User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
Page:
 
bolo_76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Make the economics make sense. Minor league teams shouldn't be able to afford All-pro type players to begin with.


You are right. I addressed that in an earlier post. But at some point even BBB teams will start to make money. I started my BBB team from scratch level 1-5 guys mostly. As we have played and made good financial moves we can afford some better players, as our stadium increases we will be able to add more and afford more. I agree with you for a new team but you can't hold everyone back forever.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Sorry, I should have been more clear.

Minor league teams shouldn't be able to afford All-pro type players to begin with or ever.
 
bolo_76
offline
Link
 
Nah I messed up; upon re-reading you did say "to begin with" sorry, should have read more carefully. We're on the same page.
 
Link
 
I propose that all gutted teams are placed in their own league. Teams have a season to rebuild and can then moveup to whatever bottom rung league they choose. Players that play on these rebuilding teams are given faster XP gains and an extra boost. However, there would be a one time allowance for this so players couldn't make it a habit of building a player by playing for these squads. This gives incentive for players to play on these teams and also allows these teams to rise up to contention.
In addition to this, there should be a GM mentor program where successful owners agree to GM one of these gutted teams to help the new owners build their squad back up.
 
bolo_76
offline
Link
 
What is the benefit to the mentoring GM. I like the idea but people on here are greedy and will want something in return.

Also how would you allow teams to pick where they wanted to go? You would end up with a ton of teams wanting to get into the USA BBB leagues and no where else.
 
LaughMadcap
offline
Link
 
Ok, I didn’t see this when it was posted (I’ve been busy recruiting), so I apologize if I repeat what others have said. I don’t really feel like reading all the posts.

As someone who took over a team last season, I REALLY like this idea. The level of players I need to recruit to be competitive won’t sign with me because, well, I’m rebuilding. So I am forced to sign lower level players.

Ok, here’s my answer to your questions, for what it’s worth, and usually people think my ideas aren’t worth much (like the Commissioner idea I’m still upset about), but I keep givin’ ‘em anyway.

Ok, here are my answers.

#1
Every season teams move up and down, correct? So when a team is sold and you move it down to the bottom, have the next team that WOULD have moved up, move up. In other words, at the end of every season, the teams are ranked yes? (If not, then rank them.) The top two go up, and the bottom 1 goes down (or something like that). Just have the #3 team move up, and if another team is sold, the #4 team, etc. This seems simple to me.

#2
You’re right. Not allowing people to sell the team would only strand players and piss more people off. If people want to go, they will go and won’t care about your “You can’t sell the team” rule. Then people will get stuck on a CPU team and everyone will be angry. This is a bad idea.

#3
I don’t care, but I would say go ahead and give it to an owner and let him/her do with it what he/she can. Why not? The team’s going to be bad regardless, so they might as well try to get a head start on next season.

#4
So abandon the level cap/exp penalty/sportsmanship idea. I don’t like it anyway. I think it’s a bad way to solve the problem you want to solve, but I’ve already expressed my opinion about that, and I know what I would like isn’t going to happen. But you could make the bottom level a cap free level. Don’t give out awards for that level (so people aren’t trying to win it so they can have a little trophy on their page). Make it like the minor leagues, and only teams who are really bad and really poorly run will stay there. Other teams will move out once they get good. This also provides incentive to try and get OUT of these leagues, and this will also help avoid the colluding problems. Who wants to win a league where no one wants to be? It’s like the D-Leagues except with human owned teams. This idea probably ahs problems and may not be a good solution, but it sounds good to me right now.

#5
Ok, this could be an optional thing. The new owner could have the OPTION of moving down (I would have taken it). Also, if a GM doesn’t want to buy the team, you could offer it to one of the players. If anyone who ahs a player on the meat (and doesn’t own another team, of course) wants to buy the team, they can.

Making this an option would also solve the problem with #2 and #4.

Ok, those are my ideas. Do with them as you will.
 
Apocihq
offline
Link
 

My idea is to stick with the main thought, moving the team to the bottom tier and resetting the team. However, none of the teams will be moved down mid-season. Any teams that have previously played the recently sold team will have stats and any record of that previous game removed. It will be considered a 'bye' week. The sold team will continue playing the set schedule, allowing both itself and the teams it plays to earn XP. Only XP will be gained from playing these games. Stats will not be counted for league statistics, nor records affected. At the end of the season, the team moves to the lowest tier. The 3rd best ranking team would move up as well as the two division winners. The ranking system would be based on league record, and whichever rules are used to determine playoff seeds. If two teams are tied from different divisions, they could have a ranking game played while the final championship game is played.

Now that I think about it, I also agree that there should be a separate list to a buy a gutted and play in the league the team is currently at. People choosing to own a team would have an option to select whether or not to buy a gutted team. If they purchased it mid-season, the above rules would apply, but the team could spend the rest of the season recruiting and preparing for the next coming season. XP would be gained, but the games and statistics would not count. Flex points for the purchase would count for the current mid-season purchase and for the following season. Any gutted teams not selected for purchase will move to the bottom tier end-of-season.

1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

Don't move any teams up or down mid-season. End of season, transfer additional teams up the ladder depending on number of sold teams. This could be based on league record and the tie-breaker settings used for playoff rankings. Teams purchased as gutted option would stay put.

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

Allow players end of season contracts with the ability to sign new contracts. They will still play scheduled games, but they won't count towards the record of any other teams. Stats will not count either. XP will still be gained.

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

Bad. Recently dropped players may have a hard time finding a team to their liking mid-season. Leave the players on the team, but able to freely sign new contracts (unless the team is purchased with the purchase gutted team option). They will still receive XP, blowouts will not count towards season stats, or team records.

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

They could purchase a gutted team. Or wait for the second season of a reset/addition team.

5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

This solution allows people who want to take over a gutted team the option, however statistics and records will be disallowed for the current season. The team would still have a chance to be a champion at the beginning of the new season, with the new owner.
 
Nat Belmont
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LaughMadcap


#4
But you could make the bottom level a cap free level. Don’t give out awards for that level (so people aren’t trying to win it so they can have a little trophy on their page). Make it like the minor leagues, and only teams who are really bad and really poorly run will stay there. Other teams will move out once they get good. This also provides incentive to try and get OUT of these leagues, and this will also help avoid the colluding problems. Who wants to win a league where no one wants to be? It’s like the D-Leagues except with human owned teams. This idea probably ahs problems and may not be a good solution, but it sounds good to me right now.


It's a little off topic, but I really like that idea!
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome

I disagree on this point. I think that due to the limited funds of a new team, there will already be a cap in place. With only a limited amount of money, new teams simply won't be able to afford to hire a roster full of lvl. 20s. They will have to make decisions in order to stay within their budget.


Well obviously this isn't happening. Teams are somehow stacking new teams with great talent.
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bolo_76
Originally posted by awesome

Make the economics make sense. Minor league teams shouldn't be able to afford All-pro type players to begin with.


You are right. I addressed that in an earlier post. But at some point even BBB teams will start to make money. I started my BBB team from scratch level 1-5 guys mostly. As we have played and made good financial moves we can afford some better players, as our stadium increases we will be able to add more and afford more. I agree with you for a new team but you can't hold everyone back forever.


Realistically, BBB stadiums shouldn't be increasing. For this truly to be a tiered league representation, BBB teams should struggle to sell out games. That part of the game is broken if you are going to rely on $$$.

Team level cap suggestion starts everyone on the same playing field but doesn't stunt team financial growth.
 
Maddencoach
offline
Link
 
No team should move regardless of the sutuation. Okay the Owner sells the team "BIG DEAL" Your contract becomes void and you automatically get a new contract and you have the choice if you want to take it or leave it. If you take it then you have to deal with the CPU coaching the team. That's another reason why I think that GM should have the first option to buy the team and then players can bid for it, if no one wants to take the team then you cant say that you didn't have a choice in the matter.

After the season is over, Best two teams or 1, or however many movesup and an equal number of the worst team moves down. It's simple, if you perform better than all the teams in your leauge then you get promoted and if you do worst than all the other teams then you get demoted

Team level caps should be implemented and if you are a player and your teams keeps droping down than so will your budget so unless that high level player wants to make the same amount as a low level player than he would find himself another team
Last edited Jun 29, 2008 23:17:22
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sois
Originally posted by awesome


I disagree on this point. I think that due to the limited funds of a new team, there will already be a cap in place. With only a limited amount of money, new teams simply won't be able to afford to hire a roster full of lvl. 20s. They will have to make decisions in order to stay within their budget.


Well obviously this isn't happening. Teams are somehow stacking new teams with great talent.


Which is the whole point of my suggestion: Teams in lower leagues should be making less money than they are now.
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome

Which is the whole point of my suggestion: Teams in lower leagues should be making less money than they are now.


Sorry awesome, didn't see the suggestion.

My only problem with this is that is starts creating a problem with friend teams. You can't split friend teams up. Too much money comes into the site with groups.

A team level cap allows you to start with your friends and stay with them forever, win or lose. Any ideas about constraining cash will eventually force teams to split the friend groups up, which isn't good for business.

I like the monetary system as it is. A team level cap will allow teams to start at the same level and grow at the same rate. They can all build humoungous stadiums in lower levels, just as it happens now.

This idea requires the least amount of tinkering.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sois
Originally posted by awesome


Which is the whole point of my suggestion: Teams in lower leagues should be making less money than they are now.


Sorry awesome, didn't see the suggestion.

My only problem with this is that is starts creating a problem with friend teams. You can't split friend teams up. Too much money comes into the site with groups.

A team level cap allows you to start with your friends and stay with them forever, win or lose. Any ideas about constraining cash will eventually force teams to split the friend groups up, which isn't good for business.



Actually, it won't affect this because they will all sign early in their careers for long contracts. If their teams are managed properly, money won't be an issue as they won't be receiving outrageous contracts. The longer the team stays together, the better it will be, thus more likely to advance into the higher leagues where the money is better, thus being able to pay its loyal members the higher required salaries for the higher levels that they have achieved.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
...there should not be teams full of lvl. 23+ players in USA BBB.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.