User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Iamoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blakecomer
but i mean... does the record not prove my point... even if there were non-existent teams? that top to bottom zeta is better than alpha?


No... it doesn't. For at least two reasons:

1- It's preseason, and no one game plans.(although the 100 point difference in the Bern game seems odd)
2- The top teams in Zeta didn't necessarily play the top teams in Alpha. That is yet to be seen.
couple more pre-season games and we'll have a better idea.

But again - NO GAMEPLANNING can have wins and losses that shouldn't happen. If you don't know by now that the pre-season in dot ball means nothing, than I can't help you.


Also -
Not sure how you think it proved your point, because... when we throw out those 3 non entity teams, it was only 7-6.. This does not prove a top to bottom comparison.

Believe what you want, it's all good... but I stand by that the Championship will come from Alpha.
Edited by Iamoop on May 26, 2010 18:44:52
 
Pernbronze
offline
Link
 
The devils threw the offensive side just to test the defense, if we had tried offensively things probably would have been different.
 
Iamoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pernbronze
The devils threw the offensive side just to test the defense, if we had tried offensively things probably would have been different.


see? exactly. Pre-season means nothing.
 
stevie2442
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iamoop
Originally posted by Pernbronze

The devils threw the offensive side just to test the defense, if we had tried offensively things probably would have been different.


see? exactly. Pre-season means nothing.


Yup..every at least halfway decent owner/GM knows that pre-season means shit...WSB has lost at least 2 preseason games/season in the last 2 years, yet they have won 40 straight regular season/playoff games, and the last 2 championships.
 
Kayrod
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/compare_teams.pl?team1=4439&team2=4178

This should be a decent barometer, even though the scrim is just for fun.
 
Iamoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kayrod
http://goallineblitz.com/game/compare_teams.pl?team1=4439&team2=4178

This should be a decent barometer, even though the scrim is just for fun.


eh... with neither team gameplanning the results will be suspect... but it should show something....

also we'll be scrimming them tomorrow... which should also show something, but again.. no gameplanning...

(um... i think I sound like a broken record).
 
Kayrod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iamoop
eh... with neither team gameplanning the results will be suspect... but it should show something....

also we'll be scrimming them tomorrow... which should also show something, but again.. no gameplanning...

(um... i think I sound like a broken record).


They look like they improved on last year. D-line is a lot tougher than last year. First time we've lost to them in 3 for fun scrims.

My DC has gone MIA for about a week now. Might need to find a new one.
 
bj21
offline
Link
 
In close games, I would agree that preseason games mean nothing. In lopsided victories, unless the loser was trying their punter at QB and OT's at WR, I think the scores are telling in that no amount of game planning is going to correct a 60+ point loss.

The one thing we won't know until the season is in full swing is just how good a good team in a weaker division is. Sometimes, you don't know until the playoffs.

So sure, preseason doesn't mean a lot but it also isn't completely meaningless.
 
Iamoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bj21
In close games, I would agree that preseason games mean nothing. In lopsided victories, unless the loser was trying their punter at QB and OT's at WR, I think the scores are telling in that no amount of game planning is going to correct a 60+ point loss.

The one thing we won't know until the season is in full swing is just how good a good team in a weaker division is. Sometimes, you don't know until the playoffs.

So sure, preseason doesn't mean a lot but it also isn't completely meaningless.


I'll agree, and that's why the Bern loss by 100 seems so strange.... it's possible they were trying something new, but that big a loss indicates something else.

I've also noticed that the Overall rating isn't necc a good indicator of a team....

I've seen Overall 51's lose to 48's and 48's beat 54's..... it's a strange strange game...

but I like it and win or lose, I still enjoy owning a team. (although.. i like winning better)
 
blakecomer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iamoop
1- It's preseason, and no one game plans.(although the 100 point difference in the Bern game seems odd)


no game planning shows what team is straight up better. not who has the best AI. i realize that plays in. but when it comes down to man on man. i'm taking zeta.

you'll see.
 
Iamoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blakecomer
no game planning shows what team is straight up better. not who has the best AI. i realize that plays in. but when it comes down to man on man. i'm taking zeta.

you'll see.


actually... I disagree even on that. Because the playbooks that are used may not relate to anything at all on the team.

(Because, really, who removes the play book for pre season?)

So, the only way it could be considered straight up would be if both teams chose the default AI..... which neither is doing.

So, most likely, there is a gameplan in place for a specific team, but that team is not the one you are playing. It skews the results dramatically.

And without a gameplan, then the players are not necc in the position they should be.

I said you can have your opinion. And you are welcome to it. But so far your arguments for it are all circumstantial, and when the flaws in your logic are pointed out, you try to defend it anyway.

again a 7-6 split doesn't tell me that top teams in ZETA are better than top teams in Alpha... It says they are pretty equal so far.

(btw, I'm not taking any of this personally, I know I come off dry and snooty and obnoxious online... - well.. in fairness I am dry and snooty and obnoxious.... but I'm just enjoying the conversation, really... not trying to fight)
 
stevie2442
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iamoop
Originally posted by blakecomer

no game planning shows what team is straight up better. not who has the best AI. i realize that plays in. but when it comes down to man on man. i'm taking zeta.

you'll see.


actually... I disagree even on that. Because the playbooks that are used may not relate to anything at all on the team.

(Because, really, who removes the play book for pre season?)

So, the only way it could be considered straight up would be if both teams chose the default AI..... which neither is doing.

So, most likely, there is a gameplan in place for a specific team, but that team is not the one you are playing. It skews the results dramatically.

And without a gameplan, then the players are not necc in the position they should be.

I said you can have your opinion. And you are welcome to it. But so far your arguments for it are all circumstantial, and when the flaws in your logic are pointed out, you try to defend it anyway.

again a 7-6 split doesn't tell me that top teams in ZETA are better than top teams in Alpha... It says they are pretty equal so far.

(btw, I'm not taking any of this personally, I know I come off dry and snooty and obnoxious online... - well.. in fairness I am dry and snooty and obnoxious.... but I'm just enjoying the conversation, really... not trying to fight)


That may be, but it's correct...your opinion that is...we purposely threw the offensive gameplan out the window to work on our defense, and to see how they would do.
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Kevin Bacon > Zeta

The end.
 
Jonfus42
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bj21
In close games, I would agree that preseason games mean nothing. In lopsided victories, unless the loser was trying their punter at QB and OT's at WR, I think the scores are telling in that no amount of game planning is going to correct a 60+ point loss.

The one thing we won't know until the season is in full swing is just how good a good team in a weaker division is. Sometimes, you don't know until the playoffs.

So sure, preseason doesn't mean a lot but it also isn't completely meaningless.


Not 100% true. Another team I lolGM for lost to a team 65-3 in preseason and beat them in the title game 16-7.

 
bj21
offline
Link
 
Well then I guess I am proven wrong. I've never seen it happen to or against any of my teams. :shrug:
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.