Originally posted by kalkmanc
Originally posted by Duckfan127
Originally posted by dabutracing007
Originally posted by Gambit
QB - lots of ways of looking at QB's so let's see who stands out in different categories.
1st, productivity - VERY important.
1) Peabody 4025 yards
2) Amaya 3970 yards
3) Young II 3960 yards
4) Washim 3910 yards
2nd, % completion - not so important, as it can depend on style of offense, but generally an all-conference QB needs to have a good rating. I noticed the best QB's with 3000+ passing yards were in the 60%-65% range, so then I checked which of the above were in that range:
1) Peabody 61.1%
2) Young 61%
3) Amaya 60.8%
to me that elimated Washim, although he had 59.4% (close)
I pretty much ignored Yds/att or Yds/com as these relate to what kind of offense the team runs.
I then looked at TDs vs INTs and I saw that the best QB's had 25+ TD's but 3 had 30 or more (33, 30, 30) TD's. One of these with 30 TD's was Peabody. He also had a very respectful ratio of 14 INT's against these 30 TD's. Of the two remaining QB's, Amaya had 26 TD's against 20 INT's and Young II had 18 TD's against 26 INT's.
So my conclusion is that the best QB from Zeta is Peabody. Honorably mention to Amaya. Pohl also deserves an honorable mention for the best QB without top end passing numbers, but he can't really be considered All-Conference when you compare him to Peabody because Peabody was much more productive with 4025 yards passing and had comparably high completion percentage and TD's and TD to INT ratio.
So Pohl had more TD's, one more INT, and a higher completion % but Peabody is the clear choice?
Honorable mention to your teams qb who sucks my team was 15-1 oh wait yours wasn't my teams a 1 seed and yours isn't. Face it Porto sucks .
yea, the true factor in how good a qb is is how he leads his team to win and pohl does that
Another thing to include in the QB evaluation could be QB rating.
Originally posted by Duckfan127
Originally posted by dabutracing007
Originally posted by Gambit
QB - lots of ways of looking at QB's so let's see who stands out in different categories.
1st, productivity - VERY important.
1) Peabody 4025 yards
2) Amaya 3970 yards
3) Young II 3960 yards
4) Washim 3910 yards
2nd, % completion - not so important, as it can depend on style of offense, but generally an all-conference QB needs to have a good rating. I noticed the best QB's with 3000+ passing yards were in the 60%-65% range, so then I checked which of the above were in that range:
1) Peabody 61.1%
2) Young 61%
3) Amaya 60.8%
to me that elimated Washim, although he had 59.4% (close)
I pretty much ignored Yds/att or Yds/com as these relate to what kind of offense the team runs.
I then looked at TDs vs INTs and I saw that the best QB's had 25+ TD's but 3 had 30 or more (33, 30, 30) TD's. One of these with 30 TD's was Peabody. He also had a very respectful ratio of 14 INT's against these 30 TD's. Of the two remaining QB's, Amaya had 26 TD's against 20 INT's and Young II had 18 TD's against 26 INT's.
So my conclusion is that the best QB from Zeta is Peabody. Honorably mention to Amaya. Pohl also deserves an honorable mention for the best QB without top end passing numbers, but he can't really be considered All-Conference when you compare him to Peabody because Peabody was much more productive with 4025 yards passing and had comparably high completion percentage and TD's and TD to INT ratio.
So Pohl had more TD's, one more INT, and a higher completion % but Peabody is the clear choice?
Honorable mention to your teams qb who sucks my team was 15-1 oh wait yours wasn't my teams a 1 seed and yours isn't. Face it Porto sucks .
yea, the true factor in how good a qb is is how he leads his team to win and pohl does that
Another thing to include in the QB evaluation could be QB rating.





I will stick to my recomendation still that you need to chill and take the game a little less seriously. 























