User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
CBs still perform "Runnaway Corner" perfectly:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10446621
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10449941
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10450287

... and FS walking the line is still a favorite when it comes to defending the endzone:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10446658
(combined with not recognizing the goalline)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10450567

But there's something new to introduce too!

Free TE!
Now, we all know that TE'll touchdown will leave the TE uncovered when it comes to defend the endzone. But there's another great play the TEs need. Idea is to cover the TE by the LOLB and just let him go when he is about 5-7 yards deep (that's right when the pass is most likely to be thrown...). Now that'll be o.k. - if the SS would take over in this very moment. But GLB lets the SS stay back so far before - so there's no way he'll catch up.
(Of course, the LOLB has noone to cover and letting the TE go just leaves him in the middle of the field as a spectator.)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10446900


... and watch that perfect play by my FS:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10450038

(double cover that already well covered WR - that is NOT going into the endzone - instead of helping out the already beaten CB - great decision by the SIM)
((before the "add vision" posts come: vision is 40+ and SV is 5))
 
Dimes
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10448525

I realize it's a zone, but if that's the case then why does one CB always cover his guy in the zone while the other one runs to a spot first oblivious of anyone who comes into the zone, leaving the WR wide open?

Or if that's how zone coverage works in the game, then why doesn't every defender run to a spot first? It's always just one CB, never both. Ive seen it happen with every CB we've played against and every CB on my team, i'd find it pretty hard to believe that it's a build issue.

It looks like the left side is playing prevent and everyone else is playing man-to-man. Just lookin for some consistency or a way to burn this page of the playbook
 
Dimes
offline
Link
 
I guess maybe I should be a little more clear, my question is...why does every other defender cover a receiver who is in their zone except for one CB?

And if the receiver that is 5 yards (or less) away from the CB is not in the CB's zone, then what exactly is the CB's zone on that play?
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dimes
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10448525

I realize it's a zone, but if that's the case then why does one CB always cover his guy in the zone while the other one runs to a spot first oblivious of anyone who comes into the zone, leaving the WR wide open?

Or if that's how zone coverage works in the game, then why doesn't every defender run to a spot first? It's always just one CB, never both. Ive seen it happen with every CB we've played against and every CB on my team, i'd find it pretty hard to believe that it's a build issue.

It looks like the left side is playing prevent and everyone else is playing man-to-man. Just lookin for some consistency or a way to burn this page of the playbook


We had some discussion about Runaway Corner here. It clearly shows i.m.h.o., that the path is coded wrong. Playing zone that way makes no sense at all, for the CB is not able to defend any guy - neither the WR that is already attacking his zone nor the HB that might go on a shorter outside route.

(Just keep bringing that play up, for it might increase the chance that we are recognized by Bort.)

To add further: it occures to me, that play is called even more if you play "medium pass" and "man coverage". Can anyone confirm this?

(i.e.: if that happens in the beginning of first quarter and you set to all short or all long or any combination of both, then it sure isn't a medium pass play)
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Another Waterbreak

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10463252

(from http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=567115 )
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10273973 - another stupid zonal formation. Not strictly a "Secondary" issue, but still related to the Runaway Corner problem.

Now we've had this crop up a few times, this is the first time for the TD (I think). Each man heads to their "zone" before then attempting to read the play...and the secondary still makes no move as they hang around the back of the endzone even though it's an obvious run after about 2 seconds.
 
Spoken Jr
offline
Link
 
Please explain this one: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10482869
Sometimes he runs out of bounds for no apparent reason also. It makes no sense to me.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jc2605
Please explain this one: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10482869
Sometimes he runs out of bounds for no apparent reason also. It makes no sense to me.


What exactly do you think is going wrong?

Looks just like a regular coverage, but the CB can't hold onto his man (fake? less agility?). Afterwards the CB misses agility (so he can't keep speed and make the turn) or he is faked/juked out by the WR (the SS had some problems too).
 
ironman4579
offline
Link
 
I think part of the problem is, some people are posting any play here in which their CB gets beat in some way. Many of these are not actual "buggy" plays like the extremely brutal runaway corner etc. Just because your player got beat, doesn't mean there's something wrong. Let's try to keep this to the actual stupid plays that RAPB has done a wonderful job of sorting for us. If people just keep posting plays that their player got beat on, Bort will never take the real coverage issues seriously.

 
DaRealest
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10397555
 
Spoken Jr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ironman4579
I think part of the problem is, some people are posting any play here in which their CB gets beat in some way. Many of these are not actual "buggy" plays like the extremely brutal runaway corner etc. Just because your player got beat, doesn't mean there's something wrong. Let's try to keep this to the actual stupid plays that RAPB has done a wonderful job of sorting for us. If people just keep posting plays that their player got beat on, Bort will never take the real coverage issues seriously.



If the CB consistently got beat, I'd agree and say it's a problem with the CB. My CB consistently performs very well. It's just one play per game where everything goes buggy and sometimes that one buggy play comes at a crucial moment. Luckily, this last time, it had no real ill effect on the outcome of the game. If multiple people are having the same problem or similar problems, then either none of us know what we are doing or there is a problem with the game. Considering the mods tend to pick players apart and attribute most "bugs" to poor builds or improper tactics, then multiple instances of the same bug might give the mods an idea that something needs to be said or done to correct the issue for the mass of players.
 
Spoken Jr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by jc2605

Please explain this one: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10482869
Sometimes he runs out of bounds for no apparent reason also. It makes no sense to me.


What exactly do you think is going wrong?

Looks just like a regular coverage, but the CB can't hold onto his man (fake? less agility?). Afterwards the CB misses agility (so he can't keep speed and make the turn) or he is faked/juked out by the WR (the SS had some problems too).


I appreciate the answer but it's not agility. As I stated above, things like this only happen once per game so it's very dificult to pinpoint it to a single attribute. I wonder if low confidence can cause things like this to happen. What if his in game morale was low for that one play? Even though the morale bar stays full, my CB has low confidence and I know, recently found out, that morale is constantly going up and down throughout the game.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaRealest
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10397555


Poor agility on a Safety causing overshoot.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by DaRealest

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10397555


Poor agility on a Safety causing overshoot.


+1 - and you might add a head fake by the HB.

Overshots are quite common for FS/SS, for they usually need to head full speed towards the runner. Agility/SA Change Direction makes them turn in time to adjust at the very last moment and maybe high vision will finally have them slow down before it's too late.

I consider a safety to be "smart" if he is aware of the time and way he needs to slow down (because of insufficient agility) just in time to make a tackle ("breakdown" on open field tackles). But unfortunately, there are very few safeties with 60+ vision. At least, my FS has not yet.

b.t.w.: It is NOT buggy to leave the HB open in the first place. It is a heavy blitzing play (all 3 LBs), so the idea is to bring the QB down before he is able to throw. Naturally, a quick pass to a RB is the answer to that play.


Originally posted by Koncorde
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10273973 - another stupid zonal formation. Not strictly a "Secondary" issue, but still related to the Runaway Corner problem.

Now we've had this crop up a few times, this is the first time for the TD (I think). Each man heads to their "zone" before then attempting to read the play...and the secondary still makes no move as they hang around the back of the endzone even though it's an obvious run after about 2 seconds.


Looks like a short or medium distance pass defense to me. Seems like de the LDE is supposed to cover the strongside WR on a short route, so like LDE and all LBs playing 4 zones under and the strongside CB + both safeties playing a cover 3 for the deeper pass coverage.

Of course, that is a worse call when it comes to defending the goalline. If the CB plays deep and the LDE is supposed to cover the short zone, you'll give up 6-7 yards on outside routes for sure (no way the LDE can catch up on a quick out that fast).

Afterwards it's just a problem of the SIM not recognizing the goalline. No less than 6 defenders (SS, FS, all LBs and weakside CB) are heading for a tackle midway the endzone. strongside CB joins in later.

On the other hand, the TE plays worse. Just stands there and waits at first! Since he should know the rush is at his side, he should head for the DE first (just to make sure he can't turn in time) and then try to block the LOLB (he does, but way to late).

Can you actually post more of these plays?

Maybe we find out if there is a serious bug besides the "build in" problem of quick outs and how this play is supposed to work. I disagree that it is wrong to head towards your zone with moderate speed while the play is still not read yet. If the LBs just watch, they'll never be in position to defend quick in-routes if it's pass (and that'll be "wrong" for it's a pass defense).

Of course, that's only "right" for playing inside zones that are not attacked yet. On outside zones, there is no reason to head more towards the outside than anyone attacking the zone does (same on deep zones... if noone is as deep yet then noone can attack the zone that deep - so why would a defender be where he is not needed for sure?).

The problem might be, that the SIM has been coded like:

- first run to the spot that's designed to be the best position for zone
- watch if there is someone attacking your zone
- then decide to play that attacker

I.m.h.o. that first step is wrong.
Last edited Jul 12, 2008 05:54:16
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
I'll try and find those earlier in the season. Most of the time though we've just written it off as being a poor call at a bad time (to give up short yardage, in exchange for deep cover - most often down in their end, or close to FG range) but on a goalline stand I think it's even more dangerous.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.