Bump
Forum > Suggestions > Offical Thread for Promotion System Changes (Enforcing Level Caps Etc)
How about this,
When a team misses the playoffs two seasons in a row, they are placed into a cap according to their player value rather than continuing with the 1 cap jumps. In addition to thwarting sand baggers, this would also help out teams who have gotten into too high of a promotion schedule and need to be placed in lower leagues (not sure how much that happens though).
Maybe make all promotions under level 24 based exclusively on level/player value to prevent the 25 in a cap 18 phenomenon.
When a team misses the playoffs two seasons in a row, they are placed into a cap according to their player value rather than continuing with the 1 cap jumps. In addition to thwarting sand baggers, this would also help out teams who have gotten into too high of a promotion schedule and need to be placed in lower leagues (not sure how much that happens though).
Maybe make all promotions under level 24 based exclusively on level/player value to prevent the 25 in a cap 18 phenomenon.
Seric
offline
offline
Originally posted by Clarka3
i agree completely. make the level caps hard caps. if the team fails enough to stay behind, fine- but make them cut all players over the level cap.
As a manager of a team that I inquired about sticking back into cap 22 for this season (since all but one of our players were level 22, and the 1 player was level 23 by about 100 XP). We were told we could do so but we had to cut the level 23 player. Which sounds fine, but then you see teams that exploit the system and end up with more than one guy way over the cap level and it's just not fun, nor fair that we'd have to cut that guy to stay behind while exploiters get away with it.
make the damn caps hard and be done with it..
I would have no problem with a hard cap but stop acting like everyone who's been in that position where they get promoted into a league where they out level the cap range are doing it on purpose.
I have been in that position and I didn't do it on purpose. I did my best to make the playoffs but missed it by a single game. Hell the season before I missed the playoffs and actually requested to move up 2 caps instead of 1 due to my team level. The following season I got moved up 1 cap because I missed the playoffs by a single game and due to levels alone I went 16-0 as I did little changes to tactics if any at all (especially on the defense as I had no DC the entire season up to the playoffs). I stated from the get go what happened in the league forum and no one had an issue with it, or no one came forward with it. Frankly I was actually surprised I went 16-0 as there were a lot of teams I thought could beat me.
i agree completely. make the level caps hard caps. if the team fails enough to stay behind, fine- but make them cut all players over the level cap.
As a manager of a team that I inquired about sticking back into cap 22 for this season (since all but one of our players were level 22, and the 1 player was level 23 by about 100 XP). We were told we could do so but we had to cut the level 23 player. Which sounds fine, but then you see teams that exploit the system and end up with more than one guy way over the cap level and it's just not fun, nor fair that we'd have to cut that guy to stay behind while exploiters get away with it.
make the damn caps hard and be done with it..
I would have no problem with a hard cap but stop acting like everyone who's been in that position where they get promoted into a league where they out level the cap range are doing it on purpose.
I have been in that position and I didn't do it on purpose. I did my best to make the playoffs but missed it by a single game. Hell the season before I missed the playoffs and actually requested to move up 2 caps instead of 1 due to my team level. The following season I got moved up 1 cap because I missed the playoffs by a single game and due to levels alone I went 16-0 as I did little changes to tactics if any at all (especially on the defense as I had no DC the entire season up to the playoffs). I stated from the get go what happened in the league forum and no one had an issue with it, or no one came forward with it. Frankly I was actually surprised I went 16-0 as there were a lot of teams I thought could beat me.
Seric
offline
offline
Originally posted by Brewster
Originally posted by Chysil
Originally posted by Dr. E
Below are two rules in minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
+ 1
I think this would be the easiest way to fix it.
Originally posted by Chysil
Originally posted by Dr. E
Below are two rules in minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
+ 1
I think this would be the easiest way to fix it.
Seric
offline
offline
Originally posted by azrolator
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
This really isn't a problem and breaking up teams or over promoting them will only make competitive balance worse. Every season people freak out about the few over cap guys on some team in their league, then those teams turn out to be a non-issue because they suck, which is why they are so far above their leagues level. Happens every time.
This is what happened to the first team in the OP against cap 22 teams:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342266
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342994
One of those was a scrim against a 22 cap team, but the team in question is in an 18 cap league, the other link was from one of the regular season games, both wins.. It looks to me as if they played 1 team of double promoted boosters, who were level 14 to the other teams 25, and then 1 game against double promoted non boosters that were level 11 to the other teams 25. Both wins obviously, which is exactly what the original post was pointing out, that level 25 guys shouldn't be in this level 18 competitive league against level 11's and 14's. Even if they played a team that had players all the way to the level cap, those guys would still be outleveled by 7!
I really don't understand your reply, as you gave links to a game that was from 18 cap league, and said it was 22. Your seem to be making the statement that teams that are 7 levels higher than the league cap they are in, somehow, suck and are non-issues, but you backed it up with links to a team that is 7 levels higher than the league cap, that has won both its games by a large margin. Not sure if I just am not understanding what you were trying to say, but thanks for providing examples to back up the OPs suggestion anyways.
Edited: took out your -1 as I didn't want people to think I agreed with you.
Perhaps you should check the teams that won because both of those teams are in a Cap 22 league.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342266 - Winning team Whistler Canuckleheads http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4325 Competitive Minors Lv 22 #4
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342994 - Winning team Artic Wings http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4526 Casual Competitive Lv 22 #3
Before you act as if he was trying to pull the cover over peoples eyes, try verifying what you're saying because you just made yourself look like a fool. Then you say they won the games but they lost both of the games. Obviously you didn't actually take the time to look at them but trying to act like you did. He didn't edit his post, so obviously the games are the exact ones you're refering to.
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
This really isn't a problem and breaking up teams or over promoting them will only make competitive balance worse. Every season people freak out about the few over cap guys on some team in their league, then those teams turn out to be a non-issue because they suck, which is why they are so far above their leagues level. Happens every time.
This is what happened to the first team in the OP against cap 22 teams:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342266
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342994
One of those was a scrim against a 22 cap team, but the team in question is in an 18 cap league, the other link was from one of the regular season games, both wins.. It looks to me as if they played 1 team of double promoted boosters, who were level 14 to the other teams 25, and then 1 game against double promoted non boosters that were level 11 to the other teams 25. Both wins obviously, which is exactly what the original post was pointing out, that level 25 guys shouldn't be in this level 18 competitive league against level 11's and 14's. Even if they played a team that had players all the way to the level cap, those guys would still be outleveled by 7!
I really don't understand your reply, as you gave links to a game that was from 18 cap league, and said it was 22. Your seem to be making the statement that teams that are 7 levels higher than the league cap they are in, somehow, suck and are non-issues, but you backed it up with links to a team that is 7 levels higher than the league cap, that has won both its games by a large margin. Not sure if I just am not understanding what you were trying to say, but thanks for providing examples to back up the OPs suggestion anyways.
Edited: took out your -1 as I didn't want people to think I agreed with you.
Perhaps you should check the teams that won because both of those teams are in a Cap 22 league.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342266 - Winning team Whistler Canuckleheads http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4325 Competitive Minors Lv 22 #4
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342994 - Winning team Artic Wings http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4526 Casual Competitive Lv 22 #3
Before you act as if he was trying to pull the cover over peoples eyes, try verifying what you're saying because you just made yourself look like a fool. Then you say they won the games but they lost both of the games. Obviously you didn't actually take the time to look at them but trying to act like you did. He didn't edit his post, so obviously the games are the exact ones you're refering to.
Seric
offline
offline
Also all of my posts are just arguing points. In the end, I agree with this thread and in fact this issue is what I sent to Catch22 when the option was given. Anyone who wants proof of this is free to send me a PM and I will forward the PM I sent. I actually am one of the teams that "benefitted" from this, though not by design. The fact that I agree with the fact that something does need to be done should show that not all teams that are in this situation do it on purpose.
I just have to point out that all 5 teams in the OP have multiple losses in their regular season proving they are not good examples of a bad promotion system.
However, I do I think teams should be stopped from double tanking seasons (reset cap after two missed playoffs), and maybe sub 26 cap leagues should have more rigid promotion so teams go 4-14-22 like they should and use the competitive/elite system to sort the good from the bad.
However, I do I think teams should be stopped from double tanking seasons (reset cap after two missed playoffs), and maybe sub 26 cap leagues should have more rigid promotion so teams go 4-14-22 like they should and use the competitive/elite system to sort the good from the bad.
Gunner65
offline
offline
+1 ... I posted a suggestion like this a couple of season's ago and got as much attention as this one probably will but I agree with the OP
ChildishGambino
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dr. E
There are several of these threads now. Be nice if a Mod would combine them.
Yes I agree.
There are several of these threads now. Be nice if a Mod would combine them.
Yes I agree.
Morbid Da Clown
offline
offline
Probably 85-90% of GLB agree with the OP. And I bet 99% of them are probably paying customers. So this will never get done as the non boosters will complain about competitiveness also, so your gonna have non boosting teams 2-4 seasons older and a few levels higher then most others in leagues at lower levels. Unless you actually spend a season to lose you will always play against teams that out level you. The current league cap system rewards those that lose more then those that actually try to win.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























