User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Hey Al, I think he's a cowboys fan
 
Al Jack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
Hey Al, I think he's a cowboys fan


With that type of delusional thought process he has to be.
 
Al Jack
offline
Link
 
No offense to you of course.
 
Kaceltx
offline
Link
 
Accusation of a delusional thought process coming......get this, get this...........coming from a Raiders fan.

Irony at its best.

SS Will Smokeya
 
Al Jack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kaceltx
Accusation of a delusional thought process coming......get this, get this...........coming from a Raiders fan.

Irony at its best.

SS Will Smokeya


I haven't made any delusional proclamations.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Al Jack

I didn't really get my numbers from anywhere. The point is that not every WR looks in this forum. If you consider the number of agents in SA AA #1 and look at how many people post in this forum, it is LIKELY much less than half. It is LIKELY that even less would take the time to review the game logs. That is why I said "approximate" and "ABOUT half." The data that you would collect from your "research study" would not be accurate based upon that and would skew the results in your favor, thereby reinforcing your delusions of grandeur.


That is the dumbest argument ever, especially since someone who isnt even an Alpa Conference WR took the time to review ALL 15 game logs. (And pretty quickly I might add). An Alpha Conference WR would only have to review 1 game. It is pretty easy to review all of your WRs catches for 1 game. I do it all the time for 2 WRs. Either way it is not necessary, because that portion of my question was answered so quickly by Smoke.

Also please point me to where I said I have never been beat on a play. I watch a lot of game play by play and had seen at least 9 of the 12 plays posted, but that did not make me feel like Swift was not the best CB.

I felt like the best judge of a WR is the number of times beaten for a long pass or TD.

Again I say you cannot argue that someone is not the best without the evidence of someone better.
 
marz2007
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Al Jack

You said your player is the best in GLB and asked for help in "proving or disproving this theory."


Originally posted by marz2007
(which it isn't hard to detect the sarcasm).


 
Al Jack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BreakYoSelfFool
Originally posted by Al Jack


I didn't really get my numbers from anywhere. The point is that not every WR looks in this forum. If you consider the number of agents in SA AA #1 and look at how many people post in this forum, it is LIKELY much less than half. It is LIKELY that even less would take the time to review the game logs. That is why I said "approximate" and "ABOUT half." The data that you would collect from your "research study" would not be accurate based upon that and would skew the results in your favor, thereby reinforcing your delusions of grandeur.


That is the dumbest argument ever, especially since someone who isnt even an Alpa Conference WR took the time to review ALL 15 game logs. (And pretty quickly I might add). An Alpha Conference WR would only have to review 1 game. It is pretty easy to review all of your WRs catches for 1 game. I do it all the time for 2 WRs. Either way it is not necessary, because that portion of my question was answered so quickly by Smoke.

Also please point me to where I said I have never been beat on a play. I watch a lot of game play by play and had seen at least 9 of the 12 plays posted, but that did not make me feel like Swift was not the best CB.

I felt like the best judge of a WR is the number of times beaten for a long pass or TD.

Again I say you cannot argue that someone is not the best without the evidence of someone better.


It has to do with an indequate sample size and poor testing procedures. I notice that none of the WRs in the 3 plays that were pointed out to you have posted showing that you were beat. That is the point. You are not asking everyone. If you want good data, you have to PM everybody individually and wait for everybody to check and PM you back. If 1 person does not PM you back, your data is not conclusive.

Also, the way you are trying to "prove" your hypothesis is completely flawed. You are trying to determine if your CB is the best ever in GLB, so you ask WRs? You also only ask WRs from 1 conference? To make this determination, you have to collect data from every CB in GLB and see where you rank. To do this, you would need OBJECTIVE rating criteria that is not devised by you. Ask a unbiased person to devise rating criteria and see where your CB ranks. You would also need to collect and analyze the data in an objective fashion. You would need to compare yourself with every CB in GLB to prove your hypothesis. This would mean reviewing every CBs stats and calculate a number based upon the evaluation, and then rank them accordingly. Either that or you can devise a study that is flawed in its testing procedures and conclude that you are the best ever.
 
Al Jack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by marz2007
Originally posted by Al Jack


You said your player is the best in GLB and asked for help in "proving or disproving this theory."


Originally posted by marz2007

(which it isn't hard to detect the sarcasm).




Read the rest of his posts and he hardly sounds sarcastic. You said he was being sarcastic. He didn't. He is demanding proof that someone is better. That is not sarcasm.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 00:28:23
 
marz2007
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Al Jack
Originally posted by marz2007

Originally posted by Al Jack



You said your player is the best in GLB and asked for help in "proving or disproving this theory."


Originally posted by marz2007


(which it isn't hard to detect the sarcasm).




Read the rest of his posts and he hardly sounds sarcastic.


bingo, the first sentence is sarcasm. No one is that full of themselves . (I hope)
 
marz2007
offline
Link
 
All he wanted is for WRs to post plays so he can improve... not very hard to see the real intention of this thread /boggle.
 
Al Jack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BreakYoSelfFool
I feel that my CB, Major Swift of the San Juan Leopards, is probably the greatest to ever play this game.

I would like your help either proving or disproving this theory. I would like you WRs to check your game against the San Juan Leopards and please post any pass plays completed for a TD or for more that 10 yds against Major Swift this season if you have them.

Please only include plays where Swift was lined up in front of your WR and not plays where he just made the tackle. (I watch the play by play pretty closely, but I have only seen a couple of these)


At no point does he mention improvement. Only that he is the best and wants others to help him prove or disprove it. When someone pointed out the plays where he was beat, he goes off on the person who posted it.

If he played on my team, I would have to strongly consider trading him. I don't like players with his mind set. It isn't good for a team oriented game imo.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Al Jack

It has to do with an indequate sample size and poor testing procedures. I notice that none of the WRs in the 3 plays that were pointed out to you have posted showing that you were beat. That is the point. You are not asking everyone. If you want good data, you have to PM everybody individually and wait for everybody to check and PM you back. If 1 person does not PM you back, your data is not conclusive.

Also, the way you are trying to "prove" your hypothesis is completely flawed. You are trying to determine if your CB is the best ever in GLB, so you ask WRs? You also only ask WRs from 1 conference? To make this determination, you have to collect data from every CB in GLB and see where you rank. To do this, you would need OBJECTIVE rating criteria that is not devised by you. Ask a unbiased person to devise rating criteria and see where your CB ranks. You would also need to collect and analyze the data in an objective fashion. You would need to compare yourself with every CB in GLB to prove your hypothesis. This would mean reviewing every CBs stats and calculate a number based upon the evaluation, and then rank them accordingly. Either that or you can devise a study that is flawed in its testing procedures and conclude that you are the best ever.


How would I ask a WR from another league or conference how well my CB defended them?

You seem to be an expert in performing surveys and studies. Would you say that when u perform a survey you start with a high sample size or you start small and work your way up?

You seem to be upset that I made my request more sensational to get more responses.

If you have a problem with how I judge CBs, tough luck. Judging CBs the best is always a matter of OPINION. It can never be proven as a FACT. What can be proven as a FACT is how many times a player was beat in coverage. My goal is was to find out how many times my CB was beat for this type of play in coverage. I have found that the answer is 12 in over 800 plays. I never even asked if anyone else felt like my CB was the best or not. I would not have minded if any WR owner that Swift faced said that someone else guarded their WR better. I dont even mind if another owner feels that their CB is better.

You have some good suggestions, it is too bad that they are pretty impossible to actually put into action
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 00:57:11
 
marz2007
offline
Link
 
Just because he didn't state something literally word for word, doesn't mean thats not his intent.

Originally posted by BreakYoSelfFool

I feel that my CB, Major Swift of the San Juan Leopards, is probably the greatest to ever play this game.

I would like your help either proving or disproving this theory. I would like you WRs to check your game against the San Juan Leopards and please post any pass plays completed for a TD or for more that 10 yds against Major Swift this season if you have them.

Please only include plays where Swift was lined up in front of your WR and not plays where he just made the tackle. (I watch the play by play pretty closely, but I have only seen a couple of these)


OR

" HI GUYS, I WANT TO SAVE MY SELF THE TROUBLE OF GOING THROUGH PLAYS SO I CAN IMPROVE MY GUY. CAN U POST PLAYS WHERE WRs GET THE BETTER OF ME? THANKS!

It worked, shadow gave him everything he wanted.
 
marz2007
offline
Link
 
BTW sorry if I gave away your secret plan BREAKYOSELFOOL
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.