User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by MRIGUY

Use this Bort because it is my idea.


That's a pretty good idea in general TBH. If you win, you should get promoted, but coming short should mean you gotta make the cut.


That is where having a tourney comes into to play.....

You just can't play against teams in your own conference......

This way you will be able to get a feel of how each team ranks against other teams. Take those results and compare to how the teams do in their own conference and you should have a good fell of how the teams rank against each other....

The problem I have is that if in AAA#1 the two winners of the league are blown away by 70+ by the teams in league AAA #4 & 5 & 6, the teams in AAA#1 should not be promoted. They are in a weak conference and will get absolutely killed in PRO
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
It has to be fair though, since we don't choose the leagues we get promoted into, nor do we control the strength of the teams in it. Otherwise, you create more unhappy owners. Whatever system you come up with, it should be one that every AAA team has the opportunity to earn their way to Pros every season.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
It has to be fair though, since we don't choose the leagues we get promoted into, nor do we control the strength of the teams in it. Otherwise, you create more unhappy owners. Whatever system you come up with, it should be one that every AAA team has the opportunity to earn their way to Pros every season.



Correct, but just because you win a league that is inferior to all other leagues because you lucked into that random league, doesn't mean you should be able to promote to Pro.......


You should be able to atleast hold your own in a AAA tourney.....
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Beachsand DTD

Correct, but just because you win a league that is inferior to all other leagues because you lucked into that random league, doesn't mean you should be able to promote to Pro.......


You should be able to atleast hold your own in a AAA tourney.....


So long as the tourney and all it's games are free, I could live with this, although it seems to marginalize the regular season and playoffs.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Beachsand DTD
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by MRIGUY


Use this Bort because it is my idea.


That's a pretty good idea in general TBH. If you win, you should get promoted, but coming short should mean you gotta make the cut.


That is where having a tourney comes into to play.....

You just can't play against teams in your own conference......

This way you will be able to get a feel of how each team ranks against other teams. Take those results and compare to how the teams do in their own conference and you should have a good fell of how the teams rank against each other....

The problem I have is that if in AAA#1 the two winners of the league are blown away by 70+ by the teams in league AAA #4 & 5 & 6, the teams in AAA#1 should not be promoted. They are in a weak conference and will get absolutely killed in PRO[/QU
OTE]

U don't have to worry about that happening.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by MRIGUY
Originally posted by Beachsand DTD

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by MRIGUY



Use this Bort because it is my idea.


That's a pretty good idea in general TBH. If you win, you should get promoted, but coming short should mean you gotta make the cut.


That is where having a tourney comes into to play.....

You just can't play against teams in your own conference......

This way you will be able to get a feel of how each team ranks against other teams. Take those results and compare to how the teams do in their own conference and you should have a good fell of how the teams rank against each other....

The problem I have is that if in AAA#1 the two winners of the league are blown away by 70+ by the teams in league AAA #4 & 5 & 6, the teams in AAA#1 should not be promoted. They are in a weak conference and will get absolutely killed in PRO
[/QUOTE]

U don't have to worry about that happening.

I was using this as an example.....It could happen in any league.....

in AAA#7 - Guarada Conference, pretty much the entire USA AAA#2 populated........ That was one tough conference, why should we not be able to be promoted because we got the short end of the straw......If we can prove that we can beat an entire other league, then we should be able to be promoted (even if we do not win our conference)....
Edited by Beachsand DTD on Jul 14, 2010 18:00:08
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
Originally posted by Beachsand DTD


Correct, but just because you win a league that is inferior to all other leagues because you lucked into that random league, doesn't mean you should be able to promote to Pro.......


You should be able to atleast hold your own in a AAA tourney.....


So long as the tourney and all it's games are free, I could live with this, although it seems to marginalize the regular season and playoffs.


But it would allow a better promotion system....
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
there are several issues with tournaments.

1) Would lead to longer post-season and more dormant time for teams that are eliminated. Dormant time is not a good thing in an online game.

2) We typically need between 30-80 spots filled in the Pro leagues. This high number pretty much renders the tournament results meaningless.

3) You're still going to have people complaining that such and such team that qualified for the tournament out of X league isn't as good as such and such team that did not qualify for the tournament out of Y league.

We are discussing some ideas right now but in the end we're probably going to go with something that is simple and straight forward. Conference winners and best available teams using standard tie breaking procedures. Yes, it might be initially unfair to some teams but as Bort has said over time the leagues will even out.

That being said, if you have an idea that makes sense, we'll evaluate it and discuss it. Obviously, we need to have something set in stone soon, so we're not going to be mulling this over for the next two weeks. So if you have an idea - now's the time to get it out here.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
there are several issues with tournaments.

1) Would lead to longer post-season and more dormant time for teams that are eliminated. Dormant time is not a good thing in an online game.

2) We typically need between 30-80 spots filled in the Pro leagues. This high number pretty much renders the tournament results meaningless.

3) You're still going to have people complaining that such and such team that qualified for the tournament out of X league isn't as good as such and such team that did not qualify for the tournament out of Y league.

We are discussing some ideas right now but in the end we're probably going to go with something that is simple and straight forward. Conference winners and best available teams using standard tie breaking procedures. Yes, it might be initially unfair to some teams but as Bort has said over time the leagues will even out.

That being said, if you have an idea that makes sense, we'll evaluate it and discuss it. Obviously, we need to have something set in stone soon, so we're not going to be mulling this over for the next two weeks. So if you have an idea - now's the time to get it out here.


let the winners advance then have the rest advance based on a SOS system...

quality of win goes up as you play teams with higher effective levels.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MRIGUY
let the winners advance then have the rest advance based on a SOS system...

quality of win goes up as you play teams with higher effective levels.


Whatever system gets more teams from AAA #1 into Pros, is the best, right?

The new AAA system has not even been in place one day and it is already turning into the BCS with teams trying to form a super-league so that they can control the access of other teams to get into the Pros.

Shall we add a preferred league option to go along with preferred region so that folks can request which league to join? Perhaps we can renamed AAA #1 to SEC, AAA#2 to Big 12, AAA#3 to Big 10, etc...
Edited by Plankton on Jul 14, 2010 20:01:29
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Just do the tournament World Cup style for AAA...

Top 8 teams from each conference go to the top Championship Tournament. #1 seeds play #8 seeds (and so forth) in the first round but from different leagues (AAA1 #1 seed plays AAA4 #8 seed for example). There would be a cutoff point in this elimination tournament where all teams would promote. Basically, it would allow the strongest AAA teams to promote (there might be a AAA league where no teams promote),

You could even do this for 8 teams from each conference that dont make the playoffs (Toilet Bowl). Only difference is they are playing to stay in AAA. There would be the potential for a AAA league to not have an demotions.

It would certainly increase the parity across the AAA league much quicker than anything else.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
Whatever system gets more teams from AAA #1 into Pros, is the best, right?

The new AAA system has not even been in place one day and it is already turning into the BCS with teams trying to form a super-league so that they can control the access of other teams to get into the Pros.

Shall we add a preferred league option to go along with preferred region so that folks can request which league to join? Perhaps we can renamed AAA #1 to SEC, AAA#2 to Big 12, AAA#3 to Big 10, etc...


Yeah...SEC would be AAA #1.

I like your idea.
 
AdamantEnigma
offline
Link
 
A Strength of Schedule ranking system would be a lot more powerful of a tool if the pre-season scrimmages could be scheduled outside of the league, imo. This would set up a round-robin environment where you could determine the true strength of a league's teams (more specifically, a conference, for purposes of promotion) by testing them against random competition from the other leagues in the same tier.

Most teams with AAA playoff aspirations will have their rosters set by season rollover, so the "haves" would already be established squads that are ready to roll by the time the schedules are put up, and be ready to represent for their league. You'd need to disable the chemistry impact during these scrimmages to level the playing field (since some rosters are built from the ground up and barely change, while others are force to churn through large chunks of players to stay competitive), and set these games as closed to the participants so there'd be no excuses for the Basic AI cruising that some teams like to go with in their scrimmages.


An alternative approach would be to schedule the post-season scrimmages outside of the league, where the concept would be the same, and could provide a better gauge of the top teams in a conference, since you could limit the SoS to just seeing how the playoff teams fared against one another. The drawback to this approach would be if the 1 seed bows out in the first round, they could tank their scrimmages on purpose to try and force their conference to remain intact (outside of the eventual conference winner) for another run the following season.

On the flip side, the disadvantage to using the pre-season is that it's the pre-season... the AI hasn't be tweaked to complement the Depth Chart, and coordinators often like to do testing in the pre-season to test out the changes of gameplay in the new season's sim. But the advantage would be that no team is a lock for the conference crown, so they'd each have an equal stake in trying to win their scrimmages in hopes of a promotion.
Edited by adamantenigma on Jul 14, 2010 21:09:43
 
Link
 
Originally posted by adamantenigma
A Strength of Schedule ranking system would be a lot more powerful of a tool if the pre-season scrimmages could be scheduled outside of the league, imo. This would set up a round-robin environment where you could determine the true strength of a league's teams (more specifically, a conference, for purposes of promotion) by testing them against random competition from the other leagues in the same tier.

Most teams with AAA playoff aspirations will have their rosters set by season rollover, so the "haves" would already be established squads that are ready to roll by the time the schedules are put up, and be ready to represent for their league. You'd need to disable the chemistry impact during these scrimmages to level the playing field (since some rosters are built from the ground up and barely change, while others are force to churn through large chunks of players to stay competitive), and set these games as closed to the participants so there'd be no excuses for the Basic AI cruising that some teams like to go with in their scrimmages.


An alternative approach would be to schedule the post-season scrimmages outside of the league, where the concept would be the same, and could provide a better gauge of the top teams in a conference, since you could limit the SoS to just seeing how the playoff teams fared against one another. The drawback to this approach would be if the 1 seed bows out in the first round, they could tank their scrimmages on purpose to try and force their conference to remain intact (outside of the eventual conference winner) for another run the following season.

On the flip side, the disadvantage to using the pre-season is that it's the pre-season... the AI hasn't be tweaked to complement the Depth Chart, and coordinators often like to do testing in the pre-season to test out the changes of gameplay in the new season's sim. But the advantage would be that no team is a lock for the conference crown, so they'd each have an equal stake in trying to win their scrimmages in hopes of a promotion.


I highlighted the part I really really like.....


That gives an extra 4 games already.......I think Bort should be able to do this.....
 
aerophil
offline
Link
 
Beachsand is worried because although he's got an awesome team, he just had not only 4 of the teams that finished ahead of him last season but also a bunch of really good teams from the opposite side of the league all get squashed into one conference leaving them 14th overall in rating in the conference. Effective level underrates them but he may still end up a 7 or 8 seed (again) without the benefit of a home promo in the playoffs leading to a quick exit and no chance of going Pro whereas his team has the talent to get to the championship game if they'd been placed in the other conference in our own league.
Edited by aerophil on Jul 14, 2010 22:17:09
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.