User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Tackling: The most useless attribute?
Page:
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
You linked my DT that is the base for all pass rushing DT's right now.

His main role is to get sacks, not make tackles.

Nice try though.


Break it down now.
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Originally posted by jaxinthebox

You didn't prove shit, but for the sake of argument, let's say every player needed 100 strength to tackle a 120 strength RB. That would make the sim more unrealistic than it already is. I'm certain Merton Hanks could tackle Christain Okoye 4 out of 5 Times in a head to head battle if Merton had good vision and tackling.


You only need 60 str and DvG to tackle that hb.


My FS is a coverage FS and hasn't comitted to run stopping or pass coverage. He invested his VAs in Vision. Should I have to use DvG to tackle Okoye?

BTW, I can provide links if needed, but there are games I have DC'd where my FSs are missing 5-8 tackles/game just because they lack strength and DvG. As an agent building a safety, I shouldn't have to choose DvG if I know what play is coming. Vision ( Studying game film) would give me a HUGE advantage IRL.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Wrong again. But good try. For SOME positions it's true...

See if you can dig up the % of CB's that carry DVG, Make Tackle %, Sure Tackler, Textbook Tackler... Now find how many HB's use some stack of break tackle VA's...

CB's can still tackle pretty much just as well as most DT's even though every LOGICAL major factor that should impact a tackle (size, strength, TACKLING) are MASSIVELY in favor of DT's...


So let's say that it's true that tackling plays the biggest role in the equation, but that there are many factors. I'll just throw some random numbers out there: 35 % tackling, 25% strength, 10% size, 20% agility, 10% vision. That gets your base score. Add on top of that the bonus from SAs. Next add the bonus from VAs, AEQ, and tackle style. Adjust by morale, stamina, position, relative speed, whether the dot is fighting off a block, and the RNG.

So even though tackling might play a very large portion (the largest) of the base roll, there are so many other factors that go into play, two of the most important for this discussion being the relative positions of the players and whether the dot is fighting off of a block, that by the time it goes through all of the calculations, tackling doesn't play a huge part in whether your dot makes a tackle.

Here's just a list of factors you are neglecting to take into account:

1. The relative positions of the dots when a defensive dot makes an attempt at the tackle matters. A CB or LB tackling an HB head-on is different than a DT trying to tackle an HB who is running away.

2. DTs are usually trying to make tackles while attempting to break a block or being partially blocked by an olinemen. This makes tackling much harder.

3. Even though tackling might be the most important attribute in the base score, there are so many factors that play into the tackle roll that its importance becomes diluted.

4. Confidence and, more importantly, stamina matter in the tackle roll. A DT who has been fighting off an olineman is going to be more tired than a CB who just had to run around an 8 blocking, 50 strength WR. I think it also stands to reason that heavier players lose in-game energy faster than smaller players. This would have a huge effect on DTs trying to make a tackle on an HB.
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jaxinthebox
My FS is a coverage FS and hasn't comitted to run stopping or pass coverage. He invested his VAs in Vision. Should I have to use DvG to tackle Okoye?

BTW, I can provide links if needed, but there are games I have DC'd where my FSs are missing 5-8 tackles/game just because they lack strength and DvG. As an agent building a safety, I shouldn't have to choose DvG if I know what play is coming. Vision ( Studying game film) would give me a HUGE advantage IRL.


Yeah, but the flaw here is this is GLB and you need VA's to counter VA's. Is it the correct way to do things? nope, but that the system we got.
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024

So let's say that it's true that tackling plays the biggest role in the equation, but that there are many factors. I'll just throw some random numbers out there: 35 % tackling, 25% strength, 10% size, 20% agility, 10% vision. That gets your base score. Add on top of that the bonus from SAs. Next add the bonus from VAs, AEQ, and tackle style. Adjust by morale, stamina, position, relative speed, whether the dot is fighting off a block, and the RNG.

So even though tackling might play a very large portion (the largest) of the base roll, there are so many other factors that go into play, two of the most important for this discussion being the relative positions of the players and whether the dot is fighting off of a block, that by the time it goes through all of the calculations, tackling doesn't play a huge part in whether your dot makes a tackle.

Here's just a list of factors you are neglecting to take into account:

1. The relative positions of the dots when a defensive dot makes an attempt at the tackle matters. A CB or LB tackling an HB head-on is different than a DT trying to tackle an HB who is running away.

2. DTs are usually trying to make tackles while attempting to break a block or being partially blocked by an olinemen. This makes tackling much harder.

3. Even though tackling might be the most important attribute in the base score, there are so many factors that play into the tackle roll that its importance becomes diluted.

4. Confidence and, more importantly, stamina matter in the tackle roll. A DT who has been fighting off an olineman is going to be more tired than a CB who just had to run around an 8 blocking, 50 strength WR. I think it also stands to reason that heavier players lose in-game energy faster than smaller players. This would have a huge effect on DTs trying to make a tackle on an HB.


Great post, but you forgot VISION. When I played football I had a huge advantage because I would watch game film. Vision (or vision and confidence) needs much more influence on the quality of play from any player imo...
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Nope but you need str to get the punt further then 30 yards.

VA's have changed the game. You need VA's to break tackles and make tackles.





Originally posted by jktooley


See if you can dig up the % of CB's that carry DVG, Make Tackle %, Sure Tackler, Textbook Tackler... Now find how many HB's use some stack of break tackle VA's...

CB's can still tackle pretty much just as well as most DT's even though every LOGICAL major factor that should impact a tackle (size, strength, TACKLING) are MASSIVELY in favor of DT's...


My point here... Because you obviously missed it... Is CB's don't HAVE anything working in their favor logically that should aid in making a tackle. No CB's are rocking DVG... They're all weak, lite, small... Yet the pretty much tackle as successfully as most DT's...

Can you please follow along now? Not sure if you got sidetracked by other posters here or what.


Originally posted by Meatdawg
I proved that "if you know how to build" you can make tackles.

Sorry if it was over your head.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=921670 Yes... I envy your GLB building acumen...


Originally posted by Deathblade
Break it down now.


Oh look! DYNOSAHRRRRR

Originally posted by Meatdawg
Yeah, but the flaw here is this is GLB and you need VA's to counter VA's. Is it the correct way to do things? nope, but that the system we got.


Oh look... While I was creating massive post, more proof that you were missing the original point....
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Originally posted by jaxinthebox

My FS is a coverage FS and hasn't comitted to run stopping or pass coverage. He invested his VAs in Vision. Should I have to use DvG to tackle Okoye?

BTW, I can provide links if needed, but there are games I have DC'd where my FSs are missing 5-8 tackles/game just because they lack strength and DvG. As an agent building a safety, I shouldn't have to choose DvG if I know what play is coming. Vision ( Studying game film) would give me a HUGE advantage IRL.


Yeah, but the flaw here is this is GLB and you need VA's to counter VA's. Is it the correct way to do things? nope, but that the system we got.


So if my FS has superior vision to the HB and knows what play is coming that's a disadvantage?
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
So let's say that it's true that tackling plays the biggest role in the equation, but that there are many factors. I'll just throw some random numbers out there: 35 % tackling, 25% strength, 10% size, 20% agility, 10% vision. That gets your base score. Add on top of that the bonus from SAs. Next add the bonus from VAs, AEQ, and tackle style. Adjust by morale, stamina, position, relative speed, whether the dot is fighting off a block, and the RNG.

So even though tackling might play a very large portion (the largest) of the base roll, there are so many other factors that go into play, two of the most important for this discussion being the relative positions of the players and whether the dot is fighting off of a block, that by the time it goes through all of the calculations, tackling doesn't play a huge part in whether your dot makes a tackle.

Here's just a list of factors you are neglecting to take into account:

1. The relative positions of the dots when a defensive dot makes an attempt at the tackle matters. A CB or LB tackling an HB head-on is different than a DT trying to tackle an HB who is running away.

2. DTs are usually trying to make tackles while attempting to break a block or being partially blocked by an olinemen. This makes tackling much harder.

3. Even though tackling might be the most important attribute in the base score, there are so many factors that play into the tackle roll that its importance becomes diluted.

4. Confidence and, more importantly, stamina matter in the tackle roll. A DT who has been fighting off an olineman is going to be more tired than a CB who just had to run around an 8 blocking, 50 strength WR. I think it also stands to reason that heavier players lose in-game energy faster than smaller players. This would have a huge effect on DTs trying to make a tackle on an HB.




I understand a TON of what you're saying... And I realize that's what's going on... But the fact that it has THAT much of an impact is pretty freaking goofy... And to further compound it is the fact that you can actually have VERY little in the attribute, and still perform it successfully...


But the blocking example doesn't work... I've seen MULTIPLE CB's being blocked by WR's, and the second the HB passes the WR on an outside rush he's tackled by the engaged CB...
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
So a DT thread about high tackling and missing tackles is now a cb thread about tackling?

CB's already have a few major things in there favor.

-High vision
-High agl
-Super Vision
-NOT HAVING TO MAKE TACKLES BEHIND THE LIND OF SCRIMMAGE
-most of the time, bruiser isnt active.

Remove the stacks, you get easier to tackle.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley


I understand a TON of what you're saying... And I realize that's what's going on... But the fact that it has THAT much of an impact is pretty freaking goofy... And to further compound it is the fact that you can actually have VERY little in the attribute, and still perform it successfully...


But the blocking example doesn't work... I've seen MULTIPLE CB's being blocked by WR's, and the second the HB passes the WR on an outside rush he's tackled by the engaged CB...


And how many WRs do you know that have 140+ strength and 100+ blocking? The more I think of it, the more I really think the single biggest factor in DTs missing so many tackles is that they are attempting most of those tackles while being blocked or having just fought off a block. That and the stamina and morale drain that DTs likely suffer in attempting the break block roll repeatedly must give a pretty huge penalty to tackling attempts. And of course they are more likely to be facing an HB with Bruiser and SYM both triggered.
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
[



I understand a TON of what you're saying... And I realize that's what's going on... But the fact that it has THAT much of an impact is pretty freaking goofy... And to further compound it is the fact that you can actually have VERY little in the attribute, and still perform it successfully...


But the blocking example doesn't work... I've seen MULTIPLE CB's being blocked by WR's, and the second the HB passes the WR on an outside rush he's tackled by the engaged CB...


None of that matters because a DB that has studied game film and knows what play is headed his way can dive at a RB and tackle him before he gets going.
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Break it down now.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ta-ATEOOo8M
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
So a DT thread about high tackling and missing tackles is now a cb thread about tackling?

CB's already have a few major things in there favor.

-High vision
-High agl
-Super Vision
-NOT HAVING TO MAKE TACKLES BEHIND THE LIND OF SCRIMMAGE
-most of the time, bruiser isnt active.

Remove the stacks, you get easier to tackle.


Not my fault that you didn't take the time to fully read my response to your post about VA's needing counter VA's to be overcome before you went full-out on the offensive...
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jaxinthebox

Great post, but you forgot VISION. When I played football I had a huge advantage because I would watch game film. Vision (or vision and confidence) needs much more influence on the quality of play from any player imo...


Vision is already one of the better attributes in the game.
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Not my fault that you didn't take the time to fully read my response to your post about VA's needing counter VA's to be overcome before you went full-out on the offensive...


Lets talk about punting now.

And trying to prove a point about DT's and LB'ers with CB's already means you lost perspective.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.