User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
reallifedavid
offline
Link
 
The sim stank here. There is no doubt about it. In a real game, a coach would pull a qb if he were playing that poorly. (remember dan marino's last game).

The question here isn't did the sim screw this team, its should that merit a refund.
 
BWN
offline
Link
 
That 7 in Field General sure didn't help anything.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dmac2008
Originally posted by Serenity

Originally posted by Deuceswild26


Strength: 34 Blocking: 9
Speed: 18.37 Tackling: 9
Agility: 22.68 Throwing: 59
Jumping: 14.5 Catching: 14.5
Stamina: 52.66 Carrying: 14.5
Vision: 47.75 Kicking: 9
Confidence: 29.12 Punting: 9


Confidence killed him.
WTF @ 52 stamina.


no wonder..... no re-sim needed lol

As soon as your QB threw an INT he probably went and cried.



He threw only 15 picks ALL YEAR--no crying was involved.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deuceswild26
Strength: 34 Blocking: 9
Speed: 18.37 Tackling: 9
Agility: 22.68 Throwing: 59
Jumping: 14.5 Catching: 14.5
Stamina: 52.66 Carrying: 14.5
Vision: 47.75 Kicking: 9
Confidence: 29.12 Punting: 9


Low confidence, low Throwing, hell low pretty much everything except Vision and Stamina. A level 25 QB should have Throwing in the 70's or 80's and Confidence at least to 40. It looks like you spent way too many points in special abilities and not enough in stats. Stats are more important than SAs, for the most part.
 
Beavers
offline
Link
 
no replies about the pancakes comment I made earlier?
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Well it's not a horrible build, but 59 throwing is pretty low for a level 25, and 29 Confidence is just plain bad - but i can't say that's solely responsible for the picks.
 
RyguyRB
offline
Link
 
Your team seems to have lost pretty big to teams that are similar level to you during the season as well. I take it you probably waited to boost, but if you combine poor gameplanning, low confidence, bad builds, good gameplanning by Miami, and a terrible luck sim, maybe this is what happens?

I dont mean this as a flame, just pointing out that you have a trend of losing big to teams similar to you (3-26, 16-37) so maybe theres something more going on? Obviously 10 picks is on the ridiculous side, but if you went something like 100% long pass gameplan or something and combine it with poor builds and an unlucky sim, I can understand how this could happen.
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Pancakes don't mean much at all.
 
Dmac2008
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Deuceswild26

Strength: 34 Blocking: 9
Speed: 18.37 Tackling: 9
Agility: 22.68 Throwing: 59
Jumping: 14.5 Catching: 14.5
Stamina: 52.66 Carrying: 14.5
Vision: 47.75 Kicking: 9
Confidence: 29.12 Punting: 9


Even if it was build, the two teams played way earlier in the season and he only threw ONE interception. Doesn't it make sense that his build could only be WORSE earlier in the year due to leveling and/or late boosting?


It does make sense the other players on their D got better but, the QB's confidence did not. It would have been ok if he had been completing his passes but after that first pick and a couple deflections it was all down hill.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot
Well it's not a horrible build, but 59 throwing is pretty low for a level 25, and 29 Confidence is just plain bad - but i can't say that's solely responsible for the picks.


If I had to guess I would say it's the horrid build coupled with bad luck. It's possible the Perfection really worked on morale-lowering SAs during the season, and that coupled with a couple early interceptions may have murdered the QB's morale lower than it had ever been, hence a record-worst performance.

One pick won't kill you at 29 confidence, but two picks (including one by a defensive end of all people) coupled with some morale-lowering SAs might.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Even if it was build, the two teams played way earlier in the season and he only threw ONE interception. Doesn't it make sense that his build could only be WORSE earlier in the year due to leveling and/or late boosting?


No. Especially with Confidence that low. Confidence can ruin your day if you get behind early or make a big mistake early. It starts a death spiral - you throw an early INT that ends in a quick TD for the opponent. That lowers your capabilities for a while thanks to your low Confidence, which leads to throwing another INT. That further lowers your capabilities, and leads to more INTs.

If you don't make that initial mistake, or the mistake isn't major, Confidence isn't as much of a factor.
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Perhaps modifiers relating to morale are heightened during playoff games? It would make sense in real life as there is more on the line.
 
jamyp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Vilita

I don't know, theres no mention of the fact the other team fumbled 3 times and the Nashville team 0.

Also, it appears the Nashville team did 100% pass for the game, which will facilitate more interceptions if you are passing on every down



The last announced settings were 50/50 run/pass. If one of my teammates knows anything different, I'm sure they will correct me.


this is correct
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reallifedavid
The sim stank here. There is no doubt about it. In a real game, a coach would pull a qb if he were playing that poorly. (remember dan marino's last game).

The question here isn't did the sim screw this team, its should that merit a refund.


1) Yes I remember Marino's last game.. what a tragedy. His career was such a successful tragedy - so I suppose that final game was appropriate as an exit.

2) QB with 59 Passing competing against level 25's? Just saying.

3) You are absolutely right - in a real game, that QB would have gotten yanked very early. The issue here is the level of Depth Control. Maybe more options will be implemented in the future - though I doubt season 4.

4) Should it merit a refund, even assuming the sim was screwed up? Hell no. At most, the game could arguably be resimmed - but even under the most extreme circumstances which I can think of - I'd probably oppose rerunning the game. We all know the game is in BETA and that the stats are basically meaningless. The problem is that too many people become financially attached to their players and don't want to see "the great reset" when it happens - which will happen if anyone wants the game to ever get out of Beta.
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Cybershot

Well it's not a horrible build, but 59 throwing is pretty low for a level 25, and 29 Confidence is just plain bad - but i can't say that's solely responsible for the picks.


If I had to guess I would say it's the horrid build coupled with bad luck. It's possible the Perfection really worked on morale-lowering SAs during the season, and that coupled with a couple early interceptions may have murdered the QB's morale lower than it had ever been, hence a record-worst performance.

One pick won't kill you at 29 confidence, but two picks (including one by a defensive end of all people) coupled with some morale-lowering SAs might.


Tend to agree here - 10 still seems stupid high though.

I think it was the perfect storm of low confidence/inaccurate arm, bad start, and poor luck. Perhaps poor tactics as well?

Remember that those CBs' moral would be skyrocketing as well. Can't help.

I think maybe a suggestion stating a limit on the effect of moral on this kind of start should be made? Possibly, moral could be recouped at halftime a bit (pep talk = ^ morale?).
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.