums saying that it had been made but no one knew who had made it. I never even intended it for public consumption. It was in response to a particular team and their situation. Then there is that post with all the numbers (how could anyone possibly know specific numbers?) and 2 weeks later it is, as they say Quoted for Truth seemingly EVERYWHERE, even though a lot of people who know have pointed out that there is a lot wrong in the post. People seem almost obsessed with coming to a consensus about builds and tactics on here and when anyone does or says something that is not, let's say, mainstream, then everyone says How could they possibly be right?

Or people will see 1 player's build and say wow, that changes everything about what we thought about making position X. Really? Because so many factors go into stats and performance. First there is the issue of most positions requiring a minimum of 4 attributes to be effective, with some requiring as many as 7. Just because QB X has 70 confidence and had a good season doesn't necessarily mean that the confidence was the sole reason why and not that plus other attributes. Also you have to take into consideration supporting cast, level of competition, the gameplan their team runs, individual tactics - so many things factor in, My DT Art had 19 FFs last season. So I must be building him well, right? But 15 of them came in 3 games against depleted teams (9 in one game). If you were to just look at his stats, that would be a pretty poor indication of what he did against even competition. I am starting to go on and on so I will stop.

*ends rant*
*steps off of soapbox*
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
People will always spread rumors - but clever people make up their own mind.

The nature of this game supports that "secret information" thing. As there is no official guide and not even a confirmed explanation of what the attributes and skills really go into - there's a lot of guessing and figuring. And of course people tend to follow as soon as someone is pretending to have some kind of plan.

Well... and some guys actually have - because they worked hard on what works for them. Like the guide you made for this Hiroshima team.

A consensus about builds will hopefully never been reached. But you got to admit, that some builds really provide great information - if you "read" them right and take "only" what they really proof. Like that that CB build serenity opened last season blew the "secret" that you don't need any tackling even at levels 20+ (if you got speed). I'd bet, most people wouldn't have thought so. So if you didn't like tackling on secondary and thought about leaving it alone, you'd have one less thing to worry about after that information.

Another common behavior: people are not willing to make up their minds based on enough relevant information. Let's take your DT Art. "Simple" people will just look at those 19 FFum. Others will at least check the game log. But very few guys actually watch a couple of games, compare competition and make up their mind on how this particular player did. But what do you know before seeing that? Maybe your guy is only playing great when facing backups? Maybe he sucks putting pressure on the line during pass plays? You never know until you checked him!

But since it's a lot more work to do, spreading rumors is just easier!

(b.t.w.: could you PM that Hiroshima build plan to me real quick? )
 
Link
 
Well, my anecdotal evidence... Our vastly out leveled team has advanced to the superbowl again... We're at a 5ish level disadvantage this season against the good teams. This grew from the 4 level disadvantage we had last season. Granted, maybe its different in the higher leagues, but from what I can tell, you dont get any benefits from forcing your starters to play 80 plays a game.

Though it could be because we get an added chemistry bonus for being BFF... Who knows.
 
Parab00n
offline
Link
 
I didn't read this thread, besides Page 3. He owns 3 teams, all have losing records. I don't buy the crap about his guys playing 70 plays and finishing with over 70 energy unless he isn't playing on Hard.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.