User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Make weight not such a gigantic factor in realized speed
Page:
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1010199&pbp_id=2411133
 
jsid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1010199&pbp_id=2411133


whats really interesting here the difference between the max and min TE, and more broadly the difference between the left and right sides of the coverage team. It looks like the left side (right side in the reply's perspective) moves slower.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
You can use this one too since all the relevant players only played two plays in this game and had over half the game to rest: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1010199&pbp_id=2420782

One thing that sticks out immediately is that the speed script can't get granular enough to give exact results like we want. There's a big difference between a 15 that looks like ---------------- and a 15 that looks like _______/\______/\___; the latter is significantly slower.

It looks like it's more than 5% in most cases.
 
xcoach2
offline
Link
 
agree w op.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
It looks like it's more than 5% in most cases.


Looks like the speed script isn't accurate...

Reviewing the pbp 1 tick at a time, the minimum weight CB and SS both gain something like a 1/2 yard of field position from the 20 to the 45, vs their maximum weight counterparts. So it looks like the benefit is roughly 2% distance (~2 extra yards over 100 yards traveled). 25 yards (the distance traveled) times 4 = 100 yards, 0.5 yards times 4 = 2 yards, 2 of 100 = 2%.

So I guess my 2% number was pretty much spot on.
Edited by Warlock on Feb 5, 2010 19:33:01
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by w_alloy

It looks like it's more than 5% in most cases.


Looks like the speed script isn't accurate...

Reviewing the pbp 1 tick at a time, the minimum weight CB and SS both gain something like a 1/2 yard of field position from the 20 to the 45, vs their maximum weight counterparts. So it looks like the benefit is roughly 2% distance (~2 extra yards over 100 yards traveled). 25 yards (the distance traveled) times 4 = 100 yards, 0.5 yards times 4 = 2 yards, 2 of 100 = 2%.


You have to measure it from the 30 for the left side and from the 27 from the right... pause the replay right as the ball is kicked. Factor that in, plus the fact your 1/2 yard figure is not totally accurate, and the fact that the DTs and OTs clearly demonstrate a much bigger difference than the CBs and SSs, and we are at over 5% on average.

I plan to do some more complete analysis when I have the time.
 
joesox
offline
Link
 
-1 I propose a clear formula to how weight affects attributes..all just not speed but all of them
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Alright, here is the second kick in some more detail. I penciled in the number of pixels each dot is ahead.

http://img205.imageshack.us/img205/7679/dotspeed.jpg

I counted 47 pixels for 5 yards, which doesn't seem to be exactly correct, but I don't feel like spending more time to figure out exactly what it is and it has to be close. So using 9.4 pixels per yard, starting from the 30 for the CB/SS and 27 for the DT/OT, we get...

CB 7 px difference = .74 yard difference over 28 yards = 2.7% difference
SS 9 px difference = .96 yard difference over 28 yards = 3.4% difference
OT 17 px difference = 1.81 yard difference over 24 yards = 7.5% difference
DT 30 px difference = 3.19 yard difference over 24 yards = 13.3% difference
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
You have to measure it from the 30 for the left side and from the 27 from the right... pause the replay right as the ball is kicked. Factor that in, plus the fact your 1/2 yard figure is not totally accurate, and the fact that the DTs and OTs clearly demonstrate a much bigger difference than the CBs and SSs, and we are at over 5% on average.

I plan to do some more complete analysis when I have the time.


Why? Looking at other replays with non-linear speed totals, shows that the dots do not travel at the same speed, from the 20 to the 27.

As for the rest... I would suggest that the players be swapped next game (minimum wt SS goes to maximum wt SS spot and vice versa), this way you have accurate controls in place and can compare/contrast.

There's nothing logical about these results TBPH, how is it that one position gets a much bigger benefit from being lighter than another position gets? So far FBs, CBs and SS are all ~2%... DT is at ~8%, TE is at ~20% and OT is at ~4%.

 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Final energy and morale:
Pos _ Ply _ Ene _ Mor _ Name
----------------------------------------------------
.OT ... ..2 ... .93 ... .35 ... MinWt OT
.OT ... ..2 ... .92 ... .35 ... MaxWt OT
.TE ... ..2 ... .92 ... .38 ... MinWt TE
.TE ... ..2 ... .93 ... .35 ... MaxWt TE
.CB ... ..2 ... .91 ... .37 ... MaxWt CB
.CB ... ..2 ... .94 ... .37 ... MinWt CB
.DT ... ..2 ... .95 ... .37 ... MaxWt DT
.DT ... ..2 ... .93 ... .37 ... MinWt DT
.SS ... ..2 ... .94 ... .37 ... MinWt SS
.SS ... ..2 ... .94 ... .38 ... MaxWT SS
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Here is the other kick with totals if anyone else wants to do the math, since it looks like they might not have been full energy/morale at the second play.

If you have trouble reading my scribbles the numbers are 2, 9, 11, 20. Note that they also didn't travel as far this time.

http://img709.imageshack.us/img709/6140/dotspeed2.jpg
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
% weight difference:
MaxWt CB is 12.2% heavier than MinWt CB
MaxWT SS is 13.1% heavier than MinWt SS
MaxWt TE is 20.9% heavier than MinWt TE
MaxWt OT is 18.5% heavier than MinWt OT
MaxWt DT is 25.9% heavier than MinWt DT
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock


Why? Looking at other replays with non-linear speed totals, shows that the dots do not travel at the same speed, from the 20 to the 27.


No clue what you could mean by this. Speed is obviously locked at a set value until the ball is kicked.

These results don't seem perfectly logical because there are a number of factors out of our control, like I have mentioned numerous times.

This is also why I didn't engage you on your example: claiming you know there is a 2% difference between those two FBs, with a speed script that isn't even that granular, on seperate seasons, with a shitload of other factors that we can't account for, is silly. You can say there is a 2% difference +/- 5%, that would make much more sense.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
looks like 10 or 10.5 pixels per yard, in photoshop with the ruler tool, to me. I also only count a 4 pixel difference between CBs, a 7 pixel difference between SS.... back of dot to back of dot that is.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
looks like 10 or 10.5 pixels per yard, in photoshop with the ruler tool, to me. I also only count a 4 pixel difference between CBs, a 7 pixel difference between SS.... back of dot to back of dot that is.


pics or it didn't happen
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.