User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > INT's coming at a high rate in playoffs
Page:
 
kr0n
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Did you ever think to consider you need higher confidence to perform better in the playoffs? I mean it's alot of pressure.


Yep.

My QB was terrible the past 2 seasons in the playoffs.

I bumped confidence to soft cap this season and we're in the league championship.

He's not lighting teams up or anything but he's avoiding this "INT's in the playoffs" problem.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Originally posted by Serenity



Originally posted by Bort




No, the only think I monkeyed with, really, was trying to fix the elusive back problem where they dance around too much, get them to run forward and maybe break some tackles, etc. I haven't touched the passing or coverage side of things all season.


Nothing happened mid season.


If you say so. Our QB results look like this:
First four games: 65.08PCT average - 9TD, 1 int - 1 playoff team
Second four games: 57.38PCT average - 4 TD, 5 int - 3 playoff teams
Third four games: 66.4PCT average - 12 TD, 2 int - 2 playoff teams
Last four games: 53.83PCT average - 4 TD, 6 int - 2 playoff teams
Playoffs (3 games): 52.6PCT average - 4 TD, 7 int

That's more ints in the last seven games than in the first 12. That's a drop of 15% in PCT.

Maybe it's just better competition, maybe it's raw luck, but I'm hearing a lot of complaints (some of which may be unfounded, I agree) so it seems like something changed.

I think an easy solution would be to sim a scrimmage between members of our own teams on off game nights. That would allow us to test builds and tactics scientifically, instead of the click and pray system that is currently in place. If our QB dropped off against our secondary, then I could at least say...hmmm, they raised attribute X, let's work on Y with our WRs and QB and see if we can beat that. Right now we have no idea what the opponents builds are like so the only thing we can think when a player stops making plays is that the sim has changed.

I'm not bitching, btw. This is a great game, and I'm enjoying it, but I want to enjoy it more and the best way to do that is to understand it.

T


I completely agree about the scrimmage idea, or something to the effect. Right now we're having to use our "consilation" games as a proving grounds for certain theories because we couldn't afford to risk drastic changes in the regular season....too little too late.
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HydrOshocK

Like I've said before....like it or not, your product is now driven by supply and demand. You can't keep it in beta forever, or hope for long term financial success if you don't have a much more open dialog with your investors.
.02



Strictly speaking, it stopped being a beta when we started paying for it. (Once again, not complaining, just trying to be accurate.)

T
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HydrOshocK
I completely agree about the scrimmage idea, or something to the effect. Right now we're having to use our "consilation" games as a proving grounds for certain theories because we couldn't afford to risk drastic changes in the regular season....too little too late.


The problem is, you can't see the builds you're playing against, so it isn't really a good test. Plus a lot of people screw around and play their DT at QB and stuff like that.

T
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by tsherr

If you say so. Our QB results look like this:
First four games: 65.08PCT average - 9TD, 1 int - 1 playoff team
Second four games: 57.38PCT average - 4 TD, 5 int - 3 playoff teams
Third four games: 66.4PCT average - 12 TD, 2 int - 2 playoff teams
Last four games: 53.83PCT average - 4 TD, 6 int - 2 playoff teams
Playoffs (3 games): 52.6PCT average - 4 TD, 7 int

T


When you beat San Diego, a team that you threw 1 Int against early in the season, then throw 1Int against in the playoff win. What did you attribute their Interceptions to?


Generally I attribute interceptions to the defense catching the ball.

Anyway, I'm done. I don't want to argue about this, I just want to point out my experiences so that it can be looked at and if the game can be improved, it will be. I trust Bort to do that.


T
Last edited Jul 19, 2008 15:30:04
 
skibodragula
McFroggin
offline
Link
 
My two cents....I got smoked in the first round...not picks or anything...in general labeled...those guys got smoked too later...I see it as balancing the lvls-to the opposing positions and THEN tactics that work...it would explain bizarro QB issues, DE's with crazy stats and such....I think( my two cents remember) that if a team opens up pandoras tactical box, then the advantage goes to them....every % added for chemistry, depth chart sub., advanced energy and extreme player builds compounds the effects...

I suppose thats where ANY GIVEN SUNDAY comes in...this thing works pretty good, gotta unlock the box is all...
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
That would hold if the defense all leveled up from 15 to 17 and the offense stayed at 15, but clearly that doesn't happen. Everyone should be getting better.

T


Some builds are better, and there are particular habits with QB's.

For instance I have a cornerback who, between level 4 and 15 had 6 Interceptions in 16 games, to being level 20 and having 24 in 19. This is despite other players getting better (or maybe because of it?).

As previously stated. A level 10QB might have 50 for passing, with all his equipment on it might be 62. By level 16 he has spent 0 points on Passing, but adds his 4 extra points on for equipment onto it.

In the same time a cornerback has added 30pts onto his build in attributes that more directly affect how effectively they both cover an opposition WR, and also how well they are able to predict and react to throws in the air. That level 10 CB who defended 5 passes and made 4 tackles last season might defend 6 passes and make 2 interceptions with just 1 tackle this year.

At the same time their level 10LB has stacked his Glare SA's. The DT's have improved their block breaking skills. The DE's have maxed their agility and strength. The OLB and Safeties are faster and stronger - or maybe maxed their vision.

So basically the defence has had 11*30pts to spend on killing your QB(1 of) and your WR(2 or 3of) your TE (1 of) and your O-Line (5 of)...your HB and FB probably not being much use as pass blockers don't count.

On the other side of the coin - our own QB improved his % greatly this year and has thrown no more Ints and pretty much the same amount of yardage and TD's - so obviously whatever we've done has been effective.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Originally posted by Koncorde

When you beat San Diego, a team that you threw 1 Int against early in the season, then throw 1Int against in the playoff win. What did you attribute their Interceptions to?


Generally I attribute interceptions to the defense catching the ball.

Anyway, I'm done. I don't want to argue about this, I just want to point out my experiences so that it can be looked at and if the game can be improved, it will be. I trust Bort to do that.


T


So when your team caught the ball 8 times was that due to your builds, or are you saying their QB has reason to be annoyed because the Sim cheated them?
Last edited Jul 19, 2008 15:34:25
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Originally posted by HydrOshocK

I completely agree about the scrimmage idea, or something to the effect. Right now we're having to use our "consilation" games as a proving grounds for certain theories because we couldn't afford to risk drastic changes in the regular season....too little too late.


The problem is, you can't see the builds you're playing against, so it isn't really a good test. Plus a lot of people screw around and play their DT at QB and stuff like that.

T


Agreed. We have however discovered a method how to analyze the sim's way of determining player build, so we're constantly working to prove our theories correct. Unfortunately it took us time to figure it out and our players had all been boosted and built according to how the sim was. The process to correct it will obviously require another full financial investment this season from everyone on my team also because every skill point and equipment boost will be needed. That's more money that is being asked from me if I choose to continue.

The question remains, is our financial investment worth a better explanation and open lines of communication from the game's developers? I'd have to think so. If not I'd rather find out now before any further silent changes are made, thus completely ruining my gaming experience and forcing me to cash in my chips....which would lead to another gutted team in a great league because everyone would leave with me.

again, not complaining....just sayin
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde

So when your team caught the ball 8 times was that due to your builds, or are you saying their QB has reason to be annoyed because the Sim cheated them?


I have never said the sim cheated. Don't ever put words in my mouth.

I have no idea what caused the ints. If his ints also went up later in the season, the I'd still wonder if it was a sim change. But your other post on the points the defense has to beat a QB has a lot of merit, and may be the solution to my concern. I'll have to think about it.

T
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HydrOshocK

Agreed. We have however discovered a method how to analyze the sim's way of determining player build, so we're constantly working to prove our theories correct. Unfortunately it took us time to figure it out and our players had all been boosted and built according to how the sim was. The process to correct it will obviously require another full financial investment this season from everyone on my team also because every skill point and equipment boost will be needed. That's more money that is being asked from me if I choose to continue.

The question remains, is our financial investment worth a better explanation and open lines of communication from the game's developers? I'd have to think so. If not I'd rather find out now before any further silent changes are made, thus completely ruining my gaming experience and forcing me to cash in my chips....which would lead to another gutted team in a great league because everyone would leave with me.

again, not complaining....just sayin


Very good points. As owners, we are sort of like franchisees. It is our job to make the game fun for players, but we have to do it without a franchisee manual or really any help from the franchisor (heck, we don't even have a search function in the forums.) I understand Bort doesn't want to tip his hand, and I think adding the internal scrimmage games would solve the issue.


T
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kr0n
Originally posted by Voltron

Did you ever think to consider you need higher confidence to perform better in the playoffs? I mean it's alot of pressure.


Yep.

My QB was terrible the past 2 seasons in the playoffs.

I bumped confidence to soft cap this season and we're in the league championship.

He's not lighting teams up or anything but he's avoiding this "INT's in the playoffs" problem.


I did the same thing when I soft capped confidence he started tearing teams up,
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Originally posted by HydrOshocK


Agreed. We have however discovered a method how to analyze the sim's way of determining player build, so we're constantly working to prove our theories correct. Unfortunately it took us time to figure it out and our players had all been boosted and built according to how the sim was. The process to correct it will obviously require another full financial investment this season from everyone on my team also because every skill point and equipment boost will be needed. That's more money that is being asked from me if I choose to continue.

The question remains, is our financial investment worth a better explanation and open lines of communication from the game's developers? I'd have to think so. If not I'd rather find out now before any further silent changes are made, thus completely ruining my gaming experience and forcing me to cash in my chips....which would lead to another gutted team in a great league because everyone would leave with me.

again, not complaining....just sayin


Very good points. As owners, we are sort of like franchisees. It is our job to make the game fun for players, but we have to do it without a franchisee manual or really any help from the franchisor (heck, we don't even have a search function in the forums.) I understand Bort doesn't want to tip his hand, and I think adding the internal scrimmage games would solve the issue.


T


No doubt, there are two things that I'd like to see to give us more room to work. First is an extra day in between games....I know the non-owners don't like a lot of down time because they don't have as much to do, but it's hard as hell to handle everything us owners have to deal with, and try to figure out this mystery sim at the same time.

Second, we have to have some type of practice time to try test our tactics and player builds before just blindly setting #s that we hope are correct. Maybe the two ideas can be combined and the extra day in between can be a practice day, where our team plays itself and all players benefit from the practice time in some beneficial way to keep everyone happy. I don't know but I sure as hell would liked to have a manual...even Madden has a manual with some useful info.

Last edited Jul 19, 2008 15:48:44
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HydrOshocK

No doubt, there are two things that I'd like to see to give us more room to work. First is an extra day in between games....I know the non-owners don't like a lot of down time because they don't have as much to do, but it's hard as hell to handle everything us owners have to deal with, and try to figure out this mystery sim at the same time.

Second, we have to have some type of practice time to try test our tactics and player builds before just blindly setting #s that we hope are correct. Maybe the two ideas can be combined and the extra day in between can be a practice day, where our team plays itself and all players benefit from the practice time in some beneficial way to keep everyone happy. I don't know but I sure as hell would've liked to have a manual...even Madden has a manual with some useful info.



Yeah, an extra day would certainly help (but right now, it'd kill player enjoyment.) And I'd love to see a manual. And now we're way off topic.

T
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Originally posted by Koncorde


So when your team caught the ball 8 times was that due to your builds, or are you saying their QB has reason to be annoyed because the Sim cheated them?


I have never said the sim cheated. Don't ever put words in my mouth.

I have no idea what caused the ints. If his ints also went up later in the season, the I'd still wonder if it was a sim change. But your other post on the points the defense has to beat a QB has a lot of merit, and may be the solution to my concern. I'll have to think about it.

T


Not my intention to put words in your mouth, my poor phrasing. I meant it in the way of "leads you to believe something that is not true" with regards to the impact the proposed "changes" made.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.