User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add Gold / Silver / Copper Leagues For Each Level Cap And Change Promotion System
Page:
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dkmfan
I like some of the ideas, but IMO there are some serious issues with the structure you are using.
I think the GSC (gold, silver, copper) would be highly limiting in placing teams. Especially with the bonus/penalty system you propose for that placement. Sometimes the system needs to pull a few good teams up an extra cap, and the ranking "demotion" would quickly become a headache.

Instead, I would eliminate the bonuses and the GSC ranks. I would start with assigning cap pools on day 42 (plenty of time to recruit), with league assignment on day 0. The system would take the best 32 teams and make that #1, #2 33-64 and so on through the whole cap. This would offer better matching, and wouldn't hurt teams too badly if they have to jump an extra cap, since the leagues would be as competitive as possible.

Now for the exploit killers. 1) teams would be assessed on player talent- the whole roster will be considered with no regard for the depth chart. Previous success will be considered but only from the previous season (too easy to tank preseason). 2) SPs not assigned will count heavily to a players value. 3) Any team without a filled roster by day 0 will be repossessed.

This is sort of my ideal structure.


the main problem with that is the teams with the best rosters are not always the teams that play the best. Game planning is far more important



Originally posted by Time Trial
Yes, but I'm also assuming that boosting players will find a home in Gold, which will keep the actual levels very similar. It will allow players who don't boost the chance to play other players that don't boost right through their entire careers. You probably don't see a lot of non-boosted players playing in Pro or World league... you won't see that many playing in Gold either.

Owners would still be able to recruit the best players for their age group (and shouldn't the best build for their age be part of the point?). Good building will be rewarded in the long term, as will boosting. Which it already does in the current system, but doesn't allow the SSB players the huge advantages that they currently are seeing. Cap-building will still exist as long as ALGs exist, but that's just part of the system.


well you have to be a little careful about that because Bort said explicitly he was never going to add "non boosting leagues", so creating a system that's going to pair up a lot of teams that use non boosters almost exclusively is probably going to get shot down by the higher ups.

the way I see it, gold is for the cream of the crop of the level cap. If you are a non booster, and annoyed that no gold teams will take you because you don't boost... that's just part of the territory. From a business stand point, that's what is supposed to encourage people to boost. Kind of like how you need to boost if you want to play in the pros leagues etc
 
dkmfan
offline
Link
 
I do include previous success in assessing the team (I did bury that point), I only disqualify the pre-season because it would be too easy to manipulate those results (especially with active GMs), in hopes of facing "lesser" competition when it counts.
 
jstevens
offline
Link
 
+1

parity and competitive playing is the next level in your game Bort. don't be greedy, but make this game actually worth playing, paying and logging into every day!

you have planted a good seed Chysil...keep watering it though.
 
oauitam
offline
Link
 
Good idea. +1

My only side question is why it isn't Gold, Silver and Bronze?
Where did copper come in?

Steve
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oauitam
Good idea. +1

My only side question is why it isn't Gold, Silver and Bronze?
Where did copper come in?

Steve


it's following the pee-wee style... ask Bort
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
Originally posted by Time Trial

Yes, but I'm also assuming that boosting players will find a home in Gold, which will keep the actual levels very similar. It will allow players who don't boost the chance to play other players that don't boost right through their entire careers. You probably don't see a lot of non-boosted players playing in Pro or World league... you won't see that many playing in Gold either.

Owners would still be able to recruit the best players for their age group (and shouldn't the best build for their age be part of the point?). Good building will be rewarded in the long term, as will boosting. Which it already does in the current system, but doesn't allow the SSB players the huge advantages that they currently are seeing. Cap-building will still exist as long as ALGs exist, but that's just part of the system.


well you have to be a little careful about that because Bort said explicitly he was never going to add "non boosting leagues", so creating a system that's going to pair up a lot of teams that use non boosters almost exclusively is probably going to get shot down by the higher ups.

the way I see it, gold is for the cream of the crop of the level cap. If you are a non booster, and annoyed that no gold teams will take you because you don't boost... that's just part of the territory. From a business stand point, that's what is supposed to encourage people to boost. Kind of like how you need to boost if you want to play in the pros leagues etc


I agree, but this would not preclude boosting players from playing in the Silver and Copper leagues. In fact, teams that want to get out of Silver and Copper and move up the rankings are going to try and recruit boosting players just as they do now. The problem with a non age-based system of caps is that it actually punishes boosting. A player that has boosted every season up to level 36 will get there faster, but will invariably be weaker than a player that took much longer to get there and has had more time to train. Gold teams will be looking for players that were SSB and are much further along in their development.
Edited by Time Trial on Jan 7, 2010 10:00:44
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
boost makes you significantly better long term, and a little worse short term. if you want t play pros / world league you will need to have boosted a significant amount of your career. So I think teams pushing for pros usually will go after someone relatively the same age as the rest of their players.

I know age was a huge issue for the team I was on that replaced a few players
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
its a good idea and goes along with alot of the vertical as well as horizontal promotion schemes - aka teams can move up the ladder each season via cap raises but can progress to different leagues within each wrong based on their performance.

The horizontal promotion schemes along with rpi type rankings & Player Age Caps are the best ideas to come forth in solving the competition and promotion problems. I would bet that the eventual solution will encompass a little of both (Not sure if Bort wants to change the structure though).


I would expand the horizontal progression to more than just gold/silver copper though. Something like this:

Lvls 0-13 Cap
Conf. A....Conf B....Conf. C....Conf. D... Conf. E....Conf F.... Conf. G...Conf H...

Lvl 14-23 cap
Conf. A....Conf B....Conf. C....Conf. D... Conf. E....Conf F.... Conf. G...Conf H...

Lvl 24-28 cap
Conf. A....Conf B....Conf. C....Conf. D... Conf. E....Conf F.... Conf. G...Conf H...

Sample Team:
Team could starts off in conf H in their first season, but crushes the competition. The next season they would move up to lvl 23 cap and could move to a different conference where there is better competition (e.g. Conf F).

In season 2, the team makes the playoffs and wins the league, but is pretty compettive with most of the league. The team stays in Conf F and moves up to the next lvl cap (along with the rest of the conference)
Edited by jearly on Jan 7, 2010 11:12:29
Edited by jearly on Jan 7, 2010 11:08:34
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
Id like to see 8 teams drop from each division and both Silver Champ and runner up get promoted. More turn out this way and it keeps teams fresh.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
Id like to see 8 teams drop from each division and both Silver Champ and runner up get promoted. More turn out this way and it keeps teams fresh.


Yeah, but if you look at Pee Wee, do you actually see 16 teams in Silver that are better than the bottom 16 teams in Gold? I was a fan of the old "if you don't make playoffs you are out" idea, but after seeing it in action I would be far more in favour of four silver leagues and have the winner and the runner up advance than to have 8 leagues and have that many advance.

Perhaps a compromise... 5 leagues where the winner and runner up advance. Then the bottom five teams from each conference would advance.
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Well the thing is, for all non playoff teams to demote, it would mean there's 8 silver leagues

there is only 1 cap with more than 8 leagues (that isn't 14 cap). 22 cap has 9 leagues. Take out 1 for gold, and at least 1 for copper... you are left with less than 8 silver. So it wouldn't be a promotion of all non playoff teams, I think in most instances it would be roughly 3-5 teams per cap getting demoted
Edited by Chysil on Jan 8, 2010 06:36:18
 
recockulous
offline
Link
 
Time Trial's idea sucks, but the OP is on to something. You've got all these anonymous leagues under the caps - why not make them more competitive.

And I think a copper trophy is meaningful, if you're rebuilding.
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Guess I'll bump this to see if any more discussion will come
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I'm going to bump this myself because I was thinking about it recently, and had the thought come up:

What would you do with teams who dropped down from above? Let's say a former AAA teams wants to load up with lv 24 players and head down to a 26 league. Where do we place them? Silver? Figuring out the number of leagues and how to split them becomes harder when you have teams who have no past record at a lower tier.

Where do newly purchased teams start?

Also, couldn't we accomplish a very similar goal if we simply sorted all teams by past season's record, and fill the next tier's leagues in that order, starting at league 1? League 1 basically becomes the "Gold" league, leagues 2,3,4 etc become "Silver" and the rest get filtered into 5,6,7, etc with CPU teams to fill remaining holes. It might be hard to figure out designations, but you'd tend to end up with all the good teams together, while the non-trying teams get lumped together at the end as well.
 
tuba_samurai
offline
Link
 
+1
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.