User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Do you believe in Evolution?
Page:
 
shaun123987
offline
Link
 
It's hard to answer 100% of questions on evolution. It just seems to me that it is all pretty random and isn't definite. What triggers these mutations to help them? Out of all the things that the mutations could be, they just happen to be something positive and help the animal survive in nature?
 
shaun123987
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JoSCh
Originally posted by OttawaShane

Originally posted by JoSCh


Originally posted by shaun123987



Originally posted by OttawaShane




That's like asking if I believe the sun rises in the east and sets in the west.

And for those confused...evolution isn't purposeful, or all of a sudden. Members of a species will occasionally have mutations. Like a longer beak. If that beak helps the bird thrive, it will be a better breeder, and it will help make more birds with long-ish beaks. In time, if the mutations helps the species, all of those birds will thus have longer beaks. Or they've all accidently pecked each others eyes out in the nest, and the trait vanishes or the species dies out.



So all the mutations just happen to be positive mutations that help them with what they need to survive? What about mutations that make them inefficient?



They die off?

For someone who seems to spell and formulate questions well, you sure ain't much for thinkin'.


Actually I really respect that a sceptic asked that question - it shows he *is* thinking and putting the pieces together. Nice work.


Possible if he's young, smart, and repressed. But this is the internet; I suspect a trap and wanted to start ridiculing him early. Pre-emptive douchebaggery? Possibly, and if so, I'm sorry.


Not really sure what kinda trap you were expecting
 
rhavec
offline
Link
 
Anyone who can believe creationism but not evolution is ignorant.
 
nit2wnit
offline
Link
 
Humans did not evolve from Monkeys because of one simple fact. Their dick to body ratio is a lot smaller than humans. Humans have one of the biggest dick to body ratios of all mammals. Here is the order for dick to body ratio for mammals. Starting from largest to smallest.

1. Zebra (Because they are from Africa)
2. Horse
3. Donkey
4 Pig (corkscrew dick)
5. Humans
 
HTFC
offline
Link
 
ROFL, just read a few posts.

Dinosaurs = Dragons?
So all the stories of dragons in medieval times were dinosaurs?
Sorry to tell you but dragons are a myth and dinosaurs had been extinct long before then.

There IS proof of evolution and NO proof of Religion.

Everyones gotta have their opinion though.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JoSCh

Possible if he's young, smart, and repressed. But this is the internet; I suspect a trap and wanted to start ridiculing him early. Pre-emptive douchebaggery? Possibly, and if so, I'm sorry.


Haha...that was my vague impression of him when I read his question, thanks for putting it into words.

 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shaun123987
It's hard to answer 100% of questions on evolution. It just seems to me that it is all pretty random and isn't definite. What triggers these mutations to help them? Out of all the things that the mutations could be, they just happen to be something positive and help the animal survive in nature?


We may never know that. What we have a better chance of understanding are mental/cognitive changes that have happened through evolution. There's a whole field dedicated to psychophysics, the study of the relationship between physical stimuli and how we perceive them. All the physical changes, like, if a bird has a long beak, could as far as I know only be inferred to have been caused by an environmental demand, in this case like to be able to reach into holes and pluck out insects.
 
ziot
offline
Link
 
If evolution means this thread becoming a shit thread in the next few pages, I could the possibility of it being real
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shaun123987
It's hard to answer 100% of questions on evolution. It just seems to me that it is all pretty random and isn't definite. What triggers these mutations to help them? Out of all the things that the mutations could be, they just happen to be something positive and help the animal survive in nature?


Most mutations aren't positive, or are neutral or don't even allow the embryo to make it into infancy.
 
shaun123987
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Originally posted by shaun123987

It's hard to answer 100% of questions on evolution. It just seems to me that it is all pretty random and isn't definite. What triggers these mutations to help them? Out of all the things that the mutations could be, they just happen to be something positive and help the animal survive in nature?


Most mutations aren't positive, or are neutral or don't even allow the embryo to make it into infancy.


That's what I'm trying to get at about mutations and how they help animals survive.
Last edited Jun 11, 2008 11:23:08
 
shaun123987
offline
Link
 
I mean a bird could need a longer beak to help reach for food, but he could have a mutation that gives him longer legs or bigger wings.
 
Link
 
anyone that questions evolution. Why do some snakes have leg bones, whales have hip bones. Why do humans have a tail bone.
Also Evolution is proven, evolution of thought.

Also what proof is there for creationism besides the bible that is in reality just a collection of stories that there is no valid proof
 
Semineer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ziot
If evolution means this thread becoming a shit thread in the next few pages, I could the possibility of it being real


Another Creationist?
 
Oden
offline
Link
 
Evolution is real. End of story. Why should I even bother to convince these people that it's true? Seriously, why should I bother? They're likely to stay ignorant about this the rest of their lives, and it's their loss. However, if I ever become world dictator, I will teach Determinism in schools ( http://youtube.com/watch?v=JX_sXsfCb9A ), and also teach about the untruths of all of the world religions.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shaun123987
Originally posted by OttawaShane

Originally posted by shaun123987


It's hard to answer 100% of questions on evolution. It just seems to me that it is all pretty random and isn't definite. What triggers these mutations to help them? Out of all the things that the mutations could be, they just happen to be something positive and help the animal survive in nature?


Most mutations aren't positive, or are neutral or don't even allow the embryo to make it into infancy.


That's what I'm trying to get at about mutations and how they help animals survive.


yeah, but some of the mutations are very helpful - the longer beak that allowed some birds to catch food more easily...the thumb that allowed a primate to hold a stick to fend off a bear. It was the odd mutation that allowed its owner to do stuff better and therefore be a more desireable breeding partner. That meant the mutation become more widely spread, and after many generations, the norm.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.