User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by oldskool

I'd like to report every person that owns every player on their team for using FP contracts. I mean, think about it: They bought FP for that player's owner for the sole reason of getting that player on that team. Doesn't that break this rule?


No, because if those players didn't (re)sign there because they were given FP


If the owner wasn't given those FP, the player wouldn't have signed there. Bort gave him the FP in exchange for cash, he made a player with the points & signed it to his team.
*gasp* Bort's a cheater!
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by superpunk

I don't understand why that's bad, or how opposing it doesn't make you a communist


Think about every sport that has a salary cap


I've informed Senator McCarthy. I would watch my back if I were you.

Even sports that have salary caps aren't completely level. Owners like Snyder lump bonus moeny into LTBE incentives that increases out of pocket expenses while increasing cap space, or invests heavily in bonuses, etc. It doesn't work for them because the Redskins are crap, but still it's a legit strategy.

Anyhow, that's my two cents. Don't see what the big deal is, but it's not like there was any open dialogue on this beforehand to flesh things out with a multitude of counselors.

Good talk.

Commie.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
Originally posted by Jed

Originally posted by superpunk


Explain why owners doing this is bad?


Because if this were to be the mainstream norm, then the best players would just go play for the owners who will pay the most real money. In turn, the only way to recruit would be to offer as large FP contracts as possible. It happened in Cyberdunk and really hurt that game.


It's like being the Yankees. The owners willing to spend the much will generally have the best players. The team owners willing to spend the much will generally have the best teams.

I don't understand why that's bad, or how opposing it doesn't make you a communist , but then again I don't know what Cyberdunk is.


Because it would create an environment where players will only sign contracts for FPs. It's already hard enough as it is with so many that only want to be in the USA leagues or only on a Pro team.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
I'd like to report every person that owns every player on their team for using FP contracts. I mean, think about it: They bought FP for that player's owner for the sole reason of getting that player on that team. Doesn't that break this rule?


No, you're reading more into than you need to be. You're example is a "reach" and would not violate the FP Contract rules.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by norsemanvike
Originally posted by superpunk
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by superpunk

Explain why owners doing this is bad?

Because if this were to be the mainstream norm, then the best players would just go play for the owners who will pay the most real money. In turn, the only way to recruit would be to offer as large FP contracts as possible. It happened in Cyberdunk and really hurt that game.

It's like being the Yankees. The owners willing to spend the much will generally have the best players. The team owners willing to spend the much will generally have the best teams.

I don't understand why that's bad, or how opposing it doesn't make you a communist , but then again I don't know what Cyberdunk is.

Because it would create an environment where players will only sign contracts for FPs. It's already hard enough as it is with so many that only want to be in the USA leagues or only on a Pro team.

How long before GLB policies reflect a ban on league names and "pyramiders"?
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Hey, I'm all for renaming the leagues to not have country names

But sorry, that was off-topic. I think there's a number of places that's being discussed already.
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 16:10:58
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by norsemanvike
Originally posted by oldskool

I'd like to report every person that owns every player on their team for using FP contracts. I mean, think about it: They bought FP for that player's owner for the sole reason of getting that player on that team. Doesn't that break this rule?


No, you're reading more into than you need to be. You're example is a "reach" and would not violate the FP Contract rules.


How do you figure? At its very base it can be construed thusly:
1) Log in as someone.
2) Buy flex for that someone so that they make/boost a player that you want on your team.
3) Sign their player to your team.

Just because the "people" involved is a singular person doesn't mean they're excluded from the rule as it's currently worded.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Just because the "people" involved is a singular person doesn't mean they're excluded from the rule as it's currently worded.


Wording aside, you've now had.....2 or 3 Mods tell you publicly that it's not being interpreted that way. If that changes in the future, another public announcement will be made. In the meantime, please move on to your next point of contention, it's not going to be interpreted or enforced that way right now.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Is it just me, or have we got yet another thread where the SAME OLD FACES are making the biggest whiney arsed stance against the rules of the game??

Personally, I'm glad that someone has actually come up with a rule - I'll be even happier if it gets policed and/or not exploited.

But as we all know, when the exploiters include the Mods, it kind of makes these 'rules' hold less water than they perhaps otherwise would have done.....

I appluad the attempts, but I honestly think we're too far down the track to have much control over what the 'gamers' do to 'win' - short of actually bypassing all the 'slapping of the wrist' and just carrying out a wholesale ban of the exploiters - starting with a couple of the Mods and their collective 'friends' .........

 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
But as we all know, when the exploiters include the Mods, it kind of makes these 'rules' hold less water than they perhaps otherwise would have done....


I would absolutely love for you to PM me evidence to show that a Mod is breaking a rule. Till then, you have absolutely no leg to stand on with that argument. So stop throwing around remarks like that without any proof.
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Is it just me, or have we got yet another thread where the SAME OLD FACES are making the biggest whiney arsed stance against the rules of the game??

Personally, I'm glad that someone has actually come up with a rule - I'll be even happier if it gets policed and/or not exploited.

But as we all know, when the exploiters include the Mods, it kind of makes these 'rules' hold less water than they perhaps otherwise would have done.....

I appluad the attempts, but I honestly think we're too far down the track to have much control over what the 'gamers' do to 'win' - short of actually bypassing all the 'slapping of the wrist' and just carrying out a wholesale ban of the exploiters - starting with a couple of the Mods and their collective 'friends' .........


#1 i don't know of any proof of Mods offering FP packages for people to sign. But that may be true, I dont know.

#2 this rule only applies to the future, so if a mod did since this was posted, PM me or one the admins the info, and we will take care of it.

#3 I am sure if the problem escalates, there will be stricter punishment in the future, maybe even wholesale bans above and beyond repeat offenders.
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 16:23:55
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by oldskool

Just because the "people" involved is a singular person doesn't mean they're excluded from the rule as it's currently worded.


Wording aside, you've now had.....2 or 3 Mods tell you publicly that it's not being interpreted that way. If that changes in the future, another public announcement will be made. In the meantime, please move on to your next point of contention, it's not going to be interpreted or enforced that way right now.


OK, I'll ignore the fact that as a whole the game's introduced a rule that will not be enforced or interpreted as it's stated, and I'll move to some new points.

-I referred someone who made a team; am I guilty of FP contracts if I sign a player onto his team?

-I can give someone FP as long as it's not contract-related:
Originally posted by norsemanvike
Q: Can I give flex points to players already on my team?
A: As long as it's not tied to a condition of any contract; new, re-negotiated, or otherwise.

...how is this determined? If I give someone $1 via paypal for making a game-winning field goal, am I already breaking the rule? If they use that $1 towards buying flex did I break the rule at that point? What if they use the flex on another player that's not on my team? Is it against the rules to establish a "$1 for best play of the game" award on my team, or is that outside the realm of "condition of any contract"?

And now, to actual contractual questions:

-If they re-sign with my team at some point after I give them the $1 game-winning kick bonus, did I break the rule?
-What's the designated "acceptable time limit" between when I can give someone money/FP and when they can sign/re-sign with me without it being viewed as illegal? Is it OK if I pay someone now and he re-signs during the offseason? Is it OK if he re-signed two days ago and I paid him today?
 
Hans Hammer
offline
Link
 
WILL IT ALLOWED FOR TO GIVING FLEX POINTS FOR TO ASK HUMAN REJECT CONTRACTING OFFER?
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
I think you're being more than a little ridiculous with it, oldskool. I realize you're probably just doing it to make a point, but still...

The rule is what it is, they can't account for every eventuality. You think it's a pointless rule, and so do I. But it is a rule. Nothing can be done about that now. I can definitely see situations where this could do more harm than good, and cause even greater unnecessary headaches for mods, but hey - they made their bed.
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hans Hammer
WILL IT ALLOWED FOR TO GIVING FLEX POINTS FOR TO ASK HUMAN REJECT CONTRACTING OFFER?


If you mean, "I will give you 100FP if you dont sign with X team" the answer is no, that is not allowed. I don't think that it is a problem that needs addressed though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.