User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
There's a massive difference between winning a division and winning a Superbowl or a Conference.

The Saints and Colts ARE teams to beat....why? Because they have established themselves as forces. They've shown themselves as consistently good teams. WHICH is why I said if the Bengals can have another good season, I'll start to believe that they've turned the franchise around.

You can fly your "we won the divison" banner all you want. To me and many others, it take more than one good season to show that you're a legit contender and a "team to beat".
If you believe teams are only as good as their last season, you feel free to run with that champ.

I've supported everything I've said, given you stats and facts but you cling to one year...just one season...to support your claim. IF you want to keep the blinders on, you go right ahead. It just really smacks of narrow mindedness.

How about I'll just tell you that the Bengals are super and I think they're a lock to win the division next year as you obviously don't take well to people disagreeing with you.

Hugs and kisses
Bish
 
LokiThunder
offline
Link
 
There's a massive difference between winning a division and winning a Superbowl or a Conference.

The Saints and Colts ARE teams to beat....why? Because they have established themselves as forces. They've shown themselves as consistently good teams. WHICH is why I said if the Bengals can have another good season, I'll start to believe that they've turned the franchise around.

You can fly your "we won the divison" banner all you want. To me and many others, it take more than one good season to show that you're a legit contender and a "team to beat".
If you believe teams are only as good as their last season, you feel free to run with that champ.

I've supported everything I've said, given you stats and facts but you cling to one year...just one season...to support your claim. IF you want to keep the blinders on, you go right ahead. It just really smacks of narrow mindedness.

How about I'll just tell you that the Bengals are super and I think they're a lock to win the division next year as you obviously don't take well to people disagreeing with you.

Hugs and kisses
Bish



No, you've made up many things, trying to put words in my mouth. You never showed why the Bengals aren't the team to beat in the North this year, since they swept the division and haven't gone backwards. You cannot accept simple knowledge and fact, instead relying on past trends, snapshots in history, and just hate on the Bengals.

You've posted no facts as to what team has improved s quickly and leapfrogged the Bengals as the team to beat. Instead going with the "scared of the Ravens and Steelers" routine. Why? point out fact, in the now, not the past. You've given nothing concrete, just shadow and smoke.


And the childish taunt at the end... All kinds of original...
Edited by LokiThunder on Feb 11, 2010 19:39:10
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
I haven;t made up jack! I've given fact and precident. If you choose to ignore it, thats your business.

If you want more, so be it....

The secret is out about Benson. Next year, teams will have more film and plan for him more. Given that Ocho Cinco is their only legit receiving threat, teams will stack the box.

Ocho Cinco is only getting older and the team lacks a true burner. Despite the fact Palmer is damn good, he needs more weapons to be consistently successful.

The Bengals were brought together by tragedy. Don;t underestimate the effect that playing for ZImmer after he lost his wife had on that defense. They were a group of overachievers last year...can they repeat it?

The Ravens were without Reed for a large chunk and the Steelers were without Polamalu. They both finished 1 game behind the Kittens. Both of those players could easily swing one game, if not more. The Browns...well, we're a non-factor...likely in 2010 as well unfortunately.

There's a quick four.... Now, this is not to say that these will happen. They may not and I could very well be wrong. However, your arrogance is a little over the top considering the fact that the Bengals have a history of being INCONSISTENT.



How about you respond with something of substance this time rather than the same tired line?

DOn;t go away mad pumpkin

Bish
Edited by Sean Bishop on Feb 11, 2010 20:48:13
Edited by Sean Bishop on Feb 11, 2010 20:47:44
 
LokiThunder
offline
Link
 
You're allowing for injuries on the Steelers and Ravens, but not fr the Bengals? The Bengals were starting their #4 TE all season! Odom, who had 8 sacks in 5 games, went on IR after playing just a 1/3 or the season, and Andre Smith didn't even start until the last couple games. Oh, and the Bengals lost Chris Henry which completely deflated the offense, if you want to check those numbers. Oh, and the Bengals lost one of their starting safeties early too, Roy Williams. But that's football.

Reed's on the fence about retiring, so listing him isn't an improvement to the Ravens. He only missed four games.
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/players/gamelog?playerId=3552

Troy missed a lot of games, does one starter returning outweigh a pass rusher of similar impact, losing your top 3 TE's and a starting safety?

As for the Ocho thing, you can say the same about the Ravens WR's, or about Hines Ward has slowed way down. You can say about Ray Rice what you said about Benson, except you'll say "well Flacco can make'em pay", but you don't go that route with the Bengals, why?. They're not facts for or against, just standard observation. You're spinning your wheels with nothing.


As always, you've got nothing concrete, just bias and childish attempts to belittle.
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LokiThunder
You're allowing for injuries on the Steelers and Ravens, but not fr the Bengals? The Bengals were starting their #4 TE all season! Odom, who had 8 sacks in 5 games, went on IR after playing just a 1/3 or the season, and Andre Smith didn't even start until the last couple games. Oh, and the Bengals lost Chris Henry which completely deflated the offense, if you want to check those numbers. Oh, and the Bengals lost one of their starting safeties early too, Roy Williams. But that's football.

Reed's on the fence about retiring, so listing him isn't an improvement to the Ravens. He only missed four games.
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/players/gamelog?playerId=3552

Troy missed a lot of games, does one starter returning outweigh a pass rusher of similar impact, losing your top 3 TE's and a starting safety?

As for the Ocho thing, you can say the same about the Ravens WR's, or about Hines Ward has slowed way down. You can say about Ray Rice what you said about Benson, except you'll say "well Flacco can make'em pay", but you don't go that route with the Bengals, why?. They're not facts for or against, just standard observation. You're spinning your wheels with nothing.


As always, you've got nothing concrete, just bias and childish attempts to belittle.


OK let's retort now that we're actually talking football.

When was the TE position last actually an important position for the Bengals? The last time I really recall the Bengals using a TE often was...gad..it was years ago. I want to say Rodney Someone? Kelly is a solid blocker but he's not a playmaker so no...I don't think using backup TEs affected the Bengals much.

The loss of Odom...absolutely....I had forgotten about him. He was having a helluva year before he got hurt.

Chris Henry...without a doubt hurt the team emotionally. Is that the reason for the offensive collapse? Maybe.... however, I would also put it out there that the Bengals offense was getting figured out. I don;t say this to be callous but I don;t think it was the only thing that led to the Bengals falling apart.

Andre Smith, at this point, is maybe an average right tackle. There;s a reason he didn't start all year....he's simply not that good.

On the Reed and Polamalu point, either of them are a bigger loss to the team than Odom...and they had their injuries apart from them as well. Both Reed and Polamalu are among the top defensive players in the league. Who cares if Reed is contemplating retirement...I would still take him in a heartbeat. When Barry Sanders retired was he on his last legs? Hell no. Some players are just smart enough to get out early.

As for the Ocho thing, the Ravens do face the same problem as they only have Mason as a legit receiver and continue to look for a real #1. If they DO get one, their offense will start to be very very scary. Ray Rice is harder to gameplan for than Benson as Benson is a downhill runner whereas Rice is an all-purpose back. Stack the box against Rice and he's worlds better than Benson as a receiver out of the backfield.

For the Steelers, Ward has slowed down but they've also got young talent with Holmes and Wallace. The problem with the Steelers offense, as it has been for the last few years (yes I said years...sorry...looking at history and trends again), is their offensive line.

So there's some concrete to throw on your driveway. Thanks for giving me something new to work with this time around. It's actually starting to resemble a conversation about football.

Factually yours,
Bish

 
LokiThunder
offline
Link
 
OK let's retort now that we're actually talking football.

I always was. You were trying to put words in my mouth, namecalling, and being condescending.


When was the TE position last actually an important position for the Bengals? The last time I really recall the Bengals using a TE often was...gad..it was years ago. I want to say Rodney Someone? Kelly is a solid blocker but he's not a playmaker so no...I don't think using backup TEs affected the Bengals much.


It's vitally important. Reggie Kelly is one of the best blocking TE's in the NFL and that gives Carson more time and opens better holes for the RB. He doesn't catch a ton of passes or stretch the field so people who just check box scores doen't see his impact on the offense. Ask anyone who pays attention to the team, Reggie Kelly is huge for the offense.


The loss of Odom...absolutely....I had forgotten about him. He was having a helluva year before he got hurt.


Yep


Chris Henry...without a doubt hurt the team emotionally. Is that the reason for the offensive collapse? Maybe.... however, I would also put it out there that the Bengals offense was getting figured out. I don;t say this to be callous but I don;t think it was the only thing that led to the Bengals falling apart.

The offense wasn't figured out, they just didn't have a second receiver to stretch the field opposite Chad. Check out the numbers on TD passes prior to Henry getting hurt, then TD passes after. It's a direct correlation.


Andre Smith, at this point, is maybe an average right tackle. There;s a reason he didn't start all year....he's simply not that good.

Again, you show you don't know what you're talking about. Andre Smith didn't start because he held out, then broke his foot. Once everything healed and he got back into football shape, he took over the role of RT. Had zero to do with talent level. When he was on the field he looked every bit the best tackle in the draft.


On the Reed and Polamalu point, either of them are a bigger loss to the team than Odom...and they had their injuries apart from them as well. Both Reed and Polamalu are among the top defensive players in the league. Who cares if Reed is contemplating retirement...I would still take him in a heartbeat. When Barry Sanders retired was he on his last legs? Hell no. Some players are just smart enough to get out early.

Losing Reed for 4 games is not a bigger loss than losing Odom for 11. The retirement thing is a statement meant to show the Ravens won't be immediately better by Reed returning, since he may retire due to nerve damage or something. It has nothing to do with his level of play.
Troy, is a bigger loss, but I countered with the Bengals losses since you were playing the "we'll be better when X returns" game. The IR-ed on the Bengals side far outweighed the loss of Troy. So the returning from injuries thing doesn't make the Steelers better in the slightest. It actually puts the Bengals even further ahead.

Reggie Kelly (may retire), Antwan Odom, Roy Williams, Ben Utecht (listing because he was IR-ed, likely to retire though), Chase Coffman (set several TE NCAA receiving records). Oh, and the Bengals were without their top DT Domata Peko for about 4 games, and since you listed Reed and he was out a similar about of time...


As for the Ocho thing, the Ravens do face the same problem as they only have Mason as a legit receiver and continue to look for a real #1. If they DO get one, their offense will start to be very very scary. Ray Rice is harder to gameplan for than Benson as Benson is a downhill runner whereas Rice is an all-purpose back. Stack the box against Rice and he's worlds better than Benson as a receiver out of the backfield.

Rice is a better Receiver than Benson, but Benson is better plowing through tacklers. Six of one, or a half dozen of the other. Cedric stays healthy and he makes the pro bowl. Prefer people underestimate him, and comparing Mason with Ocho is silly!


For the Steelers, Ward has slowed down but they've also got young talent with Holmes and Wallace. The problem with the Steelers offense, as it has been for the last few years (yes I said years...sorry...looking at history and trends again), is their offensive line.

The Steelers have always had one of the worst passing blocking o-lines in the NFL. If you watch Steelers games, that's painfully obvious. Theu run block well and that's the key. They stick with the run and it often pays off. That and Ben's great at keeping plays alive and escaping sacks. They're successful because they make teams play the run, and can stretch the field with Wallace and Holmes. That's how their offense works.



So there's some concrete to throw on your driveway. Thanks for giving me something new to work with this time around. It's actually starting to resemble a conversation about football.

Factually yours,
Bish



At least you're trying to post facts, even if they're a bit off. But you're getting better.
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
Loki,

Bet you thought I;'d forgotten about you...however, given that we;re finally getting into some meat, I'd be a bad playmate if I didn't get back to you.

It's vitally important. Reggie Kelly is one of the best blocking TE's in the NFL and that gives Carson more time and opens better holes for the RB. He doesn't catch a ton of passes or stretch the field so people who just check box scores doen't see his impact on the offense. Ask anyone who pays attention to the team, Reggie Kelly is huge for the offense.

That's fair enough. However, given that Benson is typically a between the tackles runner, TE won;t have as much of an effect on run game. I have no doubt that he makes a difference but I think game changer is a bit of a stretch. But then again, not my team so I'll take your word for it.



When he was on the field he looked every bit the best tackle in the draft.


Um...Michael Oher?

Rice is a better Receiver than Benson, but Benson is better plowing through tacklers. Six of one, or a half dozen of the other. Cedric stays healthy and he makes the pro bowl. Prefer people underestimate him, and comparing Mason with Ocho is silly!

Rice is better than Benson period.... And this is not to slag Benson but Rice has the makings of a HOF back. He can run inside or out and is a good receiver. Makes me ill that he's a Raven.

Comparing Mason to Ocho.... Actually I think its a pretty good comparison. Two very good receivers. Mason was strictly a return guy for a few years but apart from that, tehy've posted similar type numbers.

All this being said, I think that Benson is easier to gameplan for given his power running style. However, if the Bengals can pick up a good WR this coming year, the Bengals offense could be very good.
 
LokiThunder
offline
Link
 
That's fair enough. However, given that Benson is typically a between the tackles runner, TE won;t have as much of an effect on run game. I have no doubt that he makes a difference but I think game changer is a bit of a stretch. But then again, not my team so I'll take your word for it.

Not just the running game, but in the passing attack, where as you mentioned, the TE is of little offensive value. Kelly is like an extra tackle giving Palmer time to go deep. This year, he lacked that partly due to the o-line not giving him the time needed to throw deep. That's part of my beef with the o-line needing to improve.




Um...Michael Oher?

What about him? He's go a movie out and a lot of publicity, but it doesn't take away from how well Andre Smith played. You think Oher played better, several others don't. Fact is, Andre Smith played well and wasn't off the field due to below average play, like you originally said.



Rice is better than Benson period.... And this is not to slag Benson but Rice has the makings of a HOF back. He can run inside or out and is a good receiver. Makes me ill that he's a Raven.

Rice has a long, long way to go to be a HOF back, so why say something like that? In actuality, the average career for a RB in the NFL is under 4 years, so he's likely nothing near a HOF back when he hangs up his cleats.
Point is, as long as Benson is running the ball to his strength, he's the better back. Rice can do a lot more and is more valuable to his team, but if all Benson does is bang in the middle and go off tackle, which are his strengths, then I don't mind. Bernard Scott can handle the scat back detail. The Ravens save a roster spot, but give up power inside. I'm alright with it. 6 of one, half dozen of the other.




Comparing Mason to Ocho.... Actually I think its a pretty good comparison. Two very good receivers. Mason was strictly a return guy for a few years but apart from that, tehy've posted similar type numbers.

That's laughable! Mason is well, well on the decline and is a slow possession guy. Chad still has his speed and gamebreaking ability. You're playing the boxscore game again when you lok at the flat numbers. As mentioned before, the Bengals passing attack took a serious downturn after Henry was lost.



All this being said, I think that Benson is easier to gameplan for given his power running style. However, if the Bengals can pick up a good WR this coming year, the Bengals offense could be very good.

I agree 100% he's easy to gameplan for, but he still generates solid yards in a run, run, curl, punt offense. Never made the Bengals gameplanning out to be anything more than checkers while the rest play chess. Which is another testament to Benson.




As for taking a little extra time to respond. Not a big deal. Figured you just wanted a little more time to make sure your facts were a bit more on target after all my previous corrections. Maybe I'll write something up about the Browns in the next few days. Buddy is a big fan, so we talk about them to some length. Give you a chance to jump on things I may not be up to date on.

Don't mind helping spread some knowledge.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.