Originally posted by The Avenger
Originally posted by beenlurken
FYP
Also, having been someone who has paid a lot of attention to ST MVP rankings over the seasons.... KR stats >>>> PR stats in the MVP formula. That alone could account for why player 2 is ranked higher. Also (as you already mentioned) the ST tackles player 2 accumulated can be a difference maker.
I am not saying I think player 2 should be ranked higher by any means just trying to help you see the flaw in Borts logic. Its pretty ridiculous that player 2 gets an advantage because he plays on a weaker team that allows him more KR stat opportunity.
So 1700 PR yards more win MVP over 2000 less KR yards, less TDs at KR and PR and a much lower global rank according to GLB?
Remove the global rank... it means nothing to the equation MVP equation (again different code... that sucks even worse than the league ranking code).
Also you still have it wrong... it should be 1700 more KR yards (and possibly 80 more KR's... yes that sounds ridiculous but Bort factors in # of punts for punters so he might factor in # of returns for KR's) and potentially 20 ST tackles wins MVP over 2000 less PR, less TDs at KR/PR.
Personally I dont think ST tackles should count for returners in the equation (ST coordinators should not be putting a returner builds in position to make tackles on ST's) or there should be a stiff penalty for missed tackles in regards to the MVP formula.
Originally posted by beenlurken
FYP
Also, having been someone who has paid a lot of attention to ST MVP rankings over the seasons.... KR stats >>>> PR stats in the MVP formula. That alone could account for why player 2 is ranked higher. Also (as you already mentioned) the ST tackles player 2 accumulated can be a difference maker.
I am not saying I think player 2 should be ranked higher by any means just trying to help you see the flaw in Borts logic. Its pretty ridiculous that player 2 gets an advantage because he plays on a weaker team that allows him more KR stat opportunity.
So 1700 PR yards more win MVP over 2000 less KR yards, less TDs at KR and PR and a much lower global rank according to GLB?
Remove the global rank... it means nothing to the equation MVP equation (again different code... that sucks even worse than the league ranking code).
Also you still have it wrong... it should be 1700 more KR yards (and possibly 80 more KR's... yes that sounds ridiculous but Bort factors in # of punts for punters so he might factor in # of returns for KR's) and potentially 20 ST tackles wins MVP over 2000 less PR, less TDs at KR/PR.
Personally I dont think ST tackles should count for returners in the equation (ST coordinators should not be putting a returner builds in position to make tackles on ST's) or there should be a stiff penalty for missed tackles in regards to the MVP formula.






























