User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Politics and Religion > "I love you Grandma." "I love you too. Let's $%!#."
Page:
 
FredEx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003
Define "totally cool." Would I do it? Absolutely not. I find it morally reprehensible. Do i think other should be forbidden from doing it? Absolutely not. To each their own. how people can be pro gay and yet be anti incest is mind numbing.


people will rip you for this post but you make a good point
 
Blomtastic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DoomsdaySoDope
Care to explain how you came to this conclusion?


Incest is a felony crime in most places. It involves real harm to people (its a form of abuse) and is very often leaves permanent psychological damage. Its also a conscious act to be intimate with a relative.

Homosexuality is something you are born with, and is simply a different sexual orientation. Its innate.

To compare a homosexual with someone who practices incest is illogical and borderline hate speech. That's fucked up.
 
Venkman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blomtastic
Incest is a felony crime in most places. It involves real harm to people (its a form of abuse) and is very often leaves permanent psychological damage. Its also a conscious act to be intimate with a relative.

Homosexuality is something you are born with, and is simply a different sexual orientation. Its innate.

To compare a homosexual with someone who practices incest is illogical and borderline hate speech. That's fucked up.


to be fair, your conflating consensual, both people of the age of consent, incest (which this apparently is), with a father having sex with his underage daughter...very different scenarios.

ed: I'm sure that pkr will correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm quite sure the incest he's talking about is (for example) a brother and sister who are 20 years old, consensually decide to marry and have kids. he is not talking about the scenario of a father going into his 15 year old daughters bedroom, convincing her that she loves him and they should have sex.
not saying I agree with him, but I think this is more what he was trying to say, that the first situation is acceptable if it fits with their moral values, while the second situation is always going to be wrong.
Edited by seths99 on Apr 29, 2010 12:59:05
 
icebergin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NObodyn0se
Why is everyone assuming these two are in New Zealand? Because it's a NZ website?

The only location mentioned in the article is Indiana.


Damn it.
 
FredEx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blomtastic
Incest is a felony crime in most places.

irrelevant

Originally posted by Blomtastic
It involves real harm to people (its a form of abuse) and is very often leaves permanent psychological damage.

in some cases, just like any form of relationship.

If we were to outlaw relationships based on likelihood to cause psychological damage, then you just opened the floodgates my friend...

Originally posted by Blomtastic
Its also a conscious act to be intimate with a relative.

Homosexuality is something you are born with, and is simply a different sexual orientation. Its innate.

You can't be born with innate desires which lead you to one day love a mate who happens to be related to you? please, when people have a God complex regarding nature/nurture they tend to look like idiots.

Originally posted by Blomtastic
To compare a homosexual with someone who practices incest is illogical and borderline hate speech. That's fucked up.

this would only be true if pkrplyr were taking an anti-incest stance, but he wasn't.
Edited by FredEx on Apr 29, 2010 12:57:18
 
Blomtastic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seths99
to be fair, your conflating consensual, both people of the age of consent, incest (which this apparently is), with a father having sex with his underage daughter...very different scenarios.


To be fair, my response is to the statement "how people can be pro gay and yet be anti incest is mind numbing. " There was no qualification given to the type of incest. The wording is pretty explicit that someone who is against incest should also be against homosexuality, which I find to be quite offensive.
 
Venkman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blomtastic
To be fair, my response is to the statement "how people can be pro gay and yet be anti incest is mind numbing. " There was no qualification given to the type of incest. The wording is pretty explicit that someone who is against incest should also be against homosexuality, which I find to be quite offensive.


see my edit. i'd agree with you if it wasn't for the fact that i interpreted what he said a little differently by reading into it a little bit.
Edited by seths99 on Apr 29, 2010 13:00:30
 
pkrplyr2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blomtastic
Originally posted by DoomsdaySoDope

Care to explain how you came to this conclusion?


Incest is a felony crime in most places. It involves real harm to people (its a form of abuse) and is very often leaves permanent psychological damage. Its also a conscious act to be intimate with a relative.

Homosexuality is something you are born with, and is simply a different sexual orientation. Its innate.

To compare a homosexual with someone who practices incest is illogical and borderline hate speech. That's fucked up.


Wow. You use the same logic as the people who hate homosexuality.
 
Blomtastic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003
Wow. You use the same logic as the people who hate homosexuality.


I can't hear you over the sound of you bangin' your sister.
 
icebergin
offline
Link
 
I am pro-homosexual and anti-incest for one reason:

Pissing in the gene pool.

I also support eugenics and child-birth being a right (not a privilege), though. So, take that for what it's worth.

I see Idiocracy as being a movie about our actual future.
 
Sapper06
offline
Link
 
I tend to agree with the gay/incest comparison.
Unless you can prove people are NOT born that way, then the comparison has to stand.

Plus, if God didnt want that boy to screw his grand-mama, he wouldnt be screwing her.
 
pkrplyr2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blomtastic
Originally posted by seths99

to be fair, your conflating consensual, both people of the age of consent, incest (which this apparently is), with a father having sex with his underage daughter...very different scenarios.


To be fair, my response is to the statement "how people can be pro gay and yet be anti incest is mind numbing. " There was no qualification given to the type of incest. The wording is pretty explicit that someone who is against incest should also be against homosexuality, which I find to be quite offensive.


What is this whole thread about? holy shit. maybe when people start talking about homosexuality, I should scream "BUT WHAT IF HE IS ONLY 15 YEARS OLD!!!!!! YOU ARE DISGUSTING SUGGESTING THAT 15 YEAR OLDS MARRY GROWN MEN." Seriously, pay attention and don't make leaps that don't exist.

 
FredEx
offline
Link
 
it's not as simple as "born that way or not born that way" - people are (probably) born with certain predispositions, ergo, let them do what they want with their own lives.
 
pkrplyr2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blomtastic
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003

Wow. You use the same logic as the people who hate homosexuality.


I can't hear you over the sound of you bangin' your sister.


So by your logic, are you saying that people who support homosexual relationships are gay? I don't believe that to be true but if you have a link supporting that, I would love to read it.
 
pkrplyr2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FredEx
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003

Define "totally cool." Would I do it? Absolutely not. I find it morally reprehensible. Do i think other should be forbidden from doing it? Absolutely not. To each their own. how people can be pro gay and yet be anti incest is mind numbing.


people will rip you for this post but you make a good point


It appears you are correct. I would also throw polygamy into this but that may be too much at one time.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.